You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 2.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 15 of 80 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
Stirlingsays Flag 11 Jul 14 7.25am

The picture is kind of pointless.

It doesn't mean much at all. These are enemies.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Jul 14 9.17am

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Jul 2014 7.25am

The picture is kind of pointless.

It doesn't mean much at all. These are enemies.

I think its quite evocative, as photojournalism goes - as for what it means, well not much. Its kind of what conflict does to people over time. Of course if it was Palestinians cheering the death of Israeli's it might be presented much more cynically.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Jul 14 11.34am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 11 Jul 2014 9.17am

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Jul 2014 7.25am

The picture is kind of pointless.

It doesn't mean much at all. These are enemies.

I think its quite evocative, as photojournalism goes - as for what it means, well not much. Its kind of what conflict does to people over time. Of course if it was Palestinians cheering the death of Israeli's it might be presented much more cynically.



Of course you're right but I want to add something here.

I think there's an implication by many and in your last sentence that we should be fair and balanced to both sides here. That we should be above it all and view these things as though we aren't invested in the motivations and wanted outcomes of both sides.

I don't mean the desired outcome of a peaceful two state solution that I think all of us can wish for....But of the other stated outcomes that an organisation like Hamas (which is now representated across all government) pushes for.

I don't think that's quite appropriate if a person to support the Palestinian government if they are a supporter of or indeed a contributor to life in the west.....But I know many on the left do in great numbers.

Now of course the Palestinians, like the Israelis are a diverse body of groups and views. But outside of that a huge power based in based upon Hamas which now has an external approach to the world which is violent to pretty much everything I believe in.....Indeed now rockets come from both Gaza and the West Bank.

Why should I be even handed to a power base which if I were to walk among them would probebly take me prisoner and or kill me?

Israel isn't ideal and has a government that seeks to worsen the sitation not better it.....But as a country and culture it resonates far more with me and what I can accept.

When I judge actions I will frequently criticise both but when it comes to supporting sides....I support the values that I believe in....Because one side represents western civilisation and the other....with exceptions accepted, doesn't.

The Palestinians have to embrace the moderates until I can start to view them more favourably......And I can't see that happeneing now....As once you vote in Hamas they aren't going to let you vote them out.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ghosteagle Flag 11 Jul 14 12.07pm

Quote matt_himself at 11 Jul 2014 6.24am

Quote moylerg at 11 Jul 2014 12.10am

....if course,there will not be a retraction in sight... From Mr Matt Up Himself I mean. It is quite adult to show humility, or so I thought. Don't see much for the protagonist on this thread.


What's this got to do with you sweetheart?

The fact is that a Russia Today journalist, yes that credible organ Russia Today whose mission is to undermine the US and its allies, prints a picture of what could be anything.

Every media organization tilts a certain way, there is no such thing as objective reporting. I don't think RT is any better or worse than say the BBC, it just depends what they are reporting on and what they want to emphasize.

 

ghosteagle Flag 11 Jul 14 12.19pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Jul 2014 11.34am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 11 Jul 2014 9.17am

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Jul 2014 7.25am

The picture is kind of pointless.

It doesn't mean much at all. These are enemies.

I think its quite evocative, as photojournalism goes - as for what it means, well not much. Its kind of what conflict does to people over time. Of course if it was Palestinians cheering the death of Israeli's it might be presented much more cynically.



Of course you're right but I want to add something here.

I think there's an implication by many and in your last sentence that we should be fair and balanced to both sides here. That we should be above it all and view these things as though we aren't invested in the motivations and wanted outcomes of both sides.

I don't mean the desired outcome of a peaceful two state solution that I think all of us can wish for....But of the other stated outcomes that an organisation like Hamas (which is now representated across all government) pushes for.

I don't think that's quite appropriate if a person to support the Palestinian government if they are a supporter of or indeed a contributor to life in the west.....But I know many on the left do in great numbers.

Now of course the Palestinians, like the Israelis are a diverse body of groups and views. But outside of that a huge power based in based upon Hamas which now has an external approach to the world which is violent to pretty much everything I believe in.....Indeed now rockets come from both Gaza and the West Bank.

Why should I be even handed to a power base which if I were to walk among them would probebly take me prisoner and or kill me?

Israel isn't ideal and has a government that seeks to worsen the sitation not better it.....But as a country and culture it resonates far more with me and what I can accept.

When I judge actions I will frequently criticise both but when it comes to supporting sides....I support the values that I believe in....Because one side represents western civilisation and the other....with exceptions accepted, doesn't.

The Palestinians have to embrace the moderates until I can start to view them more favourably......And I can't see that happeneing now....As once you vote in Hamas they aren't going to let you vote them out.

I think that this is a good post that highlights something that is important but rarely recognized. That’s being that while we can argue backwards and forwards about the morality and consequences of the actions of the two sides that ultimately most people take sides then try to justify the actions of their chosen side. In contrast to you, i see Israel as acting against the ideals of Western civilization by conquering a land and people based on an idea of racial superiority and to me the Palestinians represent the values of resisting tyranny. I support the other 'side' but agree that the actions of both are open to plenty of criticism.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Jul 14 1.41pm

Quote ghosteagle at 11 Jul 2014 12.19pm

I think that this is a good post that highlights something that is important but rarely recognized. That’s being that while we can argue backwards and forwards about the morality and consequences of the actions of the two sides that ultimately most people take sides then try to justify the actions of their chosen side. In contrast to you, i see Israel as acting against the ideals of Western civilization by conquering a land and people based on an idea of racial superiority and to me the Palestinians represent the values of resisting tyranny. I support the other 'side' but agree that the actions of both are open to plenty of criticism.


It's interesting how we get to thsse positions.

I can appreciate the plight of the Palestinians as being the subject of injustice....To a certain extent historically and also in the modern sense.

For example, I saw most of that documentary about the Israeli police making normal life for Palestinians awful in those parts of the west bank that they wanted for settlement expansion.

I feel that situations like that are not only illegal but morally corrupt and it should be subject to UN action.

However how we got to this situation is another story entirely and I can't blame the Israelis for gaining a homeland after WW2.

The Arabs have an argument against it being 'their' land. Still, as far as I see it....Multiple Arab countries attacked Israel in concert in three wars and they lost all three.

You lose a war and what is left is the reality....It's how all the boundries have been set around most of the world.

However Palestinians like all peoples deserve fairness within the context of humanity. Still, it's hard to do that when their representatives are extreme.

What is the solution to the sitaution? A new viable state that hates Israel is a huge discentive to Israel to allow happen.

Like Jamie said, the UN need to be involved heavily in any two state solution....Which still isn't an independent country. Still, we can't have Hamas operating in any way in the direction of a new state.....We would be at war before we know it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 11 Jul 14 3.59pm

Quote ghosteagle at 11 Jul 2014 12.19pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Jul 2014 11.34am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 11 Jul 2014 9.17am

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Jul 2014 7.25am

The picture is kind of pointless.

It doesn't mean much at all. These are enemies.

I think its quite evocative, as photojournalism goes - as for what it means, well not much. Its kind of what conflict does to people over time. Of course if it was Palestinians cheering the death of Israeli's it might be presented much more cynically.



Of course you're right but I want to add something here.

I think there's an implication by many and in your last sentence that we should be fair and balanced to both sides here. That we should be above it all and view these things as though we aren't invested in the motivations and wanted outcomes of both sides.

I don't mean the desired outcome of a peaceful two state solution that I think all of us can wish for....But of the other stated outcomes that an organisation like Hamas (which is now representated across all government) pushes for.

I don't think that's quite appropriate if a person to support the Palestinian government if they are a supporter of or indeed a contributor to life in the west.....But I know many on the left do in great numbers.

Now of course the Palestinians, like the Israelis are a diverse body of groups and views. But outside of that a huge power based in based upon Hamas which now has an external approach to the world which is violent to pretty much everything I believe in.....Indeed now rockets come from both Gaza and the West Bank.

Why should I be even handed to a power base which if I were to walk among them would probebly take me prisoner and or kill me?

Israel isn't ideal and has a government that seeks to worsen the sitation not better it.....But as a country and culture it resonates far more with me and what I can accept.

When I judge actions I will frequently criticise both but when it comes to supporting sides....I support the values that I believe in....Because one side represents western civilisation and the other....with exceptions accepted, doesn't.

The Palestinians have to embrace the moderates until I can start to view them more favourably......And I can't see that happeneing now....As once you vote in Hamas they aren't going to let you vote them out.

I think that this is a good post that highlights something that is important but rarely recognized. That’s being that while we can argue backwards and forwards about the morality and consequences of the actions of the two sides that ultimately most people take sides then try to justify the actions of their chosen side. In contrast to you, i see Israel as acting against the ideals of Western civilization by conquering a land and people based on an idea of racial superiority and to me the Palestinians represent the values of resisting tyranny. I support the other 'side' but agree that the actions of both are open to plenty of criticism.


The ideals of western civilisation? As in the conquest and settlement of Latin America by the Spanish and Portuguese? As in the conquest and settlement of N. America by the Brits and French? As in the conquest and settlement of Australasia by the Brits?

Zionism did arise in a context of nationalist movements in Europe in the late 19th/early 20th century Europe, its true. But, its not simply the standard westerners conquer and settle a foreign land on basis they are superior to the locals scenario...The Jews inhabited the area, were expelled (in large part) by the Romans...their religious rituals always contained at heart a yearning to return to Zion from exile...so, there was an historical linkage between the settlers and the land ...not that any of that automatically means their cause is right, or in any way excuses the abject failure of the right in Israel since they took over the political agenda nearly 40 years ago to truly seek a just peace with the Palestinians with a viable Palestinian state...any more than Hamas' ideology would involve a truly democratic society for non Muslims (including Palestinian Christians, let alone Jews).

The sad thing is that Zionism arose from centuries of utter oppression of Jews in Europe...only thing is, one cannot but sympathise with the Palestinians as ending up as the fall guys for the (in all too many instances) state sanctioned discriminatory acts of a significant part of European Christian civilisation...

But, I do agree ,many people adopt their "position" and then channel morality to fit their support for that position...including the "parties" to the dispute..

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 11 Jul 14 7.33pm

Quote matt_himself at 11 Jul 2014 6.24am

Quote moylerg at 11 Jul 2014 12.10am

....if course,there will not be a retraction in sight... From Mr Matt Up Himself I mean. It is quite adult to show humility, or so I thought. Don't see much for the protagonist on this thread.


What's this got to do with you sweetheart?

The fact is that a Russia Today journalist, yes that credible organ Russia Today whose mission is to undermine the US and its allies, prints a picture of what could be anything.

Sweetheart? Very nice of you, but no thanks. I just wanted to suggest make a small observation, sorry to intrude. Occasionally, amongst personally attacks, a bit of humility would not go amiss. But, you avoided point made, showing you obviously have none. I have no interest in getting involved in the political debate of this thread, just observing some interesting characteristics in the debate. Please carry on

 


Most certainly not European.

bright&wright Flag 12 Jul 14 9.16am

Quote Kermit8 at 10 Jul 2014 11.09pm

Quote matt_himself at 10 Jul 2014 10.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Jul 2014 9.51pm

A sad state of affairs...


Of the people you can make out in that photo, a lot look Arab.

Why do you continue to put this unsubstantiated bilge on here?


One of the more obvious figures there is wearing the Jewish fringed shawl.

You need to go back to the opticians.

Edited by Kermit8 (10 Jul 2014 11.10pm)


It's funny how all these pro-Palestine types (yeah I'm talking about you) forget about all the atrocities they cause and focus solely on the Israelis. If Palestine/Gaza had the same fire power you don't think they'd use it?

Also, champagne socialists like yourself go up to London flying the flag of Palestine and crying foul against democracy, the government and Israel and yet, I wonder how many of you have ACTUALLY been to the Gaza Strip?

Just because you support them and all their bombings doesn't mean they wouldn't still kidnap, torture and probably kill you in a heartbeat.

Such ignorance.

 


'We are going to make a little bit of history here’ Mr. J. Ertl.

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jul 14 9.24am

Quote legaleagle at 11 Jul 2014 3.59pm

The ideals of western civilisation? As in the conquest and settlement of Latin America by the Spanish and Portuguese? As in the conquest and settlement of N. America by the Brits and French? As in the conquest and settlement of Australasia by the Brits?

Zionism did arise in a context of nationalist movements in Europe in the late 19th/early 20th century Europe, its true. But, its not simply the standard westerners conquer and settle a foreign land on basis they are superior to the locals scenario...The Jews inhabited the area, were expelled (in large part) by the Romans...their religious rituals always contained at heart a yearning to return to Zion from exile...so, there was an historical linkage between the settlers and the land ...not that any of that automatically means their cause is right, or in any way excuses the abject failure of the right in Israel since they took over the political agenda nearly 40 years ago to truly seek a just peace with the Palestinians with a viable Palestinian state...any more than Hamas' ideology would involve a truly democratic society for non Muslims (including Palestinian Christians, let alone Jews).

The sad thing is that Zionism arose from centuries of utter oppression of Jews in Europe...only thing is, one cannot but sympathise with the Palestinians as ending up as the fall guys for the (in all too many instances) state sanctioned discriminatory acts of a significant part of European Christian civilisation...

But, I do agree ,many people adopt their "position" and then channel morality to fit their support for that position...including the "parties" to the dispute..


This is a good old 'nutty' left post.

You refer to the 'ideals of western civilization' by harking back to acts committed at the earliest over three hundred years ago. You might think in those terms but I thought it was rather obvious that what I meant was the rule of law, freedom of the press, lower levels of corruption in public institutions, security for the citizen/subject......You lived a life influenced by western tenets of a free education and free health care at the point of delivery (though our good old US friends still have some way to go on that)

You know it's a tad irritating when a self hating westerner incorrectly makes statements on western history to infer that the west's actions are somehow different or worse than any other historical effort by...I don't know...The Persians or the Mongols or any other 'group' in human history.

Humans are tribal and regularly go to war.....This isn't an 'ideal of the west' it is a stamp that identifies the species....And most other living species as well in some context or other.


Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jul 2014 11.48am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 12 Jul 14 9.37am

This is a hugely difficult issue to deal with, especially as the Isralies love to accuse anyone who criticises them as being anti-semitic.

In essence the situation is the legacy of yet another British f@ckup.

After Israel was given independence, having fought a hard battle against the British, they established modern day Israel and did so on the premise that the lands were unoccupied. A stance they still hold on to today.

The truth is that Palestine has been continuously habited by the Palestinians for 3000 years and there's plenty of historical evidence to support this.

The Palestinians were cooperative with the Israelis to a point with many arguing for a two nation settlement. Sadly the Israelis want none of that.

Skipping a lot of history, what you're left with is one nation fighting for its land back (the Palestinians) against the occupiers (Israel) who are increasingly hostile towards the locals.

The cartoon below is a great example of how the Israelis view the world's media coverage of the situation whilst the truth is that most of the media is pro-Israel.

For a good read on the subject take a look at Once Upon A Country: A Palestinian Life by Sari Nusseibeh
[Link]

Israeli view.png Attachment: Israeli view.png (320.30Kb)

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

legaleagle Flag 12 Jul 14 9.48am

Stirling,

In your eagerness to transpose everything into simplistic left/right terms and categorise anything you don't agree with as "nutty" or "self-hating", you didn't even realise my reference to western civilisation was commenting on the post after your one, where the poster berated Zionism as contrary to the ideals of western civilisation.

Your references to things I mention betray your utter lack of knowledge..so what I am talking about was at least 300 years ago, was it? Try telling that to indigenous people in Australia who were having their children taken away from them by the state to be "civilised" until the second half of the 20th century. Try telling my relatives who died in the holocaust in the 20th century. Find out something about the realities of Belgian and German colonisation of Africa in the early 20th century.

The fact other groups in history may have acted in a similar way (though on nothing like the worldwide industrial scale due to advances in technology), does not mean that we should not look carefully and where appropriate critically at our own recent history. The relative prosperity of western civilisation (certainly in Europe) and the resultant liberal democracy arose off the backs of the proceeds of plunder of other parts of the world. And if you think being aware of this must mean one is "self hating" and not appreciative of the benefits of living here, then you are truly a lost cause.

 

legaleagle Flag 12 Jul 14 10.03am

Quote Eagle_SA at 12 Jul 2014 9.37am

This is a hugely difficult issue to deal with, especially as the Isralies love to accuse anyone who criticises them as being anti-semitic.

In essence the situation is the legacy of yet another British f@ckup.

After Israel was given independence, having fought a hard battle against the British, they established modern day Israel and did so on the premise that the lands were unoccupied. A stance they still hold on to today.

The truth is that Palestine has been continuously habited by the Palestinians for 3000 years and there's plenty of historical evidence to support this.

The Palestinians were cooperative with the Israelis to a point with many arguing for a two nation settlement. Sadly the Israelis want none of that.

Skipping a lot of history, what you're left with is one nation fighting for its land back (the Palestinians) against the occupiers (Israel) who are increasingly hostile towards the locals.

The cartoon below is a great example of how the Israelis view the world's media coverage of the situation whilst the truth is that most of the media is pro-Israel.

For a good read on the subject take a look at Once Upon A Country: A Palestinian Life by Sari Nusseibeh
[Link]


I "get" where you are coming from, but its important to remember that we shouldn't "demonise" either side into a single monolithic group. What you say about some on the Palestinian side and a two state solution is right. BUT, it applies equally to the Israelis. There has consistently been a significant minority in Israel (look up the "Peace Now" movement, for example) supportive of a just two state solution. Unfortunately, on the Israeli side (as on the Palestinian) rejectionists have been in (and continue to be in) the ascendancy.

Re 3,000 years ago, I think you will find the Palestinians at that time were in large part, the Jews before their expulsion.

But, you are right, it wasn't an "empty land", it had been continuously inhabited since the Jews were ethnically cleansed out of the area, and "we" basically have a large share of the blame for today's problems arising from the Balfour Declaration.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jul 14 10.56am

Quote legaleagle at 12 Jul 2014 9.48am

Stirling,

In your eagerness to transpose everything into simplistic left/right terms and categorise anything you don't agree with as "nutty" or "self-hating", you didn't even realise my reference to western civilisation was commenting on the post after your one, where the poster berated Zionism as contrary to the ideals of western civilisation.

Your references to things I mention betray your utter lack of knowledge..so what I am talking about was at least 300 years ago, was it? Try telling that to indigenous people in Australia who were having their children taken away from them by the state to be "civilised" until the second half of the 20th century. Try telling my relatives who died in the holocaust in the 20th century. Find out something about the realities of Belgian and German colonisation of Africa in the early 20th century.

The fact other groups in history may have acted in a similar way (though on nothing like the worldwide industrial scale due to advances in technology), does not mean that we should not look carefully and where appropriate critically at our own recent history. The relative prosperity of western civilisation (certainly in Europe) and the resultant liberal democracy arose off the backs of the proceeds of plunder of other parts of the world. And if you think being aware of this must mean one is "self hating" and not appreciative of the benefits of living here, then you are truly a lost cause.

My post referred to 'ideals of western civilization' and yours refers to 'ideals of the west' so it's quite a reasonable assumption to feel you were referring to my post. If you weren't, fair enough....Still.

Your pompous characterizations of me not knowing even basic human history is symptomatic of the folly of believing that people who know the same things feel the same way way about them.

As all groups in our history have basically behaved the same way on war your exclusive attack on western actions in your post continually misses the point that criticizing the 'west' or any group is simply a proxy for criticizing any section of humanity that is subject to those same cultural and historical inputs......This is how humans act. It would be less irritating if your writings reflected that.

Sure there are groups who are affected by historical events as they were by acts before that...Which groups did they supplant?....We could go back all the way to the first bleeding cell....What's the point and what does it prove? Life isn't fair and we try to even things a little but no people are fairly blamed for the actions of generations before them who happened to live on the same piece of dirt....It's ridiculous.

It was you who referred to acts of war carried out hundreds of years ago in reference to 'ideals of the west' and then repeated your 'west' fixation in your follow up post.

Any human civilization is only ever a water or food supply away from war or chaos and this continual focus upon acts of the 'west' betrays the general faulty 'self-hating' mindset of someone who listened far too much to standardized left wing monologs without analyzing them critically and instead adopted them.

I describe your post as 'nutty' left because it is....Please tell me where I will find this tired view outside of sections of the left?

You should stop moaning about characterization....If you don't like it adopt some less cliched viewpoints. and then you might not be identified so easily.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jul 14 11.04am

Quote Eagle_SA at 12 Jul 2014 9.37am

This is a hugely difficult issue to deal with, especially as the Isralies love to accuse anyone who criticises them as being anti-semitic.

In essence the situation is the legacy of yet another British f@ckup.

After Israel was given independence, having fought a hard battle against the British, they established modern day Israel and did so on the premise that the lands were unoccupied. A stance they still hold on to today.

The truth is that Palestine has been continuously habited by the Palestinians for 3000 years and there's plenty of historical evidence to support this.

The Palestinians were cooperative with the Israelis to a point with many arguing for a two nation settlement. Sadly the Israelis want none of that.

Skipping a lot of history, what you're left with is one nation fighting for its land back (the Palestinians) against the occupiers (Israel) who are increasingly hostile towards the locals.

The cartoon below is a great example of how the Israelis view the world's media coverage of the situation whilst the truth is that most of the media is pro-Israel.

For a good read on the subject take a look at Once Upon A Country: A Palestinian Life by Sari Nusseibeh
[Link]


Israel didn't 'fight' the British. You are talking about the actions of terrorists and extremists who couldn't wait. Their actions weren't endorsed by the Israeli majority.


Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jul 2014 11.05am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 12 Jul 14 11.16am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Jul 2014 10.56am

Quote legaleagle at 12 Jul 2014 9.48am

Stirling,

In your eagerness to transpose everything into simplistic left/right terms and categorise anything you don't agree with as "nutty" or "self-hating", you didn't even realise my reference to western civilisation was commenting on the post after your one, where the poster berated Zionism as contrary to the ideals of western civilisation.

Your references to things I mention betray your utter lack of knowledge..so what I am talking about was at least 300 years ago, was it? Try telling that to indigenous people in Australia who were having their children taken away from them by the state to be "civilised" until the second half of the 20th century. Try telling my relatives who died in the holocaust in the 20th century. Find out something about the realities of Belgian and German colonisation of Africa in the early 20th century.

The fact other groups in history may have acted in a similar way (though on nothing like the worldwide industrial scale due to advances in technology), does not mean that we should not look carefully and where appropriate critically at our own recent history. The relative prosperity of western civilisation (certainly in Europe) and the resultant liberal democracy arose off the backs of the proceeds of plunder of other parts of the world. And if you think being aware of this must mean one is "self hating" and not appreciative of the benefits of living here, then you are truly a lost cause.

My post referred to 'ideals of western civilization' and yours refers to 'ideals of the west' so it's quite a reasonable assumption to feel you were referring to my post. If you weren't, fair enough....Still.

Your pompous characterizations of me not knowing even basic human history is symptomatic of the folly of believing that people who know the same things feel the same way way about them.

As all groups in our history have basically behaved the same way on war your exclusive attack on western actions in your post continually misses the point that criticizing the 'west' or any group is simply a proxy for criticizing any section of humanity that is subject to those same cultural and historical inputs......This is how humans act. It would be less irritating if your writings reflected that.

Sure there are groups who are affected by historical events as they were by acts before that...Which groups did they supplant?....We could go back all the way to the first bleeding cell....What's the point and what does it prove? Life isn't fair and we try to even things a little but no people are fairly blamed for the actions of generations before them who happened to live on the same piece of dirt....It's ridiculous.

It was you who referred to acts of war carried out hundreds of years ago in reference to 'ideals of the west' and then repeated your 'west' fixation in your follow up post.

Any human civilization is only ever a water or food supply away from war or chaos and this continual focus upon acts of the 'west' betrays the general faulty 'self-hating' mindset of someone who listened far too much to standardized left wing monologs without analyzing them critically and instead adopted them.

I describe your post as 'nutty' left because it is....Please tell me where I will find this tired view outside of sections of the left?

You should stop moaning about characterization....If you don't like it adopt some less cliched viewpoints. and then you might not be identified so easily.


Many thanks for your kind words and for giving me the benefit of your completely non-nutty and uncliched point of view, Stirling. I know a brick wall when I meet one. Time to move on.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 12 Jul 14 11.16am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Jul 2014 11.04am

Quote Eagle_SA at 12 Jul 2014 9.37am

This is a hugely difficult issue to deal with, especially as the Isralies love to accuse anyone who criticises them as being anti-semitic.

In essence the situation is the legacy of yet another British f@ckup.

After Israel was given independence, having fought a hard battle against the British, they established modern day Israel and did so on the premise that the lands were unoccupied. A stance they still hold on to today.

The truth is that Palestine has been continuously habited by the Palestinians for 3000 years and there's plenty of historical evidence to support this.

The Palestinians were cooperative with the Israelis to a point with many arguing for a two nation settlement. Sadly the Israelis want none of that.

Skipping a lot of history, what you're left with is one nation fighting for its land back (the Palestinians) against the occupiers (Israel) who are increasingly hostile towards the locals.

The cartoon below is a great example of how the Israelis view the world's media coverage of the situation whilst the truth is that most of the media is pro-Israel.

For a good read on the subject take a look at Once Upon A Country: A Palestinian Life by Sari Nusseibeh
[Link]


Israel didn't 'fight' the British. You are talking about the actions of terrorists and extremists who couldn't wait. Their actions weren't endorsed by the Israeli majority.


Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jul 2014 11.05am)


But those 'terrorists' ended up being the government of Israel - Begin, Ben Gurion etc.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jul 14 11.25am

Quote Cucking Funt at 12 Jul 2014 11.16am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Jul 2014 11.04am

Quote Eagle_SA at 12 Jul 2014 9.37am

This is a hugely difficult issue to deal with, especially as the Isralies love to accuse anyone who criticises them as being anti-semitic.

In essence the situation is the legacy of yet another British f@ckup.

After Israel was given independence, having fought a hard battle against the British, they established modern day Israel and did so on the premise that the lands were unoccupied. A stance they still hold on to today.

The truth is that Palestine has been continuously habited by the Palestinians for 3000 years and there's plenty of historical evidence to support this.

The Palestinians were cooperative with the Israelis to a point with many arguing for a two nation settlement. Sadly the Israelis want none of that.

Skipping a lot of history, what you're left with is one nation fighting for its land back (the Palestinians) against the occupiers (Israel) who are increasingly hostile towards the locals.

The cartoon below is a great example of how the Israelis view the world's media coverage of the situation whilst the truth is that most of the media is pro-Israel.

For a good read on the subject take a look at Once Upon A Country: A Palestinian Life by Sari Nusseibeh
[Link]


Israel didn't 'fight' the British. You are talking about the actions of terrorists and extremists who couldn't wait. Their actions weren't endorsed by the Israeli majority.


Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jul 2014 11.05am)


But those 'terrorists' ended up being the government of Israel - Begin, Ben Gurion etc.

Ben-Gurion never agreed with killing British soldiers....Begin....Well yes.

Regardless, Israel didn't 'fight' Britain....The majority never agreed with the bombings.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jul 14 11.46am

Quote legaleagle at 12 Jul 2014 11.16am

Many thanks for your kind words and for giving me the benefit of your completely non-nutty and uncliched point of view, Stirling. I know a brick wall when I meet one. Time to move on.


So I'm a brick wall if I don't agree or accept your points?...Presumably you're implying that you aren't?

I try to argue on reason, if that reason is proven incorrect I would and do alter my view.....And so should everyone....To move an inch closer to indefinable truth is more important than the delusion of ego.

During my time on Hol my views on things have shifted somewhat during discussions and I've learned the occasional thing as well.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 12 Jul 14 11.51am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Jul 2014 11.25am

Quote Cucking Funt at 12 Jul 2014 11.16am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Jul 2014 11.04am

Quote Eagle_SA at 12 Jul 2014 9.37am

This is a hugely difficult issue to deal with, especially as the Isralies love to accuse anyone who criticises them as being anti-semitic.

In essence the situation is the legacy of yet another British f@ckup.

After Israel was given independence, having fought a hard battle against the British, they established modern day Israel and did so on the premise that the lands were unoccupied. A stance they still hold on to today.

The truth is that Palestine has been continuously habited by the Palestinians for 3000 years and there's plenty of historical evidence to support this.

The Palestinians were cooperative with the Israelis to a point with many arguing for a two nation settlement. Sadly the Israelis want none of that.

Skipping a lot of history, what you're left with is one nation fighting for its land back (the Palestinians) against the occupiers (Israel) who are increasingly hostile towards the locals.

The cartoon below is a great example of how the Israelis view the world's media coverage of the situation whilst the truth is that most of the media is pro-Israel.

For a good read on the subject take a look at Once Upon A Country: A Palestinian Life by Sari Nusseibeh
[Link]


Israel didn't 'fight' the British. You are talking about the actions of terrorists and extremists who couldn't wait. Their actions weren't endorsed by the Israeli majority.


Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jul 2014 11.05am)


But those 'terrorists' ended up being the government of Israel - Begin, Ben Gurion etc.

Ben-Gurion never agreed with killing British soldiers....Begin....Well yes.

Regardless, Israel didn't 'fight' Britain....The majority never agreed with the bombings.


I'm not sure about that, Stirling. You seem to be but I'm not. I know people who were there at that time, both British and Israeli, and the British really weren't wanted there at all.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Page 15 of 80 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine