You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?
November 16 2026 1.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?


Page 15 of 25 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
FinchleyEagle Flag 17 Apr 14 5.22pm

I hate to say it, as he writes for that despicable 'newspaper', but Martin Samuel has well and truly nailed it.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

eryr Flag Caerphillydelphia 17 Apr 14 5.22pm

Anyone know what these Villa sackings are about? Presume it's nothing to do with texts and team-sheets!?

 


Dulce et decorum est pro Palace mori

"Gee, you and I oughtta get on swell Mister Burton, as we're both Selts".
"No, I am a Selt. You are a Sunt."

"24 hours in a day, 24 beers in a case. Coincidence? I think not." ~ Stephen Wright

[Link]

rednblue Flag Lincolnshire 17 Apr 14 5.23pm

Looks like FYP fanzine have a lawyer whose contributed his view
[Link]
Seems to me that the only rule is not to disclose information (which Cardiff have done) - there's nothing about asking for it (which we have allegedly done). Would be bloody hilarious if Cardiff are the only ones punished for this!

 

MPE Flag Maidstone 17 Apr 14 5.26pm

What have Cardiff got to gain? They will not get the points! This is seriously unbelievable, this just shows OGS has no substance as a manager, as he had no plan b to change things around, how do they explain why Marshall was beaten 3 times? Is it because we knew what gloves he would be wearing? Always someone casting a cloud over anything good we do, I sincerely hope Cardiff get beaten 4 times now, and end up rock bottom! And Dougie Freedman, what an absolute grass!

 


Just when I thought that I was out...........they pull me back in

SnapperKain Flag SE25 6PU 17 Apr 14 5.28pm

This has all the makings of a daytime soap opera with subterfuge, cloak and dagger dealings, accusations of betrayal, power crazed megalomaniac with Simon Cowell's trouser sense and Gadaffi's sunglasses and a national news organisation (namely the BBC) writing conspiracy theories penned by a supporter of a rival, complete with spelling mistakes and errors. You watch, it'll be coming soon to one of those crap Sky/Virgin channels scheduled between "Here comes Honey Boo Boo" and "Gypsy Sisters" or something.

It'll probably be called "Tan the man with no Plan"...

Edited by SnapperKain (17 Apr 2014 5.31pm)

 


The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 17 Apr 14 5.36pm

Quote alaneagle1 at 14 Apr 2014 9.43pm

I'll help EVERTON.
PALACE TEAM FOR WEDNESDAY.

Speroni
Mariappa
Ward
Ledley
Dann
Delaney
Puncheon
Jedinak
Jerome
Chamakh
Bolasie

Edited by alaneagle1 (14 Apr 2014 10.14pm)


Lads i gave Martinez the Palace Line up in advance.!!!
made all the difference 2-3 2-3

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

ianh Flag London 17 Apr 14 5.44pm

Cardiff's letter claims it was an "unexpected result"
how can a team in a higher league position and on the back of a victory over Chelsea beating a relegation struggler be "unexpected"

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 17 Apr 14 5.44pm

Graham Taylor just said on 5Live this kind of thing happens all the time and Cardiff should've just kept quiet about it. Scoffed at the idea the result of the game was in any doubt at all.

F*ck off Tan, you odious turd.

Edited by Seth (17 Apr 2014 5.47pm)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 17 Apr 14 5.48pm

Quote eryr at 17 Apr 2014 5.22pm

Anyone know what these Villa sackings are about? Presume it's nothing to do with texts and team-sheets!?


Bullying and criticising training program

 

peterg Flag Anerley 17 Apr 14 5.50pm

"Unexpected result" b*llocks. Not here in SE25 it wasn't. We just beat Chelski fair and square (maybe Cardiff missed that) and Cardiff were there for the taking. Crap owner, crap manager, crap supporters.

Name the three teams you most want to go down.

1 Cardiff
2 Cardiff
3 Cardiff

Edited by peterg (17 Apr 2014 5.53pm)

 


The right place at the right time

wayne80 Flag Eastbourne 17 Apr 14 5.59pm

Sour grapes. I'd be flabergasted if this went anywhere and if it does it would be a complete travesty. If Sunderland field an ineligable player for 4 games and only get a fine then how can they punish us any differently.

 


Rachid Harkouks passport was lost in the post ......Honest.

Team of the 80's, well we were for a few months in the autumn of 1979...
(Insert name of latest manager) Red And Blue Army
RIP staffie most helpful hol member and all round good bloke.

glimpse31 Flag london 17 Apr 14 6.14pm

This will go somewhere. It won't tarnish our amazing survival but it will cost money. I have a feeling, with the bbc being involved, there's a lot of genuine evidence and unfortunately we've been caught at it. I do believe however that yes, this is rife and other clubs including Cardiff are doing the same. We were just a little naive in this instance and didn't cover our arse. Oh well, wouldn't cry over it.

 

Lucas Oliver Flag Miles away 17 Apr 14 6.36pm

Just emailed the team sheet for the 4-0 defeat at Fulham to Cardiff. Experimenting with Speroni out wide feeding Gabbidon up top in a 2-2-6 formation.

 


Nope it's not my name

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 17 Apr 14 6.43pm

Quote The Sash at 17 Apr 2014 3.43pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 17 Apr 2014 1.37pm

Quote Baldfella at 17 Apr 2014 12.37pm

Quote fed up eagle at 17 Apr 2014 12.34pm

Apparently Cardiff are trying to say that the result we got there should not stand due to the supposed leak.
This smacks of desperation on Cardiff's part but I wouldn't put it past the powers that be to screw us over.
This story is on the BBC sport website.

Thoughts?

Not against you personally mate but you're the most recent poster that seems to think the powers that be would want to "screw us over" ! What do you base this on ?

Complete rubbish, Palace make the same contributions towards their partition in the Premier League, they will get same treatment as any other club.

As stated before: SECTION B Rule B15 states: "In all matters and transactions relating to the league each club shall behave towards each other club and the league with the utmost good faith".

SECTION B Rule 17 goes on, "A Club shall not without the Board’s prior written consent either during its membership of the League or at any time after its membership has terminated disclose or divulge either directly or indirectly to any Person whatsoever or otherwise make use of any confidential information as to the business or finances of the League or any other Club or any of their dealings, transactions or affairs or as to any other matters which may come to its knowledge by reason
of its membership save to statutory and regulatory authorities or as may be required by law or to such Officials and Auditors of that Club to whom such disclosure is strictly necessary for the purpose of their duties and then only to the extent so necessary".
That to me is what Cardiff may be using as justification for their complaint, I may be wrong but as I read that as a non Englishman, it could also implicate Cardiff for their failings.

Also there is no mention of this type of issue in APPENDIX 5 & 6 Managers and clubs code of conduct.

So unless the Premier league introduce a new rule, it's a storm in a teacup, as this sort of thing has been going on for years, even when I was playing it was going on, every club tried to get their opponents lineup before they named theirs, and I retired in 1977, it's called trying to outwit your opponent.

Exactly - As I said earlier, there is no actual 'rule' that has been broken, you could argue if we did do this then we went against a very shaky and vague ethical 'guidleine' to which no-one can actually pass a judgement on


So you're saying that some clubs don't get better treatment than others? Man utd don't get certain decisions that we wouldn't? You can dismiss what I say as complete rubbish, you're entitled to your opinion, but the fact is I have absolutely no faith in the people running the game. Every one knows that they love making examples of people, unless you're one of the big five of course.

 

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 17 Apr 14 7.00pm

I'd love to know what Tan's real beef with Moody is. Surely an overspend on the transfer budget for a multi billionaire isn't enough to produce such vitriol. As for super grass Freedman! All the love gone in an instant. I've gone from wishing him well to hoping his managerial career falls on it's arse in a heartbeat.

 

jpegnall Flag Surrey 17 Apr 14 7.14pm

Just sack Moody. If it is true he is an idiot anyway. Seriously, what did he think he was doing.

 

Leicestershireeagle Flag South Leicestershire 17 Apr 14 7.15pm

Interesting to see Monk say an outside source is trying to unsettle the club.

Tin-foil hat time, but who, out of the clubs around them, could possibly have an agenda specifically against Swansea, and could quite comfortably have contacts within the (Welsh) press?

Hmmmm.

Anyway, I don't think there's ever been any doubt that we probably sourced a likely Cardiff lineup, whether that be through empirical and historical evidence, thorough preparation and scouting and so on.

However, reading FYP's piece, from a lawyer no less, it seems that we have be all accounts don't nothing wrong, and by all accounts Cardiff are actually drawing negative attention to theirselves and nothing more.

I can't for a second imagine that Moody or anyone else in the club would be as stupid as to text a mate and offer a bribe or a payment. I can believe however, that if asked politely, there'd be enough disillusioned staff that would happily tell Moody whatever he wanted.

Either way, the sooner the league come and say one or another , whether there is a case to answer or not, the better.

 


RED AND BLUE ARMY!

laddo Flag london 17 Apr 14 7.20pm

Have a feeling Moody will go which is a great shame. Ultimately all clubs do it and at the same time such info rarely makes a difference to the result.

Freedman is a fcuking Cnut. Pure and simple. Bitter and jealous at what we have achieved without him. He is dead to me now.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

mariajh Flag Dartford 17 Apr 14 7.20pm

We can't be deducted points if Sunderland weren't. They've only got to look at our team selection, did it change? No, we've had the same starting 11 for week (barring injuries). And as far as Dougie is concerned, just about sums him up. He left when he got offered more money, obviously has no love of the club, forget about him now, we've got a fantastic manager with a great back room staff...get behind them.

 

homes Flag New Eltham 17 Apr 14 7.22pm

Quote jpegnall at 17 Apr 2014 7.14pm

Just sack Moody. If it is true he is an idiot anyway. Seriously, what did he think he was doing.


all i know about moody is that he landed every single target that Pulis wanted. What warrants him being labeled an idiot

 


IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".

Page 15 of 25 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?