This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
It was Peter Hargreaves' opinion you were dismissing! Clearly on reflection you have rightly withdrawn it. Elephants value the older member's of their herd and rely on them to find water in periods of extreme drought. You dismiss old people's opinions at your peril young man! My attack on Economists and students was obviously in retaliation and for a wind-up. I apologise for insulting or offending anyone I still think that Economists rely too much on assumptions for their forecasts and quite often get them wildly wrong.
This is literally what economics is haha. Producing statistical models of existing data based on past events and behaviours to predict future events and behaviours to as closer degree of certainty as possible. I found it fascinating to study.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 06 May 16 11.10am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by DanH
This is literally what economics is haha. Producing statistical models of existing data based on past events and behaviours to predict future events and behaviours to as closer degree of certainty as possible. I found it fascinating to study. I'm sure it is fascinating Dan and a worthwhile career. I was only retaliating to a crass comment, and went a bit OTT with my response. Regards good buddy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
I'm sure it is fascinating Dan and a worthwhile career. I was only retaliating to a crass comment, and went a bit OTT with my response. Regards good buddy. Good day to you sir.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 06 May 16 11.14am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
Could there be a consensus?! There is a value to learning per se. There is generally a value to taking a degree,including an economics one (and speaking as someone who did a part economics degree). But, there is not necessarily any automatic correlation between academic study/achievement and "general nous" or business acumen, in the sense of the university study having led to it. Take my profession as a lawyer.Many of the sharpest and most effective lawyers I've come across don't have a law degree.The skills they have are completely unconnected to those relating to and good for the academic study of law.Similarly,some of the sharpest and most successful business people generally I've come across never went to uni and often thy are somewhat more savvy than many of those who have. Great post... good observation legal.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Get off your high horse Mr Stalker. You'll find me to be a very reasonable and fair poster with those that post sensibly. However, when someone has an attack on me, I come out guns blazing with no holds barred. On this occasion, he made the outrageous assertion that old white men's opinions are not valid, so I sent in the attack dogs. With you, it is different... you seem to stalk my posts with your childish snidey remarks and put downs on just about every topic I get involved in. If you keep it up I'll continue to have spats with you, but you could grow up and just ignore my posts. You'll see that I have apologised in the post above following his retraction of his insult to me. I have no gears to grind with you or anybody else on here, so I'd appreciate your co-operation.
Why do I have to ignore your posts? I have as much right to challenge them as anyone else. I don't know why you have this perception that I am stalking your posts - I read the thread, and commented - that's how a forum works. I have no issues with you, but I'm not going to hold off challenging a point of yours that I disagree with just because you perceive it as 'childish' or 'snidey'. Fair play for apologising.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 06 May 16 11.48am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Why do I have to ignore your posts? I have as much right to challenge them as anyone else. I don't know why you have this perception that I am stalking your posts - I read the thread, and commented - that's how a forum works. I have no issues with you, but I'm not going to hold off challenging a point of yours that I disagree with just because you perceive it as 'childish' or 'snidey'. Fair play for apologising. Sorry, but it does seem that you have been "on my case" previously.... and regarding this topic, you steamed in and made no reference or allowance for the fact that I was provoked before I had a go at students. I have no problem with anyone challenging the points I make on any topic, and if as you say, you have no issues with me, then I look forward to our next debate. I am not above apologising when I'm wrong or have behaved in an unsocial or aggressive/unfair manner. Regards
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Sorry, but it does seem that you have been "on my case" previously.... and regarding this topic, you steamed in and made no reference or allowance for the fact that I was provoked before I had a go at students. I have no problem with anyone challenging the points I make on any topic, and if as you say, you have no issues with me, then I look forward to our next debate. I am not above apologising when I'm wrong or have behaved in an unsocial or aggressive/unfair manner. Regards Ok, no problem. Until next time
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 06 May 16 11.53am | |
|---|---|
|
Now then....... behave.... "young man"
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by big_palace_fan
Looked at OU Economics but it was 6 years (part time) and £16,000 What can one do in a year?
|
|
|
Originally posted by johnfirewall
Looked at OU Economics but it was 6 years (part time) and £16,000 What can one do in a year? Could you expand please
|
|
| Tom-the-eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by big_palace_fan
Simon Wren Lewis is a fellow at Merton College, Oxford and an Economics professor in the department there. If anyone needed further reassurance that we would be worse off economically outside of the EU here it is: This is complete conjecture, nobody knows what would happen re the economy. There are many who believe that within a few years our economy will surpass its current level. Particularly when you consider the colossal savings we would make (did you know Spain are paid 110 million Euros pa to support its bullfighting industry?) Economy aside, what are your thoughts as to the eradication of our culture and loss of sovereignty? What about the 50 year old housewife who can’t get a job at Costa Coffee because they only want to employ 20 year old Polish girls, or the builder who can’t support his family due to foreign workers under cutting him as they live 10 to a house. As a young man and a student I’m sure you are very smart etc., however (and I say this respectfully) you have little real life experience or do you have any first-hand knowledge of what the country used to be like before Europe. The state of the country’s economy is paramount, however, there are many, many other factors of at least equal importance to consider. Tom PS: your earlier post is not correct An extra years education is one of the best investments anyone can make with respect to increase in wages. The best thing you can do to increase your earnings is to work for yourself.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
I think it depends on what you mean by 'good for the economy'. You can be a nation of dirt poor farmers and workers, who live on subsistence wages, ruled by a rich minority, and that can be very good for the economy. What is 'good for the economy' isn't the same as good for society. Slavery was amazing for the US economy in the until the rise of industrialism, at which point it was looking increasingly like being a liability going forwards (slaves are surprisingly expensive and its problematic when you need an educated but disposable workforce).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| Hoof Hearted 12 May 16 10.38am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by big_palace_fan
Simon Wren Lewis is a fellow at Merton College, Oxford and an Economics professor in the department there. If anyone needed further reassurance that we would be worse off economically outside of the EU here it is: It would be interesting to know what Simon Wren Lewis' economic predictions were before the decision not to adopt the Euro and remain with the Pound in 1999. A lot of eminent economists were predicting the same economic "Armageddon" as they are now about leaving the EU and yet here we are 16 years later with the best economy of all the EU countries. Just like you would check a horse's form in the Derby, I'd like to know this bloke's form. He might be a 100/1 duffer with no decent form for all we know. Little boys crying wolf perhaps? Why should we take them seriously now when they were so wrong in 1999?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
This is complete conjecture, nobody knows what would happen re the economy. There are many who believe that within a few years our economy will surpass its current level. Particularly when you consider the colossal savings we would make (did you know Spain are paid 110 million Euros pa to support its bullfighting industry?) Economy aside, what are your thoughts as to the eradication of our culture and loss of sovereignty? What about the 50 year old housewife who can’t get a job at Costa Coffee because they only want to employ 20 year old Polish girls, or the builder who can’t support his family due to foreign workers under cutting him as they live 10 to a house. As a young man and a student I’m sure you are very smart etc., however (and I say this respectfully) you have little real life experience or do you have any first-hand knowledge of what the country used to be like before Europe. The state of the country’s economy is paramount, however, there are many, many other factors of at least equal importance to consider. Tom PS: your earlier post is not correct An extra years education is one of the best investments anyone can make with respect to increase in wages. The best thing you can do to increase your earnings is to work for yourself. The clue is in the OP's ''one of''.
Time to move forward together. |
|
|
Originally posted by big_palace_fan
Could you expand please What are the quicker, cheaper alternatives to recieve some sort of worthwhile qualifiaction in that field?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
This is complete conjecture, nobody knows what would happen re the economy. There are many who believe that within a few years our economy will surpass its current level. Particularly when you consider the colossal savings we would make (did you know Spain are paid 110 million Euros pa to support its bullfighting industry?) Economy aside, what are your thoughts as to the eradication of our culture and loss of sovereignty? What about the 50 year old housewife who can’t get a job at Costa Coffee because they only want to employ 20 year old Polish girls, or the builder who can’t support his family due to foreign workers under cutting him as they live 10 to a house. As a young man and a student I’m sure you are very smart etc., however (and I say this respectfully) you have little real life experience or do you have any first-hand knowledge of what the country used to be like before Europe. The state of the country’s economy is paramount, however, there are many, many other factors of at least equal importance to consider. Tom PS: your earlier post is not correct An extra years education is one of the best investments anyone can make with respect to increase in wages. The best thing you can do to increase your earnings is to work for yourself. I understand your points, you are mistaken on education, estimates to return on education are anything from about 5-20% depending on what you do, your demographic etc etc. How many financial returns can provide this? Working for yourself and obtaining extra education are not mutually exclusive. Furthermore, I see your points about fustrations with immigrants etc etc. but I really think you should think harder about who really is causing the problems whatever they are in your life. Is a yougn eastern european woman working in costa really the cause of your life's problems, or is it tax avoiding corporations stopping the government having ample money for education, and a self perpetuating elite ruling society. The housewives fundamental problem is that she did not pick up enough education - the governments fault, not the migrant. Just because she is the most obvious problem, it doesn't mean she is the real problem. Migrants may take jobs, but they also create jobs - 1/7 new business is set up by an EU immigrant. They are net fiscal contributors, and as for comments about overcrowding/using public resources etc - this is the governments job to adequately provide. Do not take the lie that there are not the resources to do so. Furthermore, there are no collosal savings from leaving the EU. As i've said before, sovereign debt riskiness would rise from uncertainty upon leaving and cancel any benefits. UK science industry would be ruined - incredibly reliant on EU funds. Having lived in London almost my whole life (barring my time away during my undergrad degree) I see "British culture" as one that is highly multicultural - those most worried about immigration are the those who live in areas with fewest immigrants! British culture is to lead and be influential. Not to sit on the sidelines and watch the world's great power becoming increasingly disinterested in us. We are leaders.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 12 May 16 5.37pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by big_palace_fan
I understand your points, you are mistaken on education, estimates to return on education are anything from about 5-20% depending on what you do, your demographic etc etc. How many financial returns can provide this? Working for yourself and obtaining extra education are not mutually exclusive. Furthermore, I see your points about fustrations with immigrants etc etc. but I really think you should think harder about who really is causing the problems whatever they are in your life. Is a yougn eastern european woman working in costa really the cause of your life's problems, or is it tax avoiding corporations stopping the government having ample money for education, and a self perpetuating elite ruling society. The housewives fundamental problem is that she did not pick up enough education - the governments fault, not the migrant. Just because she is the most obvious problem, it doesn't mean she is the real problem. Migrants may take jobs, but they also create jobs - 1/7 new business is set up by an EU immigrant. They are net fiscal contributors, and as for comments about overcrowding/using public resources etc - this is the governments job to adequately provide. Do not take the lie that there are not the resources to do so. Furthermore, there are no collosal savings from leaving the EU. As i've said before, sovereign debt riskiness would rise from uncertainty upon leaving and cancel any benefits. UK science industry would be ruined - incredibly reliant on EU funds. Having lived in London almost my whole life (barring my time away during my undergrad degree) I see "British culture" as one that is highly multicultural - those most worried about immigration are the those who live in areas with fewest immigrants! British culture is to lead and be influential. Not to sit on the sidelines and watch the world's great power becoming increasingly disinterested in us. We are leaders. You sound "brainwashed". Answer my question about Simon Wren Lewis' "form" if you will. Thanks.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
You sound "brainwashed". Answer my question about Simon Wren Lewis' "form" if you will. Thanks. If you call rationally looking at the facts brainwashed then sure. In my eyes its a simple equation Pro of being in minus some workers wages possibly suppressed, general point about people not liking migrants in their communities (one I disagree with - they are pointing fingers at the wrong people), perhaps some notion that sovereignty isn't entirely ours but shared in an international community. Pros of being out Cons of being out
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.