You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The McCanns
November 21 2026 10.40pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The McCanns


Page 15 of 16 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
Invalid user 2019 Flag 08 May 19 8.41pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

We could invest even more money into the McCann situation....but the elites have been doing that on our behalf for how many years now?. Ultimately perhaps the McCanns were too smart and too lucky for anything to come of it.


Edited by Stirlingsays (06 May 2019 4.23pm)

I operate from a perspective that we'll never truly know what happened at this point. I'm with you on the money point though. I'm all for people individually donating where they wish, but when it's countless millions from the public purse it doesn't sit well with me. It's not a stretch to say that lives could've been saved with those resources and the media gaze had instead been placed on more recent missing children.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 08 May 19 8.56pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Just seen this thread(again etal) & having just been in the Algarve, got back today, NO ONE is in the slightest bothered about the McCanns.

As far as the people who WE spoke to, it happened, its a shame, but loads of local kids go missing as well. What ever happened to all the missing kids in this country from decades ago?

just saying.

It does sound like a harsh approach, but it's a valuable and sobering perspective to highlight too. It shines a light on the constant media obsession with the case here and how it's impacted the national psyche.

It's in the media's interest to have go to cases that they can pontificate about for a decade. For them it's more like a soap storyline that the public become engrossed in rather than trying to help solve a crime. I wonder how many other missing kids' plights have been snuffed out or not properly investigated or funded due to the weight this case carries.


 

becky Flag over the moon 08 May 19 9.09pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Or her parents could have shaken her to death and lobbed her down a well. It would be nice to know, wouldn't it?

Perhaps we could invest time and resources into investigating the matter?

Oh no, wait: let's talk about knifings in London instead and then go ballistic and start insulting everyone when we're unable to take on and digest very simple words.

What an absolute intellect void this thread is.

Edited by ChrisGC (08 May 2019 5.15pm)

12 years and over £12 million and NOT ONE SINGLE line of inquiry has led anywhere - they know nothing more today than they did 12 years ago, except (in some cases) who didn't do it.

What chance is there, realistically, of suddenly finding a fresh piece of conclusive evidence that will ever solve this case? I would suspect none at all.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 08 May 19 9.57pm

Originally posted by becky

12 years and over £12 million and NOT ONE SINGLE line of inquiry has led anywhere - they know nothing more today than they did 12 years ago, except (in some cases) who didn't do it.

What chance is there, realistically, of suddenly finding a fresh piece of conclusive evidence that will ever solve this case? I would suspect none at all.

More chance in my opinion of success then spending a single bean on knife crime without addressing community enablement, which was my original point.

The fact that it's almost hopeless is what I'm getting at.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 08 May 19 9.59pm

Originally posted by dollardays


You've spend the entire thread talking about devoting money to Maddie, so the irony is lost on you not me and I've deflected from nothing.

If you want to talk about this issue in a serious way, I suggest that you attempt to do so. My comment and suggestion of where I think our attention and resources should be reflect the seriousness of the topic at hand. If you want to instead endlessly rinse a dark and depressing topic for some kind of forum thrill or point scoring you keep at it.

The clue is in the thread title ffs.

Just another poster who thinks they're more intelligent then they are. Embarrassing.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 08 May 19 10.26pm

Originally posted by dollardays

I operate from a perspective that we'll never truly know what happened at this point. I'm with you on the money point though. I'm all for people individually donating where they wish, but when it's countless millions from the public purse it doesn't sit well with me. It's not a stretch to say that lives could've been saved with those resources and the media gaze had instead been placed on more recent missing children.

In terms of guilt and innocence I've been in both camps over the McCann incident. My automatic bias was obviously towards innocence at first because of how most of the media presented the case and of how the McCanns front up.

When I looked into the evidence side of things I ended up 65/35 with accidental death and cover up.

Sure I could be wrong.....I think it happened once in 92.

As for the money spent on it. Initially I think few of us would have had a problem: a missing child is a missing child. However, after a time it really hasn't been defensible from a balanced and/or rational perspective. However, Maddie is a headline and the politician who says no gets the hitjob articles.


Edited by Stirlingsays (08 May 2019 10.27pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Invalid user 2019 Flag 08 May 19 10.28pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

More chance in my opinion of success then spending a single bean on knife crime without addressing community enablement, which was my original point.

The fact that it's almost hopeless is what I'm getting at.

Is your post no longer 'ironic' Chris? Becky is entirely right in what she says. , which mirrored my POV. And again, just because one person here said early on that the money should be spend on knife crime instead, why on earth are you suggesting that those are the two options at hand. They clearly aren't.

If you want to talk about knife crime, there are plenty of threads for that, and this isn't one of them. The very real issue here is whether the money 12 years and over £12 million are a worthwhile ongoing expense, and beyond that, whether targetting this money at other missing children would've made more of a difference. Logically it would've done.

Edited by dollardays (08 May 2019 10.29pm)

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 08 May 19 10.38pm

Originally posted by becky

12 years and over £12 million and NOT ONE SINGLE line of inquiry has led anywhere - they know nothing more today than they did 12 years ago, except (in some cases) who didn't do it.

What chance is there, realistically, of suddenly finding a fresh piece of conclusive evidence that will ever solve this case? I would suspect none at all.

Tragically, almost no chance. You're bang on in my view with what has become the futility of it all. It's turned into an something that's distasteful and yet always has legs due to the media obsession surrounding it.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 08 May 19 10.39pm

Originally posted by dollardays

Is your post no longer 'ironic' Chris? Becky is entirely right in what she says. , which mirrored my POV. And again, just because one person here said early on that the money should be spend on knife crime instead, why on earth are you suggesting that those are the two options at hand. They clearly aren't.

If you want to talk about knife crime, there are plenty of threads for that, and this isn't one of them. The very real issue here is whether the money 12 years and over £12 million are a worthwhile ongoing expense, and beyond that, whether targetting this money at other missing children would've made more of a difference. Logically it would've done.

Edited by dollardays (08 May 2019 10.29pm)

You're not actually reading my posts, are you?

Re-read the final sentence ffs, what are you arguing with?

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 08 May 19 10.40pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

In terms of guilt and innocence I've been in both camps over the McCann incident. My automatic bias was obviously towards innocence at first because of how most of the media presented the case and of how the McCanns front up.

When I looked into the evidence side of things I ended up 65/35 with accidental death and cover up.

Sure I could be wrong.....I think it happened once in 92.

As for the money spent on it. Initially I think few of us would have had a problem: a missing child is a missing child. However, after a time it really hasn't been defensible from a balanced and/or rational perspective. However, Maddie is a headline and the politician who says no gets the hitjob articles.


Edited by Stirlingsays (08 May 2019 10.27pm)

Yes, it's certainly an incident where a couple of different scenarios make sense. All disconcerting in their own way.

I tend to agree that enough time has passed that tragically its very unlikely that this is going to be resolved, and it's become the endless investigation that nobody dare call time on.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 08 May 19 11.22pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

You're not actually reading my posts, are you?

Re-read the final sentence ffs, what are you arguing with?


My point is that in your previous post that both Becky and I replied to, and indeed all previous to it, it wasn't at all clear to either of us that you thought a continued spend on the search for Maddie was a bad idea.

So your view now is that the search for her is completely hopeless, but preferable to spending on inner city knife violence!! Great, I'm not sure that this is the option on the table anyway, but thanks for your ongoing mantra pertaining to it.

My straightforward view is that the endless search for, publicity for, and funds for Maddie, in part snuffs out good work in finding other missing children. That's it.

Perhaps there are aspects of the McCann case or coverage of it that you wish to join us in discussing?


Edited by dollardays (09 May 2019 1.08am)

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 08 May 19 11.28pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

You're not actually reading my posts, are you?

Re-read the final sentence ffs, what are you arguing with?

Are you?

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 May 19 8.05am

Originally posted by BarEagle

Are you?

Wahey, here he is: long time no see. Did you forget the login details to your other account Maple?

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 May 19 8.16am

Originally posted by dollardays


My point is that in your previous post that both Becky and I replied to, and indeed all previous to it, it wasn't at all clear to either of us that you thought a continued spend on the search for Maddie was a bad idea.

So your view now is that the search for her is completely hopeless, but preferable to spending on inner city knife violence!! Great, I'm not sure that this is the option on the table anyway, but thanks for your ongoing mantra pertaining to it.

My straightforward view is that the endless search for, publicity for, and funds for Maddie, in part snuffs out good work in finding other missing children. That's it.

Perhaps there are aspects of the McCann case or coverage of it that you wish to join us in discussing?


Edited by dollardays (09 May 2019 1.08am)

If the point was a barn door you'd be swinging at it with banjo and still missing it.

You're just looping back into the same couple of sentences without taking on board any reply. Good luck to you.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 May 19 9.01am

Their chips are ok but I still prefer to make my own.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Invalid user 2019 Flag 09 May 19 12.55pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

If the point was a barn door you'd be swinging at it with banjo and still missing it.

You're just looping back into the same couple of sentences without taking on board any reply. Good luck to you.

Yes, yes. All very interesting. Perhaps there are aspects of the McCann case or coverage of it that you wish to join us in discussing?


Edited by dollardays (09 May 2019 2.09pm)

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 09 May 19 12.58pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Their chips are ok but I still prefer to make my own.

£12 million pounds worth coming right up.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 23 Feb 20 8.07am

In the next month it's that time of the year folks and no I don't mean the first buds in spring. Yup the police funding for the search for Maddie is about to run out so very predictably I give this story from the police via the Daily Mail about a new lead.

[Link]

It's funny how these stories seem to surface just when the boys in blue need more money.

12 million and counting do they have a suspect? No, do they even have any firm evidence that would stand up in court? No. So far they have investigated leads of the quality that Maddie was seen with Lord Lucan* and Elvis in Albania etc.

Whatever has happened is a tragedy but it's time to stop the police gravy train. Thousands of people go missing each year and Inspector Knacker of the yard spends b*gger all trying to find them.

Until real evidence crops up (likely to be by accident somebody walking a dog etc.) this has to stop.

*Remember the non story about Lucan being in a care home in Australia what has happened to that. Still no pictures or a name or any evidence from the person making the claim. I said at the time poor journalism they should not have printed the story unless he provided proof. Anyway I know for a fact that the care home is in Grimsby this bloke in the pub told me so.

 


One more point

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Jun 20 6.51am

I thought I would give my post from Feb a little bump as the story is back in the headlines.

Of course I hope the police solve the case but so far the evidence against this new suspect is a little thin.

But as said in February every time the funding issue comes up we get a new lead.

 


One more point

Spiderman Flag Horsham 04 Jun 20 7.01am

Originally posted by Badger11

I thought I would give my post from Feb a little bump as the story is back in the headlines.

Of course I hope the police solve the case but so far the evidence against this new suspect is a little thin.

But as said in February every time the funding issue comes up we get a new lead.

I said exactly the same when I read the story last night. Just over 1 year ago (May 2019) the Police had asked for more funding, presumably this last 1 year. I do not want to go over the case again, my views have been well published on here, but the time has come to end public funding on this

 

Page 15 of 16 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The McCanns