You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish unable to progress us


Page 15 of 16 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Feb 18 8.13pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

no read all, quality and experience was quoted would you want any of there second string, you and main only highlight what you will make you right, as someone said read all the post not one sided arguments bigger pictures

Best to have nothing to bring people into the game, occupy defenders and pull them around etc then.

 


COYP

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 16 Feb 18 8.30pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I am loath to speak for another poster, but where I read "insignificant" I read relatively trivial in the scheme of where this club is going.

I don't agree with everything you have said - much opinion filtered through red mist? - but you make some good points about the way SP has managed the squad and the fact that we have lost 2 managers who - unheard of in the Prem - have walked rather than be fired. Because of the money and prestige of Prem management, I suspect most head coaches will tolerate just about anything to stay in post. So why did 2 middle-ranking managers leave? Something is not right.

Then again - and I know a lot of posters are annoyed that this is raised each time SP is criticised - there is still the small fact that we are a club that has gone from c.10p in value that owned only its name to £150M and ownership of its whole capital infrastructure... in only 8 years.

As a small unfashionable club, we are still expanding in terms of enriching the brand image and non-TV commercial revenue. We are rebuilding the ground in a sensible progressive way - stand by stand. We do not have the funds of Liverpool or Spurs to do the whole lot in one go. We will improve the training facilities and academy but, unlike most of our competition, we are having to attempt this within the M25 where land is very scarce and very expensive.

At the playing end we give the appearance of an organisation still finding its way. At the corporate end recovery from near liquidation to a sound business unit is ongoing with the trajectory still upward. As anyone in commerce will tell you, we will see improvements in the former as the latter continues to grow.

Trouble is, the pace is probably too slow for most football fans.

Cheers. You read and understood my point correctly.

There’s no such thing as mid-table mediocrity in the Prem apart from Everton who were once one of the big boys. Every season a race to 40 pts and this is our place in the food chain.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (16 Feb 2018 9.20pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 16 Feb 18 8.43pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Insignificant? Totally disagree.

Letting us have only 1 fit striker in the premier league was completely reckless and ridiculous to boot. Lo and behold Benteke got injured not long after that p&ss poor decision was made to not sign Niasse/A. N. other.

Not replacing Mandanda is such a glaring mistake that it is literally costing us points per season, which we cannot afford.

Listening to Hodgson harp on about the pressing need to sign a goalie, messing around with Guaita, and not signing a keeper in the last window is also reckless and once again Parish is playing a foolish and senseless game with squad depth. He is also annoying the manager into the bargain, who clearly isnt happy with our 2 keepers, and the fact that we only have 2 in the first place.

Parish doesnt exactly have a strong history of keeping managers overly happy. Somehow Allardyce "retired from football" on his watch.

Lo and behold Jules immediately gets injured and now we have 1 fit keeper.

Whats your point about our signings not being good enough? That is once again Parish' fault as he has the ultimate say on who we buy, so you are making my point for me there mate.

Holloway had to beg to get fired/be ALLOWED to walk which was a nonsense.

As for Parish's attempts to move us forward and play on the front foot more, notice a pattern there? We tried it with Pardew to our ruination, and then Parish goes and makes the same mistake again with FDB, but on a spectacularly stupid scale, I must admit.

The pattern is Parish making the same bonehead mistakes year after year after year.

Not replacing Mandanda is literally costing us points per season ?Give it up.

The point about those very expensive players who most fans were very happy to see sign for us is that if they’d performed to a fraction of the level in front of goal you’d expect then we’d be sitting in the precious mid-table mediocre position this season you talk about.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 16 Feb 18 8.50pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Best to have nothing to bring people into the game, occupy defenders and pull them around etc then.

sorry Rudi explain the point your making? we have a new young striker that looked not to bad,the teams i said, dont have players sitting on the bench which scare teams, they may have numbers but not quality and experience and also we are having our worst injury list we cant replace all, selling teams in transfer market make it harder now to buy there 1st team players, when was the last time we held a club up to sell them a player, and now clubs wont sell unless they have a replacement, picture is not as clear or straight forward

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Feb 18 9.17pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

sorry Rudi explain the point your making? we have a new young striker that looked not to bad,the teams i said, dont have players sitting on the bench which scare teams, they may have numbers but not quality and experience and also we are having our worst injury list we cant replace all, selling teams in transfer market make it harder now to buy there 1st team players, when was the last time we held a club up to sell them a player, and now clubs wont sell unless they have a replacement, picture is not as clear or straight forward

Yeah I know, deep breath, everyone struggles and fails to get a 2nd striker to start the season when they knew they needed one 9 months ago.

Explain the point I'm making? If you don't know it's important to have ONE available striker over a number of games and not just 1 mast he in that situation that catches the opponent out then I'll leave it there.

Benteke could've been out for 4 months, September to end of December for all Parish knew. I'd rather us have a mediocre prem striker or one who has no quality as you claim than nobody at all and I'd bet every pound note Parish spends on himself in a week that he'd admit the same, only he hopes it never happens.

This doesn't happen once with us. It happens on a regular basis.

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 16 Feb 18 10.21pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Didnt ask for stats, I am asking about squad depth.

Please answer the question I asked, not the one you hoped I asked, but didn't.

Hodgson has worked miracles with what he has been given which illuminates our goal difference. Despite demanding a keeper publicly last month he was let down by Parish.

Once again - name a team with worse squad depth (aka less cover of adequate experience/quality) in both attack and in goal.

But his reply blew a big hole in your continual repeating the same thing. If we are scoring, it doesn't matter how many strikers we have and we still have an International keeper in goal.
You cant name an alternative viable replacement to Parish, so there is little point you keep saying he should move aside.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 16 Feb 18 10.58pm

Am I allowed to say stop bellyaching and just get behind the team. ....
Its not Parishes fault we have so many injuries...... or that the 30 mil striker he bought has lost his mojo. s*** happens we have to deal with it and stick together.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Feb 18 11.04pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

Am I allowed to say stop bellyaching and just get behind the team. ....
Its not Parishes fault we have so many injuries...... or that the 30 mil striker he bought has lost his mojo. s*** happens we have to deal with it and stick together.

There's no denying that. And we always do.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Feb 18 11.16pm

Originally posted by Painter

But his reply blew a big hole in your continual repeating the same thing. If we are scoring, it doesn't matter how many strikers we have and we still have an International keeper in goal.
You cant name an alternative viable replacement to Parish, so there is little point you keep saying he should move aside.

I'm sure Maine will reply but his reply didn't blow a big hole in Maine's post. If it did, I expect half the league to have no striker as back up. Do you reckon that'll happen at all in the future? 1 striker per team, especially those fighting relegation? Yeah let's all make it equally harder. Er, no.

Were we scoring much without a striker? How about for 4 months? Benteke or any player can get injured on 1st September or 1st February.

Again ffs, nobody is saying an alternative for Parish as chairman but Parish is either playing squad Kerplunk or doesn't appreciate the necessary needs or respect the managers' desperate requirements. Therefore in these crucial moments something needs changing. That is bl33ding obvious and only Parish's relatives would disagree.

The people defending 1 striker and 2 keepers on this thread are bonkers, and they don't have the excuse of ffp that we didn't have the funds because we were supplying the money, too late.

 


COYP

Den1923 Flag 16 Feb 18 11.36pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think you'll find many of us providing constructive criticism have been supporting for a long time and it's because we know how precious prem status is. We know we're not as likely to bounce back and our stay back in the championship could be a decade. What happens to the new stand then? What happens if it is built and we're running at a loss? It's the Americans' loss until we bounce back but these things are taken a bit lightly when such things as a 2nd striker and lack of keeper back up are easily excused, and being repeated mistakes.

Just respect football people who are presumably respected when hired.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (16 Feb 2018 4.53pm)

Well said and just think how the value of the club will plumit if we lose our PL status and all the revenue that comes with it!

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 17 Feb 18 1.21am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I'm sure Maine will reply but his reply didn't blow a big hole in Maine's post. If it did, I expect half the league to have no striker as back up. Do you reckon that'll happen at all in the future? 1 striker per team, especially those fighting relegation? Yeah let's all make it equally harder. Er, no.

Were we scoring much without a striker? How about for 4 months? Benteke or any player can get injured on 1st September or 1st February.

Again ffs, nobody is saying an alternative for Parish as chairman but Parish is either playing squad Kerplunk or doesn't appreciate the necessary needs or respect the managers' desperate requirements. Therefore in these crucial moments something needs changing. That is bl33ding obvious and only Parish's relatives would disagree.

The people defending 1 striker and 2 keepers on this thread are bonkers, and they don't have the excuse of ffp that we didn't have the funds because we were supplying the money, too late.

The only thing with a big hole in it is Parish's strategy on managing our squad and executing transfers.

The fact remains that we are one back spasm away from Dion Henry starting in the premier league and we were the only team in the modern history of the premier league unable to field a single striker when Benteke went down.

If you are happy about that, and also think those situations were both totally unavoidable, then I have some time shares in Lanzarote you might be interested in.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 17 Feb 18 2.49am

I don't take relegation lightly, but frankly what "value"? And what "values"? there is more to football then the sickening money of the PL.

Originally posted by Den1923

Well said and just think how the value of the club will plumit if we lose our PL status and all the revenue that comes with it!

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 17 Feb 18 8.01am

The EPL is very close at the bottom of the table this year. We are a point off the drop zone with obvious long-term deficiencies in the squad. For whatever reason, these have not been addressed. Could be any number of reasons:
No cash, FFP, negligence, players don't want to come here, agents demands, etc, etc

and wasn't it Parish himself who said fans should not continually be grateful to CPFC2010 for saving the club, but to raise their expectations higher than just survival ? (paraphrasing)

In the end it's not my money, so the people running the club can do what they like. And overall, not too bad a job they are doing

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 17 Feb 18 10.23am

There are 6 big teams in the prem, then there's Everton and West ham, who could attach themselves to these, cos of ground and support base IMO. If West ham are run well,the sky's the limit with that ground deal.
The rest of us are basically the same. All potentially 25-35k per game and getting practically the same money every season. Teams like us and Bournemouth are a little behind because we have a lot of ground and infrastructure to catch up on, but basically parity is coming to the 14 of us who make up the numbers.
Then the future of all of us is in a cycle of about 10 years, where we blossom then fall from grace, then repeat again, probably.
We will get relegated again soon, if not this season in the foreseeable future, because we just can't grow enough within the financial constraints put in place by the big boys in order to keep the status quo. Let's be clear that is exactly what FFP is. Don't buy this bollocks about making sure clubs don't go out of existence, cos in reality who bar their own fans cares what happens to other clubs.
I say let the big 6 have a larger percentage of the overseas TV rights that they're bleating about in return for scrapping the phoney FFP regs they've helped produce. Then Sugar Daddies can come in and buy clubs and spend what they want and more City's, Chelsea's and PSG's can spring up. Hang on that's what they don't want isn't it? Would be interesting to see their reaction to a proposal like that.
So basically we are where we're gonna be unless a big investor can come in and buy us and spend what he wants. Until that let's just enjoy the ups and downs like we used to without the constant bleating.


 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 17 Feb 18 10.56am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

There are 6 big teams in the prem, then there's Everton and West ham, who could attach themselves to these, cos of ground and support base IMO. If West ham are run well,the sky's the limit with that ground deal.
The rest of us are basically the same. All potentially 25-35k per game and getting practically the same money every season. Teams like us and Bournemouth are a little behind because we have a lot of ground and infrastructure to catch up on, but basically parity is coming to the 14 of us who make up the numbers.
Then the future of all of us is in a cycle of about 10 years, where we blossom then fall from grace, then repeat again, probably.
We will get relegated again soon, if not this season in the foreseeable future, because we just can't grow enough within the financial constraints put in place by the big boys in order to keep the status quo. Let's be clear that is exactly what FFP is. Don't buy this bollocks about making sure clubs don't go out of existence, cos in reality who bar their own fans cares what happens to other clubs.
I say let the big 6 have a larger percentage of the overseas TV rights that they're bleating about in return for scrapping the phoney FFP regs they've helped produce. Then Sugar Daddies can come in and buy clubs and spend what they want and more City's, Chelsea's and PSG's can spring up. Hang on that's what they don't want isn't it? Would be interesting to see their reaction to a proposal like that.
So basically we are where we're gonna be unless a big investor can come in and buy us and spend what he wants. Until that let's just enjoy the ups and downs like we used to without the constant bleating.


I actually think West Ham’s ground is going against them if anything. It’s killed the club.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 17 Feb 18 11.38am

Good post Dangermouse especially the last sentence.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 Feb 18 11.41am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

There are 6 big teams in the prem, then there's Everton and West ham, who could attach themselves to these, cos of ground and support base IMO. If West ham are run well,the sky's the limit with that ground deal.
The rest of us are basically the same. All potentially 25-35k per game and getting practically the same money every season. Teams like us and Bournemouth are a little behind because we have a lot of ground and infrastructure to catch up on, but basically parity is coming to the 14 of us who make up the numbers.
Then the future of all of us is in a cycle of about 10 years, where we blossom then fall from grace, then repeat again, probably.
We will get relegated again soon, if not this season in the foreseeable future, because we just can't grow enough within the financial constraints put in place by the big boys in order to keep the status quo. Let's be clear that is exactly what FFP is. Don't buy this bollocks about making sure clubs don't go out of existence, cos in reality who bar their own fans cares what happens to other clubs.
I say let the big 6 have a larger percentage of the overseas TV rights that they're bleating about in return for scrapping the phoney FFP regs they've helped produce. Then Sugar Daddies can come in and buy clubs and spend what they want and more City's, Chelsea's and PSG's can spring up. Hang on that's what they don't want isn't it? Would be interesting to see their reaction to a proposal like that.
So basically we are where we're gonna be unless a big investor can come in and buy us and spend what he wants. Until that let's just enjoy the ups and downs like we used to without the constant bleating.


Excellent post talks a lot of sense if you continue to do this I will have to report you. What do you think this forum is for, considered intelligent posts?

 


One more point

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 Feb 18 11.44am

In order to '' progress '' us, in my opinion the key is identifying and retaining a good manager. And by that I mean keeping someone for a number of years rather than months.

We've had so many changes and so much instability at manager level that there is no embedded footballing philosophy, no consistent transfer policy, no consistent squad development, and youth team players rarely get opportunities to challenge for first team football as they are untrusted and unknown to the succession of managers we have had.

Now I know that's a tall order in modern day football and with the pressure that goes with trying to stay in the PL, managers are rarely given any time once results start to slip.

But for me, that's the challenge that Steve has to move the club away from an annual relegation battle.


 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Feb 18 3.08pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

In order to '' progress '' us, in my opinion the key is identifying and retaining a good manager. And by that I mean keeping someone for a number of years rather than months.

We've had so many changes and so much instability at manager level that there is no embedded footballing philosophy, no consistent transfer policy, no consistent squad development, and youth team players rarely get opportunities to challenge for first team football as they are untrusted and unknown to the succession of managers we have had.

Now I know that's a tall order in modern day football and with the pressure that goes with trying to stay in the PL, managers are rarely given any time once results start to slip.

But for me, that's the challenge that Steve has to move the club away from an annual relegation battle.


Wasn't that the plan for FdB?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Feb 18 3.20pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Wasn't that the plan for FdB?

That's what I thought when I read it. One small problem. The football strategy was naive.

 


COYP

Page 15 of 16 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us