You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go
November 16 2026 6.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson has to go


Page 15 of 18 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 17 Jan 19 11.52pm

Who would we replace him with, Sam? Pulliss? Someone who will require a large transfer kitty? SP and the Yanks haven't provided sufficient funds for significant signings for 3 windows. Paying him off will scupper any new signings, along with coaching staff.... watching question time and realised Diane Abbott looks like Flash out of Zootropolis, about as incentive as well...hope we beat the Scourers

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 Jan 19 11.57pm

Originally posted by Mathers

It’s all well and good that a lot of people think he’ll leave at the end of the season but how much closer to the relegation zone do we need to be to take some action THIS SEASON.

We are dangerously close to be cut adrift with the the bottom 7 teams to scrap it out. I genuinely think he might only have 4 league games left (Liverpool-A, Saints- A, Fulham - H, West Ham- H) and has to get a minimum of 6 points.

In which case I assume that you would be advocating Benitez getting the sack at Newcastle if you followed them.

And if you were a Burnley fan then you would have sacked Dyche a few weeks back.

As someone who seems to want Hodgson out, I ask again - who would you replace him with ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 18 Jan 19 12.12am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Here's my view.

Roy sets the team up, plays an active part in training and come match day that group of players are ready to compete and know what they have to do.

Outside of a core of the starting eleven plus one or two others, he hasn't got too many options. We have lacked game changers on the bench because the squad is light on quality. Hence the reluctance to use subs, although I think he could change things at least to give the opposition a different player to deal with.


But you can't hold him responsible for Ward and Sakho missing free headers - potential 4 more points. Or Zaha unable to score one on one's - point lost last Saturday - and there have been others. The stats show - and we can see for ourselves - that chance creation is not an issue but the finishing.

Unless I'm mistaken, after the Solanke deal fell through we were told there were five strikers on our wanted list. Where are they ? Or is the return of Benteke mean that we aren't looking any more ?


At Selhurst this season there have been two abject performances - Southampton and Chelsea. We got what we deserved from those games.


So yes, Roy's stats don't look great but they do not reflect the overall performance of the players.

Roy is directly responsible for setting the team up, directing training and instructing the coaching.

Therefore, he is directly responsible for the lack of ability of top, top players being unable to convert chances.

Why can't we finish? Because it's not being drilled into the team. It is absolutely criminal that we had 30 odd chances Vs Burnley and converted 2.

There is plan A and plan.... A. Yes, there's not strength in depth in the squad, fair enough. That said, it is apparent that our players spend all week practicing more without the ball than with it. It's about structure and shape. Great base, but after all the missed chances surely, the emphasis should be on finishing? Just get the wingers to practice putting the ball in/ making the correct decision regarding shots Vs passing and have the strikers (whoever plays that role) working on creating space and finishing. Stay onside and in the box!!!!

A training game of headers and volleys wouldn't go a miss ffs.


Edited by ChrisGC (18 Jan 2019 12.13am)

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 18 Jan 19 7.53am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Roy is directly responsible for setting the team up, directing training and instructing the coaching.

Therefore, he is directly responsible for the lack of ability of top, top players being unable to convert chances.

Why can't we finish? Because it's not being drilled into the team. It is absolutely criminal that we had 30 odd chances Vs Burnley and converted 2.

There is plan A and plan.... A. Yes, there's not strength in depth in the squad, fair enough. That said, it is apparent that our players spend all week practicing more without the ball than with it. It's about structure and shape. Great base, but after all the missed chances surely, the emphasis should be on finishing? Just get the wingers to practice putting the ball in/ making the correct decision regarding shots Vs passing and have the strikers (whoever plays that role) working on creating space and finishing. Stay onside and in the box!!!!

A training game of headers and volleys wouldn't go a miss ffs.


Edited by ChrisGC (18 Jan 2019 12.13am)

Strikers in general do the "finishing" we don't have any strikers fit or good enough.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 18 Jan 19 9.08am

Originally posted by Mathers

It’s all well and good that a lot of people think he’ll leave at the end of the season but how much closer to the relegation zone do we need to be to take some action THIS SEASON.

We are dangerously close to be cut adrift with the the bottom 7 teams to scrap it out. I genuinely think he might only have 4 league games left (Liverpool-A, Saints- A, Fulham - H, West Ham- H) and has to get a minimum of 6 points.

Being cut adrift with the bottom 7 is not an issue. Being cut adrift with the bottom 3 is, and we are nowhere near that.

Huddersfield and Fulham look doomed. We have more points on the board and superior goal difference to Cardiff, Southampton, Newcastle, Burnley and quite frankly we are better than all of those teams and all of them would have to get above us in the table.

We have strikers returning to fitness and are playing well as a team. Chance conversion is our only problem. Some of the panic and cries to sake the manager on here are quite baffling.

 

Mathers Flag 18 Jan 19 10.39am

Originally posted by NEILLO

In which case I assume that you would be advocating Benitez getting the sack at Newcastle if you followed them.

And if you were a Burnley fan then you would have sacked Dyche a few weeks back.

As someone who seems to want Hodgson out, I ask again - who would you replace him with ?

Not at all. I dont have a burning hatred of Hodgson at all i just think people need to wake up and realise we are in real danger of relegation this season. We cant just write off teams because they have had a bad 1st half to the season. West Brom were pretty much buried last season but still managed 11 points from the final 6 games so saying Fulham and Huddersfield are already gone is incredible naive.

Definitely not saying we should even contemplate the managerial dinosaurs- Hughes, Pardew, Allardyce, Pulis- but if we do slip closer to the relegation zone then changing the manager is likely to be the only option.

I would want Wilder(Sheff Utd), Rodgers (Celtic), Garcia (Marseille), Wenger (short term), Karanka (free) but its not my call.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 18 Jan 19 12.59pm

[Link]

Another piece just released this morning showing how much we're underachieving. Oh yeah you can't criticise roy, from Croydon, speech impediment and an old man so he gets a free ride.

 

fledgling Flag Beckenham 18 Jan 19 1.23pm

Originally posted by rikz

[Link]

Another piece just released this morning showing how much we're underachieving. Oh yeah you can't criticise roy, from Croydon, speech impediment and an old man so he gets a free ride.

I only skimmed the piece but I'm struggling to see how marquee signings on big wages bought pre-Hodgson strengthens the "Hodgson out" argument?

 

Painter Flag Croydon 18 Jan 19 1.48pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Roy is directly responsible for setting the team up, directing training and instructing the coaching.

Therefore, he is directly responsible for the lack of ability of top, top players being unable to convert chances.

Edited by ChrisGC (18 Jan 2019 12.13am)

Could you blame your driving instructor for you having an accident.

This is the same logic, as strikers missing as Roy coached them.

 

PatrickA Flag London 18 Jan 19 1.55pm

I have been disappointed with aspects of Hodgson’s management this season e.g the negativity for certain home games, the lack of tactical changes and the delay in reacting to what is happening during games.
However, I do have some sympathy with him having just watched today’s press conference.
Although he didn’t complain about it, he doesn’t seem to have much of a clue of what is happening in this transfer window.
Now he could be a good actor, but he seemed genuinely in the dark as if this is an area that’s outside his remit.
I’m bemused why he’s not more involved and why resources are not being made available.
Some will say it’s a negotiating tactic and that Hodgson doesn’t want the club to show its hand but I feel that he’s not being backed ( same as last January and to an extent in the summer).

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 18 Jan 19 2.05pm

Originally posted by rikz

[Link]

Another piece just released this morning showing how much we're underachieving. Oh yeah you can't criticise roy, from Croydon, speech impediment and an old man so he gets a free ride.

not sure about that shows us underachieving, but it does highlight how much we've drastically overcommitted on higher wages, leaving us with a crippling wage bill..

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 18 Jan 19 3.05pm

Originally posted by Mathers

Not at all. I dont have a burning hatred of Hodgson at all i just think people need to wake up and realise we are in real danger of relegation this season. We cant just write off teams because they have had a bad 1st half to the season. West Brom were pretty much buried last season but still managed 11 points from the final 6 games so saying Fulham and Huddersfield are already gone is incredible naive.

Definitely not saying we should even contemplate the managerial dinosaurs- Hughes, Pardew, Allardyce, Pulis- but if we do slip closer to the relegation zone then changing the manager is likely to be the only option.

I would want Wilder(Sheff Utd), Rodgers (Celtic), Garcia (Marseille), Wenger (short term), Karanka (free) but its not my call.

I don't disagree with you that relegation is a possibility. We are, once again, in a relegation battle.

And yes, it's still possible that teams beneath us could pick up suddenly - I haven't written anyone off yet, it's too soon.


But we are not in a Pardew like downward spiral. In my view it would be a mistake to replace Hodgson at this time.


As for your suggestions as a replacement, I think it's your turn to have a dose of reality !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 18 Jan 19 3.25pm

I find it amazing that we a constantly in a relegation battle. Lessons surely must have been learned - we have a good squad and although nothing is for granted there is something wrong in the set up. Roy is too negative at home. Attack! 8 defensive players at home is just not right. Have a go, encourage the players to express themselves, have no fear.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 18 Jan 19 3.28pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Roy is directly responsible for setting the team up, directing training and instructing the coaching.

Therefore, he is directly responsible for the lack of ability of top, top players being unable to convert chances.

Why can't we finish? Because it's not being drilled into the team. It is absolutely criminal that we had 30 odd chances Vs Burnley and converted 2.

There is plan A and plan.... A. Yes, there's not strength in depth in the squad, fair enough. That said, it is apparent that our players spend all week practicing more without the ball than with it. It's about structure and shape. Great base, but after all the missed chances surely, the emphasis should be on finishing? Just get the wingers to practice putting the ball in/ making the correct decision regarding shots Vs passing and have the strikers (whoever plays that role) working on creating space and finishing. Stay onside and in the box!!!!

A training game of headers and volleys wouldn't go a miss ffs.


Edited by ChrisGC (18 Jan 2019 12.13am)

Unless you have been doing a ' Bielsa ' I don't think you are qualified to comment on training practises.

You make it all sound so easy. It isn't. I played at a reasonable standard and coached teams for years after I stopped playing. So yes, you address the areas of weakness ( i.e. finishing in our case ) alongside the tactical stuff. And I've seen players score goals in training that they can only dream of replicating on a match day. Have a look at Palace TV and watch some of the goals scored in practise sessions. These are the same players that are missing chances come actual games..

Our conversion rate is a definite concern, but I would be more worried if we weren't creating chances at all.

Hodgson has not had the benefit of an out and out goalscorer worthy of the name at his disposal. And it looks increasingly like we are relying on Benteke to resolve that issue.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

michaelpearce Flag grays 18 Jan 19 5.33pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Unless you have been doing a ' Bielsa ' I don't think you are qualified to comment on training practises.

You make it all sound so easy. It isn't. I played at a reasonable standard and coached teams for years after I stopped playing. So yes, you address the areas of weakness ( i.e. finishing in our case ) alongside the tactical stuff. And I've seen players score goals in training that they can only dream of replicating on a match day. Have a look at Palace TV and watch some of the goals scored in practise sessions. These are the same players that are missing chances come actual games..

Our conversion rate is a definite concern, but I would be more worried if we weren't creating chances at all.

Hodgson has not had the benefit of an out and out goalscorer worthy of the name at his disposal. And it looks increasingly like we are relying on Benteke to resolve that issue.

yes he always looks down never up Chrisgc thinking, must of played a high standard of pub football,what happens in training sessions doesnt always work on match day no pressure on the training field, yes they do get paid shed loads, until you have played against them you find out they are worlds apart from us,yards quicker and faster thinking

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 18 Jan 19 5.51pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Unless you have been doing a ' Bielsa ' I don't think you are qualified to comment on training practises.

You make it all sound so easy. It isn't. I played at a reasonable standard and coached teams for years after I stopped playing. So yes, you address the areas of weakness ( i.e. finishing in our case ) alongside the tactical stuff. And I've seen players score goals in training that they can only dream of replicating on a match day. Have a look at Palace TV and watch some of the goals scored in practise sessions. These are the same players that are missing chances come actual games..

Our conversion rate is a definite concern, but I would be more worried if we weren't creating chances at all.

Hodgson has not had the benefit of an out and out goalscorer worthy of the name at his disposal. And it looks increasingly like we are relying on Benteke to resolve that issue.

Love this, "you're not qualified to comment, here's why my opinion is more valid"...
And you're less qualified than I am!

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 18 Jan 19 5.55pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

yes he always looks down never up Chrisgc thinking, must of played a high standard of pub football,what happens in training sessions doesnt always work on match day no pressure on the training field, yes they do get paid shed loads, until you have played against them you find out they are worlds apart from us,yards quicker and faster thinking

This is incorrect. In every profession it is proven that the more you practice, the better you are under real conditions.

"The training kicked in" is usually the first line of every fire/police/contact report for a reason.

As for pub football, nothing wrong with that pickle. Not that I've ever played it mind you.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 18 Jan 19 6.01pm

Originally posted by Painter

Could you blame your driving instructor for you having an accident.

This is the same logic, as strikers missing as Roy coached them.

I don't understand this analogy.

If you practice hard and are prepared, you pass your driving test.

If you train hard, specifically on shooting, you will score goals.

The competence of the instructor is relevant to success in both instances.

Edited by ChrisGC (18 Jan 2019 6.02pm)

 

jeeagles Flag 18 Jan 19 6.03pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Love this, "you're not qualified to comment, here's why my opinion is more valid"...
And you're less qualified than I am!

Haha, that’s why the internet is great. If you disagree I’ll belittle you at best or if all other arguments fail I’ll call you a nazi snowflake.

I was thinking about that how despite how many chances we had against Cardiff, Grimsby and Burnley many of them were just pot shots. Hence why we are only scoring stunners or penalties.

After one of the 2014 World Cup games, against Italy I think, Roy was asked if he was concerned about the number of shots England had against them. Roy said then that he wished there was a statistic that reported how many shots that worried him. At the moment, there aren’t many chances where we are actually looking like it’s a threat.

He just seems to keep us in a non threatening well drilled formation that suffers narrow defeats week in, week out.

 

CharlesPaterson Flag 18 Jan 19 6.08pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Our conversion rate is a definite concern, but I would be more worried if we weren't creating chances at all.


So you'd be happy to finish in the bottom 3 as long as we created enough chances..

As has been stated many times on various threads, the only stats that matter are the number of points..

And love him or hate him, his stats show that from these home fixtures: Southampton, Newcastle, Wolves, Cardiff, Watford we've picked up only 2 points!


 

Page 15 of 18 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go