This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I thought Luca picked up a cheap booking for bringing Grealish down. Grealish leaned into Luca at which point I thought Luca should let him go as it was obvious that Grealish would then ease off and let it appear that he had been shoved to the ground. Which he did and Luca took a yellow for it. We all know what happens when players get reputations, and Grealish is well on his way to getting one I think that was a massive influence on the refs decision and so already the case. I’d like to know had the whistle not gone and no goal would grealish have appealed for a pen? Also, may obviously seem biased, given we had the majority of decisions in fast half, but I thought both Grealish and McGinn were going down far too easily all afternoon.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I've looked at the incident time and time again. If there is any contact at all it is Wilf outside the box and that is minimal. Cahill withdraws his leg before Grealish goes to ground. What the ref saw was Grealish going down easily on 3 or more occasions during the match which probably influenced his decision to call the free kick for simulation. It is irrelevant whether the ball goes in the net as the ref has already blown his whistle. The fact it did go into the net is why the pundits are blaming VAR for not intervening. The only time I could see VAR coming into play on this passage of play was if they could clearly see Cahill bring down Grealish which would then mean a penalty. You cannot allow a goal to stand regardless of VAR if the whistle has been blown as this signifies a stoppage in play and will have been heard by the players which then, may or may not influence how they challenge for the ball. In this instance I don't think hearing the whistle would have stopped the shot or the goal, but that is not the point, the play has been stopped. The VAR would have reviewed the challenge by Cahill and taken the same view as the ref that he did not make contact and therefore it was a reasonable decision by the ref to blow up against Grealish for simulation. At the end of the day this is one of those decisions that can go against you just as easily as it goes for you. I am pleased that we have had the rub of the green against both Utd and now Villa as we had our fair share of poor calls last year. Just my take on it but I thought Lineker and Co were bang out of order on MOTD last night. Spot on. Pundits and the media really need to get over their hatred of everything VAR. Yes, it is not perfect yet but give it a chance. Haven't seen them bleating about the marginal decisions that have gone against City.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I think that was a massive influence on the refs decision and so already the case. I’d like to know had the whistle not gone and no goal would grealish have appealed for a pen? Also, may obviously seem biased, given we had the majority of decisions in fast half, but I thought both Grealish and McGinn were going down far too easily all afternoon. Agreed very disappointed in him yesterday
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I was expecting to see how the ref had made a howler on MOTD and Villa denied etc.etc. So it was a surprise to see that Grealish did, in fact, dive, and the referee promptly blew for it. That was where the game stopped, on the referee's whistle, not on what happened after. Friend is a highly competent referee, and acted correctly. Honestly some people defending the ref are deluded. I’m so happy we got the call as we deserved the win 100% but we got lucky. If it was on the other foot and zaha had been pushed when running at speed and booked, we’d be absolutely fuming. Everyone saying there is no contact with Cahill, why did Cahill spin around and drop to the floor holding his leg if there is no contact. Yes we deserved the win, yes I’m happy with the call, but be honest, the ref made an error that we benefited from.
|
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
Honestly some people defending the ref are deluded. I’m so happy we got the call as we deserved the win 100% but we got lucky. If it was on the other foot and zaha had been pushed when running at speed and booked, we’d be absolutely fuming. Everyone saying there is no contact with Cahill, why did Cahill spin around and drop to the floor holding his leg if there is no contact. Yes this detail of Cahill holding his leg makes me unsure. Can’t believe there hasn’t been any other angles or close ups.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Having just witnessed the incident on TV, my view is that the referee was spot-on with his decision.Grealish took off as though he was on the end of a swimming pool and quite rightly was penalised by the referee. All this hogwash that the referee was too quick on his whistle etc etc.He saw it as a dive and didn't need to wait at all before blowing - there was no 'Advantage' situation. Spot on. I though it looked like Greasylish deliberately flung his leg out to make contact. Edited by NickinOX (01 Sep 2019 12.53pm)
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
Honestly some people defending the ref are deluded. I’m so happy we got the call as we deserved the win 100% but we got lucky. If it was on the other foot and zaha had been pushed when running at speed and booked, we’d be absolutely fuming. Everyone saying there is no contact with Cahill, why did Cahill spin around and drop to the floor holding his leg if there is no contact. Yes we deserved the win, yes I’m happy with the call, but be honest, the ref made an error that we benefited from. With the greatest of respect I disagree but divergent opinions are all part of the rich tapestry in such forums. I have been accused many times of supporting referees come what may and NOT admitting they have ever made a mistake but I would suggest this is unfair as I have always maintained that they do err from time to time and I would be deluded if I concluded thay are correct 100% of the time. I do feel with all honesty that Kevin Friend was absolutely right and proper in blowing for an infringement but of course others have a different opinion which I respect but take an alternative viewpoint.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Yes this detail of Cahill holding his leg makes me unsure. Can’t believe there hasn’t been any other angles or close ups. This is what a lot of players do when they think there might be a close decision, they try and deflect attention from the situation by pretending they are injured. Seen it hundreds of times to try and escape cards. Friend honestly thought he made no contact otherwise it would have been a simple penalty to give. I have slowed it down frame by frame and I cannot see sufficient contact with Cahill to warrant a penalty. Now whether there was a push by Zaha that led to him diving in spectacular fashion is another argument.
|
|
|
. Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I've looked at the incident time and time again. If there is any contact at all it is Wilf outside the box and that is minimal. Cahill withdraws his leg before Grealish goes to ground. What the ref saw was Grealish going down easily on 3 or more occasions during the match which probably influenced his decision to call the free kick for simulation. It is irrelevant whether the ball goes in the net as the ref has already blown his whistle. The fact it did go into the net is why the pundits are blaming VAR for not intervening. The only time I could see VAR coming into play on this passage of play was if they could clearly see Cahill bring down Grealish which would then mean a penalty. You cannot allow a goal to stand regardless of VAR if the whistle has been blown as this signifies a stoppage in play and will have been heard by the players which then, may or may not influence how they challenge for the ball. In this instance I don't think hearing the whistle would have stopped the shot or the goal, but that is not the point, the play has been stopped. The VAR would have reviewed the challenge by Cahill and taken the same view as the ref that he did not make contact and therefore it was a reasonable decision by the ref to blow up against Grealish for simulation. At the end of the day this is one of those decisions that can go against you just as easily as it goes for you. I am pleased that we have had the rub of the green against both Utd and now Villa as we had our fair share of poor calls last year. Just my take on it but I thought Lineker and Co were bang out of order on MOTD last night. Every word exactly right.
|
|
|
If Jenas thinks that was the worst refereeing decision ever then he clearly hasn't been to many Palace matches.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Having just witnessed the incident on TV, my view is that the referee was spot-on with his decision.Grealish took off as though he was on the end of a swimming pool and quite rightly was penalised by the referee. All this hogwash that the referee was too quick on his whistle etc etc.He saw it as a dive and didn't need to wait at all before blowing - there was no 'Advantage' situation. Very rare that I agree with Willo on referees, but this time I do. I think there was a touch from Zaha outside the box that caused Grealish to partially lose his balance and might perhaps have been a free kick. Inside the box Cahill stuck out a leg but withdrew it very quickly, I don't think there was any contact. Grealish stabbed the ball away and then dived over thin air where Cahill's leg might have been but wasn't. A yellow card was not unreasonable. Having said that, if Palace had had a goal chalked off in those circumstances I'd have been pretty upset.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
This is what a lot of players do when they think there might be a close decision, they try and deflect attention from the situation by pretending they are injured. Seen it hundreds of times to try and escape cards. Friend honestly thought he made no contact otherwise it would have been a simple penalty to give. I have slowed it down frame by frame and I cannot see sufficient contact with Cahill to warrant a penalty. Now whether there was a push by Zaha that led to him diving in spectacular fashion is another argument. Yes I know. Only on this one he (obviously) ran the risk of a penalty being given because it makes it appear he did clatter Grealish. The ref should’ve let the thing play out and then gone to VAR, even though VAR report says it wouldn’t have been (going on 2nd opinion again).
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by DeanMiles
Cahill has been very lucky in his last two games now. Should have seen red against United and he did foul Grealish at the end of the Villa game. I heard this spoken about on TV & as Rashford is going away from goal it can't be a red card for Cahill.
The pyramid to beat all pyramids!! Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in? |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.