You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton match thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Southampton match thread


Page 15 of 17 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 23 Jan 20 9.00pm

Been a fan since my dad took me when they were in the 4th division. In that time I don't think many teams have been promoted and relegated as much as Palace. In the good times you cheer, bad times you moan BUT you stay with them.

I think the problem we have here is that we're split down the middle as to whether we're in a good or a bad time.

We all want to stay in the EPL, but if the football we play to achieve this is so dire then you must expect complaints.

I really hope we can get a full first team out soon and see how the tactics are then. The EPL is a brutal place. A cliche but no easy games.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Gribbo Flag Bromley 23 Jan 20 9.31pm

No easy games, but some games easier than others. Setting up with the same team and tactics away to Man City and home to Southampton is a case in point. One is definitely easier than the other. I can see that, the bookies can see that.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Jan 20 9.33pm

Have we scored yet?

 


Red and Blue Army!

southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Jan 20 9.37pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

No easy games, but some games easier than others. Setting up with the same team and tactics away to Man City and home to Southampton is a case in point. One is definitely easier than the other. I can see that, the bookies can see that.

The set up and tactics are the same for every game, injuries or no injuries. How else to explain the lowest goals count and low possession percentage? Injuries or not, the emphasis is on defence, with 8 defence-minded players starting, whoever the opposition.
Not having one shot on goal, even a hit and hope from 30 yards, or one corner in a game is inexcusable.

 

Jacey Flag 23 Jan 20 9.39pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m a fan of nearly 50 years standing and long for the day Hodgson is no longer manager.
I’m not trying to persuade his supporters that I’m right or that I know more than them.
I acknowledge that he’s done a reasonable job and was fortunate to witness us win at Man City and Arsenal, something I never thought I would see.
Why do I want a new manager then?
In simple terms I can’t stand the way we play.
I can’t stand his apparent mistrust of skill and the negative effect on players such as Zaha and Townsend.
For me football is about more than results and I want my team to play with passion and verve - not try to bore the opposition to defeat.
Some will say this is naive, there’s too much at stake, money etc etc.
However, my favourite season in recent years was the Championship season which was ultimately successful.
Zaha and Bolassie running havoc down the wings with a free scoring Murray.
You can actually obtain results with three genuine attacking players and still be solid at the back with the other 7 outfield players.
The only time I hear Hodgson praise Ayew and Townsend is for their defensive work.
We play every home game as if we’re facing Man City.
Before anybody asks, I’ve no suggestions as to a replacement but we’re going to have to cross that bridge at some point in any event.

Can't stand the way we play??
Brighton felt the same way and dreamed of a new expansive style,putting scout master Potter in charge and despite the apparent attractive football they play,are they not just two points above the drop zone??

 

PatrickA Flag London 23 Jan 20 9.48pm

I’m not interested in Brighton and I’m not asking anybody to agree with me.
Some fans are happy to stay up regardless of style of play and they are entitled to their opinion.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 23 Jan 20 9.56pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m not interested in Brighton and I’m not asking anybody to agree with me.
Some fans are happy to stay up regardless of style of play and they are entitled to their opinion.

And therein lies the rub, dear Palace fans.

You either let Roy Hodgson's tactical setup and starting 11 wash over you like some kind of dull tepid tidal wave, guaranteeing premier league footy every season, or you long to see us have a bit of a go.

Parish has made his choice and he likes the TV money and fame of being a Premier League chairman above all else, so its Roy or bust at the minute.

Remember AWB - without a chronic injury crisis at right back he would still be plugging away in the reserves and going out on loan to s*** sides in league 2.

AWB tells you all you need to know about Hodgson.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

samprior Flag Hamburg 23 Jan 20 10.13pm

The saints game was awful but I think there were quite a few contributing factors. All I'll say is the 7 seasons in the premier league have been a hell of a lot more enjoyable/ memorable than the 7 seasons which preceded it! Obviously there were a couple of major moments relegation survival and playoff win clearly being lifelong memories but you can rattle off a list for every season we've been in the prem. So I'd personally like us to stay there and whoever the manager is that keeps us there will get my backing.

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m not interested in Brighton and I’m not asking anybody to agree with me.
Some fans are happy to stay up regardless of style of play and they are entitled to their opinion.

 

The Yorkshire Eagle Flag Great Ouseburn, N Yorkshire 24 Jan 20 8.22am

Like PatrickA, being a long standing (or sitting when I can) fan, I remember the Cliff Holton n ‘Budgie’ Burne days with fond memories. So what’s different now? Well just about everything, but in particular that they and the teams of those days were not afraid to shoot! I don’t know what the stats say for the season but if the Saints game is anything to go by I bet we are at the foot of the ‘ attempts league’. We just don’t shoot enough. The two goals Southampton scored were top class and both from outside the area, which is something we rarely attempt, but when you set up to defend and play most of the game in your own half that is not altogether surprising. They won’t all be like Townsend’s ‘worldie’ but we would surely score more if we stopped trying to play like Arsenal and play through the opposition. There are always knock-downs, deflections and resultant scraps from a speculative shot on target!

Please Roy, give us something positive and resembling entertainment!


 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Jan 20 8.31am

Originally posted by The Yorkshire Eagle

Like PatrickA, being a long standing (or sitting when I can) fan, I remember the Cliff Holton n ‘Budgie’ Burne days with fond memories. So what’s different now? Well just about everything, but in particular that they and the teams of those days were not afraid to shoot! I don’t know what the stats say for the season but if the Saints game is anything to go by I bet we are at the foot of the ‘ attempts league’. We just don’t shoot enough. The two goals Southampton scored were top class and both from outside the area, which is something we rarely attempt, but when you set up to defend and play most of the game in your own half that is not altogether surprising. They won’t all be like Townsend’s ‘worldie’ but we would surely score more if we stopped trying to play like Arsenal and play through the opposition. There are always knock-downs, deflections and resultant scraps from a speculative shot on target!

Please Roy, give us something positive and resembling entertainment!


I will say it hasn't all been boring this season. The Liverpool game reminded me of the past, the two Arsenal games were pretty entertaining and in the Man City game Tosun reminded me of Murray. However, he did a good Calvin Andrew impression against Southampton.
I may be repressing memories but the Spurs and Southampton game were the worst I remember.

 


Red and Blue Army!

PatrickA Flag London 24 Jan 20 8.44am

One of by best memories since we have been back in the Premier League is the 3-3 at home to Liverpool.
The atmosphere was fantastic and the ground was rocking.
We came back from 3-0 down and believe we could have scored a winner if the game had gone on for 5 more minutes as we threw the kitchen sink at them.
What has this got to with Hodgson or the Southampton game?
I can’t say for sure, but believe that if Hodgson had been manager for that Liverpool game he would have tried to shut up shop at 3-0 down to ensure that the defeat was not heavier and would congratulate himself if the damage was thereby limited.
Against Southampton we never looked like coming back at them and never even tried 2 up front or ‘throwing the kitchen sink ‘ at them.
And it’s not just the Southampton game.
We’re averaging around 3 efforts on goal per game and I think we have only scored one goal in the first half at home all season.
Our set pieces and corners are the worst I can remember since I started following the club.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 24 Jan 20 8.52am

Caught between a rock and a hard place.
Ifor our status it's like having a model perfect looking wife on your arm who turns her back in bed,dont cook ,dont do chores and thinks you are her slave.
Alternatively a bit of a plain jane who sucks like a Dyson,cooks and cleans and basically loves to be a partner.
At the moment we have the model.
But would sometimes like a plain jane.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 24 Jan 20 9.07am

Originally posted by cryrst

Caught between a rock and a hard place.
Ifor our status it's like having a model perfect looking wife on your arm who turns her back in bed,dont cook ,dont do chores and thinks you are her slave.
Alternatively a bit of a plain jane who sucks like a Dyson,cooks and cleans and basically loves to be a partner.
At the moment we have the model.
But would sometimes like a plain jane.

It's a wonder you've never been asked to host Soccer Saturday

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Jan 20 9.15am

Originally posted by PatrickA

One of by best memories since we have been back in the Premier League is the 3-3 at home to Liverpool.
The atmosphere was fantastic and the ground was rocking.
We came back from 3-0 down and believe we could have scored a winner if the game had gone on for 5 more minutes as we threw the kitchen sink at them.
What has this got to with Hodgson or the Southampton game?
I can’t say for sure, but believe that if Hodgson had been manager for that Liverpool game he would have tried to shut up shop at 3-0 down to ensure that the defeat was not heavier and would congratulate himself if the damage was thereby limited.
Against Southampton we never looked like coming back at them and never even tried 2 up front or ‘throwing the kitchen sink ‘ at them.
And it’s not just the Southampton game.
We’re averaging around 3 efforts on goal per game and I think we have only scored one goal in the first half at home all season.
Our set pieces and corners are the worst I can remember since I started following the club.

It's just not entertainment we are serving up.We are just grinding out results on the back of dire, unattractive football with the sole objective of staying in the PL.

I suspect that many supporters have reached the stage when they simply do not look forward to a home game and I am in this category.When I drive from the south coast I question my sanity and wonder why on earth I am subjecting myself to such trauma given I have the long journey back after witnessing utter dross.But,in the final analysis if we survive we will all be grateful and filled with glee accepting that the end justified the means.

Suffice to say with the same ownership and management team in situ next season we can expect more of the same.

Edited by Willo (24 Jan 2020 9.21am)

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 24 Jan 20 9.23am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

And therein lies the rub, dear Palace fans.

You either let Roy Hodgson's tactical setup and starting 11 wash over you like some kind of dull tepid tidal wave, guaranteeing premier league footy every season, or you long to see us have a bit of a go.

Parish has made his choice and he likes the TV money and fame of being a Premier League chairman above all else, so its Roy or bust at the minute.

Remember AWB - without a chronic injury crisis at right back he would still be plugging away in the reserves and going out on loan to s*** sides in league 2.

AWB tells you all you need to know about Hodgson.

We've been largely lucky this season. We took more points early this season than we were really entitled to, or our performances deserved.

this should see us safe this year - but this won't happen every year. We keep going like we are now with this mix of Hodgson and lack of investment in playing squad then we will be relagated sooner rather than later.

I'm not saying Hodgsons the problem - hes done the best job he can with the players he's got - but something needs to change, or relegation beckons.

Nice to see us interested in a couple of youngsters, this may well be the way forward..hopefully they'll get some gametime. Excited to see what Scott Banks has, and Tosun is the type of player we needed, time will tell if he's the right player.

I beleive Hodgson can get us performing better with the addition of the right players and a better squad. So lets get the squad in a better state, then Hodgson can hand over the reigns to a new man.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

EddieMac Flag 24 Jan 20 9.28am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

We've been largely lucky this season. We took more points early this season than we were really entitled to, or our performances deserved.

this should see us safe this year - but this won't happen every year. We keep going like we are now with this mix of Hodgson and lack of investment in playing squad then we will be relagated sooner rather than later.

I'm not saying Hodgsons the problem - hes done the best job he can with the players he's got - but something needs to change, or relegation beckons.

Nice to see us interested in a couple of youngsters, this may well be the way forward..hopefully they'll get some gametime. Excited to see what Scott Banks has, and Tosun is the type of player we needed, time will tell if he's the right player.

I beleive Hodgson can get us performing better with the addition of the right players and a better squad. So lets get the squad in a better state, then Hodgson can hand over the reigns to a new man.

Any points we have got this season we have deserved. Just because we dont have 40 shots on target and 80% percent possesion doesnt mean we have been lucky. There is more than 1 way to win a football game and if you score more goals than your opposition you deserve to win.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 24 Jan 20 9.44am

A couple of seasons ago towards the back end when we had Cabaye and RLC, Wilf and Andros firing we were playing some of the most attractive football I can remember a Palace team playing. Roy was our manager then.
So Roy is just setting the team up to play to the players strengths. With our current squad we can expect more of the same. Hopefully e can keep grinding out the points and not come up against too many teams at the top of their game (e.g. Southampton)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Jan 20 9.51am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

We've been largely lucky this season. We took more points early this season than we were really entitled to, or our performances deserved.

this should see us safe this year - but this won't happen every year. We keep going like we are now with this mix of Hodgson and lack of investment in playing squad then we will be relagated sooner rather than later.

I'm not saying Hodgsons the problem - hes done the best job he can with the players he's got - but something needs to change, or relegation beckons.

Nice to see us interested in a couple of youngsters, this may well be the way forward..hopefully they'll get some gametime. Excited to see what Scott Banks has, and Tosun is the type of player we needed, time will tell if he's the right player.

I beleive Hodgson can get us performing better with the addition of the right players and a better squad. So lets get the squad in a better state, then Hodgson can hand over the reigns to a new man.

I don't think that will happen. Hodgson had the best players in England to choose from and by the end they were the worst England side I've ever seen. Negative side to side all behind the ball knock it up to Kane and hope he does something football - sound familiar? If history is repeating itself Hodgson will be gone next season.
Succession management Mr Parish!

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 24 Jan 20 9.53am

Do some of you want Premier League football?? It is a genuine question because the moaning about Roy Hodgson is becoming pathetic. Have you not learnt from other clubs examples such as Stoke. They had a Manager who had kept them in the PL for ten years but their fans started to moan non stop about their style of football so the Chairman panicked and sacked Tony Pullis. Take a look where they are now, just above the trapdoor in the Championship. Not quite as bad was the Arsenal fans hounding Wenger out and they, based purely on league points, are no better than us now.

Be careful what you wish for.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

PatrickA Flag London 24 Jan 20 10.00am

I’m sorry but I just don’t see how Hodgson is playing to our strengths, certainly in the attacking sense.
The only forward who is playing to his potential this season is Ayew and that is more owing to hard work and endeavour.
The contributions of Zaha, Townsend, Benteke and Wickham this season have been negligible.
Yes there are extenuating circumstances and injuries and loss of form haven’t helped.
But Benteke won’t score if he never receives a cross in a game and Zaha and Townsend will not present a threat to the opposition goal while Hodgson stations them around the halfway line.
I think Townsend has had one good game this season at home to Liverpool.
I had forgotten what a forward pass to Zaha looks like until I saw the Mcarthy pass that led to the goal against Man City.
Most of the time Zaha receives the ball with his back to goal and either passes the ball back or is tackled/fouled.
If , by some chance, we do bring in some forward players in this window and we do play in a more attacking way I’ll be only too happy to admit I was wrong and the problem has been the resources.
We shall see.

 

Page 15 of 17 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton match thread