You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley v Palace Match thread
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Burnley v Palace Match thread


Page 15 of 17 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
EddieMac Flag 24 Nov 20 2.04pm

Originally posted by Painter

You fall for the nonsense about not winning without Zaha, we are very capable of not winning with him in the team.
Burnley were lucky last night, they didn’t create much, only getting a lucky break from a Kouyate mistake. They then reverted to how we play after going ahead, pack the defence making it hard to score and frustrating the opposition.
The vast majority of games are won by the team that scores first, Burnley aren’t a bad team, they finish above us regularly at the end of the season.

Spot on. It was a poor game overall but I’l go as far as saying that Palace fans who think we should be hammering Burnley havn’t got a clue about football. Burnley have played the majority of the season with Tarkowski, Mee or Taylor but had them all back last night. The game could have went either way but unfortunately it went to them. Nothing to do with tactics or not being able to win without Zaha. It’s just how football goes.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 24 Nov 20 2.07pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Spot on. It was a poor game overall but I’l go as far as saying that Palace fans who think we should be hammering Burnley havn’t got a clue about football. Burnley have played the majority of the season with Tarkowski, Mee or Taylor but had them all back last night. The game could have went either way but unfortunately it went to them. Nothing to do with tactics or not being able to win without Zaha. It’s just how football goes.

Spot on. At last someone who knows about football.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Nov 20 2.10pm

The elephant in the room is, why pay someone 100k a week to play in Africa during a pandemic? No thanks, you're not going, would be my answer. Has already caused problems for us twice this season. Also Ayew looked totally out of shape yesterday: we need to get a handle on this. The big teams would not be allowing this.

 


Red and Blue Army!

eritheagle Flag Erith 24 Nov 20 2.12pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Spot on. It was a poor game overall but I’l go as far as saying that Palace fans who think we should be hammering Burnley havn’t got a clue about football. Burnley have played the majority of the season with Tarkowski, Mee or Taylor but had them all back last night. The game could have went either way but unfortunately it went to them. Nothing to do with tactics or not being able to win without Zaha. It’s just how football goes.

I agree. Burnley are a very organized and capable Premier League team who had all their players back last night.
We were well worth a draw and if we'd had a better final ball and strikers that were on their toes (yes, I mean you Batsman) we would've got a point or more.
If they hadn't got the early goal I think the game would've taken a very different direction.

It was a frustrating night but both us and Burnley are similar and we both sometimes win games like that and sometimes we lose them. Neither of us will go down.

 

Harpo Flag Oxfordshire 24 Nov 20 2.13pm

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

I'm starting to wonder if Roy has lost the players. If you look at the way we came out today, it was awful. Burnley had all the energy, we looked like we were still on holiday.

It's one thing if players screw up (they did), or if tactics are bad (they were), but if our players don't look like they are interested, that's a major negative reflection on the manager.

I believe there is something in that. I've never been a football manager, and there's good reason for that, but... the two things that bug me are back passing and speed of attack.

Nothing worthy of a text book, but if you pass back, you only have 9 players upfield, whereas they have 11. And that ratio coupled with sluggish progress prevents our players finding sufficient space in their half. We are always going to be outnumbered.

Cut the back passes, work on crossing and passing the ball and move up with a decent pace.

Problem solved. Maybe.


 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 Nov 20 2.24pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I’l go as far as saying that Palace fans who think we should be hammering Burnley havn’t got a clue about football. Burnley have played the majority of the season with Tarkowski, Mee or Taylor but had them all back last night.

What you really mean is that people who don't share your opinions don't have a clue about football.

A poor side like Newcastle managed to put three past Burnley who had both Tarkowski and Taylor playing though admittedly not Mee

 

EddieMac Flag 24 Nov 20 2.31pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

The elephant in the room is, why pay someone 100k a week to play in Africa during a pandemic? No thanks, you're not going, would be my answer. Has already caused problems for us twice this season. Also Ayew looked totally out of shape yesterday: we need to get a handle on this. The big teams would not be allowing this.

Zaha didn’t get Covid in Africa. He didn’t play Ivory Coast’s last 2 games. Liverpool let Salah go and he got Covid. Clubs have no choice.

 

EddieMac Flag 24 Nov 20 2.33pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

What you really mean is that people who don't share your opinions don't have a clue about football.

A poor side like Newcastle managed to put three past Burnley who had both Tarkowski and Taylor playing though admittedly not Mee

If your opinion is that we should be hammering Burnley then yes you havn’t a clue. There is not a single game in this division where we can expect to hammer a team.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 24 Nov 20 3.52pm

I didn't think we were that bad. You have to accept that adapting to life without Zaha would take time. But no reason we couldn't.

The main thing for me was that Clyne looked very decent on the ball and okay without it.

Townsend was abject. He did one pass that was so awful he held his hand up in apology for 20 seconds.

Burnley were always going to be bang up for last night and so it proved. When they have their first choice defence fully match fit, they are without question a tough nut to crack.

And so it proved.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

palace chick Flag South Croydon 24 Nov 20 6.05pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I didn't think we were that bad. You have to accept that adapting to life without Zaha would take time. But no reason we couldn't.

The main thing for me was that Clyne looked very decent on the ball and okay without it.

Townsend was abject. He did one pass that was so awful he held his hand up in apology for 20 seconds.

Burnley were always going to be bang up for last night and so it proved. When they have their first choice defence fully match fit, they are without question a tough nut to crack.

And so it proved.

In truth no prem game is winnable unless you are tactically ready for it or if not going how you expect you are able to change it during a match. Last night and dare I say many times under Hodgson he doesn’t change things other than a player for a player and playing them the same way. Last night it was obvious that the two central defenders together with the keeper weren’t able to pass it out of defence to a midfield player. They all mostly lumped it up to two small forwards who then lost it in the air giving it back to Burnley to play keep ball. Schlup who isn’t bad in the air came on for Reidewald late on when it would have been better if he had gone into his normal wide midfield position with Eze going alongside Bats. Ayew was poor, at least Townsend who played badly didn’t hide? Then even later Benteke came on which then gave us two players who could both win balls in the air. Those changes should have been made far earlier or perhaps they both should have started knowing how Burnley play. It’s a thin line and if we hadn’t of made a mistake and Pope hadn’t of made that late save from Benteke we would have got a point or three. However I feel we set up wrong from the start and then didn’t change it early enough. Hodgson and Lewington got it wrong last night. Perhaps we didn’t need the long ball if we had played Cahill and Sakho?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Nov 20 6.39pm

Originally posted by palace chick

In truth no prem game is winnable unless you are tactically ready for it or if not going how you expect you are able to change it during a match. Last night and dare I say many times under Hodgson he doesn’t change things other than a player for a player and playing them the same way. Last night it was obvious that the two central defenders together with the keeper weren’t able to pass it out of defence to a midfield player. They all mostly lumped it up to two small forwards who then lost it in the air giving it back to Burnley to play keep ball. Schlup who isn’t bad in the air came on for Reidewald late on when it would have been better if he had gone into his normal wide midfield position with Eze going alongside Bats. Ayew was poor, at least Townsend who played badly didn’t hide? Then even later Benteke came on which then gave us two players who could both win balls in the air. Those changes should have been made far earlier or perhaps they both should have started knowing how Burnley play. It’s a thin line and if we hadn’t of made a mistake and Pope hadn’t of made that late save from Benteke we would have got a point or three. However I feel we set up wrong from the start and then didn’t change it early enough. Hodgson and Lewington got it wrong last night. Perhaps we didn’t need the long ball if we had played Cahill and Sakho?

Finally, someone who properly understands poor tactics and how those decisions influence tight matches.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 24 Nov 20 6.52pm

we didn't look too bad until we got to the final third then we didn't quite click, poor choices, over-hit passes etc Ayew was unusually poor, Andros was appalling, he's OK but is quite predictable as an out and out winger, he'd be better as a wing back but we don't play that way, I've been a bit anti-McArthur not out of opinionatedness, I just think he belongs in the championship now helping a team like Sheffield Wednesday or Birmingham, very little attacking threat and gave the ball away at crucial times. It's no disgrace to lose at Burnley, they do what they do very well, and we probably deserved a point, but Pope is a bit good. I hope we can get safe asap and go for a cup run otherwise it will be as boring a season as the last one. Contracts are up in the summer so I'm looking forward to a shake up, I think we need a new midfield, keep Reidewald all the others can foxtrot oscar - we are crying out for what Loftus Cheek gave us a couple of seasons back, mind you we played through the park quite well yesterday, but Burnley shut us out when we got close extremely well.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Nov 20 8.04pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

we didn't look too bad until we got to the final third then we didn't quite click, poor choices, over-hit passes etc Ayew was unusually poor, Andros was appalling, he's OK but is quite predictable as an out and out winger, he'd be better as a wing back but we don't play that way, I've been a bit anti-McArthur not out of opinionatedness, I just think he belongs in the championship now helping a team like Sheffield Wednesday or Birmingham, very little attacking threat and gave the ball away at crucial times. It's no disgrace to lose at Burnley, they do what they do very well, and we probably deserved a point, but Pope is a bit good. I hope we can get safe asap and go for a cup run otherwise it will be as boring a season as the last one. Contracts are up in the summer so I'm looking forward to a shake up, I think we need a new midfield, keep Reidewald all the others can foxtrot oscar - we are crying out for what Loftus Cheek gave us a couple of seasons back, mind you we played through the park quite well yesterday, but Burnley shut us out when we got close extremely well.

We had enough very good moments to score and you're very right about McArthur because he overhit the best move of the half from both teams if he'd passed as he should've which to be quite honest wasn't a difficult ask Batshuayi had an easy tap in and he actually wasn't offside, go to 22 mins....

[Link]

Our biggest problem during the entire game was our defending and it really was a total disaster in every possible way, we simply shot ourselves in the foot with splendid perfection.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Nov 20 8.21pm

Originally posted by palace chick

In truth no prem game is winnable unless you are tactically ready for it or if not going how you expect you are able to change it during a match. Last night and dare I say many times under Hodgson he doesn’t change things other than a player for a player and playing them the same way. Last night it was obvious that the two central defenders together with the keeper weren’t able to pass it out of defence to a midfield player. They all mostly lumped it up to two small forwards who then lost it in the air giving it back to Burnley to play keep ball. Schlup who isn’t bad in the air came on for Reidewald late on when it would have been better if he had gone into his normal wide midfield position with Eze going alongside Bats. Ayew was poor, at least Townsend who played badly didn’t hide? Then even later Benteke came on which then gave us two players who could both win balls in the air. Those changes should have been made far earlier or perhaps they both should have started knowing how Burnley play. It’s a thin line and if we hadn’t of made a mistake and Pope hadn’t of made that late save from Benteke we would have got a point or three. However I feel we set up wrong from the start and then didn’t change it early enough. Hodgson and Lewington got it wrong last night. Perhaps we didn’t need the long ball if we had played Cahill and Sakho?

You are very very wrong, Kouyate played like a rabbit in headlights and he was the reason we lost because he headed the ball into our box instead of away and into the path of Rodriguez how on earth is that the fault of Mr Hodgson, Kouyate gave our team no reason at all to settle and build, and how on earth can Mr Hodgson be blamed for the best move of the first half to be ruined by McArthur overhitting a simple pass for Batshuayi to score with an open goal. if you look for negatives you will find them.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 24 Nov 20 8.38pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

You are very very wrong, Kouyate played like a rabbit in headlights and he was the reason we lost because he headed the ball into our box instead of away and into the path of Rodriguez how on earth is that the fault of Mr Hodgson, Kouyate gave our team no reason at all to settle and build, and how on earth can Mr Hodgson be blamed for the best move of the first half to be ruined by McArthur overhitting a simple pass for Batshuayi to score with an open goal. if you look for negatives you will find them.

McArthur didn't even overhit it....it was a great, teasing ball across the face of the goal. Michy should've anticipated it better and got on the end of it.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Nov 20 8.55pm

Originally posted by sprites

McArthur didn't even overhit it....it was a great, teasing ball across the face of the goal. Michy should've anticipated it better and got on the end of it.

Watch it again! go to first half and 28.46 (or 22.08 on actual time on pic) .....

[Link]

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 24 Nov 20 8.56pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

We had enough very good moments to score and you're very right about McArthur because he overhit the best move of the half from both teams if he'd passed as he should've which to be quite honest wasn't a difficult ask Batshuayi had an easy tap in and he actually wasn't offside, go to 22 mins....

[Link]

Our biggest problem during the entire game was our defending and it really was a total disaster in every possible way, we simply shot ourselves in the foot with splendid perfection.

The run from MacArthur was great, but the pass was overhit or the wrong angle, great servant but this should be his last season, somebody in the Loftus Cheek mould to replace him, hopefully he gets his form back after his injury, Fulham go down, £20mil well spent.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Nov 20 9.00pm

Our general passing under pressure is very suspect and has been for many many seasons, this is completely down to the ability of our players and not the ability of our manager.

Edited by Tickled pink (24 Nov 2020 9.19pm)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Nov 20 9.13pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

The run from MacArthur was great, but the pass was overhit or the wrong angle, great servant but this should be his last season, somebody in the Loftus Cheek mould to replace him, hopefully he gets his form back after his injury, Fulham go down, £20mil well spent.

yes agree, McArthur has been brilliant for us but the last few seasons have started to show he hasn't the pace to keep up, he always used to score really important goals and set players up throughout the season but this is becoming quite a rare occurrence for him these days, Loftus Cheek looked excellent the last time he came on for Fulham against Everton and it was because of this that Fulham took total control during the second half, they do play the ball around quite brilliantly shame about their somewhat hit and miss defending at times ..like us really.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 24 Nov 20 9.25pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

You are very very wrong, Kouyate played like a rabbit in headlights and he was the reason we lost because he headed the ball into our box instead of away and into the path of Rodriguez how on earth is that the fault of Mr Hodgson, Kouyate gave our team no reason at all to settle and build, and how on earth can Mr Hodgson be blamed for the best move of the first half to be ruined by McArthur overhitting a simple pass for Batshuayi to score with an open goal. if you look for negatives you will find them.

We were set up to ,win the game, and if Kouyate, had not have given them their goal, and McArthur, had put the ball on Bats , toe, we would have all been happy. Second half the tactics were spot on, the application wasn’t , played reasonably well but couldn’t get past a good defence, and a first class keeper. It happens we have won matches in that way on a good many occasions . Tactics can only help , Both ,Bats, and Big Bent, could , should even have finished but credit Pope, whatever the tactics were seen to be we could have won , and at least not have lost that game.

 

Page 15 of 17 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley v Palace Match thread