You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs West Ham Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs West Ham Match Thread


Page 15 of 17 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
sprites Flag Auckland 26 Jan 21 8.45pm

Originally posted by BM

If we go with Wilf and Eze wide the future is bright. Townsend has to be dropped now. Another feeble performance and please don’t give me the usual “puts in a shift” nonsense. Cahill can warm the bench too. Woeful tonight but as usual everyone will let him off. Our best 11 is: Guiata; Clyne, Tomkins, Sakho, Mitchell; Eze, Jairo, Jimmy, Wilf; Ayew, Benteke.
Tonight’s ratings: Guiata 6: Ward 6, Kouyate 6, Cahill 4, Mitchell 5; Townsend 3, Luka 5, Jimmy 6, Eze 6; Benteke 6, Wilf 6.

No one gets a 6. 3,4 and 5 all round.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 26 Jan 21 8.45pm

Originally posted by Willo

Perhaps,just perhaps, in the "Cold light of day", those that have been very critical of Mr Hodgson straight after a defeat might just change their views.

Keen fisherman I see

 

EddieMac Flag 26 Jan 21 8.45pm

Originally posted by palace chick

That was my suggestion yesterday in team for Westham thread. I suggested that we played the two Mac’s with Luka in the middle with Zaha and Townsend either side. After tonight’s performance by Luka and Townsend perhaps Eze for Townsend and Reidewald for Luka? The weak ageing back 4 can’t cope with two in the middle of midfield with no pace and too old as well. The formation now played by Hodgson just can’t do it. Amazed he is trying to play more attack minded with the players available. Westham can and did do it because they are younger, more pace and eager to chase it down. We have none of that I’m afraid and don’t be fooled by the substitutions making a difference as Westham had already done a job on us before they came on :-(

100% this needs to happen and I wouldn’t be surprised if it does. Luka is a much better player when he gets to sit in front of the back 4, he hasn’t the legs to be up and down the pitch.

I would go with the 2 macs and Luca with Zaha Eze on wings with Benteke up top (for now). Just get back to playing on the counter attack. I like yourself am shocked that Roy is sticking with this 4-4-2.

 

gaz1959 Flag Bamford Lancashire 26 Jan 21 8.49pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

As much as Roy needs to shoulder the blame for his woeful tactics, we have a squad of players who are either not PL standard or are well past their sell by date.

We have 4 central midfield players with not a lick of speed amongst them. McCarthur is the best of them but he can’t be playing week in and out but because he is our only midfield player with attacking qualities then he plays constantly.

Agree but who manages the team ? Or does he not plan for the future or us he nit allowed to by SP & Dougie ( Bolton a better team) Freedman,
. ???


Edited by EddieMac (26 Jan 2021 8.42pm)

Edited by gaz1959 (26 Jan 2021 8.50pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Jan 21 8.50pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

As much as Roy needs to shoulder the blame for his woeful tactics, we have a squad of players who are either not PL standard or are well past their sell by date.

We have 4 central midfield players with not a lick of speed amongst them. McCarthur is the best of them but he can’t be playing week in and out but because he is our only midfield player with attacking qualities then he plays constantly.

Edited by EddieMac (26 Jan 2021 8.42pm)

I share your view about the overall quality of our squad at this stage of many of their careers.

At the risk of being tedious, I can only re-iterate what I have asserted numerous times - We have 15 outfield players either 30 this year or are in their 30s, they are in the 'Twilight' of their careers and no longer have the pace, energy, and mobility that is required.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 26 Jan 21 8.50pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

As much as Roy needs to shoulder the blame for his woeful tactics, we have a squad of players who are either not PL standard or are well past their sell by date.

We have 4 central midfield players with not a lick of speed amongst them. McCarthur is the best of them but he can’t be playing week in and out but because he is our only midfield player with attacking qualities then he plays constantly.

Edited by EddieMac (26 Jan 2021 8.42pm)

You are right of course, 33 year old McCarthur who is played week in week out is being embarrassed. He can barely find a pass these days and gets caught on the ball so often. Unfortunately probably the best of a very poor bunch. We need legs in there. Play Jairo or at least rotate him.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 26 Jan 21 9.03pm

Looks like everyone is going against Roy now, but giving him the sack doesn’t make sense at the moment. He’s got credit in the bank and SP will not want to rock the boat at this present time.

I’m not happy with some of the performances, it’s just not good enough, is it Roy or some of our players that need a rocket?

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 26 Jan 21 9.05pm

Lets play Kouyate in the midfield, but then who would play CB, as our ploy of having 4 oldish defenders fails when they are not having a rest but are injured. I would play a 4231 formation with Townsend, Eze and Wilf on the right and Benteke up front.
We are apparently after a younger CB but will it happen especially with the AWB money mostly spent. Do we chuck out Roy now? No for the same reason we don't play Kouyate in Midfield there is no replacement currently.
Equally as frustrated as most of the rest of us and thankfully some points between us and the bottom 7 and but those points are being eaten away. We will survive but please Roy the youngsters must be given a chance before it's too late.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

CT Charlie Flag 26 Jan 21 9.07pm

Do any supporters have inside information as to why Luka remains a captain?

If I were a teammate, his captaincy alone would make me question my loyalty and commitment to the club. I loved it when Wilf was made captain. He may or may not be the soul of the team, but he certainly is the engine. Despite his antics and his temper, he is a player who (except when he's attacked and the referee turns a blind eye) exudes a passion for competing.

 

merganser Flag 26 Jan 21 9.07pm

We’re missing the zest of Schlupp.

 

Mojo87 Flag 26 Jan 21 9.16pm

Originally posted by Mathers

Really don’t see the hype with Mitchell. Weak in the tackle, positionally poor and offers no attacking threat. Not a touch on AWB who was a superb defender. Even for all PVA’s flaws, at least he offers something going forward. If Arsenal make any offer we should snap their hand off.

He doesn't get as much support from Eze than he would from Townsend or Schlupp, so occasionally he's caught in a 2v1 situation.

But definitely his passing needs to be number 1 thing for him to approve upon because he loses the ball too much for my liking.

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 26 Jan 21 9.28pm

Originally posted by Mathers

Really don’t see the hype with Mitchell. Weak in the tackle, positionally poor and offers no attacking threat. Not a touch on AWB who was a superb defender. Even for all PVA’s flaws, at least he offers something going forward. If Arsenal make any offer we should snap their hand off.

I agree. I saw a poll the other day on an Arsenal site asking whether they should sign him. I voted yes. If they're stupid enough to pay the figure being banded about, have their arm off.

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 26 Jan 21 9.30pm

Whilst I agree Roy should be replaced at the end of the season he can only be part of the problem. The management must also take responsibility for leaving him with an ageing squad . You could see the effects of that tonight when the Spammers just had more energy to outrun our ageing players. The players themselves also bear responsibility for the poor performance their passing was very bad even worse than normal. So it is the collective that is the problem.
Roy must stay till the end of the season as he does at least know how to get them to win the odd match to enable us to survive this season. After that all hell can be let lose and a culling fest can ensue. COYP

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 26 Jan 21 9.37pm

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

Whilst I agree Roy should be replaced at the end of the season he can only be part of the problem. The management must also take responsibility for leaving him with an ageing squad . You could see the effects of that tonight when the Spammers just had more energy to outrun our ageing players. The players themselves also bear responsibility for the poor performance their passing was very bad even worse than normal. So it is the collective that is the problem.
Roy must stay till the end of the season as he does at least know how to get them to win the odd match to enable us to survive this season. After that all hell can be let lose and a culling fest can ensue. COYP

Whatever credentials or track record Roy might have it is not on display at the moment and has not been for some time now. We’re getting worse and worse with 1 win in what, 10 games now and that against a team vying for the worst season in history.

We’re going down at this rate

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 26 Jan 21 9.39pm

Originally posted by merganser

We’re missing the zest of Schlupp.

Yes we are, but he alone is not the answer to our problems.

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 26 Jan 21 9.39pm

Originally posted by Foxy82

I'd rather wet my bollox and drape them over an electric fence than watch this s***e. Roy out

I'd rather watch you do this and laugh at you

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 26 Jan 21 9.46pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Looks like everyone is going against Roy now, but giving him the sack doesn’t make sense at the moment. He’s got credit in the bank and SP will not want to rock the boat at this present time.

I’m not happy with some of the performances, it’s just not good enough, is it Roy or some of our players that need a rocket?

Look, every general goes to war with the army they have. This defending Roy is BS and actually harbors on preferential bias. Were it someone else they would never have these chances. Issue is players have more to offer than Roy could get from them. More than Roy could ever get from them. So in my book, no tru palace supporter could be part of the Roy IN crowd

 

Mojo87 Flag 26 Jan 21 9.51pm

Townsend was absolutely horrendous tonight. Lightweight and gives away the ball too cheaply.
Got to be 20 plus times that he was dispossessed tonight... When the stats come out, it would be a joke!

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 26 Jan 21 9.57pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

If there was a crowd Iceland Woy would be getting a police escort of the pitch

Once again you are pathetic. I don't agree with Roy on this, but making fun of someone's disability proves how unimaginative and childish you truly are.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 26 Jan 21 10.00pm

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

Whilst I agree Roy should be replaced at the end of the season he can only be part of the problem. The management must also take responsibility for leaving him with an ageing squad . You could see the effects of that tonight when the Spammers just had more energy to outrun our ageing players. The players themselves also bear responsibility for the poor performance their passing was very bad even worse than normal. So it is the collective that is the problem.
Roy must stay till the end of the season as he does at least know how to get them to win the odd match to enable us to survive this season. After that all hell can be let lose and a culling fest can ensue. COYP


The aging squad is a bit of a misnomer.

Roy was given

Meyer
Camarasa
Riediwald
Banks

He won’t play youth, he never has. AWB only got a look in as
we ran out of players. Same with Mitchell

He won’t even play Eze in the position he plays!

Edited by robdave2k (26 Jan 2021 10.01pm)

 

Page 15 of 17 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs West Ham Match Thread