You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson
November 16 2026 3.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson


Page 15 of 27 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Dec 23 11.31am

I was disappointed when Hodgson was re-appointed for this season, believing that he should have seen last season's cameo as a final hurrah and that it was time to move on.

However, once he was appointed, I backed him as he was our manager and I was hoping that he would have us playing more on the front foot as we did during his cameo. A combination of injuries to key players and his natural cautious approach resulted in the return of Royball, however.

I accepted it until he began making his somewhat off-the-cuff remarks about youngsters and fans and his allowing his frustrations to get the better of him. I sense he may have reached the point of treading water and that's not good enough.

I have been supportive of Hodgson during his tenure at the club, recognizing that he was managing an ageing and declining squad during his 4 year tenure and that he achieved the board's aim of PL status retention.

I would not be unhappy if he and Parish agree it's time for him to step down before the January window and allow someone else to take the reins. As to who? Well I would hope Parish has been sounding a few unemployed managers out. Cooper till the end of the season wouldn't be a disaster IMO. It would enable us all to see whether he has what it takes to turn us round. It also enables him to keep his options open for next season.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 Dec 23 11.44am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Yes, this.
I agree that Roy's career, aside from the odd success, is littered with failure, but somehow his longevity has him considered as some sort of wise old owl who knows his stuff. I would say that his football is a relic of the past, and to be fair to him I still wonder as to why he took on this extra year.
But this situation also reveals Parish does it not? Which manager in their right mind would come to work for him, look at what is on offer and the history of previous managers in the last 11 seasons.

Total bunkum re being “ scared “ of a new manager. Although if one person is, I would say it is Steve Parish.

You do Hodgson a disservice in your description of his career. He wasn’t suited to the very top jobs such as Liverpool or England, but he’s done well and is highly respected for his work elsewhere. I personally know players that played for him at Fulham and also the Swiss National team, and he is held in the highest regard by them.

While the pre season talk was of a push forwards towards a top ten finish, that talk wasn’t backed up by bringing in players, Lerma excepted, that we’re going to have an immediate impact on the squad in areas that have been deficient for some time now. Couple that with the injuries we have had and those mitigating circumstances must have been taken into consideration. Because if you look only at results, the managers position would be seriously called into question by the club.

I was disappointed when Roy was re-appointed because I thought it was time for a change. But he was appointed for a reason and that reason hasn’t changed.

My hope is that Parish has a forward thinking plan that will re-set the way the club is currently being run

Edited by NEILLO (24 Dec 2023 11.45am)

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Dec 23 12.02pm

Originally posted by doombear

I was disappointed when Hodgson was re-appointed for this season, believing that he should have seen last season's cameo as a final hurrah and that it was time to move on.

However, once he was appointed, I backed him as he was our manager and I was hoping that he would have us playing more on the front foot as we did during his cameo. A combination of injuries to key players and his natural cautious approach resulted in the return of Royball, however.

I accepted it until he began making his somewhat off-the-cuff remarks about youngsters and fans and his allowing his frustrations to get the better of him. I sense he may have reached the point of treading water and that's not good enough.

I have been supportive of Hodgson during his tenure at the club, recognizing that he was managing an ageing and declining squad during his 4 year tenure and that he achieved the board's aim of PL status retention.

I would not be unhappy if he and Parish agree it's time for him to step down before the January window and allow someone else to take the reins. As to who? Well I would hope Parish has been sounding a few unemployed managers out. Cooper till the end of the season wouldn't be a disaster IMO. It would enable us all to see whether he has what it takes to turn us round. It also enables him to keep his options open for next season.

Mr Hodgson will not be holding the reins next season.
Of course 'Succession planning' is in place with options being considered.
I am not aware as to any 'Short term' "To end of season" strategy.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Dec 23 1.35pm

Originally posted by doombear

I was disappointed when Hodgson was re-appointed for this season, believing that he should have seen last season's cameo as a final hurrah and that it was time to move on.

However, once he was appointed, I backed him as he was our manager and I was hoping that he would have us playing more on the front foot as we did during his cameo. A combination of injuries to key players and his natural cautious approach resulted in the return of Royball, however.

I accepted it until he began making his somewhat off-the-cuff remarks about youngsters and fans and his allowing his frustrations to get the better of him. I sense he may have reached the point of treading water and that's not good enough.

I have been supportive of Hodgson during his tenure at the club, recognizing that he was managing an ageing and declining squad during his 4 year tenure and that he achieved the board's aim of PL status retention.

I would not be unhappy if he and Parish agree it's time for him to step down before the January window and allow someone else to take the reins. As to who? Well I would hope Parish has been sounding a few unemployed managers out. Cooper till the end of the season wouldn't be a disaster IMO. It would enable us all to see whether he has what it takes to turn us round. It also enables him to keep his options open for next season.

Cooper is a busted flush, after his experience at Forest. He needs time to recover and consider his options. 19% win rate in the Premier doesn't isn't a good record.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Dec 23 2.25pm

Originally posted by Painter

Cooper is a busted flush, after his experience at Forest. He needs time to recover and consider his options. 19% win rate in the Premier doesn't isn't a good record.

After Nottm Forest were promoted they signed 29 players in their first season back in the PL.This season they have signed 14 players. Cooper found it challenging having such a large squad.
Interestingly the new manager Espirito Santo likes to work with a small squad.


Edited by Willo (24 Dec 2023 2.25pm)

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 27 Dec 23 1.50pm

Pointless at Stamford Bridge and vs Brentford, there is no other option than to relieve Roy from his job.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 27 Dec 23 2.07pm

Roy is draining the life out of our team. Andersens statement after Brighton was damning, if that is the general mood amongst the players then Roy has lost the dressing room

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Dec 23 2.16pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

Roy is draining the life out of our team. Andersens statement after Brighton was damning, if that is the general mood amongst the players then Roy has lost the dressing room

Your mindset might change if Chelsea go down the drain tonight !

Apropos the comments by Anderson, what was reported could have been taken out of context.

 

Jacey Flag 27 Dec 23 2.25pm

Originally posted by Willo

Your mindset might change if Chelsea go down the drain tonight !

Apropos the comments by Anderson, what was reported could have been taken out of context.

Sorry Willo.
Believe the Conservatives have more chance in winning the next General Election than a Palace win at Chelsea!!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Dec 23 2.29pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Sorry Willo.
Believe the Conservatives have more chance in winning the next General Election than a Palace win at Chelsea!!

I don't read too much into polls when the General Election is months away.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 27 Dec 23 2.56pm

Set up to not lose and you're not going to win. Simple as that really.

 


Red and Blue Army!

TN17 Flag Kent 27 Dec 23 9.19pm

As a supporter from 1963, an a season ticket holder for less years, I will not be going to Selhurst while Hodgson is manager.

Blinkered team selection, negative tactics.

 

stevethenorm Flag Watton, Norfolk 27 Dec 23 9.20pm

Goodbye Roy. Thanks but enough is enough

 

redandblue4life Flag Auckland city ! 27 Dec 23 9.30pm

I have had enough now, we NEED a change !

 

BelfastEagle Flag 27 Dec 23 9.37pm

Roy should have been allowed to leave at the end of last season with dignity.

Giving him yet another years contract was inexcusable lazy and catastrophic……just kicking the can down the road to avoid making a decision yet again.

Having said that the transfer dealings in the summer were shockingly poor….an utter shambles. Who ever was involved is jointly liable for putting Roy in this situation and should go. If thats you Freedman on your bike.

 

YoDougie Flag London 27 Dec 23 9.38pm

I don't post here much but very much feel the need to share my views today.

Hodgson should not have returned for longer than the end of last season. This was a temporary appointment to see out the season to find a replacement and it's how it should have stayed.

Today and for the past weeks, we've returned to classic Royball as seen in the final season of Roy era 1; defensive shape, lack of subs and players often out of position.

Like it or not, we have officially entered a relegation battle. Roy, thank you but time to depart. A change and a plan for this club is needed.

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 27 Dec 23 9.42pm

Watched Roy…sat on the bench for 95% of the game. Is he injured or has age finally caught up with him? Motivation is a key element of a manager’s job - and I didn’t see that tonight! How can encourage, tweak the tactics sitting on your backside with a stupid smile on your face??

I’m afraid…for the first time in a while…time for a change in management

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 27 Dec 23 9.43pm

Originally posted by YoDougie

I don't post here much but very much feel the need to share my views today.

Hodgson should not have returned for longer than the end of last season. This was a temporary appointment to see out the season to find a replacement and it's how it should have stayed.

Today and for the past weeks, we've returned to classic Royball as seen in the final season of Roy era 1; defensive shape, lack of subs and players often out of position.

Like it or not, we have officially entered a relegation battle. Roy, thank you but time to depart. A change and a plan for this club is needed.


Agreed….

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 27 Dec 23 9.45pm

Everything ends in Royball eventually.

 

cROYdonrogers Flag Leamington Spa 27 Dec 23 9.46pm

There will be no change until after the Everton game when we go into a break.

 

Page 15 of 27 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson