You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City v Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Manchester City v Crystal Palace match thread


Page 15 of 15 << First< 11 12 13 14 15
The groover Flag Danbury 18 Dec 23 5.00pm

Originally posted by doombear


I think the rule now is that a goal is automatically ruled out if the ball hits the scorer's hand whether or not it was intentional (e.g. Edouard recently). In the case of the Rico Lewis goal, it's clear that the handball was accidental and so the goal stood.

I was more miffed at the Grealish goal being called onside by VAR. Some dodgy line-drawing IMO.

Edited by doombear (18 Dec 2023 3.46pm)

Nope. This is the rule: Immediately after touching the ball with the arm, even accidentally, the player scores a goal or creates a goal-scoring opportunity.

Their second should NOT have stood on that basis.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 18 Dec 23 5.32pm

Deliberate arm to ball is the simplest way.

Handball is so complicated nobody really understands it and the constantly fluctuating rules and their misinterpretation is unavoidable.


 

Elpis Flag In a pub 18 Dec 23 5.52pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Deliberate arm to ball is the simplest way.

Handball is so complicated nobody really understands it and the constantly fluctuating rules and their misinterpretation is unavoidable.


Well we all understood it 20 years ago and we all knew when as you say intentional hand or arm to ball took place .

 

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 18 Dec 23 5.57pm

its this clear and obvious error rowlocks, you dont get this in top level rugby union, if the refs decison is wrong the VAR eqivalent tell them and it is normally overturned.

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Dec 23 6.01pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Deliberate arm to ball is the simplest way.

Handball is so complicated nobody really understands it and the constantly fluctuating rules and their misinterpretation is unavoidable.


Yes, intent is the key. Being cynical players who can pass a ball 30 yards accurately shouldn't have much difficulty in chipping it a short distance onto someone's arm.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 18 Dec 23 6.01pm

I was worried when Henderson went down holding his thigh. They said it was just cramp. Anyone know for sure?

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 18 Dec 23 6.22pm

The legendary Liverpool manager , Bill Shankly once said , “ Football is a simple game”, he must turn in his grave. Because the entertainment brigade have decided that could never be interesting enough.
For years hand ball was a simple problem for a ref as long as he actually saw it, it wasn’t always the case he did see it, that’s not the point though as that is the factor for VAT to deal with.
The rule was simple, deliberate hand to ball or arm as the case may be. And quiet honestly it rarely was that hard to see with the naked eye.
Players were coached to spread themselves before trying to block, as long as those arms didn’t make a deliberate move toward the ball, it wasn’t hand to ball it was ball to hand. If the hand or more often the arm was hit. That shouldn’t be hard, but in the present climate it would never be enough fun for Sky and its customers.
I should have made it clear you could never jump in front of a clearance with arms raised above the head, or even held wide . But in defensive situations the arms away from the body was not un-natural and as long as the hand didn’t go to the ball, and naturally not above head ,, in corners and crosses with players trying to gain height this was subjective..personally I don’t think they have improved anything,
Edited by Putitout (18 Dec 2023 6.24pm)

Edited by Putitout (18 Dec 2023 7.00pm)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Dec 23 6.35pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I was worried when Henderson went down holding his thigh. They said it was just cramp. Anyone know for sure?

Looked like cramp, maybe just lack of match fitness. Unusual for a goalkeeper though.

 

EddieMac Flag 18 Dec 23 7.15pm

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker

You come across as being younger , much younger

Your thinking more like 8 I’d say.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 18 Dec 23 7.18pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Your thinking more like 8 I’d say.

 

The groover Flag Danbury 18 Dec 23 8.01pm

Originally posted by The groover

Nope. This is the rule: Immediately after touching the ball with the arm, even accidentally, the player scores a goal or creates a goal-scoring opportunity. Unless it's a top six side, then it will be ignored.

Their second should NOT have stood on that basis.

OK, I've edited the rule for accuracy.

 

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 18 Dec 23 8.50pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

On Ref Watch, Sky via Dermot Gallagher addressed the handball in the expected way; they didn't mention it. Dogso Gallagher did though say Ederson didn't deserve a red card because JPM was going away from, rather than toward, the goal.

So this would be the same Dermot Gallagher who, in the Palace v Leeds cup tie missed Tommy Black’s shot a) crossing the line and b) being punched out from behind the line and back into play ?

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Dec 23 9.17pm

Originally posted by trapperjohn

So this would be the same Dermot Gallagher who, in the Palace v Leeds cup tie missed Tommy Black’s shot a) crossing the line and b) being punched out from behind the line and back into play ?

The very fellow - given the opportunity he'll explain why he was totally in right in both cases.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Dec 23 8.12am

Originally posted by trapperjohn

So this would be the same Dermot Gallagher who, in the Palace v Leeds cup tie missed Tommy Black’s shot a) crossing the line and b) being punched out from behind the line and back into play ?

I remember the camera behind the goal. The ref had a perfect view and was not obstructed and yet he missed the goal and or the handball.

 


One more point

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 19 Dec 23 8.53am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Your thinking more like 8 I’d say.

As I said, "the season (allegedly) of goodwill".

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 19 Dec 23 10.14am

Originally posted by JRW2

As I said, "the season (allegedly) of goodwill".

No offence . Bah hunbug

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 19 Dec 23 10.15am

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker

No offence . Or Bah humbug even

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 19 Dec 23 7.36pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3842826]

Not grammar, malapropism. Some times we don't know the word used is wrong, and others laugh at us. Spelling mistakes and grammatcal errors are fine to be ignored on a website like this, but it is kind to inform someone of a misused word. I had visions of fans clambering over each other to get to the dugout and tell Roy to play Ozoh! Which was laughable. A bit like saying Plaistow Eagle is an idiom. Funny on a different level.

Thanks for the English lesson Mate - my point was think we all understood what the OP meant - so really no point in highlighting it..!!

Think I’ve written enough legal letters in my time to have a reasonable command of the English language - but thanks anyway..!!

Think the saying is “what ever floats your boat” - crack on..!!

COYP

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 20 Dec 23 10.23am

Originally posted by 55 years a fan

So All u f***ing panty wetters f*** off support another club

I'd love to know if anyone has ever actually done this after some keyword warrior like you says this

 

Page 15 of 15 << First< 11 12 13 14 15

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City v Crystal Palace match thread