You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 2.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 152 of 187 < 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 >
Stirlingsays Flag 11 Apr 15 4.02pm

Quote imbored at 11 Apr 2015 3.10pm

They don't need a coalition with SNP. They could run a minority government with a vote by vote agreement with whatever parties will join them. That is the most likely outcome for the Tories too - a minority government. Not that the election is a waste of time, but a majority looks unlikely so it will come down to who will work with who. Labour or Tory minority government is the most likely outcome.

Scotland is still part of the UK and the tactical push in the press to essentially state that their vote should count for nothing is a preemptive attempt to thwart a not unlikely outcome to this election.

Edited by imbored (11 Apr 2015 3.47pm)


Scotland population wise is a small part of the Uk....Hell, London has about a million more people than the whole of Scotland......The amount of power given to an SNP in control of most seats in Scotland would be just completely unfair.

The idea that a minority Labour government can be propped up by break-away nationalists will be carnage to Labour in England.

Like I say....not with their ideological core vote but certainly with their historical vote. Those who voted Labour without thinking will certainly take another look once they realize what is happening.

The SNP will love it though because it will polarize many in England.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Apr 2015 4.04pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

imbored Flag UK 11 Apr 15 4.19pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Apr 2015 4.02pm

Quote imbored at 11 Apr 2015 3.10pm

They don't need a coalition with SNP. They could run a minority government with a vote by vote agreement with whatever parties will join them. That is the most likely outcome for the Tories too - a minority government. Not that the election is a waste of time, but a majority looks unlikely so it will come down to who will work with who. Labour or Tory minority government is the most likely outcome.

Scotland is still part of the UK and the tactical push in the press to essentially state that their vote should count for nothing is a preemptive attempt to thwart a not unlikely outcome to this election.

Edited by imbored (11 Apr 2015 3.47pm)


Scotland population wise is a small part of the Uk....Hell, London has about a million more people than the whole of Scotland......The amount of power given to an SNP in control of most seats in Scotland would be just completely unfair.

The idea that a minority Labour government can be propped up by break-away nationalists will be carnage to Labour in England.

Like I say....not with their ideological core vote but certainly with their historical vote. Those who voted Labour without thinking will certainly take another look once they realize what is happening.

The SNP will love it though because it will polarize many in England.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Apr 2015 4.04pm)

It is a small part of the UK, yes, hence it has a much smaller number of seats. That's already something that's factored in. It makes no greater sense to say they these seats should have no worth. In fact clearly that makes no sense. As always, the number of seats will hold the value defined by how necessary they are. A problem with the outcome is a problem with the system.

A Lib Dem - Tory coalition sounded ludicrous before it happened. They took a hit because of it and as you say maybe Labour would too. It's unknown as politically they are more closely aligned on many issues. It would depend how many concessions Labour were giving. Those with power and influence should've thought about all of this before the comically one sided No to independence campaign won the day.

Edited by imbored (11 Apr 2015 4.58pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 11 Apr 15 5.19pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Apr 2015 4.02pm

Quote imbored at 11 Apr 2015 3.10pm

They don't need a coalition with SNP. They could run a minority government with a vote by vote agreement with whatever parties will join them. That is the most likely outcome for the Tories too - a minority government. Not that the election is a waste of time, but a majority looks unlikely so it will come down to who will work with who. Labour or Tory minority government is the most likely outcome.

Scotland is still part of the UK and the tactical push in the press to essentially state that their vote should count for nothing is a preemptive attempt to thwart a not unlikely outcome to this election.

Edited by imbored (11 Apr 2015 3.47pm)


Scotland population wise is a small part of the Uk....Hell, London has about a million more people than the whole of Scotland......The amount of power given to an SNP in control of most seats in Scotland would be just completely unfair.

The idea that a minority Labour government can be propped up by break-away nationalists will be carnage to Labour in England.

Like I say....not with their ideological core vote but certainly with their historical vote. Those who voted Labour without thinking will certainly take another look once they realize what is happening.

The SNP will love it though because it will polarize many in England.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Apr 2015 4.04pm)


Average constituency size in England estimated at c.72,000,in Scotland c.69,000.So,little difference between number of constituencies per national entity and population size.Why should a Scottish constituency within the UK parliament be worth any less in terms of legitimacy than an English one?

You appear to suggest when it suits you that within the UK (and I seem to recall you support the Union),it would be awful if the SNP had a block of say about 40 seats and thus formed a coalition since many would be disaffected and the Labour vote might experience "carnage".

Interestingly,I suspect if your wildest dreams came true and UKIP got a block of about 40 seats within the UK and formed a coalition with the Tories,you somehow wouldn't call it a disaster, "completely unfair" and a legitimate recipe for disaffection and that the Tory vote might thus experience "carnage".

All this scare story stuff about Labour and the SNP is no different to a similar such scare story about the Tories and UKIP should your wildest dream have taken off,and one which you would no doubt have condemned as the "usual lefty fear mongering nonsense".

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2015 5.22pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Apr 15 5.21pm

Quote imbored at 11 Apr 2015 4.19pm

It is a small part of the UK, yes, hence it has a much smaller number of seats. That's already something that's factored in. It makes no greater sense to say they these seats should have no worth. In fact clearly that makes no sense. As always, the number of seats will hold the value defined by how necessary they are. A problem with the outcome is a problem with the system.

A Lib Dem - Tory coalition sounded ludicrous before it happened. They took a hit because of it and as you say maybe Labour would too. It's unknown as politically they are more closely aligned on many issues. It would depend how many concessions Labour were giving. Those with power and influence should've thought about all of this before the comically one sided No to independence campaign won the day.

Edited by imbored (11 Apr 2015 4.58pm)

Well, I agree with some of your points here but as one who never really got my head around a Tory/Lib coalition instead of minority government I'm definitely not looking forward to Scottish nationalists being king-makers with significant power in England.....With too much power in relation to the number of votes won.

That has definitely happened with the Lib Dems this last term.

This is just a win win for the Scottish nationalists....They know that if Labour need them in Westminster that it's going to damage the union cause in England as well as Labour's generally.

As for Labour being criticised for backing the 'No' campaign in Scotland.....I think that is completely wrong......The people to blame for how things are going are the Scottish people.....They have decided to vote nationalist because that is what they feel will gain them the most from the rest of the UK.

What it is going to eventually gain them is independence because good will towards the union is gradually being eroded in England.

Outside of Labour's core vote I can see a Labour government kept in power by nationalists going down in England like a lead balloon.

System or not.


Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Apr 2015 5.23pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Apr 15 5.50pm

Quote legaleagle at 11 Apr 2015 5.19pm

Average constituency size in England estimated at c.72,000,in Scotland c.69,000.So,little difference between number of constituencies per national entity and population size.Why should a Scottish constituency within the UK parliament be worth any less in terms of legitimacy than an English one?

You appear to suggest when it suits you that within the UK (and I seem to recall you support the Union),it would be awful if the SNP had a block of say about 40 seats and thus formed a coalition since many would be disaffected and the Labour vote might experience "carnage".

Interestingly,I suspect if your wildest dreams came true and UKIP got a block of about 40 seats within the UK and formed a coalition with the Tories,you somehow wouldn't call it a disaster, "completely unfair" and a legitimate recipe for disaffection and that the Tory vote might thus experience "carnage".

All this scare story stuff about Labour and the SNP is no different to a similar such scare story about the Tories and UKIP should your wildest dream have taken off,and one which you would no doubt have condemned as the "usual lefty fear mongering nonsense".

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2015 5.22pm)


I don't begrudge Scottish seats in parliament what I begrudge is Scottish nationalists holding power and having say over England by pact or coalition.....Which by far is the largest part of the union.

The Scottish moan about the reverse but here again it has to be said, they are a population of five/six million....It isn't really comparable in fairness.

Like I say, If this happened I would blame the Scottish voters more than anyone for essentially voting for a union break-away party in massive numbers.....And Labour but only if they took the deal....In my view it's probably better...If more chaotic to go with minority government, with eventually a re-vote.

When you compare the effect of voting for Ukip with the affect of voting for break-away nationalist upon the English population you are talking about two very different concepts Legal.

Ukip aren't anti the UK union....Ukip are a party that campaigns for a referendum on the EU. The English....And I'll repeat it. The English comprise of the vast majority of the UK and tax paid into it...The UK us broadly in favour of a referendum anyway......So your musings on the impact of Ukip having some minor say makes no sense.....Outside of the pro EU left who would hate it of course.

As for what outcome I'd like.....To be honest I'm voting Ukip because of my dislike of the framing of the freedom of movement laws and for how the EU is structured generally.....Also out of irritation of how the left and the Tories have treated Ukip generally.

I want a re-alignment of our relationship with the EU.....But outside of that I don't think there is an outcome that I'm too happy with anyway.

It's going to be a very hard five years whatever happens.

I can't stand Cameron.
I quite like somethings about Miliband but Labour generally usually cock things up.
Ukip.....There most important policies align with mine.
Lib Dems.....I usually find I'm opposed to most of their ideas.
Greens.....I was quite impressed with that Aussie bird in the debates (though why is an Aussie standing for a UK seat? Never mind)....Still most Green policies are ridiculous when subjected to serious analysis.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 11 Apr 15 9.00pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Apr 2015 5.50pm

Quote legaleagle at 11 Apr 2015 5.19pm

Average constituency size in England estimated at c.72,000,in Scotland c.69,000.So,little difference between number of constituencies per national entity and population size.Why should a Scottish constituency within the UK parliament be worth any less in terms of legitimacy than an English one?

You appear to suggest when it suits you that within the UK (and I seem to recall you support the Union),it would be awful if the SNP had a block of say about 40 seats and thus formed a coalition since many would be disaffected and the Labour vote might experience "carnage".

Interestingly,I suspect if your wildest dreams came true and UKIP got a block of about 40 seats within the UK and formed a coalition with the Tories,you somehow wouldn't call it a disaster, "completely unfair" and a legitimate recipe for disaffection and that the Tory vote might thus experience "carnage".

All this scare story stuff about Labour and the SNP is no different to a similar such scare story about the Tories and UKIP should your wildest dream have taken off,and one which you would no doubt have condemned as the "usual lefty fear mongering nonsense".

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2015 5.22pm)


I don't begrudge Scottish seats in parliament what I begrudge is Scottish nationalists holding power and having say over England by pact or coalition.....Which by far is the largest part of the union.

The Scottish moan about the reverse but here again it has to be said, they are a population of five/six million....It isn't really comparable in fairness.

Like I say, If this happened I would blame the Scottish voters more than anyone for essentially voting for a union break-away party in massive numbers.....And Labour but only if they took the deal....In my view it's probably better...If more chaotic to go with minority government, with eventually a re-vote.

When you compare the effect of voting for Ukip with the affect of voting for break-away nationalist upon the English population you are talking about two very different concepts Legal.

Ukip aren't anti the UK union....Ukip are a party that campaigns for a referendum on the EU. The English....And I'll repeat it. The English comprise of the vast majority of the UK and tax paid into it...The UK us broadly in favour of a referendum anyway......So your musings on the impact of Ukip having some minor say makes no sense.....Outside of the pro EU left who would hate it of course.

As for what outcome I'd like.....To be honest I'm voting Ukip because of my dislike of the framing of the freedom of movement laws and for how the EU is structured generally.....Also out of irritation of how the left and the Tories have treated Ukip generally.

I want a re-alignment of our relationship with the EU.....But outside of that I don't think there is an outcome that I'm too happy with anyway.

It's going to be a very hard five years whatever happens.

I can't stand Cameron.
I quite like somethings about Miliband but Labour generally usually cock things up.
Ukip.....There most important policies align with mine.
Lib Dems.....I usually find I'm opposed to most of their ideas.
Greens.....I was quite impressed with that Aussie bird in the debates (though why is an Aussie standing for a UK seat? Never mind)....Still most Green policies are ridiculous when subjected to serious analysis.


According to YouGov she has British nationality and has lived here for 15 years.She is an immigrant Stirling

You do strike me as coming across as primarily an English nationalist.Voters in Scotland have proportionately no greater or lesser sway over the outcome of a government than those in England.It all depends how you view it and what you view as the most objectionable outcome.For me a Tory/UKIP coalition government with UKIP holding the balance of power with say 40 seats would be it.For you,I guess it would be a Labour/SNP government government with the SNP holding 40 or so seats.

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2015 9.04pm)

 

imbored Flag UK 11 Apr 15 10.05pm

Quote legaleagle at 11 Apr 2015 9.00pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 Apr 2015 5.50pm

Quote legaleagle at 11 Apr 2015 5.19pm

Average constituency size in England estimated at c.72,000,in Scotland c.69,000.So,little difference between number of constituencies per national entity and population size.Why should a Scottish constituency within the UK parliament be worth any less in terms of legitimacy than an English one?

You appear to suggest when it suits you that within the UK (and I seem to recall you support the Union),it would be awful if the SNP had a block of say about 40 seats and thus formed a coalition since many would be disaffected and the Labour vote might experience "carnage".

Interestingly,I suspect if your wildest dreams came true and UKIP got a block of about 40 seats within the UK and formed a coalition with the Tories,you somehow wouldn't call it a disaster, "completely unfair" and a legitimate recipe for disaffection and that the Tory vote might thus experience "carnage".

All this scare story stuff about Labour and the SNP is no different to a similar such scare story about the Tories and UKIP should your wildest dream have taken off,and one which you would no doubt have condemned as the "usual lefty fear mongering nonsense".

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2015 5.22pm)


I don't begrudge Scottish seats in parliament what I begrudge is Scottish nationalists holding power and having say over England by pact or coalition.....Which by far is the largest part of the union.

The Scottish moan about the reverse but here again it has to be said, they are a population of five/six million....It isn't really comparable in fairness.

Like I say, If this happened I would blame the Scottish voters more than anyone for essentially voting for a union break-away party in massive numbers.....And Labour but only if they took the deal....In my view it's probably better...If more chaotic to go with minority government, with eventually a re-vote.

When you compare the effect of voting for Ukip with the affect of voting for break-away nationalist upon the English population you are talking about two very different concepts Legal.

Ukip aren't anti the UK union....Ukip are a party that campaigns for a referendum on the EU. The English....And I'll repeat it. The English comprise of the vast majority of the UK and tax paid into it...The UK us broadly in favour of a referendum anyway......So your musings on the impact of Ukip having some minor say makes no sense.....Outside of the pro EU left who would hate it of course.

As for what outcome I'd like.....To be honest I'm voting Ukip because of my dislike of the framing of the freedom of movement laws and for how the EU is structured generally.....Also out of irritation of how the left and the Tories have treated Ukip generally.

I want a re-alignment of our relationship with the EU.....But outside of that I don't think there is an outcome that I'm too happy with anyway.

It's going to be a very hard five years whatever happens.

I can't stand Cameron.
I quite like somethings about Miliband but Labour generally usually cock things up.
Ukip.....There most important policies align with mine.
Lib Dems.....I usually find I'm opposed to most of their ideas.
Greens.....I was quite impressed with that Aussie bird in the debates (though why is an Aussie standing for a UK seat? Never mind)....Still most Green policies are ridiculous when subjected to serious analysis.


According to YouGov she has British nationality and has lived here for 15 years.She is an immigrant Stirling

You do strike me as coming across as primarily an English nationalist.Voters in Scotland have proportionately no greater or lesser sway over the outcome of a government than those in England.It all depends how you view it and what you view as the most objectionable outcome.For me a Tory/UKIP coalition government with UKIP holding the balance of power with say 40 seats would be it.For you,I guess it would be a Labour/SNP government government with the SNP holding 40 or so seats.

Edited by legaleagle (11 Apr 2015 9.04pm)

If this forum teaches you anything it's that people enjoy being pissed off and pointing the finger elsewhere. Whether they're Scottish, English or whatever. It's the way of the world. We use various mental gymnastics to comfort and convince ourselves that others are the problem. If you want an authentic life you have to look for the needles in the haystack and just find 'good people' which has nothing to do with nationality, disability, gender, sexuality, race, politics. Not people throwing their weight around or being overly political day to day. Just good people who see beyond the silly templates we place over communities and individuals.


Edited by imbored (11 Apr 2015 10.56pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Apr 15 1.02am

Ah egalitarians and their world views.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

imbored Flag UK 12 Apr 15 1.16am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2015 1.02am

Ah egalitarians and their world views.


Are you saying that not believing disability, gender, sexuality, race should define a person's worth is somehow a flawed or lesser world view?

Edited by imbored (12 Apr 2015 1.19am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Apr 15 1.22am

Quote imbored at 12 Apr 2015 1.16am

Are you saying that issues like not believing disability, gender, sexuality, race should define a person's worth is somehow a flawed or lesser world view?

It's not about disability, gender, sexuality or race.

It's about connection and common experience.....For example, do you regard a stranger you have never met as important to you as a family member?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

imbored Flag UK 12 Apr 15 1.27am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2015 1.22am

Quote imbored at 12 Apr 2015 1.16am

Are you saying that issues like not believing disability, gender, sexuality, race should define a person's worth is somehow a flawed or lesser world view?

It's not about disability, gender, sexuality or race.

It's about connection and common experience.....For example, do you regard a stranger you have never met as important to you as a family member?

Your own family members and friends may well fall into various groups including these so it's a bad analogy. You're immediately placing these groups as 'other than', people that you have to go out and find and experience that somehow aren't part and parcel of life by default.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Apr 15 1.34am

Quote imbored at 12 Apr 2015 1.27am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2015 1.22am

Quote imbored at 12 Apr 2015 1.16am

Are you saying that issues like not believing disability, gender, sexuality, race should define a person's worth is somehow a flawed or lesser world view?

It's not about disability, gender, sexuality or race.

It's about connection and common experience.....For example, do you regard a stranger you have never met as important to you as a family member?

Your own family members and friends may well fall into various groups including these so it's a bad analogy. You're immediately placing these groups as 'other than', people that you have to go out and find and experience that somehow aren't part and parcel of life by default.



It doesn't matter if your family members or friends fall into any particular group you mentioned as it isn't about that.

Like I said it's about connection and common experience.

So like I said, do you regard a stranger you have never met as important to you as a family member?

You see where I'm going with this.....And hence maybe why I regard egalitarianism as a limited though noble tool....But a conceptual tool that is frequently not examined by those who use it.

Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Apr 2015 1.35am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

imbored Flag UK 12 Apr 15 1.48am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2015 1.34am

Quote imbored at 12 Apr 2015 1.27am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2015 1.22am

Quote imbored at 12 Apr 2015 1.16am

Are you saying that issues like not believing disability, gender, sexuality, race should define a person's worth is somehow a flawed or lesser world view?

It's not about disability, gender, sexuality or race.

It's about connection and common experience.....For example, do you regard a stranger you have never met as important to you as a family member?

Your own family members and friends may well fall into various groups including these so it's a bad analogy. You're immediately placing these groups as 'other than', people that you have to go out and find and experience that somehow aren't part and parcel of life by default.



It doesn't matter if your family members or friends fall into any particular group you mentioned as it isn't about that.

Like I said it's about connection and common experience.

So like I said, do you regard a stranger you have never met as important to you as a family member?

You see where I'm going with this.....And hence maybe why I regard egalitarianism as a limited though noble tool....But a conceptual tool that is frequently not examined by those who use it.

Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Apr 2015 1.35am)

It very much matters. If a family member is disabled you're likely to develop an understanding of those challenges and so on. Groups aren't outside of our everyday experience, they are part of our every day life.

You said 'Ah egalitarians and their world views' as if my outlook was somehow lesser. You're free to believe that, but you love your own family because you know them, that appears to be your point. Therefore appreciating others rather than side stepping them is actually a way to acknowledge that process. We're all free to ignore that, and to varying degrees we do, but it reduces the reality of who people are and replaces it with the most convenient caricature to hand.


Edited by imbored (12 Apr 2015 2.37am)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Apr 15 7.59pm

Disabled unborn? Abort him/her!
[Link]

What a lovely man.

 

TUX Flag redhill 13 Apr 15 10.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 13 Apr 2015 7.59pm

Disabled unborn? Abort him/her!
[Link]

What a lovely man.

This rings a sad bell.
Around 18months ago my best mate (also called Geoff) and his wife chose to terminate due to 'Downs'.
They're both in their 40's and for what it's worth, many would view them as the perfect couple. They already have 2 lovely healthy children, a boy of 9 and a girl of 6.
A third, as planned, came along but they saw the results of a scan.
Rather than giving him a chance, they chose to kill their third child because he wasn't 'perfect'.

We don't talk as much as we used to.


Edited by TUX (13 Apr 2015 10.25pm)

 

imbored Flag UK 13 Apr 15 11.13pm

Quote TUX at 13 Apr 2015 10.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 13 Apr 2015 7.59pm

Disabled unborn? Abort him/her!
[Link]

What a lovely man.

This rings a sad bell.
Around 18months ago my best mate (also called Geoff) and his wife chose to terminate due to 'Downs'.
They're both in their 40's and for what it's worth, many would view them as the perfect couple. They already have 2 lovely healthy children, a boy of 9 and a girl of 6.
A third, as planned, came along but they saw the results of a scan.
Rather than giving him a chance, they chose to kill their third child because he wasn't 'perfect'.

We don't talk as much as we used to.


Edited by TUX (13 Apr 2015 10.25pm)


It's got to be said, UKIP don't half attract more than their fair share of candidates with bottom of the barrel views.

Edited by imbored (13 Apr 2015 11.14pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Apr 15 10.57am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2015 1.22am

Quote imbored at 12 Apr 2015 1.16am

Are you saying that issues like not believing disability, gender, sexuality, race should define a person's worth is somehow a flawed or lesser world view?

It's not about disability, gender, sexuality or race.

It's about connection and common experience.....For example, do you regard a stranger you have never met as important to you as a family member?

Indeed, its not about actual real things, but tags associated by accidents of geography that are themselves given meaning by lines drawn on a map that have shifted over the years.

Connection and common experience are largely irrelivent as they're nowhere near any kind of consistancy, and entirely subjective.

A stranger of course means less to me than a member of my family, but that can never actually define anything in terms of objective determinations, that stranger should have the same rights as my family member (even if I don't like them or what they stand for).

All citizens of a nation should have the same rights, irrespective of whether they're a citizen of birth or by migration (and irrespective of any defining characteristics such as gender, race, ethnicity, sexual orientation) - except where a necessity occurs (disabled people for example may have special dispensation in say welfare provision towards enabling them to experience a more full participation in society).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Apr 15 10.58am

Quote imbored at 13 Apr 2015 11.13pm

Quote TUX at 13 Apr 2015 10.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 13 Apr 2015 7.59pm

Disabled unborn? Abort him/her!
[Link]

What a lovely man.

This rings a sad bell.
Around 18months ago my best mate (also called Geoff) and his wife chose to terminate due to 'Downs'.
They're both in their 40's and for what it's worth, many would view them as the perfect couple. They already have 2 lovely healthy children, a boy of 9 and a girl of 6.
A third, as planned, came along but they saw the results of a scan.
Rather than giving him a chance, they chose to kill their third child because he wasn't 'perfect'.

We don't talk as much as we used to.


Edited by TUX (13 Apr 2015 10.25pm)


It's got to be said, UKIP don't half attract more than their fair share of candidates with bottom of the barrel views.

Edited by imbored (13 Apr 2015 11.14pm)

Indeed, which is sad, because UKIP had a very good point to begin with, about a referendum on the EU - which at its core is something the UK should decide rather than parliment. Its up to politicians to sell us on such changes, rather than force them on us.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Apr 15 11.06am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2015 1.34amYou see where I'm going with this.....And hence maybe why I regard egalitarianism as a limited though noble tool....But a conceptual tool that is frequently not examined by those who use it.
Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Apr 2015 1.35am)

The same could be said of nationalism. The key to any idealogical concept - Is that it has to be drawn on a basis which is defined within the spirit of that nation, and a democracy which does not extend the notion of equality where ever it can, eventually suffers from becoming a 'tyranny of the majority': we extend rights, and protections, to minority groups within democratic society, that maybe aren't defined for majority groups, to protect them from the majority.

The history of groups, such as the disabled, migrants, women, gay, lesbian, transgendered, the mentally ill, prisoners etc throughout history has been one where in their rights to be citizens are defined, not by their best interests or freedoms, but by the opinions of them by majority power groups - resulting in situations of oppression through ignorance, prejudice often protrayed as 'good intentions'.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

imbored Flag UK 14 Apr 15 11.22am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Apr 2015 10.57am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2015 1.22am

Quote imbored at 12 Apr 2015 1.16am

Are you saying that issues like not believing disability, gender, sexuality, race should define a person's worth is somehow a flawed or lesser world view?

It's not about disability, gender, sexuality or race.

It's about connection and common experience.....For example, do you regard a stranger you have never met as important to you as a family member?

Indeed, its not about actual real things, but tags associated by accidents of geography that are themselves given meaning by lines drawn on a map that have shifted over the years.

Connection and common experience are largely irrelivent as they're nowhere near any kind of consistancy, and entirely subjective.

A stranger of course means less to me than a member of my family, but that can never actually define anything in terms of objective determinations, that stranger should have the same rights as my family member (even if I don't like them or what they stand for).

All citizens of a nation should have the same rights, irrespective of whether they're a citizen of birth or by migration (and irrespective of any defining characteristics such as gender, race, ethnicity, sexual orientation) - except where a necessity occurs (disabled people for example may have special dispensation in say welfare provision towards enabling them to experience a more full participation in society).

I agree with what your saying here. The very point raised "do you regard a stranger you have never met as important to you as a family member?" is a mindset rather than a useful argument. I went down the social groups route because the implication was that if someone is more distant or has a less common experience it's fine for a society to care less about them or to treat them differently. Better to use your love for people to appreciate commonality, not to relegate.


Edited by imbored (14 Apr 2015 11.36am)

 

Page 152 of 187 < 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic