You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 4 2026 1.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Brexit Thread (LOCKED)


Page 1527 of 1552 < 1523 1524 1525 1526 1527 1528 1529 1530 1531 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 10 Dec 20 4.44pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Of course. Just don't hold your breath. It would be 30 years by some of the Brexiteers own estimates before we recovered to where we were. The disaster will be apparent much sooner than that.

I shall retire from this thread for a while now and not return, unless by some miracle we do get a deal agreed, for a few months when we can review just how things are progressing.

Until then you can share each other's anti-EU sentiments, and prophecies of it's impending implosion, to your heart's content.

It will implode, possibly not in the near future but it will. Barnier and his cronies will be responsible, not the bigoted racists ( according to bbs) who voted leave. Whatever you are doing during your sabbatical, I hope you stay well and enjoy yourself ( seriously )

Edited by Spiderman (10 Dec 2020 4.45pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 10 Dec 20 4.47pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Very unlikely.

The EU cannot compromise their position. They don't have the authority to do so, even if they wanted to, which they don't.

It on our side that any shift is possible and that is not going to happen, given the language.

This is just a blame game now.

They don’t have the authority? Who does then?

 

jeeagles Flag 10 Dec 20 6.11pm

Everything to do with Brexit seems to be so overstated.

Project fear hasn't really happened.
The UK has announced a pretty generous post Brexit immigration policy.
Deals with other nations are being done.
The Northern Ireland boarder issues been resolved.

There are 3 issues left to resolve to avoid a no deal.

In the event of a no deal, the EU has already set out a pathway to continue travel and trade for 6 months in the interim.

Two of the 3 issues left are slightly contentious, limit EU fishing in our waters and limit the EUs influence on our laws.

The final issue of how to deal with disputes should be pretty straight forward once the other two are done.

I suspect we'll see a lot of political posturing on both sides, but eventually agree that there will be a phased licencing of fishing in British Waters and some kind of non-dilusion agreement with level playing field rules.

Stringing out to the last minute will let voters know that both sides fought the good fight and this is the best deal that could be "slogged out".

 

Matov Flag 11 Dec 20 8.18am

Remoaners tears have never tasted so delicious as they do today and I suspect for the next 48-72 hours or so although I still fear a betrayal.

If no-deal becomes a reality (and fingers crossed) one thing that I will never be able to understand is why this was not accepted as the default position from the start with any talks with the EU handled accordingly?

These redlines about fishing and the so called equal playing field in terms of regulations have existed since day 1 and it has also been clear that the EU simply cannot deliver an agreed mandate on them.

So assume No-Deal from the start and if a deal emerges by the end of it, so be it?

Still lets see. Plenty of twists and turns and my gut instinct is still that a deal has been done with only the machinations of internal EU wrangling to work itself out.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Dec 20 8.34am

Originally posted by Matov

Remoaners tears have never tasted so delicious as they do today and I suspect for the next 48-72 hours or so although I still fear a betrayal.

If no-deal becomes a reality (and fingers crossed) one thing that I will never be able to understand is why this was not accepted as the default position from the start with any talks with the EU handled accordingly?

These redlines about fishing and the so called equal playing field in terms of regulations have existed since day 1 and it has also been clear that the EU simply cannot deliver an agreed mandate on them.

So assume No-Deal from the start and if a deal emerges by the end of it, so be it?

Still lets see. Plenty of twists and turns and my gut instinct is still that a deal has been done with only the machinations of internal EU wrangling to work itself out.

I'm still worried about the great Brexit betrayal.

 


One more point

Matov Flag 11 Dec 20 8.41am

Originally posted by Badger11

I'm still worried about the great Brexit betrayal.

Any deal with the EU involves betrayal. Because what is the point of Brexit if we do not have the freedom is fish our own waters as we want and also gain competitive advantage?

That is the point of it. Because it is beneficial for the UK.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

AuntyAnne70 Flag Tunbridge WElls 11 Dec 20 8.55am

This is why the country is so divided and you revel in it, ie "Remainers tears".

Four and a half years to get no deal and spending billions of pounds to achieve the total sum of nothing.

 

jeeagles Flag 11 Dec 20 8.55am

Originally posted by Matov

Any deal with the EU involves betrayal. Because what is the point of Brexit if we do not have the freedom is fish our own waters as we want and also gain competitive advantage?

That is the point of it. Because it is beneficial for the UK.

Given decades of free access to fishing in our waters, we probably don't have the capacity to have exclusive access.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 11 Dec 20 10.10am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Of course. Just don't hold your breath. It would be 30 years by some of the Brexiteers own estimates before we recovered to where we were. The disaster will be apparent much sooner than that.

I shall retire from this thread for a while now and not return, unless by some miracle we do get a deal agreed, for a few months when we can review just how things are progressing.

Until then you can share each other's anti-EU sentiments, and prophecies of it's impending implosion, to your heart's content.

So you remainers/rejoiners believe that IF we wanted to rejoin the EU in a few years, they would welcome us back on the same terms we are on now? NO, it will be with total freedom of movement for everyone, including the boat people, join the Euro currency, European court rulings etc etc......Is that what you want?

 

nead1 Flag 11 Dec 20 11.01am

You are essentially making the point at just how good a deal the UK had - outside the single currency, outside of Shengen, outside of the Social Chapter, numerous rebates etc. It will now be for the current Govt to demonstrate, and quickly, just how much better our lives and the economy will be as completely separate from the EU.

I have to say, I am far from optimistic. Just look at their record on a whole range of things especially Covid - hardly smacks of a competent administration on top of its game or even knowing what it's doing. The truth of the matter is that Boris likes to posture - ideally on the world stage; maybe the refusal of Merkle and Macron to engage with him might be a wake up call to "smell the coffee". His behaviour re the Internal Mkt Bill is coming back to haunt him but it's just a reflection of how he has always led his life.

As to your last point, I would certainly accept re-joining the EU as a member of the single currency, Shengen, ECJ etc - no more half in half out. Embrace Europe as we should have been doing for years and be at it's heart. Doubt that is your view but it's certainly mine.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Dec 20 11.12am

Originally posted by nead1


I have to say, I am far from optimistic. Just look at their record on a whole range of things especially Covid - hardly smacks of a competent administration on top of its game or even knowing what it's doing. The truth of the matter is that Boris likes to posture - ideally on the world stage; maybe the refusal of Merkle and Macron to engage with him might be a wake up call to "smell the coffee". His behaviour re the Internal Mkt Bill is coming back to haunt him but it's just a reflection of how he has always led his life.

=========

Boris has not done a great job so far but then we don't really leave the EU until next year. We at least can kick him out at the next election and pick a government that will do a better job.

This was always about controlling our own interests I think most Brexiteers are realistic enough to understand that we will get good and bad governments in the future which we can change unlike the straight jacket we were locked into by the EU.

 


One more point

Matov Flag 11 Dec 20 11.25am

Originally posted by AuntyAnne70

This is why the country is so divided and you revel in it, ie "Remainers tears".

.


The country is divided because a democratic vote was held, with a massive turn out, and a noisy minority of people then decided to try and have the result rendered null and void by heaping abuse and vitriol on people who dared vote for something they did not agree with.

And I said 'Remoaner' tears. Not remainers. I have zero issue with anybody who backed Remain in 2016. A perfectly legitimate position to support and back.

My utter and never ending contempt is for every single individual who then sort to try and have my leave vote rendered pointless after that result was known.

And I relish their tears. Perhaps I have to make an effort to forgive them and maybe when this is all done and dusted but until them I cherish every moment of their upset. Because they are my enemy. People who think their vote should somehow count more than mine.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 11 Dec 20 11.43am

Originally posted by nead1

You are essentially making the point at just how good a deal the UK had - outside the single currency, outside of Shengen, outside of the Social Chapter, numerous rebates etc. It will now be for the current Govt to demonstrate, and quickly, just how much better our lives and the economy will be as completely separate from the EU.

I have to say, I am far from optimistic. Just look at their record on a whole range of things especially Covid - hardly smacks of a competent administration on top of its game or even knowing what it's doing. The truth of the matter is that Boris likes to posture - ideally on the world stage; maybe the refusal of Merkle and Macron to engage with him might be a wake up call to "smell the coffee". His behaviour re the Internal Mkt Bill is coming back to haunt him but it's just a reflection of how he has always led his life.

As to your last point, I would certainly accept re-joining the EU as a member of the single currency, Shengen, ECJ etc - no more half in half out. Embrace Europe as we should have been doing for years and be at it's heart. Doubt that is your view but it's certainly mine.

so do you think British people would welcome changing the pound for the Euro?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 20 12.11pm

It is apparent that after years of negotiation the EU doesn’t understand what our bottom line is.

It is also apparent that the EU does not appreciate what being a "sovereign country" means, and if they don’t understand it now, they probably never will. I have believed that sensible people will, in the end, come to a sensible deal, which is satisfactory to both sides. This is often the reality in the real world.
There is often a great deal of brinkmanship involved, but in the end there is solution on the back of compromises from all parties.

At this juncture it is difficult to see a pathway to a deal.

 

nead1 Flag 11 Dec 20 1.02pm

My perspective is that despite all the hype, countries that are within the Euro have not done so badly with it; its a strong single currency (second only to the USD) and at the heart of most business aspects of the 27 with the fundamental aim of creating unity and peace - one of the founding principles of what has become todays EU.

I doubt however, as you say, if people were asked specifically about it that they would be pro the Euro - it would be about perceived issues of control all over again. That said, such decisions should be for Governments; that's why they are elected - to take the big decisions exactly as they should have done over membership of the EU. People at the heart of Govt at the time knew of the likely ramifications and they are now starting to unfold in a very clear and brutal way to the likely detriment of us all.

Anyway, that's my perspective - I guess time will ultimately be the decider but I for sure am not in the optimistic camp especially when the nonsence of so called Australian terms are revealed for the tosh that they always were - interestingly, strongly reinforced by Malcolm Turnbull last night

 

Matov Flag 11 Dec 20 1.05pm

Originally posted by nead1

My perspective is that despite all the hype, countries that are within the Euro have not done so badly with it; its a strong single currency (second only to the USD) and at the heart of most business aspects of the 27 with the fundamental aim of creating unity and peace - one of the founding principles of what has become todays EU.


So Greece is better off with the Euro then?

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 11 Dec 20 1.21pm

Originally posted by nead1

My perspective is that despite all the hype, countries that are within the Euro have not done so badly with it; its a strong single currency (second only to the USD) and at the heart of most business aspects of the 27 with the fundamental aim of creating unity and peace - one of the founding principles of what has become todays EU.

I doubt however, as you say, if people were asked specifically about it that they would be pro the Euro - it would be about perceived issues of control all over again. That said, such decisions should be for Governments; that's why they are elected - to take the big decisions exactly as they should have done over membership of the EU. People at the heart of Govt at the time knew of the likely ramifications and they are now starting to unfold in a very clear and brutal way to the likely detriment of us all.

Anyway, that's my perspective - I guess time will ultimately be the decider but I for sure am not in the optimistic camp especially when the nonsence of so called Australian terms are revealed for the tosh that they always were - interestingly, strongly reinforced by Malcolm Turnbull last night

So are you saying that the euro is a reason why we are not at war??

All I know is that when I lived in France the vast majority of French people hated the Euro

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Dec 20 2.10pm

Can anyone say which countries within the common market/EU would’ve gone to war with each other with disagreements escalating without the common market and then EU political union because I’m struggling. Don’t include Germany because East Germany was never in the EU.

 


COYP

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 11 Dec 20 2.27pm

Originally posted by AuntyAnne70

This is why the country is so divided and you revel in it, ie "Remainers tears".

Four and a half years to get no deal and spending billions of pounds to achieve the total sum of nothing.

Nothing ? Nothing you say? what about the £10 saving on a new dishwasher every 20 years? Some people just don"t appreciate a great deal when they get it!............

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 11 Dec 20 2.47pm

You will need a permit to drive in France or Spain if thats your holiday choice, you won"t now have medical cover unless you get it yourself, you will be paying about 5% more every day for your food, but who gives a fcuk? We are going to have all that lovely extra lolly boris promised us in only 3 weeks time! Can"t wait, might book a holiday or three on the strength of it, gentlemen, we are going to be loaded, in only 3 weeks! In boris we trust gentlemen, in boris we trust!

 

Page 1527 of 1552 < 1523 1524 1525 1526 1527 1528 1529 1530 1531 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic