This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Where have I said that we ought never criticise the government? We ought to show some restraint at the moment in an effort to sustain a national effort but these are exceptional times. We are talking about whether a report ought to be released just because some people want it to be. People are free to criticise that decision. Just as I am free to criticise Trump. Who does nothing himself to try to sustain a national effort in the USA. But that’s all people are doing: criticising the decision.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Separate problem. We elect our MPs and they form a government. Wherever they get their advice the buck stops with them and not the advisors. Nevertheless I would like to see all such advisors made redundant. They ought only work directly for political parties, primarily during election campaigns, and not be allowed near our elected representatives once chosen. There are expert civil servants there to provide the required specialist knowledge. We don't want marketing men deciding policy or spin doctors presenting it. Entirely agree but they’re here now and aren’t likely to be going anywhere soon.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
But that’s all people are doing: criticising the decision. And all I am doing is disagreeing!
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
And all I am doing is disagreeing! Fair enough. If the situation and attitudes are different in six months or a year or five years the decision is right. If not it’s wrong. If the situation is worse then it’s very wrong. Of course the people making the decision to reveal the information will be largely different to those choosing not to but that’s politics.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
And all I am doing is disagreeing! On the basis that somehow Government know best on this. When the overwhelming evidence, of decade after decade of not only ignoring the horrendous crimes but even, at least on a local level, helping it happen for political gain. Demands for transparency on any and every future investigation into it are not only perfectly acceptable but the only reasonable option given the multiple cover-ups over the years. Lies and deceit have allowed thousands of crimes to be committed. Why on earth are we meant to trust the institutions that enabled that to happen? To just accept, without total scrutiny, that really, despite it all, we should trust them to do the best thing now? And please don't tell me that they are good people. If they were, this issue would have been dealt with, for the good of all, years and years ago.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
On the basis that somehow Government know best on this. When the overwhelming evidence, of decade after decade of not only ignoring the horrendous crimes but even, at least on a local level, helping it happen for political gain. Demands for transparency on any and every future investigation into it are not only perfectly acceptable but the only reasonable option given the multiple cover-ups over the years. Lies and deceit have allowed thousands of crimes to be committed. Why on earth are we meant to trust the institutions that enabled that to happen? To just accept, without total scrutiny, that really, despite it all, we should trust them to do the best thing now? And please don't tell me that they are good people. If they were, this issue would have been dealt with, for the good of all, years and years ago. Exactly this is the whole point. For decades people in authority covered and or turned a blind eye and in some cases participated in serious sex crimes involving minors. Now we are expected to accept that a report into this should be kept secret for the public good. Seriously! When the main allegation is people in the know covering up and then the government won't tell us what they learned it beggars belief and we are expected to trust people in authority. The way you earn the trust of the public is to publish and then deal with the fall out. It will not be comfortable reading for certain political parties and the police and local councils, social services will rightly take a hammering. You then put in place procedures* to ensure it never happens again (the cover up I mean). Imagine if the MacPherson inquiry into racism in the police was never published in case it upset people Labour didn't have a problem with that did they. Too many skeletons that is the real issue here. * I would create a new criminal offence specifically aimed at people in authority such as the social service, police, politicians etc. Failure to act on serious allegations of abuse, failure to document and report these allegations etc. would result in jail time as criminal negligence. If you threaten these people with serious jail time for not doing their job they will soon decide it's not worth protecting individuals or groups. Edited by Badger11 (27 Apr 2020 8.42am) Edited by Badger11 (27 Apr 2020 8.42am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
On the basis that somehow Government know best on this. When the overwhelming evidence, of decade after decade of not only ignoring the horrendous crimes but even, at least on a local level, helping it happen for political gain. Demands for transparency on any and every future investigation into it are not only perfectly acceptable but the only reasonable option given the multiple cover-ups over the years. Lies and deceit have allowed thousands of crimes to be committed. Why on earth are we meant to trust the institutions that enabled that to happen? To just accept, without total scrutiny, that really, despite it all, we should trust them to do the best thing now? And please don't tell me that they are good people. If they were, this issue would have been dealt with, for the good of all, years and years ago. There are a number of, what I regard, as incorrect, assertions there. I don't necessarily believe the government, or anybody else actually, know "best". My belief is that as they are the ones with both the responsibility and the knowledge of what's in the report, and that we elected them to take these decisions on our behalf, we ought to give them the benefit of any doubt. If their judgement, probably guided by the Police, is that "transparency" would make matters worse then I think, whatever any personal reservations we might have, that their decision must be respected. It's easy to throw mud and suggest there were past "cover ups" but unless you know all the circumstances, what guided decision making at the time, who made them etc etc all you are doing is being wise after the event. As we know hindsight is a wonderful thing but it doesn't determine what decisions are needed now. It only provides useful experience which I am sure will have been considered. The focus has to be on the most effective way to deal with the issue now, given all the current circumstances.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There are a number of, what I regard, as incorrect, assertions there. I don't necessarily believe the government, or anybody else actually, know "best". My belief is that as they are the ones with both the responsibility and the knowledge of what's in the report, and that we elected them to take these decisions on our behalf, we ought to give them the benefit of any doubt. If their judgement, probably guided by the Police, is that "transparency" would make matters worse then I think, whatever any personal reservations we might have, that their decision must be respected. It's easy to throw mud and suggest there were past "cover ups" but unless you know all the circumstances, what guided decision making at the time, who made them etc etc all you are doing is being wise after the event. As we know hindsight is a wonderful thing but it doesn't determine what decisions are needed now. It only provides useful experience which I am sure will have been considered. The focus has to be on the most effective way to deal with the issue now, given all the current circumstances. Make matters worse for who?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
My belief is that as they are the ones with both the responsibility and the knowledge... They had the responsibility back in the 90's. And they had the knowledge of what was going on. And failed to do anything. That is why they do not deserve even the slightest benefit of the doubt because the majority of the population simply do not trust them along with wanting to know who they are seeking to 'protect'? They failed to protect those girls. A nailed on, indisputable fact. And I do not trust them to do so now. Refusing to publish this report only serves to increase that lack of trust. Can you offer a single reason why we should trust them now? For me, I believe it was Naz Shah who inadvertently exposed what the true establishment position was. That these girls were considered worthless. A cheap price to pay for 'community cohesion'. And that the same people who seek to squash these findings now genuinely wish those girls had just closed their eyes and thought of a multi-cultural England. A kind of payback for all the Imperial ills of our forefathers.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Make matters worse for who? I haven't read the report any more than you have. So we are both making assumptions. My assumption was that maybe the Police think it could make things worse at this particular time by them having to divert scarce resources. How to reassure the victims and their families is clearly important but that will only be achieved with actions, and not with reports. My expectation is that something will be released, possibly in redacted form to protect ongoing investigations, when it is considered safe to do so.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
They had the responsibility back in the 90's. And they had the knowledge of what was going on. And failed to do anything.
Refusing to publish this report only serves to increase that lack of trust. Can you offer a single reason why we should trust them now? For me, I believe it was Naz Shah who inadvertently exposed what the true establishment position was. That these girls were considered worthless. A cheap price to pay for 'community cohesion'. And that the same people who seek to squash these findings now genuinely wish those girls had just closed their eyes and thought of a multi-cultural England. A kind of payback for all the Imperial ills of our forefathers.
Who are "they"? Those dealing with things now were almost certainly not involved then. There was a different culture then. We have learned but then there has been austerity and the cuts to services and the stress it has put those working in those services under. Playing a blame game achieves nothing for anyone. Only learning lessons does any good. We need to trust them because we chose them. Who we delegate responsibility to is our burden to bear.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Who are "they"? Those dealing with things now were almost certainly not involved then. There was a different culture then. We have learned but then there has been austerity and the cuts to services and the stress it has put those working in those services under. Playing a blame game achieves nothing for anyone. Only learning lessons does any good. We need to trust them because we chose them. Who we delegate responsibility to is our burden to bear. How do we know that anything is changed unless a full investigation is carried out? The investigation would recommend changes - perhaps even go as far as to incriminate people.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
We need to trust them because we chose them. Who we delegate responsibility to is our burden to bear. Back to Trump. He was chosen too.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Who are "they"? Those dealing with things now were almost certainly not involved then. 1 There was a different culture then. We have learned 2but then there has been austerity and the cuts to services and the stress it has put those working in those services under. Playing a blame game achieves nothing for anyone. Only learning lessons does any good. We need to trust them because we chose them. Who we delegate responsibility to is our burden to bear. 1. You don't know they are not the same poeple. 2. Have they learned? Even if these are not the same people what they have learned is you can cover up scandals. To me it is not just about grooming gangs it is the cosy establishment stitch up where the local councillor takes a bung from a property developer or awards a juicy contract. We need to shine a light on the murky world of local politics and to make it clear that people will go to jail for abusing the their office or turning a blind eye. Every time we have another Baby P or Victoria Climbie we get the same BS and nobody in authority gets punished in fact the only punishment appears to be a golden goodbye and a fat pension.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
How do we know that anything is changed unless a full investigation is carried out? The investigation would recommend changes - perhaps even go as far as to incriminate people. It's a question of whether a situation will be made better or worse, by doing something. In this case releasing a report publically. The government will know they will come in for a lot of criticism if they don't, so there must be some pretty solid reasons behind it. As I said I expect, in time, for it either to be released in full, or perhaps in redacted form. Watergate was revealed by journalists, not by a government investigation. Nixon resigned before he could be impeached. It's whether the consequential actions are achieved that matter and not whether we get the opportunity to read all the salacious detail. That's what the tabloids want of course. It's not that I want anything "brushed under the carpet". I don't want things being made public that could impact on the success of investigations and prosecutions. Satisfying a salivating section of the public eager to confirm their opinions of the Police and Social Services isn't on my agenda. Finding the best way to solve the problem is. Interfering with prosecutions by allowing defence lawyers to claim their client's rights had been compromised by the release of a report would be the best way to "help peadophiles". Keeping the Police's information and future plans secret would help find and deal with them.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Back to Trump. He was chosen too. In an electoral college system that stinks. He lost the popular vote. But yes, of course he was chosen and he will be there until next January unless he gets removed by impeachment, death or ill health. So the USA have to put up with him and just make sure they learn their lesson.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
In an electoral college system that stinks. He lost the popular vote. But yes, of course he was chosen and he will be there until next January unless he gets removed by impeachment, death or ill health. So the USA have to put up with him and just make sure they learn their lesson. And vote a democrat in! Lesson not learnt then.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
And vote a democrat in! Lesson not learnt then. I don't really care too much what party they belong to! Trump is no Republican is he? Donald Duck would be a better President than Donald Trump. At least he doesn't have bunch of people who think the nonsense he spouts makes any sense.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don't really care too much what party they belong to! Trump is no Republican is he? Donald Duck would be a better President than Donald Trump. At least he doesn't have bunch of people who think the nonsense he spouts makes any sense. Most world leaders are like Bugs Bunny currently - what's up doc?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
In an electoral college system that stinks. He lost the popular vote. But yes, of course he was chosen and he will be there until next January unless he gets removed by impeachment, death or ill health. So the USA have to put up with him and just make sure they learn their lesson. sticking to the thread. the predominantly pakistani Grooming Gangs, have proven that our justice & political system has major shortcomings. and unlike yourself, i have totally lost confidence in any of the shyt.e our Elites tell us.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.