You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?
November 22 2026 4.37am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?


Page 153 of 280 < 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 >
Matov Flag 31 May 22 6.27am

Originally posted by BlueJay


Lose-lose short term. Possibly puts some pressure to further peace process and long term may force countries to more heavily invest in renewable and nuclear technology. It was always strategically a big mistake for countries to rely so heavily on a nieghbour for energy needs. Especially an unstable one.

If the long term consequence of this is to make the West become energy self-sufficient then it will be a huge positive. Absolutely zero doubts about that. I look forward to the announcement of massive investment in renewables, nuclear, fracking and maybe even starting to mine coal, which Europe has huge amounts of, once more.

But I suspect it will just make us even more reliant on the likes of Saudi Arabia and Qatar. Those liberal beacons whose petro-dollars have had such a positive effect on us all. Better to enrich, even more, those places than somewhere as barbaric as Russia.

However, I am more than happy to be proved wrong on this.

Edited by Matov (31 May 2022 6.37am)

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

W12 31 May 22 8.06am

Originally posted by BlueJay

"Agreement to ban export of Russian oil to the EU.

This immediately covers more than 2/3 of oil imports from Russia"


Lose-lose short term. Possibly puts some pressure to further peace process and long term may force countries to more heavily invest in renewable and nuclear technology. It was always strategically a big mistake for countries to rely so heavily on a nieghbour for energy needs. Especially an unstable one.

You do not intentionally cut off your fuel/energy supply until you have a viable alternative in place. Also, you cannot build nuclear power stations overnight (and we seem to have lost that expertise anyway) and "renewables" are not commercially viable and only exist due to subsidies. I suspect the upshot of this is that we will end up with the same Russian oil/gas just sourced via a different route and at a much higher cost.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 31 May 22 8.17am

Originally posted by Matov



If the long term consequence of this is to make the West become energy self-sufficient then it will be a huge positive. Absolutely zero doubts about that.
I look forward to the announcement of massive investment in renewables, nuclear, fracking and maybe even starting to mine coal, which Europe has huge amounts of, once more.

But I suspect it will just make us even more reliant on the likes of Saudi Arabia and Qatar. Those liberal beacons whose petro-dollars have had such a positive effect on us all. Better to enrich, even more, those places than somewhere as barbaric as Russia.

However, I am more than happy to be proved wrong on this.

Edited by Matov (31 May 2022 6.37am)

I definitely agree that this would be a massive plus and that it's something that people and nations, regardless of environmental perspectives, should all push towards. Energy independence is not an overnight or painless move, but we see what can happen where it's a move we make too slowly or only see the downside of. Unfortunately, many of those who overwise would be suspicious of government and corporations, bought into ideas over decades from the oil lobby, that archiac and finite status quo is the way ahead (It's certainly not only the 'green' push that people should be wary of). Reliance on other nations for energy is a perpetually twisted arm. It doesn't matter how you do it (renewables + nuclear mix etc), it does though matter that you do.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 31 May 22 8.31am

Originally posted by W12



You do not intentionally cut off your fuel/energy supply until you have a viable alternative in place.
Also, you cannot build nuclear power stations overnight (and we seem to have lost that expertise anyway) and "renewables" are not commercially viable and only exist due to subsidies. I suspect the upshot of this is that we will end up with the same Russian oil/gas just sourced via a different route and at a much higher cost.

A day that would never come, because despite your stated dislike of corporations and elites, aversion to energy independence due to pushed propoganda by said corporations means that you have an aversion to it. That comes of part of the 'package deal', with these pointless sets of packaged ideas that people are persuaded into subscribing instead of considering issues case by case.


Certainly renewables are more and more viable (again you just take on board what you want to and throw this stuff out there as indefinite fact). As for nucleur power stations (which even if you don't favour renewables, would surely be something you'd go with), we've had decades to build them, and in part due to misplaced fears of the technology, along with an oil lobby push to retain the status quo, and government mismanagement and short sightedness (even nuclear agreements we do attempt to reach tend to involve heavy external investment, with prices then set by other external countries and corporations, totally defeating the point or autonomy in this area) it hasn't happened. It's our own fault we haven't already solved this problem, it's certainly not an issue of time.

The whole point of Brexit for instance was to have more say in our own affairs. It's funny then that people are happy to let other nations on a whim massively impact us in this area. Regardless of politics and perspective should've long been be a national no brainer to forge ahead with in a meaningful manner. It speaks to tribal foolishness that we're not already there. It's not especially a point about this individual situation, more that it shouldn't even be a question or whether other countries can put the squeeze on us in this regard. Hopefully moving forward we will appreciate that freeing ourselves of that is a good thing.

Edited by BlueJay (31 May 2022 8.35am)

 

Matov Flag 31 May 22 8.40am

Originally posted by BlueJay


I definitely agree that this would be a massive plus and that it's something that people and nations, regardless of environmental perspectives, should all push towards. Energy independence is not an overnight or painless move, but we see what can happen where it's a move we make too slowly or only see the downside of. Unfortunately, many of those who overwise would be suspicious of government and corporations, bought into ideas over decades from the oil lobby, that archiac and finite status quo is the way ahead (It's certainly not only the 'green' push that people should be wary of). Reliance on other nations for energy is a perpetually twisted arm. It doesn't matter how you do it (renewables + nuclear mix etc), it does though matter that you do.

I fully agree with all of this but, and for me this is the crux, why has energy autarky not been the goal for decades? I would argue that our entire political system in the West has been in the thrall of Middle Eastern petro-dollars for so long now that our current system is institutionally incapable of switching to the kind of long term policies required.

Hence why this current 'embargo' actually makes us even more enslaved by barbarian regimes and why Russia's many attempts to enjoy closer relations with the West have been rebuffed ever since the wall came down.


 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

BlueJay Flag UK 31 May 22 8.51am

Originally posted by Matov

I fully agree with all of this but, and for me this is the crux, why has energy autarky not been the goal for decades? I would argue that our entire political system in the West has been in the thrall of Middle Eastern petro-dollars for so long now that our current system is institutionally incapable of switching to the kind of long term policies required.

Hence why this current 'embargo' actually makes us even more enslaved by barbarian regimes and why Russia's many attempts to enjoy closer relations with the West have been rebuffed ever since the wall came down.


I don't disagree. For a mix of reasons, all rather predictable and unfortunate, we have relied on areas of the world for our energy needs that bring with it more misery and trouble for us and them than it's worth. I hope for a future where we're relient on no-one, as that avoids numerous issues, some of which we're beginning to feel now. Technology and necessity will likely get us there, over and above governments with self serving election cycle mindsets.


Edited by BlueJay (31 May 2022 8.52am)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 31 May 22 8.54am

Originally posted by Matov

I fully agree with all of this but, and for me this is the crux, why has energy autarky not been the goal for decades? I would argue that our entire political system in the West has been in the thrall of Middle Eastern petro-dollars for so long now that our current system is institutionally incapable of switching to the kind of long term policies required.

Hence why this current 'embargo' actually makes us even more enslaved by barbarian regimes and why Russia's many attempts to enjoy closer relations with the West have been rebuffed ever since the wall came down.


Yep agree with all of that and the post from BJ that you originally replied to.

My guess is that whilst there may have been appetite and/or ponderance for looking at alternative energy sources governments in power may have seen it as a 'too risky' a move.

Perhaps there had to be solid ground on which to make the decision to wholeheartedly switch attentions and indeed efforts elsewhere. No doubt the average Joe let alone corporations will feel some pinches in the meantime as this goes through. There might also be the suggestion that Russia's newly earnt pariah status and warmongering will pave the way for an undertaking of such magnitude.

Just musings from me of course, not that they are often worth very much!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 31 May 22 8.59am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Indifference isn't anger.

Of course, it isn't. That though is not what the primary odour that permeates your constant posts. If you were indifferent, you wouldn't respond.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

The groover Flag Danbury 31 May 22 9.06am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The EU isn't Nato.

Both have entirely different entry criteria. For whatever reason the EU eased the way in for Greece, who conned them on the way and then have spent a long time paying for it.

Ukraine joining the EU, which is possible, would have no bearing at all on whether it would be admitted into Nato, which I cannot imagine happening in the foreseeable future.

The Eastern European countries who joined were far from "3rd world countries". They wanted to align themselves with the west after decades of being dominated by Russia. Building a democratic barrier between ourselves and the mafia state to the east made sense, and does so even more now.

I may not have been clear enough on the EU/NATO situation. If an aggressor were to attack an EU country then the others would have to come to its aid. ergo, NATO countries would get involved therefore an EU country is part of NATO by default.

When Romania joined they were a 3rd world country.

I'm not saying that we should not have let them join. But they should have entered as prospects (using a sons of A analogy), without full rights. i.e freedom of movement. etc. Until their standard of living was brought up to a higher level.

 

The groover Flag Danbury 31 May 22 9.11am

The UK have just announced that the decommission of coal fired power stations will be delayed. Lets hope they do something about the emissions.

Natural Gas will soon be replaced by Hydrogen anyway. Its already started. Russia can then stick up their a***.

[Link]

There are already trials underway.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 31 May 22 9.19am

The viability of renewables/alternative energy sources is a huge positive outcome of the Ukraine war. Under existing conditions, the west would normally have continued looking for oil, accelerated fracking and continued with existing nuclear facilities.
Now the political will exists to continue with a new generation of nuclear facilities, whilst significant monies will be available for exploiting renewables (including hydrogen).

However, the Ukraine situation has made me extremely cynical of media and political news.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

W12 31 May 22 11.40am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

The viability of renewables/alternative energy sources is a huge positive outcome of the Ukraine war. Under existing conditions, the west would normally have continued looking for oil, accelerated fracking and continued with existing nuclear facilities.
Now the political will exists to continue with a new generation of nuclear facilities, whilst significant monies will be available for exploiting renewables (including hydrogen).

However, the Ukraine situation has made me extremely cynical of media and political news.

Then you should look at what the motives are for the media to push false narratives and why that self same media is so heavily pushing the netzero agenda.

Maybe start with who owns and who funds it.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 31 May 22 11.51am

[Link]

 

BlueJay Flag UK 31 May 22 12.14pm

On Russin State TV Alexei Zhuravlev, member of Russia's parliament, threatens 2 million Ukrainians with annihilation, describing them as 'incurable' Nazis who will never be convinced to support Russia's war.


Got to love the perpetual focus on the apparent bias of our media, when we have actual close putin allies and MPs talking about their neighbours in such a way. As I said all along, and as this fellow conveniently confirms, all you need to do to be considered a Ukranian 'neo nazi' in the eyes of Russia is to opppose their invasion.


Edited by BlueJay (31 May 2022 12.27pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 31 May 22 12.19pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Of course, it isn't. That though is not what the primary odour that permeates your constant posts. If you were indifferent, you wouldn't respond.

Sometimes I don't, there are often far better things to do.

I will respond to your disfigurements and delusions as and when I can be bothered.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 31 May 22 1.16pm

Interesting series of programmes on Radio 4 this week about London banking. It was on around midday yesterday, but google "money laundering on Radio 4" and I'm sure you'll find it on play-back or whatever.
It started yesterday with the aftermath of WW2 and how banks (who were short of money) started to set up off-shore banking systems to by-pass Regulations and accept Russian money,...as a LOAN.

The story progresses day by day, until (I presume) we reach Friday's programme about the current situation where Russian money and money 'stolen' from developing countries are run through the British banking system and some of this is used to finance politics.

You have to remember this is the BBC, so whilst the historical stuff might be close to the truth, you might wonder how much they hold-back when talking about today's situation.

Listen and make up your own minds - sorry I can't find the link (yet)


GOT IT !!!
How to steal a Trillion
[Link]

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (31 May 2022 1.21pm)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

W12 31 May 22 2.19pm

[Link]

This is not just about Ukraine and Russia. These is no replacement for that amount of oil in the European economy so this is effectively economic suicide for Europe. Instead of accepting responsibility they will just blame Putin for all of their economic policy failures.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 31 May 22 2.40pm

Originally posted by W12

[Link]

This is not just about Ukraine and Russia. These is no replacement for that amount of oil in the European economy so this is effectively economic suicide for Europe. Instead of accepting responsibility they will just blame Putin for all of their economic policy failures.

Agreed.

It isn't the elites making the decisions who will struggle to feed their children. It won't be these elites whose elderly have to battle through winter to stay alive.

If they had to suffer they wouldn't do it.

But they will justify others suffering for their 'morality'.....which amount to covering for their own bad past policies.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 May 2022 2.42pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

BlueJay Flag UK 31 May 22 5.00pm

"Vladimir Putin's enemy Alexei Navalny facing extra 15 years in prison over new charges

In March, Vladimir Putin's foe Alexei Navalny - who nearly lost his life when he was poisoned with Novichok - was sentenced to nine years of strict regime prison for 'fraud and insulting the court’.

In a Twitter thread today, the anti-corruption campaigner said more charges have been filed against him which could see him spend another 15 years behind bars.

Prosecutors allege he "created an extremist group to incite hatred against officials and oligarchs", he said."

 

Stirlingsays Flag 31 May 22 6.23pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Interesting series of programmes on Radio 4 this week about London banking. It was on around midday yesterday, but google "money laundering on Radio 4" and I'm sure you'll find it on play-back or whatever.
It started yesterday with the aftermath of WW2 and how banks (who were short of money) started to set up off-shore banking systems to by-pass Regulations and accept Russian money,...as a LOAN.

The story progresses day by day, until (I presume) we reach Friday's programme about the current situation where Russian money and money 'stolen' from developing countries are run through the British banking system and some of this is used to finance politics.

You have to remember this is the BBC, so whilst the historical stuff might be close to the truth, you might wonder how much they hold-back when talking about today's situation.

Listen and make up your own minds - sorry I can't find the link (yet)


GOT IT !!!
How to steal a Trillion
[Link]

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (31 May 2022 1.21pm)

Fully agree.

As a country we should never have opened up so fully to money laundering.

It's like the black market, it's always going to be there....and I fully appreciate that financial systems are full of unethical 'sell my own grandmother' types. However, during and since the Blair years it literally become a standing joke.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 May 2022 6.24pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 153 of 280 < 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?