Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Apr 2015 2.38pm
Quote imbored at 18 Apr 2015 1.47pm
The more ideologically driven someone is the more they fall into the trap of simplifying people and the political landscape. It just seems like a bad starting point.
Jamie doesn't come in for quite so much criticism as the rest of us because he's fair, self aware, not waving a finger at anyone, and generally has really fleshed out ideas about the world.
As for debate, almost everyone is constantly looking to reaffirm their own ideas, rather than change their mind about anything. Which in and of itself suggests that on some level we all know we hold somewhat brainwashed views of the world.
Edited by imbored (18 Apr 2015 1.50pm)
Jamie does, in fact, come into quite a lot of criticism.
I'd agree with your opinion that's he as a very good poster, independent of whether people agree with him or not, that's recognised by many, including me.
However, you're wrong to accuse me or something yet ignore it when Jamie on the very same page has done the very same thing.
I don't really have an issue with the 'lefty righty' generalization thing in practice....How could I as I use it myself....I was only pointing out that I thought Jamie's point was wrong about the right's general attitude towards the NHS and Welfare.
You've kind of blown up that point......It isn't that big a deal.
People can, 'lefty righty' away as much as they like, surely.....And posters can tell them they are talking BS in reply.
That's apart of the knockabout.
And sometimes people's views are informed.....And yes, indeed, sometimes altered.
I've been informed by the forum and some of my views altered by posters whose views I read and respect.....Right or left or neither.
A closed mind is a limited one.
Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Apr 2015 2.40pm)
Yes I agree on the knockabout point on here, there's definitely something to that. I'm sure people would find more commonality in person. I can see it now. Matt and Nick, arm in arm.