You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Rugby world cup 2015
November 22 2026 1.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rugby world cup 2015


Page 16 of 26 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >
Phil H Flag 04 Oct 15 12.04pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 04 Oct 2015 10.49am

Quote Phil H at 04 Oct 2015 10.20am

Apologies if this has already been covered but....can anyone explain why three nations that would be seeded in any normal competition (SA, Wales and England) are scrapping over two qualifying places. whereas NZ seem to be in a group (with all due respect to those teams) of "unseeded" nations. It seems a bit risky to have the hosts so likely to go out in the group stage. I'm not just wearing arrogant "England"- tinted spectacles as I accept they were outclassed by Oz, and love to see emerging rugby nations like Japan doing well, but England have a record of doing pretty well in the Rugby WC don't they. Seems a bit of a duff format to me.

Because Wales made an unholy Horlicks of the Autumn internationals three years ago and dropped out of the top 8 at exactly the wrong moment. This made us the unseeded team.

We are notoriously bad during the autumn so it's mildly surprising that we have done as well as we have.

Thanks for clearing that up!! Good luck to Wales, if only England had Warburton!


Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (04 Oct 2015 10.51am)


 

sydtheeagle Flag England 04 Oct 15 12.54pm

Quote Phil H at 04 Oct 2015 12.04pm

Thanks for clearing that up!! Good luck to Wales, if only England had Warburton!

They do. He's called Fatty Armitage and he was European Player of the Year in 2014. Unfortunately, our all-knowing coaches refused to pick him because he plays his club rugby in France.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

sydtheeagle Flag England 04 Oct 15 1.16pm

Quote The Sash at 03 Oct 2015 9.50pm

Ah well 5 mins left before we are put our of our misery....one small spark is I at least won a couple of bets with mates as I had us not to get out of the pool.

Beaten by a much better side tonight but with a whimper really....tonight and the Saffers v Scotland game showed how much behind the SH we all are....

Radical change needed in English rugby to fulfil its potential - which won't happen

I haven't heard a single pundit this morning -- Barnes, Back, Ryan, Greenwood, etc. -- say anything that you and I didn't write in this thread over the past 14 days, Sash. Entirely, completely predictable in the end. It pains me because I really do admire Bomber as a person but I think he has been more out of his depth over the past 18 months than any coach of a World Cup team in any sport that I can remember. Really, it's been embarrassing.

The pity is that this is shaping up to be a fantastic World Cup -- well, it already is that. Of the likely last eight, I would say only Scotland (or Japan) have absolutely no chance of winning it. Obviously, some teams are better than others but the other seven all have at least a shot at an upset. And unfortunately with England out, the non-rugby public will largely move on.

Oh well, I'm off to buy some leeks. I'm becoming officially Welsh for the next four weeks. This has the double advantage of added support for Hennessey, Ledley and Joniesta.


 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 04 Oct 15 2.24pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 04 Oct 2015 1.16pm

Quote The Sash at 03 Oct 2015 9.50pm

Ah well 5 mins left before we are put our of our misery....one small spark is I at least won a couple of bets with mates as I had us not to get out of the pool.

Beaten by a much better side tonight but with a whimper really....tonight and the Saffers v Scotland game showed how much behind the SH we all are....

Radical change needed in English rugby to fulfil its potential - which won't happen

I haven't heard a single pundit this morning -- Barnes, Back, Ryan, Greenwood, etc. -- say anything that you and I didn't write in this thread over the past 14 days, Sash. Entirely, completely predictable in the end. It pains me because I really do admire Bomber as a person but I think he has been more out of his depth over the past 18 months than any coach of a World Cup team in any sport that I can remember. Really, it's been embarrassing.

The pity is that this is shaping up to be a fantastic World Cup -- well, it already is that. Of the likely last eight, I would say only Scotland (or Japan) have absolutely no chance of winning it. Obviously, some teams are better than others but the other seven all have at least a shot at an upset. And unfortunately with England out, the non-rugby public will largely move on.

Oh well, I'm off to buy some leeks. I'm becoming officially Welsh for the next four weeks. This has the double advantage of added support for Hennessey, Ledley and Joniesta.


That's probably the worst thing Syd...if armchair pundits can see these issues a mile off how can't professionals that close to the game....just heard LD, Inverdale and GG talking about this like it's something new...LD even suggested we have gone from 'world beaters' to this....have I missed something? At which point have Lancasters England been world beaters ???

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

sydtheeagle Flag England 04 Oct 15 4.01pm

Quote The Sash at 04 Oct 2015 2.24pm

That's probably the worst thing Syd...if armchair pundits can see these issues a mile off how can't professionals that close to the game....just heard LD, Inverdale and GG talking about this like it's something new...LD even suggested we have gone from 'world beaters' to this....have I missed something? At which point have Lancasters England been world beaters ???

I think the answer to the first question is plain and simple a loss of nerve caused or compounded by a total lack of experience. The four English coaches had been them one season running a Premiership team between them (Lancaster, at Leeds) and that team was relegated. The assistant coaches were all novices to all intents and purposes. Put simply, they neither were nor are fit for the purpose.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

sydtheeagle Flag England 05 Oct 15 7.57am

This was posted by Silverquin on the Quins Forum yesterday. Make of it what you will:

silverquin
From a friend before the game yesterday:
So, it turns out Kieran Bracken’s next-door neighbour is the senior partner at a City litigation law firm called Stewarts Law. Last night they held a RWC gathering which was hosted by Bracken. As part of the proceedings—after David “rent-a-gob” Campese had spent 15 minutes railing against everything in modern rugby—Bracken got hold of the mic and did a Q&A with injured England no. 8 Billy Vunipola! who had a beer in his hand and appeared to have a couple more inside him…

Bracken: when you were interviewed after the game against Fiji you said you didn’t know you’d scored the bonus-point try—that was a strange thing to say…
Billy: not at all. None of us knew bonus points were part of this world cup. No one had told us.

[…]

Bracken: what’s Stuart Lancaster like to work with as a coach?
BillyV: I don’t know.
Bracken: what do you mean?
BillyV: Stuart doesn’t coach the team, Andy Farrell does. I’ve never been coached by Stuart.
Campo, butting in: what effect has that had on the way the team plays?
Billy: he makes us play like a rugby league team.

(Campo then goes off on one about England’s terrible style of play is and how the RFU should just bite the bullet and hire an experienced international coach. To be fair, he’s absolutely spot on with that).

[…]

Campo: so what do you think about England picking Sam Burgess?
BillyV: it’s been disruptive. The whole squad is unhappy about it.
Bracken: WHAT? Why?
BillyV: Luther Burrell earned his place in the RWC squad and Sam didn’t. Luther should have been picked, not Sam.

[…]

Bracken: and how are you enjoying playing under Chris Robshaw?
BillyV: *shrugs shoulders, sips beer, says nothing*

So, that’s OK then.


Meanwhile Jake—who seems to have got himself quite close to the England camp—is saying that Mike Catt walked out of last week’s selection meeting and vowed not to return: seem Farrell is not only coaching the team but picking it as well…
:-0

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 05 Oct 15 8.02am

Quote sydtheeagle at 05 Oct 2015 7.57am

This was posted by Silverquin on the Quins Forum yesterday. Make of it what you will:

silverquin
From a friend before the game yesterday:
So, it turns out Kieran Bracken’s next-door neighbour is the senior partner at a City litigation law firm called Stewarts Law. Last night they held a RWC gathering which was hosted by Bracken. As part of the proceedings—after David “rent-a-gob” Campese had spent 15 minutes railing against everything in modern rugby—Bracken got hold of the mic and did a Q&A with injured England no. 8 Billy Vunipola! who had a beer in his hand and appeared to have a couple more inside him…

Bracken: when you were interviewed after the game against Fiji you said you didn’t know you’d scored the bonus-point try—that was a strange thing to say…
Billy: not at all. None of us knew bonus points were part of this world cup. No one had told us.

[…]

Bracken: what’s Stuart Lancaster like to work with as a coach?
BillyV: I don’t know.
Bracken: what do you mean?
BillyV: Stuart doesn’t coach the team, Andy Farrell does. I’ve never been coached by Stuart.
Campo, butting in: what effect has that had on the way the team plays?
Billy: he makes us play like a rugby league team.

(Campo then goes off on one about England’s terrible style of play is and how the RFU should just bite the bullet and hire an experienced international coach. To be fair, he’s absolutely spot on with that).

[…]

Campo: so what do you think about England picking Sam Burgess?
BillyV: it’s been disruptive. The whole squad is unhappy about it.
Bracken: WHAT? Why?
BillyV: Luther Burrell earned his place in the RWC squad and Sam didn’t. Luther should have been picked, not Sam.

[…]

Bracken: and how are you enjoying playing under Chris Robshaw?
BillyV: *shrugs shoulders, sips beer, says nothing*

So, that’s OK then.


Meanwhile Jake—who seems to have got himself quite close to the England camp—is saying that Mike Catt walked out of last week’s selection meeting and vowed not to return: seem Farrell is not only coaching the team but picking it as well…
:-0


That would sure explain a lot !!

Now the dust has settled a little I am struggling to actually pick any success stories from an England perspective from this train wreck. Apart from the obvious 10-12-13 cock ups, and the bizarre Line out decision against Wales, the scrum and Marler in particular has looked awful, the Aussies showed exactly what specialist 6 and 7's look like and what they should be doing and how poor we are in comparison by not having them.

The lack of composure, especially under pressure, the lack of leadership from top down, the lack of any kind of continuity in play, the swapping of 10's, the selection of Wigglesworth - probably the least dynamic of the 3 No9's, above Care, who for his faults would have given energy and go forward, the penalty count...I could go on and on...and I haven't even mentioned the players who should have been there but weren't...

Line out has been OK I guess...Watson showed he is a very good finisher and ermmm struggling for anything else...

Edited by The Sash (05 Oct 2015 12.37pm)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 05 Oct 15 9.22am

Quote sydtheeagle at 04 Oct 2015 12.54pm

Quote Phil H at 04 Oct 2015 12.04pm

Thanks for clearing that up!! Good luck to Wales, if only England had Warburton!

They do. He's called Fatty Armitage and he was European Player of the Year in 2014. Unfortunately, our all-knowing coaches refused to pick him because he plays his club rugby in France.


THIS THIS AND THIS.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Phil H Flag 05 Oct 15 2.55pm

Ok you guys understand a lot more about this than I do. But it seems to me England have 1) Enough good players to compete 2) Plenty of cash for facilities and coaching 3) Players that try really hard on the pitch 4) Fantastic home support. Seems like the raw materials are there so can only be lousy management, putting players on the pitch who've never played together, parachuting in rugby league players etc etc? Shouldn't we be getting in someone like Sir Clive to sort out the whole thing?

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 05 Oct 15 3.09pm

Quote Phil H at 05 Oct 2015 2.55pm

Ok you guys understand a lot more about this than I do. But it seems to me England have 1) Enough good players to compete 2) Plenty of cash for facilities and coaching 3) Players that try really hard on the pitch 4) Fantastic home support. Seems like the raw materials are there so can only be lousy management, putting players on the pitch who've never played together, parachuting in rugby league players etc etc? Shouldn't we be getting in someone like Sir Clive to sort out the whole thing?

1. Yes
2. Yes
3. Yes
4. Yes

England, if they truly want to be able to fulfil the potential that a huge pool of players and shed loads of cash brings need a Southern Hemisphere coach...problem is the RFU wouldn't have it...

For me go reasonable young - Jamie Joseph for example or as has been suggested on here a battle scarred old hand like Graham Henry...I know one thing - we may not have done well under this WC under Woodward but we wouldn't have had this absolute debacle and certainly note a team of such fragile mentality (a hallmark of Lancaster's England is their ability to choke)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

sydtheeagle Flag England 05 Oct 15 3.18pm

Quote Phil H at 05 Oct 2015 2.55pm

Ok you guys understand a lot more about this than I do. But it seems to me England have 1) Enough good players to compete 2) Plenty of cash for facilities and coaching 3) Players that try really hard on the pitch 4) Fantastic home support. Seems like the raw materials are there so can only be lousy management, putting players on the pitch who've never played together, parachuting in rugby league players etc etc? Shouldn't we be getting in someone like Sir Clive to sort out the whole thing?

1. To some extent. The really good players in England are young...the mature group are not so good. We will have a very good team in 4 years time. Some of those players should have been blooded in this World Cup (Wade, Slade, Itoje etc.) and others are simply not ready yet.

2. Yes. But you can have all the cash in the world and it does you no good if you hire Andy Farrell to coach your team. This whole RWC has been a massive exercise in wasting RFU money (not least on Sam Burgess).

3. Trevor Aylott always tried really hard. Wonder whether he can play scrum half? If you're not good enough, effort doesn't really matter. And at this level, Bomber picked too many players who weren't good enough (compounded by the fact that they were poorly coached, too.)

4. Doesn't really make any difference. It's nice, but it doesn't put points on the board.

Yes, we need to get a professional, experienced top-level coach in (just like we should have done four years ago.) Ideally probably not SCW but a Nick Mallet, Jake White, Wayne Smith sort with maybe Rob Baxter as an assistant being groomed for the role in future.


Edited by sydtheeagle (05 Oct 2015 3.19pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

jeeagles Flag 05 Oct 15 11.32pm

.

Edited by jeeagles (05 Oct 2015 11.33pm)

 

jeeagles Flag 05 Oct 15 11.33pm

Quote jeeagles at 05 Oct 2015 11.32pm

This World Cup has made me realise the CPFC2010 could show the RFU a thing or to about how to run a team properly. If you compare the two orginsations it shows how well we are run, and how messed up the RFU is.

Since 2003 England have won 1 six nations and 0 grand slams. Wales have 3 grand slams and 4 titles. England should be much better but are simply a hopeless.

Since 2010 Palace have achieve a higher finish every season. Where as England have regressed from World Cup quarter finalist to knocked out in the first round.

We all know CPFC2010 are screwed successful businessmen. Whilst Ian Ritchie at the RFU has a track record of old school tie jobs at the underperforming Channel 5 and British Lawn Tennis.

For advice picking manager CPFC2010 go to Steve Coppell. He's our most successful manager so must know a thing or to. The RFU go to Rob Andrew, who has achieved nothing, and won't listen to Sir Clive Woodward. Each successive palace manager under CPFC2010 has had a better track record than their predecessor (except warnock). None of the England managers since Warnock have had any track record worth talking about despite the fact they have the money to get anyone they want.

Palace have coaches with experience of the club, England have a coach from another sport.

In terms of style of place and personnel. Palace have been very careful to only sign players with the right attitude and good for the club. We've played in pretty much the same formation for 4 years bringing in players who suit the system. The England selection policy is a f***ing joke.

And when it comes to taking responsibility CPFC2010 have always been honest about their mistakes. The RFU are going to come out with a FIFA style report in a few months when they think nobody is looking which will draw the conclusion that it was a hard group and wasn't really there fault that the biggest rugby playing nation in the world went out in the first round.


 

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Oct 15 7.41am

Quote jeeagles at 05 Oct 2015 11.33pm

Quote jeeagles at 05 Oct 2015 11.32pm

This World Cup has made me realise the CPFC2010 could show the RFU a thing or to about how to run a team properly. If you compare the two orginsations it shows how well we are run, and how messed up the RFU is.

Since 2003 England have won 1 six nations and 0 grand slams. Wales have 3 grand slams and 4 titles. England should be much better but are simply a hopeless.

Since 2010 Palace have achieve a higher finish every season. Where as England have regressed from World Cup quarter finalist to knocked out in the first round.

We all know CPFC2010 are screwed successful businessmen. Whilst Ian Ritchie at the RFU has a track record of old school tie jobs at the underperforming Channel 5 and British Lawn Tennis.

For advice picking manager CPFC2010 go to Steve Coppell. He's our most successful manager so must know a thing or to. The RFU go to Rob Andrew, who has achieved nothing, and won't listen to Sir Clive Woodward. Each successive palace manager under CPFC2010 has had a better track record than their predecessor (except warnock). None of the England managers since Warnock have had any track record worth talking about despite the fact they have the money to get anyone they want.

Palace have coaches with experience of the club, England have a coach from another sport.

In terms of style of place and personnel. Palace have been very careful to only sign players with the right attitude and good for the club. We've played in pretty much the same formation for 4 years bringing in players who suit the system. The England selection policy is a f***ing joke.

And when it comes to king responsibility CPFC2010 have always been honest about their mistakes. The RFU are going to come out with a FIFA style report in a few months when they think nobody is looking which will draw the conclusion that it was a hard group and wasn't really there fault that the biggest rugby playing nation in the world went out in the first round.



Agree except what you said about Squeaky (Rob Andrew), which is wrong. He is a t***...no argument there and he needs to be removed...but he played in a World Cup final and grand-slam winning England team, then was a very successful coach domestically, taking Newcastle from nowhere to champions. He had the right pedigree for the job, but has failed miserably since getting it. This just proves that sometimes the right hire doesn't work out.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 06 Oct 15 9.02am

Not strictly being an egg chaser, I have read all posts on this thread with interest and an open mind, at first I lumped all the blame on Rob shaw for some absolutley barking mad descions on the pitch.

However having read posts from more, shall we say, knowledgeable chasers of the egg, I have been converted (no pun intended) to the idea that the management (Stuart Lackluster included) from the RFU down is to blame on not building from the success of 2003.

This is an english rugby team that has been missmanaged for over 10 years.

Stuffed shirt attitudes towards players not playing in England. Rugby league players calling the shots, players with no international pedigree getting the nod in front of established Union players.

I have always been an advocate of wishing the England " kissballers" would show as much passion, and to a degree skill in their game, however on this last showing singing the national anthem a bit loud is all the rugger buggers did better than the England football
team.

THE ONLY thing I can say about this debacle is how come we were in a group with two of the worlds top 3 sides ? thats seems a bit unfair really seeing as we are 8th in the world rugby rankings with Australia 2 and the sheep shaggers 3rd.

Always going to be a tough ask.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Oct 15 9.14am

Quote dannyh at 06 Oct 2015 9.02am

THE ONLY thing I can say about this debacle is how come we were in a group with two of the worlds top 3 sides ? thats seems a bit unfair really seeing as we are 8th in the world rugby rankings with Australia 2 and the sheep shaggers 3rd.

Always going to be a tough ask.

World Cup seedings are based on rankings at a certain point in time when the draw is made. Two of the top 8 go into each group. Because they were in a brief tailspin, Wales momentarily dropped out of the top 8, literally for a month but it was the month on which the draw was based, and were thus always going to create a pool of death. England and Australia got the short straw in the draw which added a strong team to an already ridiculously strong draw. Had Wales been drawn with Scotland and South Africa, things would have been significantly different.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 06 Oct 15 9.18am

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 9.14am

Quote dannyh at 06 Oct 2015 9.02am

THE ONLY thing I can say about this debacle is how come we were in a group with two of the worlds top 3 sides ? thats seems a bit unfair really seeing as we are 8th in the world rugby rankings with Australia 2 and the sheep shaggers 3rd.

Always going to be a tough ask.

World Cup seedings are based on rankings at a certain point in time when the draw is made. Two of the top 8 go into each group. Because they were in a brief tailspin, Wales momentarily dropped out of the top 8, literally for a month but it was the month on which the draw was based, and were thus always going to create a pool of death. England and Australia got the short straw in the draw which added a strong team to an already ridiculously strong draw. Had Wales been drawn with Scotland and South Africa, things would have been significantly different.

Well that system has to be a load of shyte then doesnt it ?


 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Oct 15 9.39am

Danny, in a lot of ways what you're saying -- and it's as true of the FA and Woy as it is of the RFU and Bomber -- is that we've failed because we've reverted to type and behaved like Englishmen. You know; conciliatory, polite, well-meaning, conservative, narrow-minded and a tiny bit self-impressed. We think we're better than we are.

If you think about it, our major sporting successes in half a century have all (or at least mainly) come from teams or athletes that are extremely un-English. The 2003 rugby World Cup was driven by Sir Clive; a man who was egotistical, driven, totally uncompromising, and utterly determined. As were most of his players. He won the World Cup but polite little English administrators couldn't cope with him so now he's out in the cold. Our recent Tour de France and Olympic Cycling successes were driven by Dave Brailsford. Another arrogant, uncompromising and totally driven coach. Andy Murray...achieved success with foreign coaches who were proven winners and bases himself in the States. Oh, and guess what? He's arrogant, uncompromising, and totally driven. And so the list goes on. You get the picture. Notice a pattern here?

The real truth is that the English mentality and persona is not suited to sporting success. We lack a cutting edge; we don't pursue becoming elite, we default to the safe option and, mainly, we just don't work hard enough. It's often said that Ronaldo and not Rooney became the best player in the world simply because the former was unwilling to settle for anything else while the latter was happy to rely on his natural talent taking him as far as it could and that was good enough.

What you point out IS a rugby issue, but it's not exclusively a rugby issue. I believe that both our rugby and football teams have the raw material (number of players, skill levels, etc.) to win World Cups but we simply lack the required mentality from the administration level right through to the playing level to achieve it. Only when we somehow put things in the hands of people who do have the right mentality do we see our potential being fulfilled. But when that happens, how many people really like our winners? Andy Murray is hardly popular. SCW is respected but not liked. Dave Brailsford is respected but considered a bit of a an oddity.

Unlike, say, Americans, who simply celebrate success and the price paid to achieve it, we don't. They believe the price is worth paying. We feel like compromising your values to win is somehow a little bit dirty. And then we wonder why our teams fail. What we've really never done is made the mental transition from the amateur sports we have played for a century to the professional games which we play now. We've assumed that if we were world class amateurs in the old days, there's no reason we can't just be world class professionals now. But it doesn't work like that. Professionalism is a great leveler and we have failed across the board to adapt.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Phil H Flag 06 Oct 15 10.33am

This is an excellent analysis Syd. I think all of us golf lovers would add Sir Nick Faldo to the list of very "un-English" but ultimately successful achievers. Sir Nick wasn't exactly popular but boy did he get the job done.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 06 Oct 15 11.20am

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 9.39am

Danny, in a lot of ways what you're saying -- and it's as true of the FA and Woy as it is of the RFU and Bomber -- is that we've failed because we've reverted to type and behaved like Englishmen. You know; conciliatory, polite, well-meaning, conservative, narrow-minded and a tiny bit self-impressed. We think we're better than we are.

If you think about it, our major sporting successes in half a century have all (or at least mainly) come from teams or athletes that are extremely un-English. The 2003 rugby World Cup was driven by Sir Clive; a man who was egotistical, driven, totally uncompromising, and utterly determined. As were most of his players. He won the World Cup but polite little English administrators couldn't cope with him so now he's out in the cold. Our recent Tour de France and Olympic Cycling successes were driven by Dave Brailsford. Another arrogant, uncompromising and totally driven coach. Andy Murray...achieved success with foreign coaches who were proven winners and bases himself in the States. Oh, and guess what? He's arrogant, uncompromising, and totally driven. And so the list goes on. You get the picture. Notice a pattern here?

The real truth is that the English mentality and persona is not suited to sporting success. We lack a cutting edge; we don't pursue becoming elite, we default to the safe option and, mainly, we just don't work hard enough. It's often said that Ronaldo and not Rooney became the best player in the world simply because the former was unwilling to settle for anything else while the latter was happy to rely on his natural talent taking him as far as it could and that was good enough.

What you point out IS a rugby issue, but it's not exclusively a rugby issue. I believe that both our rugby and football teams have the raw material (number of players, skill levels, etc.) to win World Cups but we simply lack the required mentality from the administration level right through to the playing level to achieve it. Only when we somehow put things in the hands of people who do have the right mentality do we see our potential being fulfilled. But when that happens, how many people really like our winners? Andy Murray is hardly popular. SCW is respected but not liked. Dave Brailsford is respected but considered a bit of a an oddity.

Unlike, say, Americans, who simply celebrate success and the price paid to achieve it, we don't. They believe the price is worth paying. We feel like compromising your values to win is somehow a little bit dirty. And then we wonder why our teams fail. What we've really never done is made the mental transition from the amateur sports we have played for a century to the professional games which we play now. We've assumed that if we were world class amateurs in the old days, there's no reason we can't just be world class professionals now. But it doesn't work like that. Professionalism is a great leveler and we have failed across the board to adapt.


Yep I'd agree with that - we don't lose on talent half the time but on mentality.

We seem to think putting a few pithy motivational phrases from Vince Lombardi on a dressing room wall creates a winning mentality (or a bit of Sun Tzu's Art of War on a full sleeve tattoo as far as football is concerned)...it doesn't.

I read a great little piece the other day.

When Shankly was in negotiations with Liverpool, (board and chairman) who were trying to prise him from Huddersfield, he insisted so many criteria being met before he would come in around how the club was run and was basically a totally uncompromising b****** on absolutely everything, all in a time when chairman and board were kings and manager did as they were told...he got his way.

He knew that he needed to imprint his own mentality and stamp on the club and the rest is history...

On a plus side I am actually quite relieved that I can watch the world cup without an 'interest' other than the game - bit perverse that but quite a nice feeling.

Southern Hemisphere sides to lose without question. We in the North are so far behind Saffers, AB's ands Aussies its unreal - We will be struggling behind Argentina soon given the steps they are taking to improve their players as well...

Edited by The Sash (06 Oct 2015 11.48am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Page 16 of 26 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Rugby world cup 2015