You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Swansea match thread
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Swansea match thread


Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
Den1923 Flag 26 Aug 17 6.11pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'I'm not even surprised we're losing ' by Penge Eagle

78 PL home games and only 26 won, SP is as much to blame, he let other good candidates slip like Silva at Watford and he also think an unproven 8mil player with no PL experience and a couple of loan signings who need more PL experience are enough to keep us in this league, he alone is going to cost this club it PL position and all the cash that goes with it!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Aug 17 6.12pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

I would agree re. changing the style. But these are the same players who were crap for most of Sam's tenure, and crap for an entire year before he arrived.

Don't forget, in his first 8 league games the team got 4 points. Things did not improve until after our near 40m January spending spree.

That's why I don't think it is a simple as being FDB or the playing style's fault. They might not be helping, but there are deeper squad issues that go back a long way.

Why is our spending so restricted? CYL, Williams, Sako, Mutch, Kelly, Ward, Delaney, Hennesey, etc., are not good enough. Only a couple of them regularly contribute in any meaningful positive way. We must be wasting 200k+ pw on wages.

Now, Williams may come good but the rest are overpaid and underperforming and have been for a while. That's why I don't think this is just about the manager or his system.

What on earth made you dream that up, he cant even make the bench in the League Cup. Giving him another contract sums up how poor we are in selecting players.

 

george1212 Flag london 26 Aug 17 6.14pm

Originally posted by Andy_G

De Boer could well turn out to be the biggest mistake ever. How long do we give him and his useless tactics?

Agreed. Back from the match today, my first of the season as missed Huddersfield.

I was shocked. We have taken a massive step backwards.
Its clear without Zaha we have virtually no threat but a group of heavy footed footballers with no confidence.

We looked much better with Cabaye on the pitch, we need to start him. With Ruben, Cabaye, Zaha AND Townsend all fit, then we stand a chance.

We can't afford injuries, we have no strength in depth.

Get rid of this turnip as its clear he has no idea. We have had a preseason to get ready for the new season and by new players. We have bought one CB who likes like old rope and two loanees.

Welcome to Palace, we're a joke

 

Bullhorn76 Flag Darlington 26 Aug 17 6.14pm

A very valid point from Paul Merson after the match ......The pundit

Paul Merson: Something has to change [at Palace]. Sammy Lee is there, he is a great football man. There is nothing wrong with getting the ball forward every now and then. You are asking defenders to do things [keep possession] they are not comfortable doing. Last season, defenders would just lump the ball forward, job done.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 26 Aug 17 6.17pm

Originally posted by Painter

What on earth made you dream that up, he cant even make the bench in the League Cup. Giving him another contract sums up how poor we are in selecting players.

Note the use of the word may, not will. I'm not hopeful.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 26 Aug 17 6.20pm

Just saw fdb on sky. Apparently yhey had 2 and z half chances and took 2. We had 2 very good chances and possibly 4 or 5 half chances and took none. Must have been watching a different game to me. They missed 2 absolute sitters in the first half. Maybd he should explain why We just sat back in our own half in the first half rather than press them in their half....

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 26 Aug 17 6.21pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'I'm not even surprised we're losing ' by Penge Eagle

Originally posted by Den1923

78 PL home games and only 26 won, SP is as much to blame, he let other good candidates slip like Silva at Watford and he also think an unproven 8mil player with no PL experience and a couple of loan signings who need more PL experience are enough to keep us in this league, he alone is going to cost this club it PL position and all the cash that goes with it!

Our Two loan signings have been our best players and Ruben wasn't even on the pitch.

3/4/3 total football my arse .

 

MR200% Flag 26 Aug 17 6.22pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'I'm not even surprised we're losing ' by Penge Eagle

First half was appalling ,I don't think the players has any idea of what they supposed to do from an attacking point of view ,We gave that game to Swansea ,I won't mind if we showed any signs of improvement but we didn't and we haven't. To play the way FDB wants to play we need to buy at least 6 experienced premier league ready players total cost circa £100 mln Good Luck with that

On the plus side well played Jimmy and Yohan (even though you are both far from properly fit).Punch ,I have no idea what you think your role is !!!!

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Aug 17 6.23pm

Originally posted by george1212

Agreed. Back from the match today, my first of the season as missed Huddersfield.

I was shocked. We have taken a massive step backwards.
Its clear without Zaha we have virtually no threat but a group of heavy footed footballers with no confidence.

We looked much better with Cabaye on the pitch, we need to start him. With Ruben, Cabaye, Zaha AND Townsend all fit, then we stand a chance.

We can't afford injuries, we have no strength in depth.

Get rid of this turnip as its clear he has no idea. We have had a preseason to get ready for the new season and by new players. We have bought one CB who likes like old rope and two loanees.

Welcome to Palace, we're a joke

Today made the difference in our play between our natural tactics and this wing backs bollocks really obvious. Three points in the bag if we'd played the right way for 90 minutes.

If I see more of the same s***e after the international break I'm going to want de Boer gone.

 


============
The Ferret
============

mixed nuts Flag 26 Aug 17 6.28pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

I would agree re. changing the style. But these are the same players who were crap for most of Sam's tenure, and crap for an entire year before he arrived.

Don't forget, in his first 8 league games the team got 4 points. Things did not improve until after our near 40m January spending spree.

That's why I don't think it is a simple as being FDB or the playing style's fault. They might not be helping, but there are deeper squad issues that go back a long way.

Why is our spending so restricted? CYL, Williams, Sako, Mutch, Kelly, Ward, Delaney, Hennesey, etc., are not good enough. Only a couple of them regularly contribute in any meaningful positive way. We must be wasting 200k+ pw on wages.

Now, Williams may come good but the rest are overpaid and underperforming and have been for a while. That's why I don't think this is just about the manager or his system.

These should be kept, Swansea's first goal came after Tomkins had a reasonable good chance to test their keeper and somehow he only managed to test the strength of his bollocks and then we know what happens after a change of players in defence after 44 mins means for Palace don't we, do not understand why we keep on giving away goals in the last moments of time, concentration has always been awful it was awful against Huddersfield it cost us the point at Anfield and today it shone nice and bright again.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Aug 17 6.30pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'I'm not even surprised we're losing ' by Penge Eagle

Originally posted by MR200%

First half was appalling ,I don't think the players has any idea of what they supposed to do from an attacking point of view ,We gave that game to Swansea ,I won't mind if we showed any signs of improvement but we didn't and we haven't. To play the way FDB wants to play we need to buy at least 6 experienced premier league ready players total cost circa £100 mln Good Luck with that

On the plus side well played Jimmy and Yohan (even though you are both far from properly fit).Punch ,I have no idea what you think your role is !!!!

What are you talking about? Frank said 3-4-3 suited us. I called him out for bullsh1t and look.

 


COYP

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 26 Aug 17 6.30pm

Well let's look on the bright side. We're not bottom and only 7 points off a Champions League place. -.-'

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

Ruby50 Flag Devon 26 Aug 17 6.32pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'I'm not even surprised we're losing ' by Penge Eagle

Hopefully after the latest debacle Frank will have the sense to return to the BFS system that yielded moderate success. This is imperative because the players and the fans confidence will be shot to pieces if this sh*t continues.
Maybe get Freedman and LFS to manage the team and play defensive counter attacking football with the emphasis of getting some defensive stability. Don't experiment with the kids and go back to being horrible to play against.
This on paper is the strongest side we have ever had and the last part of last season proved they can compete at a mid table level.
Don't let 4 years of hard work be ruined by a Dutch Conman. Great footballer yes but manager I don't think so. Even Steve McClaren won the Dutch Title.

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 26 Aug 17 6.37pm

Originally posted by 2424

I think everyone appreciates it take time to adapt to a new system but it's not working, you can see the players don't like it and aren't comfortable. This inevitably will lead to discontent amongst players and fans and doesn't bode well for the season. We need to get a influential player in, SAKHO fits the mould and raises the the belief of everyone. If we do get him, make him captain. Puncheon just is t good enough and looks seriously out of his depth.

I disagree re an influential player-we have bucket loads of quality in the team. We need an influential and motivational MANAGER, and with him a LEADER on the pitch. Puncheon needs to be dropped and I'd suggest Scott Dann reinstated as captain (I would say Luka but he's not clicking under FDB for some reason)

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 26 Aug 17 6.42pm

First half was poor. Thought we looked significantly better with 4 at the back and Fosu-Mensah playing RB. We need to play a 4-3-3 going forward and 4-5-1 out of possession. Townsend was wasted in the first half, trying to come central but nobody giving him the ball at the back. Puncheon simply has to be dropped, completely ineffective, and Cabaye needs to come in. Love Punch but he doesn't go in our strongest 11 as far as I'm concerned. It's a shocking start to the season and Frank needs to learn very, very quickly. But there is still time.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

george1212 Flag london 26 Aug 17 6.42pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

It's not the system, it's the players. The team that played today, apart from a 17 year old kid, is the same team that really should have been relegated last season. We're still bringing on Lee and Kelly as subs. We're still playing puncheon who's played awful for the last three years We were s**t until sakho played, and weve been s**t since he left. Why should we be suprised that we haven't won a game? Ubless we find some money from somewhere and buy at least 3 more quality players, we are in deep, deep trouble.

Accurate to be honest.

this transfer season has been a joke. Most of our team is deadwood and eventually you become the turd of the league that won't flush, until it does.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 26 Aug 17 6.44pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Whether 3-4-3 is right is one thing, but he is asking the players to move and pass which some of them fail to do. I've seen non-league teams manage it, which tells you it is not about technical ability.

We have a lack of squad depth and too many overpaid do-nothings. That is a result of several years of poor quality recruitment.

N.b. even Sam took 10 games and some truly awful football to get many of the same players to play effectively, and we only managed that for a few games before losing 4 of the last 5 matches under him.

In combination, the above tells me it's not just FDB or the system's fault. There are far deeper issues.

Good post.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Calder Flag 26 Aug 17 6.51pm

Mr_Gristle
Originally posted by NickinOX

Whether 3-4-3 is right is one thing, but he is asking the players to move and pass which some of them fail to do. I've seen non-league teams manage it, which tells you it is not about technical ability. We have a lack of squad depth and too many overpaid do-nothings. That is a result of several years of poor quality recruitment. N.b. even Sam took 10 games and some truly awful football to get many of the same players to play effectively, and we only managed that for a few games before losing 4 of the last 5 matches under him. In combination, the above tells me it's not just FDB or the system's fault. There are far deeper issues.


Good post.

george1212
Originally posted by spartakev2

It's not the system, it's the players. The team that played today, apart from a 17 year old kid, is the same team that really should have been relegated last season. We're still bringing on Lee and Kelly as subs. We're still playing puncheon who's played awful for the last three years We were s**t until sakho played, and weve been s**t since he left. Why should we be suprised that we haven't won a game? Ubless we find some money from somewhere and buy at least 3 more quality players, we are in deep, deep trouble.
Accurate to be honest.this transfer season has been a joke. Most of our team is deadwood and eventually you become the turd of the league that won't flush, until it does.


Yes.

 

Texas Eagle Flag San Antonio, Texas (via Adelaide) 26 Aug 17 7.10pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Whether 3-4-3 is right is one thing, but he is asking the players to move and pass which some of them fail to do. I've seen non-league teams manage it, which tells you it is not about technical ability.

We have a lack of squad depth and too many overpaid do-nothings. That is a result of several years of poor quality recruitment.

N.b. even Sam took 10 games and some truly awful football to get many of the same players to play effectively, and we only managed that for a few games before losing 4 of the last 5 matches under him.

In combination, the above tells me it's not just FDB or the system's fault. There are far deeper issues.

Can only agree. As I've said before we have probably a dozen players who are not good enough in the squad that need to go. I'm not blaming FdB or the style change either. If we had Mourinho or Guardiola in charge I doubt the results would be any different with this squad. Some have been good servants to the club but if they're not good enough it's time to cut them, no room for sentimentality in this business. Start with Puncheon, Ward, Delaney, Mutch etc. We need a quality striker up front with Benteke and a RB desperately. What's the latest on Connor Wickham? 29 appearances in 3 seasons and 7 goals wtf !

 


"Billy Gilbert really is God"

Bangell Flag Oxford 26 Aug 17 7.14pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

It's not the system, it's the players. The team that played today, apart from a 17 year old kid, is the same team that really should have been relegated last season. We're still bringing on Lee and Kelly as subs. We're still playing puncheon who's played awful for the last three years We were s**t until sakho played, and weve been s**t since he left. Why should we be suprised that we haven't won a game? Ubless we find some money from somewhere and buy at least 3 more quality players, we are in deep, deep trouble.

Agree with most of your points, but there are systems which suit the players and systems which don't. The current formation gets the best out of nobody.

 

Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Swansea match thread