You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Man Utd Match Thread
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Man Utd Match Thread


Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
m/k mick Flag milton keynes 06 Mar 18 12.56am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Hardest Defeat To Take Of My Life' by Midlands Eagle

Good job i havent got a cat

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 06 Mar 18 1.49am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Hardest Defeat To Take Of My Life' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by SwordFish

I’m not joking... I’m 29! I have never felt so deflated and distraught after a loss in my life. It’s destroyed me.... the passion and desire and the want to win by all the players was emense . I couldn’t fault any of them. PVA had the game of his life, Wan-Bissaka is going to be special. Benteke was back to his old self. Milivojevic fought for everything and won everything.Jimmy Mac was an engine. Sorloth could run a marathon now. Hennessey made a couple of great saves. Kelly was solid. Schlupp had touched of class. Townsend had the best first half I’ve seen from any player And Tomkins had his usual passion, fight and solid game.
We did not deserve to lose. We were fantastic. They were savers he. 2 moments of shear class (de gea save) (Matic goal)

I’m distraught!!!!

This will effect me all week!!


Wait til WBA turn us over and relegate us11

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 06 Mar 18 2.02am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Hardest Defeat To Take Of My Life' by Midlands Eagle

This thread surprises me

Even at 2 up we didn't look comfortable
With Zaha in the team he brings the ball forward and gets us up the field , giving our defenders and midfield a breather .
We lost today thru sheer tiredness of defending and closing down for 90 minutes
Don't worry mate
We've suffered a lot worse defeats than today
We didn't deserve to win today
We will stay up ~ just

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Mar 18 3.12am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Hardest Defeat To Take Of My Life' by Midlands Eagle

Does anyone know how many points we have taken off the top six this season. I mean no one expects lots but....

It must be really poor.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

WAeagle Flag Perth 06 Mar 18 3.24am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Hardest Defeat To Take Of My Life' by Midlands Eagle

Trust me it doesn't get easier as you get older I can still feel the pain of being relegated under Dowie in 2005 but you do recover to get on with your life. I believe the players did all they could but to keep the intensity up was always a big ask and this is where Roy should have made some changes. As much as Roy is doing a good job he lets everyone down with the lack of movement off the bench. Jose made significant changes but Roy as usual just sat there. I don't buy the fact we have no one on the bench either for he has made little changes throughout the year unless though injury. Let's hope we get points from Chelsea.

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 06 Mar 18 3.40am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Hardest Defeat To Take Of My Life' by Midlands Eagle

Gutted for an hour or so after the match, then logic started to set in.
We didnt expect to get anything before the game, but our game was described as most entertaining of the weekend.
If we can run a good attacking team like Utd, this close, then what are we worried about.
Our absent players will be returning real soon to make us even better, so what am i worried about ?

Like someone said, if not for a world class save and a world class goal, we would have had 3 points. Perm any 1 from 2 and we have a point.

Chelski better look out.

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 06 Mar 18 3.44am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Hardest Defeat To Take Of My Life' by Midlands Eagle

Just read the time I’m replying to your post....I’m still that angry!

So close, yet so far

 

PatrickA Flag London 06 Mar 18 5.00am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Hardest Defeat To Take Of My Life' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by matthau

Gets easier as you get older don't worry

Not sure about that.
In forty years of watching Palace I don’t think I’ve witnessed a more disappointing defeat - a last minute loss on the back of another last minute loss against Tottenham.
What makes it so disappointing is that it was a heroic performance with some very good individual performances.
Afterwards I thought how crushing it must be for the players with self doubt starting to creep in.
I just hope the return of key players who did not play in these morale sapping defeats can help the team go again.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 06 Mar 18 5.34am

The only thing to say about last night is BOLLOCKS

Sorry just needed to get that off my chest before going to work .

How we didn't get something out of that Ill never know but I guess its another that has slipped by because our squad has no depth .

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 06 Mar 18 5.51am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The Hardest Defeat To Take Of My Life' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by chateauferret

It was just like the f***ing cup final all over again. Got United exactly where we wanted them, then failed to close the game out and make a challenge when it mattered. At least we didn't do a stupid dance this time though.

Hopefully we will beat that lot at least once before I die.

Sorry lads but its my fault . I prayed to the football gods in 1972 to let us beat them once before I die and don't care what happens after that . Really feel guilty about that especially at the two cup finals when with all my pals cheering I knew what was coming ,as I did last night .

Sorry again


 

southnorwoodhill Flag 06 Mar 18 6.14am

Jose acted, made good substitutions, Roy didn't even react although the tide had clearly turned. Sorloth was knackered after 70 mins and I expected him to be replaced and a 4-5-1 system put in place. We get over run in midfield week in week out and Jimmy Mac and Luca are run into the ground by the end of a game.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Mar 18 6.29am

I was gutted when they scored their winner but that was a brilliant game of football in which we really played our part.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

phillanth Flag London 06 Mar 18 7.14am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Benteke is a scapegoat. He was excellent tonight, arguably the best player on the pitch. De Gea doesn’t pull one out the hat and it’s a complete performance all round. Forget the hysteria for a second, Benteke does a lot more than people give him credit for. He may not ever fit into our style of play but attempting to rip into him tonight is just silly. He did a lot

Well said! At last a comment from someone who actually watches the game!

 

brooky Flag Herstmonceux 06 Mar 18 7.29am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The effort and passion ' by Midlands Eagle

Last night I went to my bed devestated for the players, Roy and the fans. I felt angry but not st the club or the players but at Jose because I think he’s a disgusting human. He sat there looking entitled and cussing his players at 2-0 down. The man is vile. Nothing special about him or Man U.

This morning I feel very very proud of the club. What a effort against hundreds and hundreds of millions of pounds worth of players. I wouldn’t swap one of ours for there’s.

The back four were putting everything on the line, Tomkins was class, PVA was like a jack rabbit. Kelly was Kelly, solid. AWB was like mr soft with his long legs making there wingers look silly. The midfield were disaplined and solid. Shlup was superb, he was a great outlet, been missed. Townsend as usual was tireless. The two boys up front worked hard but clearly sorloth is the future.

Roy is doing a super job, we’ve always been in games and he’s got everyone playing hard. I’ve got no worries we about staying up with our run in compared to stoke and Southampton.

Lastly mr parish is getting a lot of stick, might be worth thinking about him as our saviour as he bailed the club out. Made a plan, got us in the prem and made the right appointment every time in that moment to keep us in the league. The recruitment has been good over all and he’s put lots money in. Not too mention the ground upgrade.

But we could always get like West Ham or get in a foreign lot from the Middle East and end up like all the failed ex prem clubs who sold there souls. If we go down I’ll thank a 70 year old for a monster effort and the chairman for a lot of memories in the prem. we won’t tho as we have a good club from top to bottom. A chairman that cares, passionate manager and players and the very best fans in the world.

Edited by brooky (06 Mar 2018 7.32am)

Edited by brooky (06 Mar 2018 7.36am)

 

brooky Flag Herstmonceux 06 Mar 18 7.31am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The effort and passion ' by Midlands Eagle

Edited by brooky (06 Mar 2018 7.34am)

 

Bullhorn76 Flag Darlington 06 Mar 18 8.34am

I might be way off but watching Roy’s ‘broken man ‘ post match interview he was talking injuries and I think when he referred to treatment room injuries he was having a pop at Sakho by saying people who feel something in there legs basically need to man up and help out the eleven who are playing week in and week out

 

cpj Flag Kent 06 Mar 18 8.49am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Jose acted, made good substitutions, Roy didn't even react although the tide had clearly turned. Sorloth was knackered after 70 mins and I expected him to be replaced and a 4-5-1 system put in place. We get over run in midfield week in week out and Jimmy Mac and Luca are run into the ground by the end of a game.

^^ This. For some unknown reason he will not use subs until the last 15 mins. We signed 3 players in January and only 1 has been given game time despite our injury crisis. We got a promising midfielder on loan for £2m from Benfica who has scored goals for Malmo last season - what was the point? Is he even going to get on the pitch at any point? The players were shattered in the second half and needed fresh legs - everyone could see it except Hodgson.

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 06 Mar 18 8.52am

Originally posted by brooky

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The effort and passion ' by Midlands Eagle

Lastly mr parish is getting a lot of stick, might be worth thinking about him as our saviour as he bailed the club out. Made a plan, got us in the prem and made the right appointment every time in that moment to keep us in the league. The recruitment has been good over all and he’s put lots money in. Not too mention the ground upgrade.

You need to look back at the history of what happened from 2008 onwards between Jordan, Parish and Alexander not to mention the finance company to make a more informed comment..

You points are wrong on many levels. We lucked promotion that season, it wasn't a plan. Made the right appointments? Warnock? Fdb? Really?

What money has Parish put in? We've been running at a profit each season so the Premier League has been paying everything. Or, do you mean the clubs money is Parish's money?

Also, if credit is being thrown around for plans instead of achievements, I'm going to fund a new ground and pump £500m into the transfer kitty in a few years time. Worship me!

Don't get me wrong, Parish has done good things but people who hero worship him are pathetic and need to grow up.

And people who refer to individuals as 'Mr' are bum kissing imbeciles.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Mar 18 9.01am

Originally posted by cpj

^^ This. For some unknown reason he will not use subs until the last 15 mins. We signed 3 players in January and only 1 has been given game time despite our injury crisis. We got a promising midfielder on loan for £2m from Benfica who has scored goals for Malmo last season - what was the point? Is he even going to get on the pitch at any point? The players were shattered in the second half and needed fresh legs - everyone could see it except Hodgson.

It is insulting to claim that an experienced manager like Hodgson somehow didn't recognise that players wre fatigued after a monumental effort.

He did bring on Riedewald to shore up the midfield but at the end of the day you just cannot introduce 'Fresh legs' without considering the shape and balance of the team.If he felt it was beneficial to make further changes he would have done so.Perhaps he just doesn't rate some of the players on the bench !

Edited by Willo (06 Mar 2018 9.02am)

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 06 Mar 18 9.27am

Originally posted by Willo

It is insulting to claim that an experienced manager like Hodgson somehow didn't recognise that players wre fatigued after a monumental effort.

He did bring on Riedewald to shore up the midfield but at the end of the day you just cannot introduce 'Fresh legs' without considering the shape and balance of the team.If he felt it was beneficial to make further changes he would have done so.Perhaps he just doesn't rate some of the players on the bench !

Edited by Willo (06 Mar 2018 9.02am)

Your points are fair and correct but at 2-1 even on TV/BBC Radio they were saying we were tired and United would go on to win the game.

Needs are and all that, a change should have been made to freshen up the team. Change the shape if needs be, we did it at 2-2.

Why have we got 2 lads on the bench (Jach and Rakip) if Roy doesn't fancy them?

Personally, I'd have brought on Rakip. Put him on the right and Townsend on the left. After all, he's only got 9 games left of his loan.

 

Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Man Utd Match Thread