You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Southampton Match Thread
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Southampton Match Thread


Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
Rainforest Flag London England 01 Sep 18 6.05pm

Saints' 2nd goal is reminiscent of Liverpool's 2nd. They caught us on the break and we couldn't track back to defend.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 01 Sep 18 6.08pm

Originally posted by Rainforest

On paper we are a better side than last season but we don't look like it.

Without Cabaye, that could be debatable. I see little evidence that he’s been adequately replaced.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

boo909 Flag Figeac 01 Sep 18 6.11pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Without Cabaye, that could be debatable. I see little evidence that he’s been adequately replaced.

I know a lot of people were saying he was getting on a bit, couldn't last the full 90 minutes but he was a huge part of the team and he's left a gaping hole in midfield that we haven't filled yet definitely.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

tpuffpendants Flag 01 Sep 18 6.16pm

People rly need to lay off Roy. Definitely not his fault - soooo many chances missed! Benteke literally missed like 10 times. An easy 6 goals we could have scored by my count. Besides macca, henn, and occasionally AWB- our entire team played like complete s**t today

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 01 Sep 18 6.30pm

Every season. It's the hope that kills you. Here we go again.

Rollercoaster. :/

 

Aray Flag South London 01 Sep 18 6.30pm

Originally posted by Rainforest

On paper we are a better side than last season but we don't look like it.

Coz we’re missing a playmaker in the middle

 

Jburton91 Flag Sittingboune 01 Sep 18 7.38pm

Game was awful today so many missed chances crosses in to the box to no body or over everybody ayew is either match rusty or useless yet to be seen give him a chance. But as for benteke he is hopeless and today Kelly wasn't much better to be honest. Games like Southampton are must wins for us

 

moffi Flag Bexhill 01 Sep 18 8.00pm

Disappointing, think even without Wilf we could've been more competitive than that. Meyer is an obvious slot in for Cabaye, looks class in possession helps you keep the ball, he has to start just like Cabaye did most games. Not sure Roy's thinking on that, Jimmy Mac was great today but you've got to fit a ball player in there otherwise you'll get out manoeuvred.. Without wilf just play 1 up and push jimmy closer.. Ayew has championship player written all over him unfortunately, strange signing.

 

Aray Flag South London 01 Sep 18 9.17pm

Originally posted by tpuffpendants

People rly need to lay off Roy. Definitely not his fault - soooo many chances missed! Benteke literally missed like 10 times. An easy 6 goals we could have scored by my count. Besides macca, henn, and occasionally AWB- our entire team played like complete s**t today

The reason why everyone is having a go at Roy is because we were outplayed from the very first minute. After 20 it was clear we had the wrong formation or players on the pitch. 4-4-2 with Jimmy and Luka as the two central midfielders wasn't working. To be frank it has only almost worked because of Zaha's quality as an outlet. Meyer surely is the playmaker?

Everyone in the main stand was screaming at Roy to change it. Nope.

Second half they score from the off but it was a miracle we were still nil nil until then. Yes we could have scored a few times but only because this was Southampton who are a very average team: we were terrible.

When he finally did make a change - opting to take off Andros and leaving on Schlupp was a strange one but leaving on Benteke and taking off Ayew? That made very little sense to me or anyone else sitting around me.

Lets hope Roy works out what his best team is but right now he hasn't got a scooby.

 

The_Dumps Flag Croydon 01 Sep 18 9.43pm

Savage words from Savage today...without Wilf a Championship team, at best.

Roy...Poor. Ayew...Poor. Benteke...Piss poor.

Meyer looked sharp.
Sorloth way better than Benteke, created a golden opportunity for Benteke to score and grab an assist to add to his goal this week, but from 2 yards out, that fool missed.

Edited by The_Dumps (01 Sep 2018 9.44pm)

 

The Dolphin Flag 02 Sep 18 7.12am

Just watched Sky match choice.
Benteke was worse than I thought - three great chances and none taken.
Their first goal - what was Sakho doing!
We were woeful live and worse on TV!

 

mars Flag Folkestone 02 Sep 18 8.13am

This post has been merged from a topic called '5 things learnt' by Midlands Eagle

We still can't win without Wilf
Benteke couldn't hit a cows arse with a banjo
Should have kept Murray
Should have kept Gayle
Need to start with Meyer

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 02 Sep 18 8.19am

This post has been merged from a topic called '5 things learnt' by Midlands Eagle

2,3,5 Yes

Other two not so objective

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

slubglurge Flag welling 02 Sep 18 8.54am

Originally posted by Harry Beever

When Roy was asked if Wickham was fit in his prenatal confwrence he appeared to laugh and couldn’t quite understand his reply. Not sure i’d Be putting too many eggs in that basket

Forget Wickham he's not too far away from celebrating his 2nd anniversary on the sick list. A calf strain to him is another 3 months. He will be injured again in Jan so we wont be able to get rid. No one will pay good money for him with his record, we might just as well pay his contract up.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 02 Sep 18 9.01am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

In my 50th year of supporting Palace, I sympathise with you entirely. But we’re also experiencing the most successful era in the club’s history and I’m still of the mindset that every season in the top flight is a bonus. We’re both too long in the tooth to just ‘blame the manager’ during a sh*tty spell even if, in some instances (Taylor, de Boer, Burley, Pardew) , that’s the right thing to do but surely this is not such a time?

We will finish mid-table. Until we’re bought by an Arab sheikh, that’s the best we can expect.

Exactly mate. Too many Johnny Come Latelys who expect European football and a top 6 finish on here! Cracks me up ...


Edited by Cucking Funt (01 Sep 2018 5.36pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Sep 18 9.07am

The optimism after the Fulham game has dissipated after three straight defeats.

Benteke was his usual abject self and how he keeps getting played is beyond my comprehension.I don't want to be unkind to donkeys by comparing him to them but I heard such a comparision on more than one occasion yesterday.He infuriates me and my blood boils when I see him trying to play football and fluffing chance after chance.

The grand total of 1 goal since the end of January, and that was a penalty, yet he is seemingly our main striker who gets picked game on game.Says it all.

Edited by Willo (02 Sep 2018 9.10am)

 

Username Flag Horsham 02 Sep 18 9.24am

Originally posted by The_Dumps

Savage words from Savage today...without Wilf a Championship team, at best.

Roy...Poor. Ayew...Poor. Benteke...Piss poor.

Meyer looked sharp.
Sorloth way better than Benteke, created a golden opportunity for Benteke to score and grab an assist to add to his goal this week, but from 2 yards out, that fool missed.


Edited by The_Dumps (01 Sep 2018 9.44pm)

Sørloth is so far out of his depth. He can't control a football and has no idea where it's going.

Yeah Benteke missed chances, the header from the corner was the only one I was really upset about. The one on one he linked up well and made the keeper work, the one from two yards, well it's hard to beat a keeper who is only a foot away from you. I felt Sørloth should have scored there with the first header as well. Nodding it to Benteke gave McCarthy time to adjust and smother it.

Thought Benteke did the target man role quite well and linked well with Ayew on a few occasions and should have had at least one penalty.

Personally, I think when Ayew is fit (people moaned when he went off but he looked knackered and at that point was just giving away fouls) he offers the movement to play as the lone striker if we revert to 4231.

To me, the much bigger problem was the midfield and the gameplan. Watching all three strikers today, the centre halves or Luka would have the ball, have no forward options so Benteke/Sørloth/Ayew start making runs ready for the long pass but it doesn't come. All three of them had to spend half their time trotting back from being offside because the pass was delayed. Even when Benteke came short at one point, Sakho still tried that ridiculous pass to PVA through 4 defenders that didn't work once. Right now we're mot playing patient, possession football. We're playing ponderous, predictable football.

We could have Harry Kane up front, the service is so inconsistent it's ridiculous. People also moaned when Andros went off but he was awful. He has one highlight moment a game, hitting the bar against Liverpool, an early cross in the last two games, and after that he's running around like a headless chicken who can't pass or control the ball.

Then you had Luka and McArthur playing exactly the same role in the first half and neither doing it well.

Jimmy looked better im the second when he pushed forward, but Luka has had a very poor start to the season. His passing is awful and his decision making and positioning are very suspect right now. Oh, and his dead ball delivery is very hit and miss. Watching him drop so deep to get the ball, at one point he dropped alongside Sakho to take a pass, then turned and passed to Kelly along the same line, which Sakho was perfectly capable of doing himself. He needs to stay further up so that in those situations the player with the ball has two options not one. His leadership was completely non-existent after the first goal as well, the body language from everyone was bad and he just stood there. Then started lunging in wildly. Would honestly rather see Kouyate start or Riedewald and Luka dropped.

Schlupp might as well have not been on the pitch. He was irrelevant in defence and attack, and only seemed capable of taking a 5 yard pass and then giving it straight back to a player who hadn't moved.

You can't win games when your midfield is that bad. When Kouyate came on we suddenly had drive and a bit of decisiveness. In the first half Luka got the ball to counter with 30 yards of open space in front of him. Instead of carrying the ball he tried a ludicrous pass with the outside of his foot and suddenly we were under pressure again. Kouyate had similar situations twice, both times he drove forward into the space and caused Southampton a problem.

When Meyer came on he wanted the ball. He demanded it. His movement was good, he can take and give off both feet. The two of them simply have to start the next game, whether they both sit and McArthur pushes forward or Meyer plays off Benteke/Ayew and Luka or Riedewald hold as well. No more 442 please.

I'd need to see the first goal again but other than that I thought Kelly had a decent ish game. He also offered better crosses than Townsend in the second half.

AWB is going to make mistakes but he's learning a position the hard way, so I don't mind that. He and PVA and Kelly kept going though. Wayne has every right to be frustrated with his teammates. He rescued us a couple of times, saves a pen and then we waste possession and chances carelessly.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 02 Sep 18 9.36am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'New arrivals' by bexleydave

Sitting watching the game yesterday, it occurred to a few of us what is it with Roy and new arrivals?

I always work on the assumption we are bringing in players who even if they are filling a gap, should be better than we have so why does Roy sign players then never play them?

Last but one window we signed a loan player and a defender who never kicked a ball in angercatvthe club. Last window we sign a set of players now warming the bench.

While on the pitch we have lost three league games in a row.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Sep 18 9.38am

The proof in the pudding will be after the break. Roy has a little time to have a good reassessment of what he is trying to achieve and where it is going very wrong. If he serves up the same failed game plan and sticks to players who quite clearly are not on song, then the cat will be out of the bag.

 

Rainforest Flag London England 02 Sep 18 10.18am

One observation I had yesterday watching the game was whenever we had the ball in our own half or the middle of the park we tend to hold the ball then passed it backwards or sideways instead of carrying it 10-20 yards to pass forward. This allowed Saints' defence to regroup. We don't tend to be quick with the ball going forward.

 

Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Southampton Match Thread