You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Brighton Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Brighton Match Thread


Page 16 of 21 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >
becky Flag over the moon 09 Mar 19 10.10pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

His free kicks were rubbish today aswell.

This is the bad side of Roy. This has been going on for MONTHS yet nothing changes. Poor corners and poor free kicks. The lad takes a good pen but for the love of god Roy is as inactive as a sloth on these things.

The midfield of today is fine when away but Kouyate or Meyer MUST start at home.

As I keep saying Hodgson is an absolute master as long as we are away. Hate to use this word but frankly his tactics and selections have been exposed in home fixtures this season.

How many more times does the Selhurst faithful have to watch a defeat for it to register with some people on here that Hodgson’s approach is not working at home this year.

As he seems unwilling or incapable of changing said approach, expect more disappointing defeats at home. Wasn’t it Einstein who said something about doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different outcomes?

Roy’s stubbornness and rigidity is an asset in this game but also a drawback.

I wonder how good you would be at kicking a ball with force and accuracy, even 70 minutes after taking a boot and set of studs at full force, to your crotch?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 09 Mar 19 10.14pm

Originally posted by cantrbury eagle

Love Lukka and his committed displays but his corners are at times woeful we never look like scoring Coppell was at the game today might be worth having a chat with him as we used to be really good in the early 90s at corners.The art of the near post flick on seems to have disappeared from the game.Also gutted about today but we will beat the Weed at Wembley this is our year come on you Palace

Brighty was good in the air, as well as the centre backs. Wrighty would do the rest in the box if it fell anywhere near him. Like a lot of skills, it takes practice to deliver a decent corner. Does Luka visit Selhurst to practice taking corners from the 4 corner flags ? You might laugh at that but Glenn Hoddle use to spend hours with a tennis ball on a piece string kicking it against his garage when he was a youngster.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Maine Eagle Flag USA 09 Mar 19 10.15pm

Originally posted by becky

I wonder how good you would be at kicking a ball with force and accuracy, even 70 minutes after taking a boot and set of studs at full force, to your crotch?

Pretty good, Becky, if I was a professional footballer who was the designated set piece taker at a premier league club.

Not having a go at Luka, he is doing as he is told.

It is up to the manager to recognize we have a problem with creating goal chances from corners and set pieces this season.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 09 Mar 19 10.17pm

Its taken me until now to recover from today’s abject performance and comment on it. Brighton were poor today, 3 shots, 2 goals. Us, 15 shots no goals from open play. It’s the same old story I’m afraid. Yes we are unlucky to be on the wrong end of that result but when you continually have the same results at home you have to ask yourself the question whether you are doing something wrong. Clearly we are.

Roy sort it out ffs. No more comment. Going to bed pissed and even more pissed off.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 09 Mar 19 10.37pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

His free kicks were rubbish today aswell.

This is the bad side of Roy. This has been going on for MONTHS yet nothing changes. Poor corners and poor free kicks. The lad takes a good pen but for the love of god Roy is as inactive as a sloth on these things.

The midfield of today is fine when away but Kouyate or Meyer MUST start at home.

As I keep saying Hodgson is an absolute master as long as we are away. Hate to use this word but frankly his tactics and selections have been exposed in home fixtures this season.

How many more times does the Selhurst faithful have to watch a defeat for it to register with some people on here that Hodgson’s approach is not working at home this year.

As he seems unwilling or incapable of changing said approach, expect more disappointing defeats at home. Wasn’t it Einstein who said something about doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different outcomes?

Roy’s stubbornness and rigidity is an asset in this game but also a drawback.

Yes, Roy really should stop taking them.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 09 Mar 19 10.38pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Good points well put. I think the question is why Roy doesn't change the team at home with what he has ? Does he genuinely believe it will all turn good sometime soon ? Is he fearful that it will effect our away form ? Is he happy with trying to scrape a point at home and get the wins away ? Does he worry about the sack ? 5 questions just there, probably others have far more.

The thing is he did change the team today from the one which I saw at Burnley last weekend. The midfield changed and the goalkeeper.
Apart from Meyer there is little creativity available. It is ok if your forward players are running into spaces for average midfielders to slot the ball into but today with the crowded area there was nowhere to run so our lack of creativity from midfield became more evident.
It just was not meant to be today.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 09 Mar 19 11.21pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Yes, Roy really should stop taking them.

No Luka should.

Stats don’t lie.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Sherlock II Flag The Big Mango 10 Mar 19 3.13am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

I’ve avoided looking at this thread all day.

Looks like it was a wise decision.

I share your sentiment.

 


Originally Sherlock, the Holmesdale Online class Of 2001

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Mar 19 3.27am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'We are much too nice' by Midlands Eagle

The Knockaert challenge ....... he was clearly the designated player to ’do a number’ on Luka by Mr Houghton and escaped wrongly with a yellow. No one returned the compliment and in my opinion this is et another example of our softness. Especially today given the fact that it was a derby against bitter rivals we did not possess that nasty side that you need and as i have said in another blog, this match was tailor made for Kouyate, In years gone by we had the players who would sort matters out, alas now I can online think of CK and perhaps Meyer. We are far too nice and suffer as a result particuarly providing protection to the likes of Zaha.

 


Bring back Brolin

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 10 Mar 19 5.42am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'We are much too nice' by Midlands Eagle

Yes, we were such a soft bunch yesterday. And with all the possession 1st half hardly any bother for Brighton's goalie.
Only Roy H knows why Kouyate (and Meyer) started on the bench. MacArthur had a day when his passing went astray and everything was in slow slow motion.
It was our main rivals and they were up for it. We were not in spite of our surrender at the Amex stadium.
Don't get it! The best suporters in the land - and the worst home record!!!!

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 10 Mar 19 6.48am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'We are much too nice' by Midlands Eagle

Brilliant post.

I've long thought Luka isn't captain material on the basis that he leaves Zaha out to dry by not absolutely crippling people for kicking him about, he doesn't even get at the ref, which as Captain he's allowed to do with a level of protection: captain's privilege. Roy Keane he is not.

Knockheart and the black fella, number 8 ran that midfield kicking everyone (especially Zaha) about and we totally melted. The ref wasn't interested in enforcing the rules properly as demonstrated by Brighton still having 11 on the pitch at half time. Any good captain would have instructed his team to get in on them hard.

Murray had a naughty kick at one of our boys too, there should have been a f***ing melee for that. We are too nice, bollockless in fact. Embarrassing.

Edited by ChrisGC (10 Mar 2019 6.50am)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Mar 19 7.13am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

The ref wasn't interested in enforcing the rules properly as demonstrated by him not giving Brighton a penalty when Scott Dann manhandled a player to the ground in the penalty area

EFA

 

YT Flag Oxford 10 Mar 19 7.57am

Originally posted by becky

I wonder how good you would be at kicking a ball with force and accuracy, even 70 minutes after taking a boot and set of studs at full force, to your crotch?

This sounds like something that might go on at an S&M party.

Not that I've been to one, I must stress, although watching Palace at home is an unbearable torture.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

YT Flag Oxford 10 Mar 19 8.00am

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

The thing is he did change the team today from the one which I saw at Burnley last weekend. The midfield changed and the goalkeeper.
Apart from Meyer there is little creativity available. It is ok if your forward players are running into spaces for average midfielders to slot the ball into but today with the crowded area there was nowhere to run so our lack of creativity from midfield became more evident.
It just was not meant to be today.



The problem is: there are too many 'todays'. Almost every home game.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 10 Mar 19 8.03am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

EFA

Yeah, so what? s*** ref, but he can't give what he doesn't see in fairness.

Tommo should've had a penalty too, which he did see. Brighton tested the ref early with a couple of nasty challenges and sussed he was weak and capitalised on it.

We didn't react to that fact in the slightest.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 10 Mar 19 8.03am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

This post has been merged from a topic called 'We are much too nice' by Midlands Eagle

The Knockaert challenge ....... he was clearly the designated player to ’do a number’ on Luka by Mr Houghton and escaped wrongly with a yellow. No one returned the compliment and in my opinion this is et another example of our softness. Especially today given the fact that it was a derby against bitter rivals we did not possess that nasty side that you need and as i have said in another blog, this match was tailor made for Kouyate, In years gone by we had the players who would sort matters out, alas now I can online think of CK and perhaps Meyer. We are far too nice and suffer as a result particuarly providing protection to the likes of Zaha.

Agree totally, they set out to try and injure Luka (amongst others) and any unbiased competent referee would have sent of the little French runt....however we dont get referees like that.....so well done Mr Pawson for f***ing up, just like many of your colleagues have in the past. Im sure you will be forensically assessed and patted on the back for another job well done!!

Apart from that, we were s*** and got what we deserved, nothing!!

 

PatrickA Flag London 10 Mar 19 8.22am

We can make as many excuses as we like about they should have had a player sent off, they were overly physical, they scored with their only shots etc.
The fact is we were not good enough and have not been good enough all season at home.
Roy’s way of playing at home doesn’t seem to suit any striker.
Batshuayi had nothing set up for him yesterday and doesn’t look the sort of player to create something for himself as he’s a poacher.
But even when we’ve tried Benteke, Ayew or Wickham the service has still been poor.
There seems to be a myth building around the amount of chances we create at home as I can only recall Burnley and Cardiff where we created lots of chances.
We missed the odd chance against Southampton, Newcastle, Watford , Chelsea and Brighton but have not really carved them open.
At home , where we can’t counterattack, we are very easy to defend against and I don’t see this changing under Roy as he won’t change his approach.
Somebody told me we have scored 7 goals in open play at home this season which sounds shocking if correct.
Our free kicks and corners are useless and leave us vulnerable to counterattack.
Roy will not take any responsibility and when asked about the poor quality in the display yesterday he just said , ‘ that’s down to individuals.’
Yes, the players are responsible too , but ultimately he is the manager and is accountable for tactics, how we set up, changes during the game and motivation.
He may have had over 40 years in the game but this does not necessarily make him right when he goes into games with an unbalanced midfield of Luka, Mcarthur and Schlupp ( leaving out Kouyate).
Or where he insists on having both Kelly and Ward on the bench at home at the expense of a winger ( Sako), if we do need to try something different.
I’m not saying this on the back of yesterday’s result and have felt this way for some time.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 10 Mar 19 8.55am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Yeah, so what? s*** ref, but he can't give what he doesn't see in fairness.

Tommo should've had a penalty too, which he did see. Brighton tested the ref early with a couple of nasty challenges and sussed he was weak and capitalised on it.

We didn't react to that fact in the slightest.

Shall we ignore Brightons stone wall pen by dann in the first half which could have made yesterday even harder to watch

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 10 Mar 19 8.57am

Originally posted by PatrickA

We can make as many excuses as we like about they should have had a player sent off, they were overly physical, they scored with their only shots etc.
The fact is we were not good enough and have not been good enough all season at home.
Roy’s way of playing at home doesn’t seem to suit any striker.
Batshuayi had nothing set up for him yesterday and doesn’t look the sort of player to create something for himself as he’s a poacher.
But even when we’ve tried Benteke, Ayew or Wickham the service has still been poor.
There seems to be a myth building around the amount of chances we create at home as I can only recall Burnley and Cardiff where we created lots of chances.
We missed the odd chance against Southampton, Newcastle, Watford , Chelsea and Brighton but have not really carved them open.
At home , where we can’t counterattack, we are very easy to defend against and I don’t see this changing under Roy as he won’t change his approach.
Somebody told me we have scored 7 goals in open play at home this season which sounds shocking if correct.
Our free kicks and corners are useless and leave us vulnerable to counterattack.
Roy will not take any responsibility and when asked about the poor quality in the display yesterday he just said , ‘ that’s down to individuals.’
Yes, the players are responsible too , but ultimately he is the manager and is accountable for tactics, how we set up, changes during the game and motivation.
He may have had over 40 years in the game but this does not necessarily make him right when he goes into games with an unbalanced midfield of Luka, Mcarthur and Schlupp ( leaving out Kouyate).
Or where he insists on having both Kelly and Ward on the bench at home at the expense of a winger ( Sako), if we do need to try something different.
I’m not saying this on the back of yesterday’s result and have felt this way for some time.

We could have done better had wilf not been so feckin selfish

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 10 Mar 19 9.06am

Originally posted by silvertop

Shall we ignore Brightons stone wall pen by dann in the first half which could have made yesterday even harder to watch

That's the point I was responding to if you read it.

 

Page 16 of 21 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Brighton Match Thread