You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton vs Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Everton vs Palace Match Thread


Page 16 of 19 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 08 Feb 20 3.13pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

BFS has done an excellent job interview today.


That guys knows his stuff you can tell by the way he was speaking and even highlighted what is wrong with us and he didn't come out and say it's Roy but you can tell that is what he was implying with not using players to their strengths.

We would be so much better if we had Sam still but clearly he wasn't going to put up with SP BS and proved it's not Americans fault.

I don't think the players are buying into Roy anymore and look like they have lost interest in this dull football.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 08 Feb 20 3.27pm

Originally posted by premier fan

Spot on - all down to Roy’s tactics


Bingo - ole roy got no clue. btw, the right back mistakes this season have cost us now 15 points. Was it worth the while selling AWB for 50 mil? when we go down, this will hit home

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 08 Feb 20 3.47pm

Could hear Ray Lewington screaming at the players to get forward and put pressure on them and still we kept playing it around at the back or in PVA's case, passing to the opposition!

McManaman called it right today. It was much better when we hit the ball long and picked up the scraps.

 

DenTyler Flag Sidcup 08 Feb 20 3.50pm

What is the betting that Roy starts with the same team and tactics in the next game.

It’s so depressing.

 

Fred Bassett Flag rotherfield 08 Feb 20 4.43pm

I have stopped listening to Roys after match interviews as they are as predictable as his tactics , I do blame Roy for not standing his ground on transfers for the past 2 transfer deadlines and a younger manager may well have decided enough is enough and walked like previous managers . Parish obviously has been involved with lack of new players hoping he can get by without any outlay, well my friends his biggest gamble is coming of the rails and Championship football is on the horizon unless something dramatic happens and I am sad to say we are destined to get relegated.

 

Aray Flag South London 08 Feb 20 4.47pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Well, I saw moments where Everton were all over the shop and we had them utterly and completely under the cosh and it was our passing again which destroyed any hope we had of building any momentum and I just cannot understand how Mr Hodgson is to blame for that!

Moments is the right word. Utterly and completely? Not from where I was sitting. 2 shots on target says it all. Zaha should have done better on at least 2 occasions though so you have a partial point. .

As for our woeful passing, which players do you think would do a better job on that front? I’d say Jairo is one - have we managed a point since he was dropped? I’m not the only one who thinks our midfield 3 isn't balanced.

If we are going to play it out from the back then Meyer or Jairo (surely he’s worth a go there) has to be in the middle as they have better skills in that regard.

Personally I’d rather us play more direct and to Benteke’s strength. . But really Ayew should have been in the middle not on the wing as he’s our best threat right now.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 08 Feb 20 5.19pm

The boys worked very hard, pleased with their effort, scored an equaliser, thought that was a fair result, unlucky to concede and lose the game.

This is the post match view of the manager we are very lucky to have.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 08 Feb 20 5.38pm

I would agree with a Roy in general we did play well and from what I saw for a great deal of the game we were the team trying to win the game. Luck as well as quality plays a part in the winning and losing of a game. We had no luck having hit the post twice and a header hitting the goalkeeper. They had a moment of quality through Richarlison and scored. Our issue today was lack of luck and some poor passing which held us back. In general I agree with Roy but am not surprised we have lost to loads of signings Everton. COYP

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 08 Feb 20 6.05pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

I would agree with a Roy in general we did play well and from what I saw for a great deal of the game we were the team trying to win the game. Luck as well as quality plays a part in the winning and losing of a game. We had no luck having hit the post twice and a header hitting the goalkeeper. They had a moment of quality through Richarlison and scored. Our issue today was lack of luck and some poor passing which held us back. In general I agree with Roy but am not surprised we have lost to loads of signings Everton. COYP


i think you was watching a different game maybe one from few season back.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

PatrickA Flag London 08 Feb 20 6.24pm

Not sure what McCarthy gives us ahead of Kouyate if Hodgson insists on 3 solid midfielders.
Kouyate is equally good at tackling, is quicker, better in the air and gets us up the field quicker.
McCarthy is arguably a slightly better passer but probably not enough to warrant a place ahead of Kouyate.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 08 Feb 20 6.45pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Not sure what McCarthy gives us ahead of Kouyate if Hodgson insists on 3 solid midfielders.
Kouyate is equally good at tackling, is quicker, better in the air and gets us up the field quicker.
McCarthy is arguably a slightly better passer but probably not enough to warrant a place ahead of Kouyate.

I agree with that and McCarthy or McCarthur should be starting, not both. Luka was woeful again today with his long passing, but his positioning in front of the back four should keep him in the side. I have no doubts that Kouyate should be starting in that midfield. Hopefully Townsend will get on the field soon as Wilf on his own needs pressure off him? Wilf was at fault with the first goal giving the ball away and Ward on the second by not challenging on the half way line hard enough. Even giving away a foul would have helped us. Mistakes like those as well as not being able to deliver a final ball is dropping us down the table. Not sure where the next points are coming from :-(

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 08 Feb 20 6.57pm

Allardyce said he was more concerned by our poor defensive play today than our attacking intent and now we look like we've lost Tomkins for a bit who has probably been our best player over recent games.

As I've said a few times now the club's / Roy's perseverance with Benteke is my biggest gripe and IMO is one of the things most likely to cost us. He was jank again today and it was no coincidence we went on a run when he was dropped after the game against Sheffield Utd earlier in the season. Ayew is a good CF, strong with good feet but no winger.

I agree Kouyate brings legs and height to the midfield and should be in ahead of McCarthy.

Failing to get another orthodox wide player during the window was very complacent bordering negligent.


 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 08 Feb 20 6.59pm

The fact is our players were of a lower quality. Quite a bit. I was impressed by Richarlison. Better than I expected. His goal was very good and the type of attacking runner I would love to see at Palace.
We were second to the ball and the passing was poor. It wasn’t good Roy. It was poor.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

EddieMac Flag 08 Feb 20 7.06pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

I would agree with a Roy in general we did play well and from what I saw for a great deal of the game we were the team trying to win the game. Luck as well as quality plays a part in the winning and losing of a game. We had no luck having hit the post twice and a header hitting the goalkeeper. They had a moment of quality through Richarlison and scored. Our issue today was lack of luck and some poor passing which held us back. In general I agree with Roy but am not surprised we have lost to loads of signings Everton. COYP

Spot on in my view. They took their chances and we didn’t. Benteke scores that header and we are level and maybe heading for a win. The game was a lot more even than people are saying. We were well on top and pushing for a goal when they hit us with a long ball sucker punch,

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 08 Feb 20 7.16pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Spot on in my view. They took their chances and we didn’t. Benteke scores that header and we are level and maybe heading for a win. The game was a lot more even than people are saying. We were well on top and pushing for a goal when they hit us with a long ball sucker punch,

You said the same for the last couple of games - if this, if that - didn't happen. 3 losses to teams we thought we were able to compete with. Check the facts, 3 games 3 losses, six against, 1 for. That is the bottom line.

 

EddieMac Flag 08 Feb 20 7.27pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

You said the same for the last couple of games - if this, if that - didn't happen. 3 losses to teams we thought we were able to compete with. Check the facts, 3 games 3 losses, six against, 1 for. That is the bottom line.

If we got battered today like we did against Southampton then I’d say it. Very fine margins today and against Sheffield Utd.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 08 Feb 20 7.29pm

Originally posted by kevlee

The fact is our players were of a lower quality. Quite a bit. I was impressed by Richarlison. Better than I expected. His goal was very good and the type of attacking runner I would love to see at Palace.
We were second to the ball and the passing was poor. It wasn’t good Roy. It was poor.

We do already have one. He's just completely stifled by our tactics and the likes of PVA being unable to pass it 10 feet to him.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 08 Feb 20 7.30pm

You lot moaning in particular about the passing have a look at the Stats,Evertons accurate pass rate was actually worse than ours.
I was at Goodison, we actually played well for periods, when the score was 1-1, we looked the team most likely to win it then Richarlison scored, end of story. Not such a bad performance as you doom merchants make out. Must admit the substitutions were strange and did not help our cause.I think Riedawald and Townsend would have been better options.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 08 Feb 20 7.32pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

You lot moaning in particular about the passing have a look at the Stats,Evertons accurate pass rate was actually worse than ours.
I was at Goodison, we actually played well for periods, when the score was 1-1, we looked the team most likely to win it then Richarlison scored, end of story. Not such a bad performance as you doom merchants make out. Must admit the substitutions were strange and did not help our cause.I think Riedawald and Townsend would have been better options.

For 6 minutes then. Yes we really rattled Everton after we equalised, but barely threatened them throughout the first half and they took us apart in the second. Six minutes when an Everton team who have had a reputation for shooting themselves in the foot for a couple of seasons were shaky does not equal a good overall performance.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Feb 20 7.39pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

If we got battered today like we did against Southampton then I’d say it. Very fine margins today and against Sheffield Utd.

Margins mean nothing in football. You either win lose or draw. It is irrelevant if you play fantastically and lose or play crap and lose. I thought we played good for 20 mins today, the rest was rubbish and we got exactly what we deserved out of the match, feck all.

 

Page 16 of 19 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton vs Palace Match Thread