You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal palace v Bright*n match thread
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal palace v Bright*n match thread


Page 16 of 23 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Oct 20 5.42pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Check out ASPFCs post early in the thread as to why we played with such negative defensive tactics

Those tactics were moments away from stealing all 3 points and leaving us in 6th.

Get all the good signigs and play with verve and excitement... and you are 3 nil down to spuds in minutes.

I am not happy and we were cr@p but people need to take a reality check. Burnley and us - the method of the under resourced.

What's funny is how much I was vilified for it. My point was, our team is basically rubbish, bordering on somewhat adequate in places. With less injuries we could certainly be somewhat better.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Petereagle Flag Brockley 18 Oct 20 5.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

CPFC under Hodgson this season :

Possession : 20th in PL
Successful passes : 20th in PL
Passes in opposition half : 19th in PL
Passing accuracy : 20th in PL.

Ouch, says it all. Somethings gotta change. If we are that defensive home to Brighton, ......

 

Fatherken Flag 18 Oct 20 5.44pm

still only 33 points from safety . In Roy's mind a point a game from now on will do

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 18 Oct 20 5.44pm

This says it all.. BBC

'We opted for the siege mentality'
Crystal Palace 1-1 Brighton


Crystal Palace

Crystal Palace boss Roy Hodgson, speaking to BBC Sport: "The quality of the defensive performance and effort they put in against a good team. We defended our way almost to a very good three points. It is something that can happen, in the first or the 95th minute - if the opponent have the ball around your area it can fall kindly or get the fortune with a deflection, which I'm sure they would say is fully deserved.

"We started to show our teeth at times in the first half. But unfortunately there is always something in a game when you lead 1-0 and the opponent is taking the game to you, there is something that brings a siege mentality to see the game through. Had we got the second goal you would have seen a different mentality, But we decided on the siege mentality and it almost saw us through.

"There is a lot more we have to give. We ran into a Brighton team that played well today. We were good enough defensively and with our discipline and spirit to come away with three points but we wouldn't be whooping for joy saying that is all our tactical work solved. Luckily I am now doing it with a group with competition for places."

On VAR: "It has been opted for. VAR was opted for. It was seen as better and ruling out clear errors of judgment. As it happens I don't know that there are so many from the on-field officials. It has brought us into a different world where when a goal is scored you wit to see if it will be chalked off. There are always going to degrees after a round of games of managers feeling they were either harshly or less harshly treated."

 

PatrickA Flag London 18 Oct 20 5.45pm

It’s a question of perception.
I am with the fans who despair at the lack of attacking intent with one shot on goal.
On the other hand I’m sure Roy will be generally content with that performance and point to the fact that Guiata had barely a save to make.
We have to accept that his way of viewing football is almost exclusively governed by the defensive side of the game.
You can guarantee he won’t change and he would argue why should he after more than 40 years in management.
Prepare for more of same.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 18 Oct 20 5.46pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

Ouch, says it all. Somethings gotta change. If we are that defensive home to Brighton, ......

What we really need is for WetSpam to get relegated and then pick up 2 or 3 of the players they nicked from us

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 18 Oct 20 5.48pm

We’ll probably draw against Fulham and then our stats will be:

W - 2
D - 2
L - 2

Roy will then convince SP that it’s a solid start to the season in uncertain times ... which let’s face it, we all would have taken from a points perspective at the beginning of the season. It’s just the turgid manner in how we play and accumulate our points that’s the problem ...

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Oct 20 5.48pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

Ouch, says it all. Somethings gotta change. If we are that defensive home to Brighton, ......

Chris Hughton had to leave in order for Brighton to become more attractive, the same will be for Roy .. meanwhile we have to sit on our hands.

Roy is not going to be around for long.

 

PA Flag Bedfordshire 18 Oct 20 5.57pm

Wasn’t that long ago we were everyone’s fave second team. We’re now the most boring team for neutrals to watch.

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 18 Oct 20 6.00pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

This says it all.. BBC

'We opted for the siege mentality'
Crystal Palace 1-1 Brighton


Crystal Palace

Crystal Palace boss Roy Hodgson, speaking to BBC Sport: "The quality of the defensive performance and effort they put in against a good team. We defended our way almost to a very good three points. It is something that can happen, in the first or the 95th minute - if the opponent have the ball around your area it can fall kindly or get the fortune with a deflection, which I'm sure they would say is fully deserved.

"We started to show our teeth at times in the first half. But unfortunately there is always something in a game when you lead 1-0 and the opponent is taking the game to you, there is something that brings a siege mentality to see the game through. Had we got the second goal you would have seen a different mentality, But we decided on the siege mentality and it almost saw us through.

"There is a lot more we have to give. We ran into a Brighton team that played well today. We were good enough defensively and with our discipline and spirit to come away with three points but we wouldn't be whooping for joy saying that is all our tactical work solved. Luckily I am now doing it with a group with competition for places."

On VAR: "It has been opted for. VAR was opted for. It was seen as better and ruling out clear errors of judgment. As it happens I don't know that there are so many from the on-field officials. It has brought us into a different world where when a goal is scored you wit to see if it will be chalked off. There are always going to degrees after a round of games of managers feeling they were either harshly or less harshly treated."

He really seems to think it was an OK performance. Mind you the BBC reporter seemed to be a complete sycophant. He didn't ask any relevant questions.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Oct 20 6.02pm

Originally posted by KAOS

We’ll probably draw against Fulham and then our stats will be:

W - 2
D - 2
L - 2

Roy will then convince SP that it’s a solid start to the season in uncertain times ... which let’s face it, we all would have taken from a points perspective at the beginning of the season. It’s just the turgid manner in how we play and accumulate our points that’s the problem ...

We can improve and have done so in the past under Roy although not a lot it has improved enough to be acceptable to most, we must all understand nothing is going to change as all want as that cannot happen until a new manager appears and that is not too far away now, It takes two to tangle and I fear some of our players on this performance today are becoming a little pissed.

Edited by Tickled pink (18 Oct 2020 6.03pm)

 

slubglurge Flag welling 18 Oct 20 6.02pm

With Roy at the helm we are stinking the league out. If we get relegated you will here the Prem leagues cheers all over the country. They are trying to sell their product around the world and we are not helping their cause

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 18 Oct 20 6.08pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

What's funny is how much I was vilified for it. My point was, our team is basically rubbish, bordering on somewhat adequate in places. With less injuries we could certainly be somewhat better.

Yeah but there's being pragmatic and putting up the "white flags" before a ball is even kicked..!!

Two entirely different things..!!

In any event I stand by what I said, team/squad is good enough at this level, its the tactics that are woefully lacking..!!

COYP

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 18 Oct 20 6.08pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

With Roy at the helm we are stinking the league out. If we get relegated you will here the Prem leagues cheers all over the country. They are trying to sell their product around the world and we are not helping their cause

100% agree. Embarrassment to the league. The last team to be this far gone in terms of anti football was ironically Brighton under Hughton towards the end before he got the sack. No such luck in our case. Parish and co don’t have the balls to replace Roy.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Oct 20 6.11pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

With Roy at the helm we are stinking the league out. If we get relegated you will here the Prem leagues cheers all over the country. They are trying to sell their product around the world and we are not helping their cause

That's the point of having Mr Hodgson here, it was never intended to be expansive ..just a means to get us over the line and to be in this league to pass the baton over at the right time to the right person.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 18 Oct 20 6.17pm

We were playing g our biggest rivals today at home. They have one if the worst defences in the league. If we had won we would have moved I to 6th and it would have been our best start in the premier league. Surely to God that was enough to say to the players, go out close them down high up the pitch and attack....

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 18 Oct 20 6.18pm

Playing this sort of football the nickname "Eagles" is inappropriate. I suggest "blue tits".


 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Oct 20 6.22pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

100% agree. Embarrassment to the league. The last team to be this far gone in terms of anti football was ironically Brighton under Hughton towards the end before he got the sack. No such luck in our case. Parish and co don’t have the balls to replace Roy.

They don't have to and don't want to because we are a million miles away from being relegated under Roy, he is quite obviously leaving under his own steam possibly at end of this season and it will be the new managers job to make us more attractive to watch, nothing is going to change meanwhile.

 

BM Flag 18 Oct 20 6.22pm

So many people on here have a false idea of who we are and what we can realistically achieve. It’s disappointing to lose and not to play very well, but the moaning and the disrespect towards a fine manager is way over the top. Many Palace fans sound like those Charlton whingers who demanded Curbishley was sacked because they wanted someone else to take the club to another level. They’re certainly on another level now. Roy is a tactical master who knows how to keep relatively small clubs in the PL. He is not perfect but we have started the season well and are unlikely to go down. He has sacrificed one of the three DMs so we should see better football most of the time. I’m glad he’s our manager and think we will have a good season.

 

andy p Flag Warrington cheshire 18 Oct 20 6.25pm

west ham showing us how you attack a game of footy

 


stuck up here with a load of northern monkeys!

Page 16 of 23 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal palace v Bright*n match thread