You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley v Palace Match thread
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Burnley v Palace Match thread


Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 24 Nov 20 9.51pm

Our inability to rescue something from the game came down to a lack of quality and tired looking looking players rather than any tactics. The squad's a ticking time bomb and has been for a while.

I nearly fell off my chair when Townsend referred to breaking into the top ten.

The centre-backs should accept a fair bit of responsibility for the first half and Roy, not for the first time this season, bemoaned a lack of willingness / quality to find a forward pass generally.

The comments that the spine of the team didn't really turn up (or just weren't good enough) are true.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Nov 20 10.08pm

Originally posted by Putitout

We were set up to ,win the game, and if Kouyate, had not have given them their goal, and McArthur, had put the ball on Bats , toe, we would have all been happy. Second half the tactics were spot on, the application wasn’t , played reasonably well but couldn’t get past a good defence, and a first class keeper. It happens we have won matches in that way on a good many occasions . Tactics can only help , Both ,Bats, and Big Bent, could , should even have finished but credit Pope, whatever the tactics were seen to be we could have won , and at least not have lost that game.

We had plenty of very decent opportunities to find that goal, our players would've had a nightmare journey home for sure and yes Pope is a brilliant keeper should be number one for our national side.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Nov 20 10.17pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

What struck me yesterday was the fact we struggled so much to retain possession in the first half and in the second seemed confused of how to actually attack the Burnley goal despite a lot of possession in their half.

My conclusion was that usually when we gain possession in a game, we look straight to Wilf. When he's not there, it seemed as though no-one knew what to do with the ball.

Makes you wonder if they run attacking drills or actually have any tactical instruction at all?


That's how I saw it too. There were several occasions when we had several players moving forward and the player on the ball didn't know who to pass it too and lost it by reason of their hesitation or took the safe option and passed back or sideways. Really frustrating.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Nov 20 10.27pm

Originally posted by sprites

McArthur didn't even overhit it....it was a great, teasing ball across the face of the goal. Michy should've anticipated it better and got on the end of it.


I agree with the match pundit and others who said McArthur overhit it. Had Batshuayi moved any earlier he would have been offside.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 24 Nov 20 10.37pm

Originally posted by doombear


I agree with the match pundit and others who said McArthur overhit it. Had Batshuayi moved any earlier he would have been offside.

Fair enough. All opinions. I just think the midfielder puts the ball along the box like that...he can't do much more. Onus must be on the striker to get there.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Nov 20 11.09pm

A lot of very glib comments on here about what could/should have been. We scored zero goals against a very poor team and got exactly what we deserved out of the match. Poor team selection from the start. Burnley like to bully so we should have started with Benteke and Schlupp who are two of our more physical players aerially and if they wanted Eze in the team then he needed to be more central.

Look at the replay and see the lack of first balls won and the inability of our front line to hold up the ball. It’s so easy to see and I put that down to the managers tactical selections.

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 25 Nov 20 7.59am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

A lot of very glib comments on here about what could/should have been. We scored zero goals against a very poor team and got exactly what we deserved out of the match. Poor team selection from the start. Burnley like to bully so we should have started with Benteke and Schlupp who are two of our more physical players aerially and if they wanted Eze in the team then he needed to be more central.

Look at the replay and see the lack of first balls won and the inability of our front line to hold up the ball. It’s so easy to see and I put that down to the managers tactical selections.

Spot on post. Unfortunately I'm expecting a similar performance against Newcastle, hopefully the boys prove me wrong...

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 25 Nov 20 8.28am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

A lot of very glib comments on here about what could/should have been. We scored zero goals against a very poor team and got exactly what we deserved out of the match. Poor team selection from the start. Burnley like to bully so we should have started with Benteke and Schlupp who are two of our more physical players aerially and if they wanted Eze in the team then he needed to be more central.

Look at the replay and see the lack of first balls won and the inability of our front line to hold up the ball. It’s so easy to see and I put that down to the managers tactical selections.

Burnley are struggling at the moment with confidence yes but they are not an easy team to break down, we had opportunities and you fully know we should've taken one of them at least, yes Benteke would've been better with the long balls out and holding up play but that sadly is all he can do at the moment, he can't find space for himself or anyone else and heading and shooting is too easy for defenders to read, he needs to drop a league these things happen, What would you have changed for this game?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Nov 20 9.11am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Burnley are struggling at the moment with confidence yes but they are not an easy team to break down, we had opportunities and you fully know we should've taken one of them at least, yes Benteke would've been better with the long balls out and holding up play but that sadly is all he can do at the moment, he can't find space for himself or anyone else and heading and shooting is too easy for defenders to read, he needs to drop a league these things happen, What would you have changed for this game?

Something I’m afraid Roy would never consider. I would have started Schlupp left, Townsend right, Benteke up the middle and Eze playing where he should be, off of and slightly behind Benteke. With Wilf out that would have given us more balance and added a bit of steel in the air, so that we didn’t just have the ball coming back at us every time the ball went forward above chest height.

In such a format who you pick as the supporting central midfielders is pretty much up for grabs however given the way we know how Burnley were going to play I would probably have stuck with Riedewald and McArthur (maybe bringing Cahill back into CH and Kouyate stepping up to take McArthur’s role as an alternative).

My main point is that Burnley knew exactly what we were going to do and out played us, out muscled us and sat back once they scored playing on the knowledge our standard one dimensional style of attacking was not good enough to break them down.

Yes we had a few decent chances, but so did they. I am of the opinion we didn’t deserve any more than we took from that game. What I will say however is that the overall performance was better than in the Chelsea and Brighton games even though we picked up a fortuitous point against the weed.

Anyway, bring on the Newcastle match and let’s see if there are any tactical changes made to how we set up and the personnel used in Wilf’s absence.

 

PatrickA Flag London 25 Nov 20 9.59am

I’ve listened to the post match interview with Hodgson and the problem he identified in the first half was that there were too many passes back to our keeper followed by launch of the long ball.
This was clearly evident and played into their hands as Burnley were winning all the headers and we were unable to get hold of the ball or win the second ball.
So not the tactics planned at the outset and Hodgson said that there was an adjustment that led to an improvement in the second half.
I suspect the defence will be changed for the Newcastle game as we have the luxury of enough fit defenders now and the two games are close together.
I also expect Schlupp to start.

 

EddieMac Flag 25 Nov 20 10.05am

Originally posted by sprites

McArthur didn't even overhit it....it was a great, teasing ball across the face of the goal. Michy should've anticipated it better and got on the end of it.

Get a grip. It was a shocking pass and Jimmy Mac knew it. We should have been level.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Nov 20 10.15am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Get a grip. It was a shocking pass and Jimmy Mac knew it. We should have been level.

In my humble opinion, McArthur, crossing with his weaker left-foot put a tad too much pace on the cross and it could have been better directed.

At least Batshuayi was in the danger zone and made a valiant effort to steer it in - Benteke would have been outside the penalty area !

When one considers this effort, the two saves the goalkeeper made from Benteke and the save from Batshuayi, we did have our chances to win the game and I feel that Burnley were fortunate to get all the points.

Edited by Willo (25 Nov 2020 10.19am)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 25 Nov 20 10.35am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Zaha didn’t get Covid in Africa. He didn’t play Ivory Coast’s last 2 games. Liverpool let Salah go and he got Covid. Clubs have no choice.

Tell that to Alex Ferguson

 


Red and Blue Army!

GujiMadDog Flag England 25 Nov 20 10.35am

Benteke, Ayew, Batshuayi, Connor Whickham and Alexander Sorloth have combined to score just 26 Premier League goals in 123 games, going back to the start of 2017.

The stats are damning despite Hodgson's claim that we can score goals without Wifie.

On the rare ocasions where we passed the ball forward accurately, we lacked the quality to open up Burnley.

Hodgson must address this. Unfortunately, while Wilfie masks our obvious short comings, the stats suggest otherwise.

Another season in the premiership with bellowing pains of frustration beckons.

Bring On The Turgid Football!!

Edited by GujiMadDog (25 Nov 2020 10.45am)

 

EddieMac Flag 25 Nov 20 10.35am

Originally posted by Willo

In my humble opinion, McArthur, crossing with his weaker left-foot put a tad too much pace on the cross and it could have been better directed.

At least Batshuayi was in the danger zone and made a valiant effort to steer it in - Benteke would have been outside the penalty area !

When one considers this effort, the two saves the goalkeeper made from Benteke and the save from Batshuayi, we did have our chances to win the game and I feel that Burnley were fortunate to get all the points.

Edited by Willo (25 Nov 2020 10.19am)

I agree. On the balance of play and with the chances created by both sides the game could have went either way. They got a lucky break due to Kouyate miss hit header. They hit the post when should have scored and woods had his chance with his head.

We had Bats 1 on 1.
McCarthurs bad pass.
Benteke’s chance which he had a mili second to react to.


It was a poor game over all but I don’t believe it was as bad a performance as some are making out. Townsend had his worst game of the season for us yet he always seemed to be the one in possession of the ball around their box.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 25 Nov 20 11.32am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Something I’m afraid Roy would never consider. I would have started Schlupp left, Townsend right, Benteke up the middle and Eze playing where he should be, off of and slightly behind Benteke. With Wilf out that would have given us more balance and added a bit of steel in the air, so that we didn’t just have the ball coming back at us every time the ball went forward above chest height.

In such a format who you pick as the supporting central midfielders is pretty much up for grabs however given the way we know how Burnley were going to play I would probably have stuck with Riedewald and McArthur (maybe bringing Cahill back into CH and Kouyate stepping up to take McArthur’s role as an alternative).

My main point is that Burnley knew exactly what we were going to do and out played us, out muscled us and sat back once they scored playing on the knowledge our standard one dimensional style of attacking was not good enough to break them down.

Yes we had a few decent chances, but so did they. I am of the opinion we didn’t deserve any more than we took from that game. What I will say however is that the overall performance was better than in the Chelsea and Brighton games even though we picked up a fortuitous point against the weed.

Anyway, bring on the Newcastle match and let’s see if there are any tactical changes made to how we set up and the personnel used in Wilf’s absence.

Agreed, good points as made by some of us also. Hopefully the Newcastle match will go in our favour?

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 25 Nov 20 11.33am

Excuses
If the manager is not happy, make changes like Murionho would make.
The manager is in charge

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Our inability to rescue something from the game came down to a lack of quality and tired looking looking players rather than any tactics. The squad's a ticking time bomb and has been for a while.

I nearly fell off my chair when Townsend referred to breaking into the top ten.

The centre-backs should accept a fair bit of responsibility for the first half and Roy, not for the first time this season, bemoaned a lack of willingness / quality to find a forward pass generally.

The comments that the spine of the team didn't really turn up (or just weren't good enough) are true.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 25 Nov 20 11.34am

?
You flatter a poor Burnley side


Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I didn't think we were that bad. You have to accept that adapting to life without Zaha would take time. But no reason we couldn't.

The main thing for me was that Clyne looked very decent on the ball and okay without it.

Townsend was abject. He did one pass that was so awful he held his hand up in apology for 20 seconds.

Burnley were always going to be bang up for last night and so it proved. When they have their first choice defence fully match fit, they are without question a tough nut to crack.

And so it proved.

Edited by A1969Eagle (25 Nov 2020 11.34am)

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 25 Nov 20 11.36am

Truley accepetd

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Finally, someone who properly understands poor tactics and how those decisions influence tight matches.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 25 Nov 20 11.38am

Ayew does not play well with Batys when in same team, review two seasons ago. Ayew became the "Bit Man" while Batsy excelled!!


Originally posted by ex hibitionist

we didn't look too bad until we got to the final third then we didn't quite click, poor choices, over-hit passes etc Ayew was unusually poor, Andros was appalling, he's OK but is quite predictable as an out and out winger, he'd be better as a wing back but we don't play that way, I've been a bit anti-McArthur not out of opinionatedness, I just think he belongs in the championship now helping a team like Sheffield Wednesday or Birmingham, very little attacking threat and gave the ball away at crucial times. It's no disgrace to lose at Burnley, they do what they do very well, and we probably deserved a point, but Pope is a bit good. I hope we can get safe asap and go for a cup run otherwise it will be as boring a season as the last one. Contracts are up in the summer so I'm looking forward to a shake up, I think we need a new midfield, keep Reidewald all the others can foxtrot oscar - we are crying out for what Loftus Cheek gave us a couple of seasons back, mind you we played through the park quite well yesterday, but Burnley shut us out when we got close extremely well.

 

Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley v Palace Match thread