You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City v Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Manchester City v Palace Match Thread


Page 16 of 18 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 18 Jan 21 1.51pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

This game was proof that a team full of "elderly statesmen" is not enough to keep us in PL. And Ward, MacArthur, Cahill, McCarty, Ayew is not getting younger. Please, please start introducing some younger players to the team - this dross will not carry us much longer.
Still, if we can win 4 of the last 19 games we ought to stay up. but my dearest these Hodgson tactics make you little to be proud of.
And as someone pointed out -most of the City goals were due to simple mistakes on our part. What was Townsend thinking when he just let Gundogan in for the second, MacArthurs cross that was picked up for the first, and Luka gave away a corner after his own passing mistake? Not to mention McCarty and that stupid push for the 4th?

Spot on. We were our own undoing yesterday. First goal Ward made a mistake then corrected it for a corner, Townsend was trying to trap a high ball just outside the box and made a hash for 2nd, 3rd lost possession in our own third after trying to play out from defence resulting in corner, 4th poor tackle right on box for a dangerous free kick. These were the errors shown just on the highlights of the goals. Unfortunately you cannot get away with these type of defensive errors for 90 mins against a quality attacking team. Some of these may of been attributable to age of the squad or just basic technique, perhaps a bit of both.

Edited by Booted Eagle (18 Jan 2021 1.54pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

slubglurge Flag welling 18 Jan 21 2.33pm

What bothers me is City could have played without a keeper and would still have won

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 18 Jan 21 2.36pm

Forget this game - everything was against us and we were 20-1 to win this game before the kick off. Why because Man C were bang in form are use to playing 2 games a week and we had less rest and are not use to playing 2 games in a week. We have rested Zaha Benteke and Kayoute and will be ready for the winnable games we have coming up. It would have been foolish to run ourselves into the ground get players suspended / injured in a game even if we were at our best we would likely lose. Next time we play them at home we might they may have played away in Europe in the week and we have a few extra days to prepare and we will give them a game.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 18 Jan 21 2.52pm

Originally posted by Daddyorc

Half way through the fixtures:

"Big 6 clubs": Lost 3 badly (Liverpool, MC, Chelsea), tied 2 (Arsenal, Spurs), won 1 (MU)

Next Level (5): Lost 2 (Everton, Wolves), tied 2 (Leicester, West Ham), Won 1 (Southampton)

The rest (8 ): Won 4 (Leeds, West Brom, Fulham, Sheffield United), tied 1 (Brighton), Lost 3 (Burnley, Aston Villa, Newcastle)

What this shows is we took most of our points (13 of a possible 24) from the bottom 8, which is good. Those are the teams we have to beat to survive. The next level teams we did okay against (5 of 15). The top level we were okay (5 of 18 ).

We probably need about 12-14 more points to survive. Of course if we get another 23 we would likely finish around 12-14 place.

Edited by Daddyorc (18 Jan 2021 12.56pm)

I know we’ll get enough points against teams down our end, I just don’t like to see us so badly outclassed and un-interested against sides that we’ve blooded the nose of in the past. I want to see us competitive in every game, okay we’ll still lose our fair share, but we look awful sometimes now and after 8 years it feels like we should be so much better and if we carry on the way we’re going the lack of attacking play, goals and with more teams outclassing us its going to catch up with us

Edited by monkey (18 Jan 2021 2.58pm)

 

Den1923 Flag 18 Jan 21 3.01pm

Originally posted by viveasheagle

Forget this game - everything was against us and we were 20-1 to win this game before the kick off. Why because Man C were bang in form are use to playing 2 games a week and we had less rest and are not use to playing 2 games in a week. We have rested Zaha Benteke and Kayoute and will be ready for the winnable games we have coming up. It would have been foolish to run ourselves into the ground get players suspended / injured in a game even if we were at our best we would likely lose. Next time we play them at home we might they may have played away in Europe in the week and we have a few extra days to prepare and we will give them a game.

I want to forget the game but it is difficult to understand how all players including subs performed so badly when even WBA held them 1-1 at the Etihad. Their passing of the ball last night was some of the worst I have ever seen you would think for the wages they earn they would at least try to make a game of it even if the odds were stacked against them. They all should donate their salaries for last night to the NHS!

 

Den1923 Flag 18 Jan 21 3.07pm

Originally posted by kev64

We had Tekkers and Batts 2 Belgium internationals although not very good ones. Jimmy Mac started again why not JR and give him a break. Roy threw in the towel before leaving London, that’s the issue. If we only want to complete in the games he think we may win then what’s the point ???

Sorry they are all highly paid professionals and should at least perform come what may! as for Tekkers and Batts they are both players who have I'm afraid not achieved the PL standards for strikers for sometime now and Tekkers is only here because Liverpool did not want him and likewise Chelsea do not want Batts.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 18 Jan 21 5.41pm

I totally get the points being made around top teams being generally beyond our reach. Also that we should scratch together enough points this season to survive.....just.

BUT WHAT ABOUT THE NEGATIVE WAY WE PLAY!

It’s dour to watch and I think the dogged insistence on repeatedly doing the same things (regardless of them being totally ineffective) is Roy main failure. It’s his stubborn refusal to alter to a clearly failing game plan that frustrates me.

I don’t mind losing (let’s face it we all got used to it over the years) but we’ve got to show something, some intent, some purpose in defeat.
Going into these games hoping to keep the goals against down and viewing a 1-0 defeat as the some sort of comfort/ objective- tells us everything we need to know.

Roy is an absolute gentleman and I am grateful for what he has done for the club, but his skills would be better deployed in some other capacity at the club - preferably supporting a new manager with a more positive approach.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Jan 21 5.46pm

At the end of the day, the game went as I had imagined with us being on the back foot for the entirety and creating nothing at all.We had 2 shots and 0 on target.

I predicted it was going to be a "Hard watch" and at one stage I turned to 'Millionaire' in disgust at what I was witnessing before my very eyes. Gave 'Dancing on ice' a wide berth!

Edited by Willo (18 Jan 2021 5.47pm)

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 18 Jan 21 6.33pm

Originally posted by Elphers40

I totally get the points being made around top teams being generally beyond our reach. Also that we should scratch together enough points this season to survive.....just.

BUT WHAT ABOUT THE NEGATIVE WAY WE PLAY!

It’s dour to watch and I think the dogged insistence on repeatedly doing the same things (regardless of them being totally ineffective) is Roy main failure. It’s his stubborn refusal to alter to a clearly failing game plan that frustrates me.

I don’t mind losing (let’s face it we all got used to it over the years) but we’ve got to show something, some intent, some purpose in defeat.
Going into these games hoping to keep the goals against down and viewing a 1-0 defeat as the some sort of comfort/ objective- tells us everything we need to know.

Roy is an absolute gentleman and I am grateful for what he has done for the club, but his skills would be better deployed in some other capacity at the club - preferably supporting a new manager with a more positive approach.

Exactly this.
We all know we’re going to struggle against the top sides sometimes, but these days it feels like Roy’s negativity has the effect on the team of throwing the towel in now before we even start. I too love Roy, he’s done us proud, but it’s too one dimensional now and no plan b. Also let’s face it, we’re not that good at Roy’s main strength anymore, which is keeping the ball out of the net.

Edited by monkey (18 Jan 2021 6.35pm)

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 18 Jan 21 7.16pm

I can put up with a lot of the anti-football, what I can't tolerate is when we did attack last night it was with zero conviction, first 20 minutes was better, previously we've played very tight but when we counter we have tried to create an opportunity, or just gain territorial advantage, give our defenders a break whatever, but we were almost wilfully impotent last night, and that's why this fence-sitter thinks Roy and his boys deserve all the flak they are getting for that 'performance'.


 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Jan 21 7.51pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

What bothers me is City could have played without a keeper and would still have won

We're still playing but haven't had any shots yet.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 18 Jan 21 10.02pm

We played a seriously classy and in form City and rested two of our up front three that had given Arsenal a lot of problems on Thursday. There weren’t many complaints about that performance, and the way they took Newcastle apart tonight puts it all in perspective

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 18 Jan 21 10.27pm

I didn’t think we played too badly in the first half but once the second goal goes in it becomes a training game for them and damage limitation for us with the Liverpool game fresh in the memory.

City’s squad cost £800mil and ours £150mil with significant proportion of that spent in 16/17.

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 18 Jan 21 10.38pm

A lot of people on here with short memories and feel the need to justify s*** football.
We beat man u this season because we had a go (Ok no zaha this time ) but like the commentators said about our record in manchester has recently been very good.... Townsends goal against them should have been goal of the season for eg.

So I dont buy all this " they are too big fish for us to fry etc" We have just bottled it as a club !!

COYP

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 18 Jan 21 10.46pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

I didn’t think we played too badly in the first half but once the second goal goes in it becomes a training game for them and damage limitation for us with the Liverpool game fresh in the memory.

City’s squad cost £800mil and ours £150mil with significant proportion of that spent in 16/17.

that is all true, but Ayew was trying to do the Benteke role and doing it very badly - Benteke is better in the Benteke role, so why play Ayew if you want a Benteke-type job done? The link up play between Eze, Ayew and Townsend was non-existent, early on it opened up for us and we were a bit tentative, later in the game we were just as tentative going in their half never mind their penalty area, and it wan't a Pulis-like clever surrender of possession, it was giving the ball away due to going nowhere in midfield. There were even times when going forward was the safe option, but they weren't 'on it'. You don't keep the score down by surrendering the ball due to lack of bottle/belief - that's why the gripes are justified imho.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 18 Jan 21 11.02pm

Originally posted by eagle@ tn34

A lot of people on here with short memories and feel the need to justify s*** football.
We beat man u this season because we had a go (Ok no zaha this time ) but like the commentators said about our record in manchester has recently been very good.... Townsends goal against them should have been goal of the season for eg.

So I dont buy all this " they are too big fish for us to fry etc" We have just bottled it as a club !!

COYP


I have to agree. For me it was what I will call 'the Wilf Syndrome' namely that our record when he isn't playing is so poor that we are beaten psychologically before we even start when he isn't playing. We saw that at Anfield during the post-lockdown match. As soon as Wilf had to go off injured, heads went down and the team was resigned to defeat and played appallingly. I sensed the same yesterday, especially in the second half, The contrast with the performance against Arsenal is massive, At the Emirates we believed we could get a result. Yes we worked hard for it but there was always the hope that Wilf might do a bit of magic that might win us the game.

The Wilfless games against Burnley and Newcastle saw two disappointing defeats. Whilst Wilf doesn't always perform well when he plays (I thought him pretty mediocre against Arsenal, for example) his presence in the side seems to give the other players more belief and confidence and we generally play better as a result.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 18 Jan 21 11.20pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

that is all true, but Ayew was trying to do the Benteke role and doing it very badly - Benteke is better in the Benteke role, so why play Ayew if you want a Benteke-type job done? The link up play between Eze, Ayew and Townsend was non-existent, early on it opened up for us and we were a bit tentative, later in the game we were just as tentative going in their half never mind their penalty area, and it wan't a Pulis-like clever surrender of possession, it was giving the ball away due to going nowhere in midfield. There were even times when going forward was the safe option, but they weren't 'on it'. You don't keep the score down by surrendering the ball due to lack of bottle/belief - that's why the gripes are justified imho.

We’ll have to agree to disagree on Benteke and every time I see his name mentioned to justify people’s narrative about the manager it just undermines their argument IMO. He’s got the touch of a rapist, continually loses the ball, a feeble shot and joke goal scoring record.

Ayew on the other hand scored more goals last season than Benteke has managed in three, works harder for the team and is better at retaining the ball. However, we’ve not seen much of that this season and I’d concede that choosing between him and Benteke at present is akin to choosing which bollock to have cut off

Ultimately Benteke probably suits the way set up best and offers height from set pieces which, with hindsight, may have helped last night but arguments either way are tenuous.

The lack of link up between the three players is down to quality, age and energy IMO even Eze is guilty of giving the ball up easily and the first two goals actually came from us trying to overplay in our half.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (18 Jan 2021 11.34pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 18 Jan 21 11.32pm

Originally posted by doombear


I have to agree. For me it was what I will call 'the Wilf Syndrome' namely that our record when he isn't playing is so poor that we are beaten psychologically before we even start when he isn't playing. We saw that at Anfield during the post-lockdown match. As soon as Wilf had to go off injured, heads went down and the team was resigned to defeat and played appallingly. I sensed the same yesterday, especially in the second half, The contrast with the performance against Arsenal is massive, At the Emirates we believed we could get a result. Yes we worked hard for it but there was always the hope that Wilf might do a bit of magic that might win us the game.

The Wilfless games against Burnley and Newcastle saw two disappointing defeats. Whilst Wilf doesn't always perform well when he plays (I thought him pretty mediocre against Arsenal, for example) his presence in the side seems to give the other players more belief and confidence and we generally play better as a result.

This is the reality. We’re a one man team lacking in attacking quality and legs. Eze obviously promising but that’s about it.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Jan 21 11.42pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

This is the reality. We’re a one man team lacking in attacking quality and legs. Eze obviously promising but that’s about it.

I concur with these sentiments.

Aged defenders who lack pace and as such we have to defend deep and cannot advance up the pitch.
Lacking in balance down the right hand side so the majority of our attacks are down the left.
Midfielders with no creativity at all.
A 'Target man' whose scoring record is abysmal and a 'Loan' striker whose is only noticed when he is flagged offside.
An old squad, lacking in pace,mobility,energy and creativity and Mr Hodgson has to try and get the best out of them.

 

Den1923 Flag 19 Jan 21 7.17am

Originally posted by Willo

I concur with these sentiments.

Aged defenders who lack pace and as such we have to defend deep and cannot advance up the pitch.
Lacking in balance down the right hand side so the majority of our attacks are down the left.
Midfielders with no creativity at all.
A 'Target man' whose scoring record is abysmal and a 'Loan' striker whose is only noticed when he is flagged offside.
An old squad, lacking in pace,mobility,energy and creativity and Mr Hodgson has to try and get the best out of them.

Excellent summary Willo,!

 

Page 16 of 18 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City v Palace Match Thread