You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs West Ham Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs West Ham Match Thread


Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
palace chick Flag South Croydon 26 Jan 21 10.02pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Whatever credentials or track record Roy might have it is not on display at the moment and has not been for some time now. We’re getting worse and worse with 1 win in what, 10 games now and that against a team vying for the worst season in history.

We’re going down at this rate

That’s my feeling as well I’m afraid to say

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 26 Jan 21 10.10pm

Originally posted by BM

If we go with Wilf and Eze wide the future is bright. Townsend has to be dropped now. Another feeble performance and please don’t give me the usual “puts in a shift” nonsense. Cahill can warm the bench too. Woeful tonight but as usual everyone will let him off. Our best 11 is: Guiata; Clyne, Tomkins, Sakho, Mitchell; Eze, Jairo, Jimmy, Wilf; Ayew, Benteke.
Tonight’s ratings: Guiata 6: Ward 6, Kouyate 6, Cahill 4, Mitchell 5; Townsend 3, Luka 5, Jimmy 6, Eze 6; Benteke 6, Wilf 6.

Kouyate a 6???? He was 100% responsible for the first goal. Look at it, Ward was on Antonio and peeled off for their left back, Fornals, as he should have. Kouyate has Antonio and just totally lets him run away from him and doesn't track him one bit. I was shouting at the TV saying "who is tracking him?!". You can't let Antonio be free in the penalty area. Then he gets the ball in open space, does (to his credit) make a nice blind cross and Mitchell, who is up against Soucek in about a 6 inch height difference can't put him off the header.

Kouyate was likely responsible for the 2nd goal too. He gets at best a 2 in my book!

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 26 Jan 21 10.15pm

wow you are generous with score.

Hes an average midfielder who watches the ball and has no positioning sense as a defender..
Roys pet.


Originally posted by Daddyorc

Kouyate a 6???? He was 100% responsible for the first goal. Look at it, Ward was on Antonio and peeled off for their left back, Fornals, as he should have. Kouyate has Antonio and just totally lets him run away from him and doesn't track him one bit. I was shouting at the TV saying "who is tracking him?!". You can't let Antonio be free in the penalty area. Then he gets the ball in open space, does (to his credit) make a nice blind cross and Mitchell, who is up against Soucek in about a 6 inch height difference can't put him off the header.

Kouyate was likely responsible for the 2nd goal too. He gets at best a 2 in my book!

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 26 Jan 21 10.19pm

Hang on re Roy

Dougie tried to bring young players for Roy to play for the future of our club, but Roy wants to play the oldest players possible..

look back at the demise of Stoke, they relied on aging players!! then it was too late and are now an average Champ team!!


Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

Whilst I agree Roy should be replaced at the end of the season he can only be part of the problem. The management must also take responsibility for leaving him with an ageing squad . You could see the effects of that tonight when the Spammers just had more energy to outrun our ageing players. The players themselves also bear responsibility for the poor performance their passing was very bad even worse than normal. So it is the collective that is the problem.
Roy must stay till the end of the season as he does at least know how to get them to win the odd match to enable us to survive this season. After that all hell can be let lose and a culling fest can ensue. COYP

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 26 Jan 21 10.23pm

OMG Chek
Galloping around makes a good midfielder for palace, you had to much to drink after that match.. Hes clueless!

Originally posted by EddieMac

Centre midfeld is where all our problems start week in and out, we get overrun overly week. For the rest of the season I would go back to 4-5-1 and shore up the middle of the park. Just play it safe and pick up the points to stay up.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 26 Jan 21 10.26pm

He was even more exposed tonight.

There was no Ray to help cover up the cracks.

A manager is supposed to managed, at no time did I see any response from Roy from the dug out.. did you?


Originally posted by Elphers40

Time for some fresh ideas is so long overdue it’s pathetic.

We do have some decent players- Roy is the problem.

Now come the string of BS excuses from Roy about how good they were and how he “can’t fault the effort of the players”. But we came up against an in form side!

I’d love someone to ask him:
1. Roy Why didn’t you react at half time and make changes?
2. Given the substitutions you did eventually make had a positive impact do you now regret leaving it until it was too late to effect the result?

I’m so fed up with this!

 

jeeagles Flag 26 Jan 21 10.31pm

Originally posted by Daddyorc

Once again you are pathetic. I don't agree with Roy on this, but making fun of someone's disability proves how unimaginative and childish you truly are.

I'm sow sowwy

Since when has a minor speech impediment been a disability. That's just downgrading disability. Snowflake.

Edited by jeeagles (26 Jan 2021 10.32pm)

 

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 26 Jan 21 10.33pm

Yet again wrong tactics and straitjacking the talent we have.
4-3-3 for me with Zaha, Eze and Batshuayi or Ayew given a free role in front of 3 strong midfielders. Drop Luka and play Riedewald, McCarthy and McCarthur.
Roy is strangling the life out of the team and needs to NOW!

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

BM Flag 26 Jan 21 10.35pm

Originally posted by Mojo87

Townsend was absolutely horrendous tonight. Lightweight and gives away the ball too cheaply.
Got to be 20 plus times that he was dispossessed tonight... When the stats come out, it would be a joke!

Same every week. Somehow gets away with it

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 Jan 21 10.42pm

As has been said or intimated, the score-line flattered us tonight.

Whilst we can moan at our defence for conceding and giving Antonio and others a hatful chances they should have taken, our two ageing CDMs were woeful - slow, dwelt on the ball, got dispossessed and were overrun by a more dynamic and numerically superior opposition midfield. Even Karen Carney recognized that and couldn't understand why Hodgson didn't do something about it half-time.

As for Benteke, after his assist for Wilf's goal he seemed to think his work was done for the night. Eze whips in a ball centre forwards thrive on and Tekkers can be seen slowly jogging into the penalty box. Big Sam you can have him tomorrow.

Whilst it was too little too late, I thought the last 15 mins with Wilf, Batshuayi, Eze and Ayew up front looked promising. It also helped that Jairo was on with more accurate passes than Luka.

With Wolves coming up on Saturday (the first of six games we really mustn't lose and from which we need at least 12 points) I'd go with Wilf, Eze, Ayew and (if available) Mateta (otherwise Batshuayi), bench Townsend, Benteke, Luka and McArthur (he needs a rest).

As for the defence, if Tomkins isn't fit then we have problems.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 26 Jan 21 10.57pm

Originally posted by Mojo87

Townsend was absolutely horrendous tonight. Lightweight and gives away the ball too cheaply.
Got to be 20 plus times that he was dispossessed tonight... When the stats come out, it would be a joke!

Townsend has been playing like that for some time. When Roy sits down to pick the team only he knows the reason why he gets in. It’s a mystery to everyone else.

 

Jaha Flag 26 Jan 21 11.20pm

I really do question why the hell batshayi hasn’t been given a chance this whole season. He looks more threatening than benteke and actually RUNS. Benteke. What the hell is toys problem picking the same players when there is a better alternative. Why jairo doesn’t start I don’t know. We are in trouble

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 26 Jan 21 11.26pm

Originally posted by Jaha

I really do question why the hell batshayi hasn’t been given a chance this whole season. He looks more threatening than benteke and actually RUNS. Benteke. What the hell is toys problem picking the same players when there is a better alternative. Why jairo doesn’t start I don’t know. We are in trouble

He was made a scapegoat by many for the defeat away to Burnley along with Ayew at which point there was a groundswell for the much misunderstood donkey Benteke to be made the focus of our attack.

 

AuntyAnne70 Flag Tunbridge WElls 26 Jan 21 11.29pm

As always when one loses, the players that aren't in the team look good.

The only problem is that when those two specifically have played this season, neither pulled up any trees.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 27 Jan 21 5.18am

Batman will get the odd goal, but he is simply not up to it as a PL player. Running around, no awareness of offside etc.
Please return to sender!

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 27 Jan 21 6.47am

In my book, taking luck out of the result, that game is a 2-9 West Ham. We lucked out.

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 27 Jan 21 6.51am

Originally posted by Jaha

I really do question why the hell batshayi hasn’t been given a chance this whole season. He looks more threatening than benteke and actually RUNS. Benteke. What the hell is toys problem picking the same players when there is a better alternative. Why jairo doesn’t start I don’t know. We are in trouble

Bats is given zero chance and Roy is playing Tekkers week in week out in sons vain hope of him finding form to justify giving him another contract.

Roy, Tekkers both should go come June

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Jan 21 9.57am

Well, that was a horrible watch. The score did not reflect the game. Fair play to West Ham, in form and well set up by Moyes who has weeded out the expensive flops.

On our side I think there are problems in many areas but specifically down the middle. Up top Benteke just doesn't hold the ball up well enough for a player of his size. In the middle, Luka and MacArthur are consistently overrun. That exposes a central defence that rarely has the same two players alongside one another. And whatever the combination, all are injury prone and past their best.

Unforced errors and substandard passing has increasingly crept into our game. West Ham pressed effectively last night but there were too many occasions where our players gave the ball away cheaply.

I think the rest of the season is going to be grim. I still think and I certainly hope that there are three worst teams than us.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

palace chick Flag South Croydon 27 Jan 21 10.29am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well, that was a horrible watch. The score did not reflect the game. Fair play to West Ham, in form and well set up by Moyes who has weeded out the expensive flops.

On our side I think there are problems in many areas but specifically down the middle. Up top Benteke just doesn't hold the ball up well enough for a player of his size. In the middle, Luka and MacArthur are consistently overrun. That exposes a central defence that rarely has the same two players alongside one another. And whatever the combination, all are injury prone and past their best.

Unforced errors and substandard passing has increasingly crept into our game. West Ham pressed effectively last night but there were too many occasions where our players gave the ball away cheaply.

I think the rest of the season is going to be grim. I still think and I certainly hope that there are three worst teams than us.

You and probably the majority of Palace fans are of the same thoughts. Annoyingly most of us see the main problem as the central midfield two that could be helped greatly by going back to a central midfield three. At least that would help the ever changing back four. It would go back to a lesser threat up front which doesn’t seem to get results with this ageing team anyway. We can see it, why can’t Hodgson?

 

Numbers Man Flag Tulse Hill 27 Jan 21 10.58am

There are problems in all areas of the team. Cahill was badly at fault on the first goal he was too far away from the play on the right and left a gap for Antonio to run into. Both centre backs were too blame for the second. Cahill looks out of form and has been poor on his return from injury. Where is Tomkins his our best centre back?

McArthur is excellent in midfield and covers every blade of grass but Milivojevic is not contributing much. We need a ball player who can hold the ball like Cabaye who has not been replaced.

Beneteke improvement has fizzled out and shouldn’t start. Wilf is effective in the centre but better on the wing. Eze could be given central striker role as a poacher with Bats providing the pace with Wilf. I like Ayew because he works hard but he is not quick or good enough as a striker and the wing is not his position. Townsend should be able to cut it but he was poor last night. We’re missing Schlupp who is better on the wing.

 

Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs West Ham Match Thread