This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, the west aren't interested in negotiations so what will be will be. All the actors here are seemingly only interested in escalation, politically, economically and militarily. If we are all going to get fried there's nothing anyone can do about it. It's just unfortunate that no one gets to be held to account. The west aren't, and won't be, doing any negotiations. They aren't directly involved. No-one though is remotely interested in escalation. That's a ridiculous idea. An excuse not to allow Ukraine to defend itself. What diplomatic efforts are being made behind the scenes is an unknown, but they will be happening for sure. In the meantime, we need to show resolve and make sure that Putin never tries this again. We know it's costly, but the cost of not doing it is greater.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The west aren't, and won't be, doing any negotiations. They aren't directly involved. No-one though is remotely interested in escalation. That's a ridiculous idea. An excuse not to allow Ukraine to defend itself. What diplomatic efforts are being made behind the scenes is an unknown, but they will be happening for sure. In the meantime, we need to show resolve and make sure that Putin never tries this again. We know it's costly, but the cost of not doing it is greater. This take is so incredibly unlikely that only a hatchling new to the world could believe it. Yeah....you know those guys who have given nearly sixty billion to continue your war.....yeah, well you know they have no influence on what happens next. By the way, you don't get to decide what represents escalation, that's the actors involved and I'm not hearing the same things you are. You can present your nonsense to the world all you like.....but I'm well aware that you're just trolling me....so desperate for attention that you dig up older posts just to get a rise. Can't you find anything more useful to do with your time old boy. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jun 2022 11.30pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by W12
Is your understanding that the BBC, CH4, Sky and the other mainstream news sources are generally truthful and accurate?
There's often less structure online, and so people tend to more easily go down hyper partisan rabbit hole routes due to their own biases and hang ups to the point where they can become far more indoctrinated than they realise. Emotional crack for the socially inept and mentally unwell. These types routinely do not recognise that this is even happening to them (as that would require a modicum of self awareness that would put the brakes on it to begin with). 'Opinion' led news from rabble rousers of the Tucker Carlson and Keith Olbermann type moulds diverge from news in a significantly negative way though, as they instead push heavily emotion led narratives to those suseptable to them who enjoy 'performative' politically polarised offerings rather than actual news (indeed Tucker Carlon has defended himself again slander with the legal position that he's not 'stating actual facts' about the topics he discusses and is instead engaging in 'exaggeration' and 'non-literal commentary' - which of course is true.) One eyed sensationalist 'commentator' led news is often derivative; a glossy version of the very same tripe people get on activist or basement dweller sites online. The opposite of having a genuine interest in nuance, people or current events. The best way to take in news is to do so from multiple sources, often of somewhat different perspectives, to form a patchwork of sorts. The main pitfall online is fear and hatred based echo chambers of left and right, that so heavily curate and skew information and events that they just function as comfort blankets for the mentally weak - dark dives built intentionally blotting out other realities and perspectives. The information is certainly out there and can be taken onboard in a fair way by the principled, but there is so little quality control that the mix of what people end up taking in instead sometimes over time leads them to places and ideas that range from unfortunate to dangerous. 'Alt media scholars' often scoffing at the mainstream, would have a point if they were not typically the most mentally out of it people you could ever interact with. Edited by BlueJay (05 Jun 2022 11.27am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
This take is so incredibly unlikely that only a hatchling new to the world could believe it. Yeah....you know those guys who have given nearly sixty billion to continue your war.....yeah, well you know they have no influence on what happens next. By the way, you don't get to decide what represents escalation, that's the actors involved and I'm not hearing the same things you are. You can present your nonsense to the world all you like.....but I'm well aware that you're just trolling me....so desperate for attention that you dig up older posts just to get a rise. Can't you find anything more useful to do with your time old boy. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jun 2022 11.30pm) Whilst I might answer more of your posts than those of other posters, I am not "trolling" you. You just post more than others, and on top of that, many of your posts demand answers due to the nature of their controversial content. As you frequently use personal insults, instead of reasoned arguments, you would be a fool not to anticipate a response. Some threads I ignore, as they are on subjects that don't interest me. Providing support to enable a country to defend itself does not equate to being in control of it. You want to present Ukraine as fighting a proxy war on behalf of the west, notably the USA. Whilst there certainly have been such wars in the past, this is not. You know that because of the attitude of the Ukrainians, who have been determined to resist. We can not negotiate for them. We can only make their negotiating position stronger or weaker. Of course, we also have a dog in the race. We don't want to see a revitalised aggressive Russia succeeding. We want to reassure those in the east of Europe that we have their back. Standing back and allowing Russia to take over Ukraine was the only other option. Half-baked tokenism was a waste of time. It was either total support, or nothing. We have been forced to accept that for the foreseeable future we cannot trust Russia, do business with her, or even have cultural exchanges with her. Russia must remain a pariah, and excluded from the world community of nations, until she commits to some basic standards of behaviour in ways that can be trusted. That won't happen unless and until the Russian people themselves decide to change the style of their leadership.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Standing back and allowing Russia to take over Ukraine was the only other option. Half-baked tokenism was a waste of time. It was either total support, or nothing. We have been forced to accept that for the foreseeable future we cannot trust Russia, do business with her, or even have cultural exchanges with her. Russia must remain a pariah, and excluded from the world community of nations, until she commits to some basic standards of behaviour in ways that can be trusted. That won't happen unless and until the Russian people themselves decide to change the style of their leadership. I thought the West stood back for far too long, watching a large Russian military build-up on the border without any diplomatic intervention. Lets not get too carried away. Russia still holds a lot of aces.
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Even mainstream media can latch onto false headlines, such as Hillsborough, etc, 'If you don't read the newspaper, you're uninformed. If you read the newspaper, you're mis-informed.'
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Even mainstream media can latch onto false headlines, such as Hillsborough, etc, Certainly, there can be skewed and polarised perspectives in mainstream news (see the contrast in MSNBC and Fox News statewide for instance) and as you say, learning 'how to read' is vitally important. Sinking into online echo chambers often goes hand in hand with not being able to do so though. A place where people have often already given in to check box identity based prejudices so more and more heavily lean into dark breadcrumbs trails, 'pop up' sites, 'communities', and pitifully one eyed echo chambers. There is simply no quality control and so emotionally revved up 'alt media scholars' can easily become more and more warped and 'out there' in perspective while simultaneously scoffing at the 'normies'. It's perfectly possible for the principled to gain insights online, but some just end up taking in massively filtered fringe 'sources' that nudge their own biases further and further due to fast tracked group polarision of concerning magnitude. For these types the online world is like a maladjusted adult version of 'Build Your Own Bear'. A comfort blanket for shut-ins and the socially inept. The real world impact? Damaging, zero contrition, 'politics over people' behaviour that leads to these them being managed and nagivated by those around them as much as cared for. Ironic that their own intolerance necessitates extreme tolerance in others. Edited by BlueJay (05 Jun 2022 2.05pm)
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I thought the West stood back for far too long, watching a large Russian military build-up on the border without any diplomatic intervention. Lets not get too carried away. Russia still holds a lot of aces. Certainly, a fair assessment of a difficult and developing situation. No-one really has all of the answers and it's not certain how things will pan out no matter the approach. 'Armchair commanders' always have all of the answers
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The situation at Severodonetsk is a good analogy in the use of propaganda in this war....well in all wars. We have contradicting stories coming from both sides on events there, who has done what and what the current state of battleground possession is. If you're looking for the truth of the matter you firstly have to accept a limit upon what is knowable. A willingness to judge the previous accuracy of a source amid how much they are willing to allow their bias to affect how they cover events...and then wait to see for ultimately what can't be lied about...which is who controls what on the ground. My post itself on here highlighted both Russias claims that Ukrainian nationalist troops were to blame, and Ukraines that this was one of several attacks by Russia in the area and on the monastery. This all sits firmly within the context that one country is staging a massive bombing and invasion campaign on another. With a stated denial of and wish to by force cleanse Ukraine of its Ukranian identity from Putin downward. That would seem to be somewhat important to the big picture.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
-
Edited by BlueJay (05 Jun 2022 3.53pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I thought the West stood back for far too long, watching a large Russian military build-up on the border without any diplomatic intervention. Lets not get too carried away. Russia still holds a lot of aces. I don't think we know whether there was any diplomatic intervention, as not all of it gets publicly known. Indeed, I would be very surprised if there wasn't any. Our major error was allowing ourselves to become reliant on Russian energy supplies. That was an epic strategic mistake and a lesson learned. I have no doubt Russian commodities will continue to find a way into the market, but the west turning their back on direct trade, and pressurising others to do the same, will take a toll. It will take time, possibly a long time, and I do not expect to see our door opening again to Russia in my lifetime, but cutting the Russian's off from the west will work. Ensuring we do this in a way that prevents famine in vulnerable countries is a challenge that needs to be faced. We must do this together, in a co-ordinated programme. Those who dismiss the importance of the UN and the WEF in facing up to such global challenges need to think again.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don't think we know whether there was any diplomatic intervention, as not all of it gets publicly known. Indeed, I would be very surprised if there wasn't any. Our major error was allowing ourselves to become reliant on Russian energy supplies. That was an epic strategic mistake and a lesson learned. I have no doubt Russian commodities will continue to find a way into the market, but the west turning their back on direct trade, and pressurising others to do the same, will take a toll. It will take time, possibly a long time, and I do not expect to see our door opening again to Russia in my lifetime, but cutting the Russian's off from the west will work. Ensuring we do this in a way that prevents famine in vulnerable countries is a challenge that needs to be faced. We must do this together, in a co-ordinated programme. Those who dismiss the importance of the UN and the WEF in facing up to such global challenges need to think again. The UN has been hijacked by the very regimes it should be tackling. Guess who is now chair on the UN Commission for Disarmament? North Korea Check out which countries are on the Humanitarian Committee.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The UN has been hijacked by the very regimes it should be tackling. Guess who is now chair on the UN Commission for Disarmament? North Korea Check out which countries are on the Humanitarian Committee. Exactly, the UN is a useless waste of money.
|
|
| W12 05 Jun 22 9.13pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
There's often less structure online, and so people tend to more easily go down hyper partisan rabbit hole routes due to their own biases and hang ups to the point where they can become far more indoctrinated than they realise. Emotional crack for the socially inept and mentally unwell. These types routinely do not recognise that this is even happening to them (as that would require a modicum of self awareness that would put the brakes on it to begin with). 'Opinion' led news from rabble rousers of the Tucker Carlson and Keith Olbermann type moulds diverge from news in a significantly negative way though, as they instead push heavily emotion led narratives to those suseptable to them who enjoy 'performative' politically polarised offerings rather than actual news (indeed Tucker Carlon has defended himself again slander with the legal position that he's not 'stating actual facts' about the topics he discusses and is instead engaging in 'exaggeration' and 'non-literal commentary' - which of course is true.) One eyed sensationalist 'commentator' led news is often derivative; a glossy version of the very same tripe people get on activist or basement dweller sites online. The opposite of having a genuine interest in nuance, people or current events. The best way to take in news is to do so from multiple sources, often of somewhat different perspectives, to form a patchwork of sorts. The main pitfall online is fear and hatred based echo chambers of left and right, that so heavily curate and skew information and events that they just function as comfort blankets for the mentally weak - dark dives built intentionally blotting out other realities and perspectives. The information is certainly out there and can be taken onboard in a fair way by the principled, but there is so little quality control that the mix of what people end up taking in instead sometimes over time leads them to places and ideas that range from unfortunate to dangerous. 'Alt media scholars' often scoffing at the mainstream, would have a point if they were not typically the most mentally out of it people you could ever interact with. Edited by BlueJay (05 Jun 2022 11.27am) I’m off here for a while but you will be found to be excusing the inexcusable
|
|
|
Originally posted by W12
I’m off here for a while but you will be found to be excusing the inexcusable
Mainstream media outlets pushing footage from a computer game as 'proof' that a mystery Ukranian pilot was shooting down Russian jets for fun. An utter fallacy. Snake Island. Reporting the deaths of 13 Ukrainian sailors, showing footage of Zelensky promising revenge, proclaiming how they would all have state funerals. And ignoring, on the same night, those self-same 13 sailors being interviewed by Russian TV, utterly perplexed as to why their funerals were being planned by their own President when they had, as per accepted norms, simply surrendered when surrounded by far superior forces. No shame in that. Standing orders no doubt. And so on and on. Whatever people might think about this conflict, or what side they do/do not support, the notion of Western MSM being in anyway impartial, as they proudly proclaim themselves to be, has been kicked into touch. And to be fair, they don't even try and pretend anymore.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.