You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?
November 22 2026 4.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?


Page 165 of 280 < 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 >
Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jun 22 12.32am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Ukraine corrupt but less corrupt than Russia shock!

[Link]

I believe Zelensky is a spur for this war as he is credible and may have made Ukraine a more palatable friend to the west.

I'd say roughly the same.

If I'm critical of Zelensky I'll suddenly be accused of being pro Russian whereas I want to be objective....Russia is well known for corruption at all levels, I'll say that.

I must admit to being a bit morbidly obsessed with this war....obviously because it affects us all....not that any of what we think matters a scoopy.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jun 22 12.39am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

On what do you base this assertion? There are some very corrupt countries, where control is in the hands of mob gangs and oligarchs and the law means nothing, unless you pay the judge. I have lived in one, and Russia itself is another. I have no idea whether there is a scale of corruption which ranks countries, but obviously you must have access to one, or you could not make that statement. Please share.

Notwithstanding whether it's true, or not, it's a red herring anyway. Russia invaded Ukraine on a pretext to regain control over territory it lost when the USSR failed. That's the only important issue to keep in focus. Everything else is illogical and inappropriate apologetics.


I've based that assertion on a couple of months of looking into this stuff.

There you go again asking me to do research for you. I can't remember all the sodding sites I've looked at. Look yourself it's not hard to find out about corruption levels in different countries.

It's all a joke with you. I had to painfully prove to you....despite your constant denials.....that Russia had been promised that Nato wouldn't expand east back in the ninties....and even though the documents are published and freely available you kept up your denials.....waste of time.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 12 Jun 22 1.31am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Ukraine corrupt but less corrupt than Russia shock!

[Link]

I believe Zelensky is a spur for this war as he is credible and may have made Ukraine a more palatable friend to the west.

You know it’s the wee hours of a weekend morning when your eyes can barely stay open and you reread a N&P post trying to work out the context for the ‘Tottenham Fan’ euphemism before the second reread tells you you’re a mile wide of the goal.

Amongst all the heated debate and my own stance on such things I have nothing more than a desire to wish that each individual has had a lovely weekend thus far and that continues tomorrow.

Goodnight and… good luck!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 12 Jun 22 7.13am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I'd say roughly the same.

If I'm critical of Zelensky I'll suddenly be accused of being pro Russian whereas I want to be objective....Russia is well known for corruption at all levels, I'll say that.

I must admit to being a bit morbidly obsessed with this war....obviously because it affects us all....not that any of what we think matters a scoopy.

Yet you asked me 'Why does it matter to you so much?'!

 

BlueJay Flag UK 12 Jun 22 11.24am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Yet you asked me 'Why does it matter to you so much?'!

Oh it's fine for something to matter to you, and for that to be expressed in any way from strident to politically and morally third rate, as long as it matters in the exact same way that it does to him.


Edited by BlueJay (12 Jun 2022 12.09pm)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 12 Jun 22 11.54am

Ukrainians flock to beaches in and soak up the sun on the banks of the Dnieper.. - [Link]

Clearly the country and potentially Kyiv are still in jeopardy, but it pays to consider that without help from the West these scenes would not be happening. The Capital would either be levelled or under the control of an oppressive Russian invader with the stated aim of snuffing out Ukranian identity and objection to Russian aggression.

Western help has bought time and focused Russian attention elsewhere, leaving room and time to still negotiate a peace deal - and limiting gains due to the military limitations on a wider operation. If the whole country had been besieged (effectively the preference of some) I fail to see how that wouldn't come with its own set of significant problems too. There are no easy answers or set in stone outcomes where multiple parties have their own long term plans and motivations.


Edited by BlueJay (12 Jun 2022 11.57am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 12 Jun 22 12.03pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


I've based that assertion on a couple of months of looking into this stuff.

There you go again asking me to do research for you. I can't remember all the sodding sites I've looked at. Look yourself it's not hard to find out about corruption levels in different countries.

It's all a joke with you. I had to painfully prove to you....despite your constant denials.....that Russia had been promised that Nato wouldn't expand east back in the ninties....and even though the documents are published and freely available you kept up your denials.....waste of time.

I am not asking you to do any research for me. You are claiming to have already done it. All I am asking is for you to share it. In case your memory is failing, what you said was :-

"The Ukraine before even 2014 was among the most corrupt countries in the world"

Which demands not just being obsessed with Ukraine, but either examining in detail every other country in the world, or having access to data which does.

You made claims about Nato denials. Claims that only a brief amount of research easily debunked. Not that that stops you thinking that you "proved" your biased opinion just because it happens to be what you want to be true. At best, there were conflicting statements made at the time, possibility as a deliberate tactic to sow confusion.

I have no doubt Ukraine had its problems before 2014. As an ex Soviet territory, it would be surprising if it had achieved western standards of democracy and accountability by then. Those problems were one of the reasons Nato membership wasn't possible.

Ukraine was work in progress. Work that Putin clearly could not tolerate being successful on his western flank and threatening Russia's own eastern provinces.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 12 Jun 22 1.15pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I am not asking you to do any research for me. You are claiming to have already done it. All I am asking is for you to share it. In case your memory is failing, what you said was :-

"The Ukraine before even 2014 was among the most corrupt countries in the world"

Which demands not just being obsessed with Ukraine, but either examining in detail every other country in the world, or having access to data which does.

You made claims about Nato denials. Claims that only a brief amount of research easily debunked. Not that that stops you thinking that you "proved" your biased opinion just because it happens to be what you want to be true. At best, there were conflicting statements made at the time, possibility as a deliberate tactic to sow confusion.

I have no doubt Ukraine had its problems before 2014. As an ex Soviet territory, it would be surprising if it had achieved western standards of democracy and accountability by then. Those problems were one of the reasons Nato membership wasn't possible.

Ukraine was work in progress. Work that Putin clearly could not tolerate being successful on his western flank and threatening Russia's own eastern provinces.

Corruption is a fact of life I'm afraid, but I don't see that the Ukraine stood out like that.

Try the UK, in particular the City of London, where the world's dirty money gets cleared up, or should I say, re-cycled.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jun 22 1.41pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I am not asking you to do any research for me. You are claiming to have already done it. All I am asking is for you to share it. In case your memory is failing, what you said was :-

"The Ukraine before even 2014 was among the most corrupt countries in the world"

Which demands not just being obsessed with Ukraine, but either examining in detail every other country in the world, or having access to data which does.

You made claims about Nato denials. Claims that only a brief amount of research easily debunked. Not that that stops you thinking that you "proved" your biased opinion just because it happens to be what you want to be true. At best, there were conflicting statements made at the time, possibility as a deliberate tactic to sow confusion.

I have no doubt Ukraine had its problems before 2014. As an ex Soviet territory, it would be surprising if it had achieved western standards of democracy and accountability by then. Those problems were one of the reasons Nato membership wasn't possible.

Ukraine was work in progress. Work that Putin clearly could not tolerate being successful on his western flank and threatening Russia's own eastern provinces.

You are a liar.

Anyone who followed our conversations mentioned and went to the links knows it and I can't be bothered wasting time on you.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jun 22 1.46pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Yet you asked me 'Why does it matter to you so much?'!

I asked you why what W12 thinks matters so much to you.

I don't spend time criticising people for whether they support side A or side B. The only people who bother me are deliberate liars, hypocrites and those willing to distort the truth out of maliciousness.

Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jun 2022 2.09pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 12 Jun 22 3.14pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You are a liar.

Anyone who followed our conversations mentioned and went to the links knows it and I can't be bothered wasting time on you.

Anyone who dismisses things in that way, through the use of ad hominems, destroys their argument completely. Unfortunately, it's your standard response when cornered, which results in many of your opinions being shown as baseless, recycled nonsense gleaned from dubious corners of the internet.

If you have evidence to support your assertion that Ukraine prior to 2014 was among the most corrupt countries, then it would benefit everyone to see it, and decide how valid it is.

As to the other claim, about Nato promising Russia not to expand, it is very easy to debunk it. No need to retrace past conversations. Just read these:-

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Edited by Wisbech Eagle (12 Jun 2022 3.23pm)

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jun 22 3.42pm

The dishonesty here is very apparent.

It lies at the heart of why these wars and lots of other conflicts happen. The type of people making these decisions are why young men ultimately end up dying in completely avoidable wars.

If you had honest men on both sides the world would be so much better.

Ok, even the journalist commentary links this guy puts on here can't really hide what happened....though the first two try harder than the last one. The articles are written..in most cases with heavy spin towards the Nato position but they can't hide what is ultimately documented in truth.

Here is a link that talks about the documents with links to them held in the Washington library that evidence what was said in minutes and why the Russians are correct when they say that assurances were given and that this grievance has some validity.

[Link]

Or you could just ignore all that and go with what ex-marketing managers are happy to sell you about the past.

Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jun 2022 3.43pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 12 Jun 22 4.33pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The dishonesty here is very apparent.

It lies at the heart of why these wars and lots of other conflicts happen. The type of people making these decisions are why young men ultimately end up dying in completely avoidable wars.

If you had honest men on both sides the world would be so much better.

Ok, even the journalist commentary links this guy puts on here can't really hide what happened....though the first two try harder than the last one. The articles are written..in most cases with heavy spin towards the Nato position but they can't hide what is ultimately documented in truth.

Here is a link that talks about the documents with links to them held in the Washington library that evidence what was said in minutes and why the Russians are correct when they say that assurances were given and that this grievance has some validity.

[Link]

Or you could just ignore all that and go with what ex-marketing managers are happy to sell you about the past.

Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jun 2022 3.43pm)

You are right. It is very apparent. It all comes from you.

Everything in the link you provided is dealt with, and debunked, in the articles I linked to. Semi-private conversations, always capable of misinterpretation, or multiple interpretation, don't amount to more than a puff of smoke. Minuting them for historians may make for interesting reading, but are nothing more than that.

Formal, legal agreements, hammered out by specialist negotiators, are the only things that matter. They don't exist. You don't make legal agreements over a dinner.

No promises were given. Those who say otherwise, whether they are Putin or posters on the Hol, are liars.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jun 22 5.02pm

I'm a liar?

No one who knows me would say that.

I'm happy for the evidence to speak for itself. All you can point towards are journalistic commentary and the spin of representatives of Nato and its establishment.

I can point to the historical minutes and documents over the period.

I've made my judgement on this issue based upon on the commitments which are made and then broken afterwards. You can make your judgement upon your 'interpretation' of what a commitment is or isn't.

You can think the west can act like a used car salesman and that's good enough to gain an advantage and I don't.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 12 Jun 22 7.23pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I'm a liar?

No one who knows me would say that.

I'm happy for the evidence to speak for itself. All you can point towards are journalistic commentary and the spin of representatives of Nato and its establishment.

I can point to the historical minutes and documents over the period.

I've made my judgement on this issue based upon on the commitments which are made and then broken afterwards. You can make your judgement upon your 'interpretation' of what a commitment is or isn't.

You can think the west can act like a used car salesman and that's good enough to gain an advantage and I don't.

That you believe all your opinions are the truth doesn't mean you don't lie. All it means is you are self-righteous. Plenty of people who know your on-line persona would recognise that in you.

Just take a look at the known facts. Firstly, no-one but Nato speaks for Nato. That James Baker and other western leaders made statements and exchanged memos during the period of German re-unification doesn't make policy, nor set things in stone. The situation was still developing. The Russian Federation didn't even exist, so giving it "assurances" is an impossibility. The people involved were all politicians trying to get a momentous change over the line. It would not be surprising if they used nuanced language, or were "economical with the truth" in doing so. Nato has, itself, stated that it never made the alleged commitment.

Secondly, what does "Nato moving east" actually mean? Nato has no territory. Its members do. It cannot "move east". It can only admit new members to the east of the current ones. Why would it do that? Nato is wholly defensive. Neither it, nor any of its members, have ever expressed a desire to take territory from anyone, including Russia. The purpose of new members joining has been to bolster their defences against any attack from elsewhere, especially from Russia. If such a threat ceased to exist, Russia disbanded its army and created DMZs, then Nato's role would match it in proportion. Win, win. For non aggressors!

As Nato opens its doors to any new member who shares their values and commitments, it would be illogical to close them to a country who meets the requirements, just because someone who isn't a member requests them not to. I don't believe Nato would ever make such a commitment. Nor do I believe any politician, or group of politicians, could commit it. Re-assuring a Gorbachev and giving him a position he can sell at home is a different matter.

This is just propaganda by Russia to try to justify its own position. Nato poses no threat to Russia itself. The threat it poses is to Russia's ability to continue its own expansion west, into the former territories it lost. Losses that still wrankle with people like Putin. Unfortunately, the right have swallowed this propaganda and are regurgitating it along with the bile they hold for western foreign policy and Nato.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jun 22 8.12pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

That you believe all your opinions are the truth doesn't mean you don't lie. All it means is you are self-righteous. Plenty of people who know your on-line persona would recognise that in you.

I don't agree with your idea of what a lie is.....however, I do recognise that I can sometimes be self righteous on certain topics. Then again, I think in certain areas that's not so bad.

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Just take a look at the known facts. Firstly, no-one but Nato speaks for Nato. That James Baker and other western leaders made statements and exchanged memos during the period of German re-unification doesn't make policy, nor set things in stone. The situation was still developing. The Russian Federation didn't even exist, so giving it "assurances" is an impossibility. The people involved were all politicians trying to get a momentous change over the line. It would not be surprising if they used nuanced language, or were "economical with the truth" in doing so. Nato has, itself, stated that it never made the alleged commitment.

I consider these kind of self justifications to be at the core of the problem.

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Secondly, what does "Nato moving east" actually mean? Nato has no territory. Its members do. It cannot "move east". It can only admit new members to the east of the current ones. Why would it do that? Nato is wholly defensive. Neither it, nor any of its members, have ever expressed a desire to take territory from anyone, including Russia. The purpose of new members joining has been to bolster their defences against any attack from elsewhere, especially from Russia. If such a threat ceased to exist, Russia disbanded its army and created DMZs, then Nato's role would match it in proportion. Win, win. For non aggressors!

You don't get to decide for different power structures what Nato is and what it represents. All you are doing is selling a pitch.....Next you're will be talking about Bambi.....I mean, only in the last paragraph you were talking about 'nuanced language' that is, 'economical with the truth'....and then you launch straight from that into saying how Russia should view Nato.....can't you see the problem there?

To me, all that matters are 'what kind of missiles can be pointed at me, from what distance'. Meaning....what is my response time'.

Not, this guy says 'we're nice guys, who would never hit you first'....yeah...you do realise that the only nation to ever make a first use of nuclear weapons is the main contributor and driver of Nato itself.....post hoc anything can be justified.

Waffle and anyone in charge of a nation's security would be a simpleton to rely upon those kind of assurances.....because as we see, assurances are waffle.


Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

As Nato opens its doors to any new member who shares their values and commitments, it would be illogical to close them to a country who meets the requirements, just because someone who isn't a member requests them not to. I don't believe Nato would ever make such a commitment. Nor do I believe any politician, or group of politicians, could commit it. Re-assuring a Gorbachev and giving him a position he can sell at home is a different matter.

This is just propaganda by Russia to try to justify its own position. Nato poses no threat to Russia itself. The threat it poses is to Russia's ability to continue its own expansion west, into the former territories it lost. Losses that still wrankle with people like Putin. Unfortunately, the right have swallowed this propaganda and are regurgitating it along with the bile they hold for western foreign policy and Nato.

Nato is no different to any other organisation or Russia itself....it does whatever the feck it wants to do and it rationises and justifies it however it wants to......you would fit right in with these kind of guys.

I look at the 'propaganda' from both sides and make my own decisions....Unlike you, I don't play 'goodies and baddies'.

I support British interests and troops first, but I don't play my nation right or wrong nor my side right or wrong.

I also will add that my criticism of how the west has handled Russia since its break up from the Soviet Union isn't an endorsement of Russia under its elites or this invasion itself.....This relates to our own elites behaviour and decisions that have responsibility for leading here.


Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jun 2022 8.33pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 12 Jun 22 10.21pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You don't get to decide for different power structures what Nato is and what it represents.

None of us do. Including you. Nato does that itself, so I suggest you read and pay heed to its website and the statements it makes there.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

To me, all that matters are 'what kind of missiles can be pointed at me, from what distance'. Meaning....what is my response time'.

That's the bottom line for everyone. The problem is that there is a huge script to be written before we reach that bottom line. The issue is not the destination, but the safest route to get there, without the journey coming to a disastrous early conclusion.

I have a lot of time for Christopher Steele, ex MI5 and Russian expert, who obviously enjoys strong contacts within the security services of both the UK and USA. I suggest you follow him on Twitter. He is convinced, via the security services, that Putin is being treated for cancer and is anticipated to become incapacitated within 6 months, necessitating a change at the top in Russia. I have no more evidence than those assertions, but Steele has been right often enough in the past to be taken seriously. If he is right, this is both an opportunity and a danger. Finding the balance between the carrot and the stick is never easy, but must be especially challenging at the moment

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Nato is no different to any other organisation or Russia itself....


Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jun 2022 8.33pm)

This is completely wrong. Nato is unlike any other organisation and especially unlike Russia.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

BlueJay Flag UK 12 Jun 22 10.24pm

Another productive day I see!

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 12 Jun 22 11.27pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

Another productive day I see!

Actually, I have got a lot done. Cleaned the car, Tcut a few scratches, jet washed some garden furniture, cut the lawn, walked the dog and cooked dinner. Got to rest my legs these days from time to time, and that's when I catch up on the various platforms I monitor, this one included. I always check to see if there's any transfer news before reading the latest attempts at an epistle to the Gods of right wing thought, to be found here.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

BlueJay Flag UK 13 Jun 22 12.07am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Actually, I have got a lot done. Cleaned the car, Tcut a few scratches, jet washed some garden furniture, cut the lawn, walked the dog and cooked dinner. Got to rest my legs these days from time to time, and that's when I catch up on the various platforms I monitor, this one included. I always check to see if there's any transfer news before reading the latest attempts at an epistle to the Gods of right wing thought, to be found here.

Okay I take it back, that does sound like a rather full day . And you routinely let ol' fringe-o extinguish his fire on you, so you're pretty much performing a service to the community anyway.


Edited by BlueJay (13 Jun 2022 12.20am)

 

Page 165 of 280 < 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?