You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?
November 16 2026 12.54pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?


Page 17 of 25 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >
millsy-125 Flag 17 Apr 14 9.31pm

[Link]

 

OllieMaidstoneEagle Flag Maidstone, Kent 17 Apr 14 9.59pm

The Welsh FA have just released this statement; "We at The Welsh FA deem that all results that invovle Welsh teams in The Premier League will now be under scrutiny and where any percieved underhand practices are hinted at,those points gained will be docked and returned to the rightful team.ie The Welsh team. The only exemption to this new rule is if The Welsh team wins they keep the points regardless(in fact lets double said points). So the revised league standings are(in alphabetical order) Cardiff City in 1st position,Swansea City 2nd and all the other cheating bsatards below" .Ollie's Dad,Ash.

 


Red and Blue Army!
LONDON BORN PALACE BRED LIVE AND DIE FOR BLUE AND RED
Football is not just a game, its a religion

fan zhiyi Flag 17 Apr 14 10.29pm

They've just done a report on the story on news at 10 and picked up on the Tan / Moody litigation angle. It then cut to our old mate Steve Claridge saying it was a load of rubbish. If even Claridge is on our side cardiff are in trouble.

 

gmostone Flag 17 Apr 14 10.29pm

Quote OllieMaidstoneEagle at 17 Apr 2014 9.59pm

The Welsh FA have just released this statement; "We at The Welsh FA deem that all results that invovle Welsh teams in The Premier League will now be under scrutiny and where any percieved underhand practices are hinted at,those points gained will be docked and returned to the rightful team.ie The Welsh team. The only exemption to this new rule is if The Welsh team wins they keep the points regardless(in fact lets double said points). So the revised league standings are(in alphabetical order) Cardiff City in 1st position,Swansea City 2nd and all the other cheating bsatards below" .Ollie's Dad,Ash.


Bah-locks to that!

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 17 Apr 14 11.03pm

Quote Sansbup at 17 Apr 2014 8.06pm

Here's what Sky have to say about it. I'll save you clicking through, the answer is nothing.

[Link]


Actually, it's not. Here's their report on the matter: [Link]

Apparently Cardiff are confident that "their FA complaint will be handled in the appropriate manner" and will "receive a fair hearing."

Not confident their complaint will be upheld or palace punished in any way then.

Everyone with any sense can see this has all been cooked up by Tan to distract from his disastrous management of his club. I'd say this has a less than zero chance of derailing our season.

Edited by Seth (17 Apr 2014 11.03pm)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 17 Apr 14 11.20pm

I see the BBC were crowing about the fact that we could get docked 3 points. Haven't these c***s heard of innocent until proven guilty? It's like the b******s are itching to make an example of us, despite the fact that unless money has changed hands, then absolutely NOTHING illegal has happened. The whole Freedman element is somewhat surprising too. How on earth did he receive the text? No loyalty from him, the bitter c***.
Just read Martin Samuels' article in yesterdays Daily Mail, even he thinks the whole thing is a load of bollocks. Why is it that every time we think things are going well then some c*** has to come and throw a spanner in the works.

f*** YOU CARDIFF CITY AND VINCENT TANN. MAY YOU ROT IN THE LOWER LEAGUES FOR MANY YEARS TO COME AND HOPEFULLY GO BANKRUPT TOO.


Edited by fed up eagle (17 Apr 2014 11.22pm)

 

Dazzling Flag Sutton 17 Apr 14 11.20pm

I hope we meet them in the Cup next season. F*cking sheep shaggers!

Edited by Dazzling (17 Apr 2014 11.20pm)

 

Dazzling Flag Sutton 17 Apr 14 11.28pm

Cardiff have called on the Premier League to order that their controversial 3-0 defeat to Crystal Palace is replayed but their plea looks set to fail.

The Welsh club lodged an official complaint to the Premier League this week alleging that their team for the game was leaked following an approach by Palace director of football Iain Moody.

Cardiff claim Moody, who they sacked last year, contacted three members of their staff to find out their line-up and that his behaviour breached Premier League rules.

Further reports from the BBC today reveal details of a five-page letter sent by Cardiff’s lawyers to the League claiming Palace boss Tony Pulis knew of Moody’s attempts and that the result “should not be allowed to stand”.

Standard Sport understands it is very unlikely the match will be played again as there is no precedent for a result to be declared void.

The Premier League confirmed this week they were investigating but Palace have already denied the accusations.

After Cardiff’s complaints came to light, Moody admitted he had talked to people within the game about what their team might be, but insisted he had not made contact with anyone at the club.

He said: “That is incredibly, extraordinarily untrue. That is untrue, completely untrue. Absolutely not — not under any circumstances.”

Chairman Steve Parish explained that they had received information from an agent, with only nine of the 11 names received being correct.

He then hit back at Cardiff, saying: “It’s completely far-fetched to me. I can’t imagine it in a million years. I think it will be sour grapes really.”

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 17 Apr 14 11.28pm

Im going to that hovel in Wales and I am going to throw fire bombs into the directors box when Cardiff play brighton next year. Thus Vincent Tan and Tony Bloom shall sleep with the fishes.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 17 Apr 14 11.40pm

Quote fed up eagle at 17 Apr 2014 6.43pm

Quote The Sash at 17 Apr 2014 3.43pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 17 Apr 2014 1.37pm

Quote Baldfella at 17 Apr 2014 12.37pm

Quote fed up eagle at 17 Apr 2014 12.34pm

Apparently Cardiff are trying to say that the result we got there should not stand due to the supposed leak.
This smacks of desperation on Cardiff's part but I wouldn't put it past the powers that be to screw us over.
This story is on the BBC sport website.

Thoughts?

Not against you personally mate but you're the most recent poster that seems to think the powers that be would want to "screw us over" ! What do you base this on ?

Complete rubbish, Palace make the same contributions towards their partition in the Premier League, they will get same treatment as any other club.

As stated before: SECTION B Rule B15 states: "In all matters and transactions relating to the league each club shall behave towards each other club and the league with the utmost good faith".

SECTION B Rule 17 goes on, "A Club shall not without the Board’s prior written consent either during its membership of the League or at any time after its membership has terminated disclose or divulge either directly or indirectly to any Person whatsoever or otherwise make use of any confidential information as to the business or finances of the League or any other Club or any of their dealings, transactions or affairs or as to any other matters which may come to its knowledge by reason
of its membership save to statutory and regulatory authorities or as may be required by law or to such Officials and Auditors of that Club to whom such disclosure is strictly necessary for the purpose of their duties and then only to the extent so necessary".
That to me is what Cardiff may be using as justification for their complaint, I may be wrong but as I read that as a non Englishman, it could also implicate Cardiff for their failings.

Also there is no mention of this type of issue in APPENDIX 5 & 6 Managers and clubs code of conduct.

So unless the Premier league introduce a new rule, it's a storm in a teacup, as this sort of thing has been going on for years, even when I was playing it was going on, every club tried to get their opponents lineup before they named theirs, and I retired in 1977, it's called trying to outwit your opponent.

Exactly - As I said earlier, there is no actual 'rule' that has been broken, you could argue if we did do this then we went against a very shaky and vague ethical 'guidleine' to which no-one can actually pass a judgement on


So you're saying that some clubs don't get better treatment than others? Man utd don't get certain decisions that we wouldn't? You can dismiss what I say as complete rubbish, you're entitled to your opinion, but the fact is I have absolutely no faith in the people running the game. Every one knows that they love making examples of people, unless you're one of the big five of course.

The point is that any general pant wetting that we have broken some sacrosanct hard an fast rule is disingenuous

Do teams get decisions on and off the pitch in favour of bigger clubs - absolutely.

Are the powers that be likely to make a ruling in favour of Tan and Cardiff that opens a massive can of worms for them in the future - of course not

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

millip Flag 18 Apr 14 12.02am

Haven't read the entire thread but as far as I can make out, Cardiff are in disrepute for disclosing their team!

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 18 Apr 14 12.33am

Quote Dazzling at 17 Apr 2014 11.28pm

Cardiff have called on the Premier League to order that their controversial 3-0 defeat to Crystal Palace is replayed but their plea looks set to fail.

The Welsh club lodged an official complaint to the Premier League this week alleging that their team for the game was leaked following an approach by Palace director of football Iain Moody.

Cardiff claim Moody, who they sacked last year, contacted three members of their staff to find out their line-up and that his behaviour breached Premier League rules.

Further reports from the BBC today reveal details of a five-page letter sent by Cardiff’s lawyers to the League claiming Palace boss Tony Pulis knew of Moody’s attempts and that the result “should not be allowed to stand”.

Standard Sport understands it is very unlikely the match will be played again as there is no precedent for a result to be declared void.

The Premier League confirmed this week they were investigating but Palace have already denied the accusations.

After Cardiff’s complaints came to light, Moody admitted he had talked to people within the game about what their team might be, but insisted he had not made contact with anyone at the club.

He said: “That is incredibly, extraordinarily untrue. That is untrue, completely untrue. Absolutely not — not under any circumstances.”

Chairman Steve Parish explained that they had received information from an agent, with only nine of the 11 names received being correct.

He then hit back at Cardiff, saying: “It’s completely far-fetched to me. I can’t imagine it in a million years. I think it will be sour grapes really.”


Here's the link: [Link]

Sounds like Tan's desperate attempt to deflect attention from his own catastrophic management of CCFC will fall flat on its face. What an odious little man he is.

Edited by Seth (18 Apr 2014 12.35am)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

sithsmith Flag 18 Apr 14 12.35am

all starts to make sense why BBC are whipping up the frenzy...

David Bond is an English sports journalist, currently the BBC's Sports Editor.

Bond began his journalistic career on the South London Press covering Millwall F.C., the football club he supports

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 18 Apr 14 1.01am

The David Bond BBC piece reports a supposed exchange between Pulis and Solskjaer after the match:

It is claimed Solskjaer said to Pulis: "I am disgusted that your head of recruitment [Moody] is texting one of my players to get our team."

Pulis allegedly responded: "Oooh, I know. I didn't ask for it."

Are they saying Tony Pulis is in fact Julian Clary in disguise?

Edited by Seth (18 Apr 2014 1.03am)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 18 Apr 14 1.27am

BREAKING: The actual letter's been leaked. Here it is:

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

quinn85 Flag dublin 18 Apr 14 2.07am

Honestly, I could have picked the Cardiff team bar 1, Jones, it's simple with the changes included, Fabio was injured, from the previous game, so not likely to play, wilf the only man with pace and quality to play that wing to replace him, I know Fabio is a full back but OGS has used wilf as replacement moving a midfielder back to cover,

And Bellamy plays 1 in 2 games, he starts less, he started the match previous so likely not to start, Daehli was his obvious replacement with OGS becoming more trusting in him,

And as I already said Jones is the only one I couldn't have predicted.

As for formation, OGS being former utd is a 4-4-2 / 4-4-1-1 (if he had the quality of player to play as a false 10) type of manager, he wasn't going to play 4-5-1 in a game he thought he could win, however if he done his homework he'd have noticed TPs favoured formation and even his starting 11, he wouldn't risk playing 4-3-3 with fear of being exposed by Yala, Punchy, Ward and Mariappa!

Simple!

 


twitter @tq85

Crystal ClearCPFC Flag Croydon 18 Apr 14 7.10am

I dont know if its been posted yet i haven't looked through sorry if it has.

from bbc sport.

Former Wales striker Iwan Roberts says knowing a rival team's line-up could be a boon or a curse.

Roberts' comments came in the wake of unproven allegations that Crystal Palace had Cardiff City's selection before their 3-0 win there on 5 April.

"It might be good if you get the team-sheet early and you find out Gareth Bale isn't playing against you - you might sleep easily," said Roberts.

"But if you find out he is playing, you might have have a sleepless night."

Roberts says in a career spanning almost 20 seasons via Watford, Huddersfield, Leicester, Wolverhampton Wanderers, Norwich, Gillingham and Cambridge United, opposition selections would often be available.

"It's a hard one to explain. I don't think it gives one team an advantage because you've still got to go out and perform and win the game.

"When I played it would happen.

"A player would have a mate in the next team you were up against who would be out of favour and would let us know their line-up so you'd have it the night before.

"It has been going on for years and years and years."

But a rival club's inside information about the availability or otherwise of a world class talent such as Real Madrid's Welsh star Bale could be a double-edged sword, says Roberts.

He said: "It can be an advantage or a disadvantage.

"It might be better to only have [that information] an hour before kick-off to worry about it."

Edited by Crystal ClearCPFC (18 Apr 2014 7.12am)

 

Green Bin Flag Carshalton Beeches 18 Apr 14 7.29am

Quote Seth at 18 Apr 2014 1.27am

BREAKING: The actual letter's been leaked. Here it is:


Damn you got there before me....very funny though, especially the bit about Freedman!

 

7@burnley79 Flag Battersea 18 Apr 14 7.34am

Quote Seth at 18 Apr 2014 1.27am

BREAKING: The actual letter's been leaked. Here it is:

Absolutely classic....
Really puts this whole debacle into perspective.
If subpoenaed can we please use this defence

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 18 Apr 14 7.48am

Tan and Cardiff should be fined and relegated to the welsh league, for wasting time and being pathetic, then they can play great teams like Newport YMCA, watched by 14 people, 2dogs and 4 sheep, the soppy t***.

 

Page 17 of 25 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?