You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour Leadership - Bald men fighting over a comb?
November 22 2026 2.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Labour Leadership - Bald men fighting over a comb?


Page 17 of 19 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
matt_himself Flag Matataland 14 Sep 15 6.01pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 14 Sep 2015 5.52pm

Quote DanH at 14 Sep 2015 5.46pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 14 Sep 2015 5.43pm

Yeah.


Lovely stuff.


Women want him. Men want to be him.

Not quite sure where that leaves you.


That leave him where he normally is - hanging around the gents looking for 'hard trade'.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 14 Sep 15 7.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 4.33pm

Quote susmik at 14 Sep 2015 4.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 3.44pm

Quote susmik at 14 Sep 2015 1.49pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 1.21pm

Quote Stuk at 14 Sep 2015 12.13pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 12.03pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Sep 2015 10.26am

Quote serial thriller at 13 Sep 2015 1.26pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Sep 2015 1.15pm

Elections are won by votes from people that overwhelmingly are not members of any political party. They tend to vote for credible leaders - the following list were spectacularly non-credible leaders of Labour that led to disastrous election campaigns:-

Kinnock, Foot, Brown, Miliband (double whammy paired with Balls)..... now Corbyn

Only a fool would be encouraged by yesterday's leadership result... it will end in tears for the Labour Party... mark my words.


But membership is massively important. UKIP's rise to hold the highest number of MEPs would never have happened without the surge in membership they gained a few years ago. The SNP gaining nearly every seat in Scotland was triggered by a mass mobilisation of activists around the referendum. The Labour party itself was born out of a desire for parliamentary recognition by the Trade Union movement, and thus its successes (Attlee, Wilson, even Blair) have all had to rely on strong membership support (under Blair, membership nearly hit 500000 having been at half of that under Kinnock).

In fact your point about leaders only proves this point. Labour lost in 83 because of a split in party membership between them and the SDP, under Milliband it nudged 200000 but that's nothing really. As for being credible, well Attlee was seen as credible in 45, Wilson was seen as credible in 74, and their manifestos were to the left of anything that's come out of the Corbyn camp so far. Interesting times.


You completely ignored or misunderstood the point I was making.

Being credible as a leader has a significant effect on your party's chances of getting elected.

I will add John Major to the list of non credible leaders. He was trounced by Blair in 97!

It's not about left or right for the majority of voters.

Labour got beat in May 2015 because of the public's lack of faith in Miliband/Balls being able to run our economy.

This morning it appears that Corbyn has appointed his best mate as Chancellor a move which has astounded senior Labour grandees and political commentators who believe that is a disastrous move.

Add that to Corbyn's intentions to re-open South Wales mines, and scrapping of Trident etc you have a very non credible leader who has almost zero chance of getting elected to PM in 2020. Fact.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (14 Sep 2015 10.27am)

I'd recommend people who think Trident is of any use in the modern age read how the Trident system operates and functions. It has only a prestige value only really, in so much as the UK having a nuclear deterrent that guarantees mutually assured destruction of a known enemy.

Realistically it should be replaced with a land based system where missiles can be easily re-targeted as required (not really a practical solution on Subs with Nuclear missiles).



You mght want to weigh up the pros and cons between a fixed and moving (if not unknown) target.

Indeed, the problem is with Trident, I'm not sure that now we are a nuclear power, that stepping back from that table is necessarily a good idea. In order to influence nuclear proliferation, you probably need to be nuclear capable.

However Trident isn't really suited to the UK Solution. The system doesn't have first strike capability or the capacity to retarget missiles easily as required, nor the range to target some likely candidates.

Trident worked for the UK because it would sit quiet and deep, in strike range of the Soviet Union. Its success is entirely based on the fact that even in the event of an enemy nuclear strike destroying all communications and access to the Prime Minister (and their nuclear deputies) retaliation was guaranteed and a number of Soviet and Walsaw block targets were assured of being destroyed.

Plus you could be reasonably sure that any engagement between the soviet and Nato, would occur with some degree of escalation so you could be reasonably prepared, and that such a conflict would likely escalate towards the use of Nuclear, Chemical and Biological weapons rather than start an all out strike).

Simply put Trident is really only viable if you're able to sit off the coast of the enemy, and for them to know you're there, ready to raise them to the ground. In terms of modern war, the likely use of nuclear weapons would be by terrorist groups, who have either stolen or acquired a weapon, and were not a nation state.


I do not know where you get your info from but since the USSR collapsed many years ago in 1991 the trident targeting system has changed in that the target can be programmed in very quickly and the warheads can be programmed in ten or fifteen minutes by computer and fired. What you have to think about is do we want to lay down our arms in order to keep peoples morality alive and leave other countries to threaten us and hold the world to ransom? I think not.

In theory it can. In reality Trident when active sits silent, without transferring communications on the bottom of the ocean, when its active, and as such doesn't take on new communications of targeting data transmitted. Also it needs permission to retarget the missiles.

It'd give away its position to do so, and thus rendered pointless. Half decent electronic warfare counter-measures would locate the submarine, and allow the enemy to potentially destroy it before the missile targeting data can be updated.

The whole point of trident is that it assured the UK could retaliate to a nuclear strike, even if the Soviet union wiped out the country in a first strike, and eliminated the entire chain of command.

That isn't a situation now, likelihood is that a nuclear attack on the UK wouldn't be nation based.

You should also read what I said, this is the perfect time to move from a Trident based Submarine system to a more sustainable and flexible land based system, which is more flexible in terms of deployment and capable of delivering more firepower (you don't have to reduce capacity in order to retarget, re-equip or resupply).

Also, in regards to enemies states who have nuclear missiles, launch detection is now far more accurate and efficient that any launch would result in a counter launch before the missiles could even clear the country of origin.

The UK would benefit from not having at least one third to all of its nuclear capability at the bottom of the sea, on a submarine that may or may not be in range of the place you want to strike.

The mistake, with hindsight, was to retain the Trident program, and scrap the UK nuclear options in the 80s, moving from the Vulcan and air deployment, to a ground based ballistic missile system.


Whatever you say but you had better get in touch with the MOD as they gave the information I gave you!!!

I'll ask, next time they're in for a meeting.


You do that.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 14 Sep 15 7.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Sep 2015 3.54pm

Quote susmik at 14 Sep 2015 2.20pm

Quote serial thriller at 14 Sep 2015 12.44am

Quote susmik at 13 Sep 2015 8.23pm

Quote serial thriller at 13 Sep 2015 2.08pm

One more point: this is a momentous result beyond Britain's borders because you now have a major party leader whose foreign policy will probably not involve war, arms supplying and economic exploitation.

I am not a Labour party member, and am undecided as to whether I'll vote Corbyn should he remain leader in 2020. But this to me is his greatest virtue.

I'm in Turkey at the moment and I've spoken to loads of people from across the Middle East, and the overriding opinion among even the more Westernised middle classes is that Britain is a massive cause of disturbance in the region. I spoke to
Likewise, that we will have a leader of the opposition who is openly critical of Israel, who are not only continuing to commit war crimes on the West Bank but a guy from Yemen, who are being bombed by Saudi Arabia, and the vitriol he poured on Britain for supplying arms to a Wahabist extremist state who have murdered around 20 000 Yemeni in 6 months was so uncharacteristic of someone who was otherwise an incredibly polite, humble man it really made me think.
are threatening to renew tensions with Iran in the area is massive. Maybe we will even stop supplying weapons and armoury to Qatar, Kuwait and the Saudis for them to channel on to IS?

It's easy to just look at home and regard the effect Corbyn's politics will have, but actually the biggest positive in my mind is that we shift our stance on the global scene.

The Yemin people were not meak and humble when I spent three years of my life in Aden fighting them as they were trying to get the oil refinery and killed many british servicemen who are buried out there. We spent months up in the mountains stopping them coming through the pass at Dhala. I also remember the time we had to go up to near Sana their main fort and collect all the dead bodies of the ITV crew and some Coldstream guards bodies as well. It was not nice and I have no sympathy for them at all ....its come back to bite them that's for sure!


What exactly does this anecdote have to do with the fact that the Saudis, backed by the British and the Americans, are bombing civilian areas in which the average age is 15, most probably committing war crimes in the process? All you seem to have really done here is highlight the tragedy of war, as I'm sure the Yemeni people fighting against you could do with as much ease.

from your previous post:
a guy from Yemen, who are being bombed by Saudi Arabia, and the vitriol he poured on Britain for supplying arms to a Wahabist extremist state who have murdered around 20 000 Yemeni in 6 months was so uncharacteristic of someone who was otherwise an incredibly polite, humble man it really made me think.

Did he not tell you about the people murdered in Aden by them and that was their own Arabs plus other people including British personnel and it was all done with Russian weapons so don't give me the soft story from your so called humble friend?? Give it a rest and see the wider picture and not just the one you like to paint. The Yemin STILL to this day behead people, stone women and cut peoples limbs off......great people!!! deserve all they get if you ask me IMO.

Of course you can't trust anyone on either side of a conflict to tell you the truth, only their truth

British Arms Companies don't just sell British Weapons. They sell all kinds, including Russian kit - The AK range is very popular out in the middle east (robust, easy to clean and fix). The US sold a s**t load of AKs to the Iraqi Military after the 2003 War.

Most countries sell Kalishnikovs these days, and an awful lot of them manufacture them as well.



Sorry to say they were not even in service back then.....

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Sep 15 7.39pm

Quote oldcodger at 14 Sep 2015 5.21pm


The image is a comment on Cameron's "The Labour Party is now a threat to our national security, our economic security and your family's security." tweet I think.

It is

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 14 Sep 15 7.47pm

Quote serial thriller at 14 Sep 2015 5.09pm

Quote susmik at 14 Sep 2015 2.20pm

Quote serial thriller at 14 Sep 2015 12.44am

Quote susmik at 13 Sep 2015 8.23pm

Quote serial thriller at 13 Sep 2015 2.08pm

One more point: this is a momentous result beyond Britain's borders because you now have a major party leader whose foreign policy will probably not involve war, arms supplying and economic exploitation.

I am not a Labour party member, and am undecided as to whether I'll vote Corbyn should he remain leader in 2020. But this to me is his greatest virtue.

I'm in Turkey at the moment and I've spoken to loads of people from across the Middle East, and the overriding opinion among even the more Westernised middle classes is that Britain is a massive cause of disturbance in the region. I spoke to
Likewise, that we will have a leader of the opposition who is openly critical of Israel, who are not only continuing to commit war crimes on the West Bank but a guy from Yemen, who are being bombed by Saudi Arabia, and the vitriol he poured on Britain for supplying arms to a Wahabist extremist state who have murdered around 20 000 Yemeni in 6 months was so uncharacteristic of someone who was otherwise an incredibly polite, humble man it really made me think.
are threatening to renew tensions with Iran in the area is massive. Maybe we will even stop supplying weapons and armoury to Qatar, Kuwait and the Saudis for them to channel on to IS?

It's easy to just look at home and regard the effect Corbyn's politics will have, but actually the biggest positive in my mind is that we shift our stance on the global scene.

The Yemin people were not meak and humble when I spent three years of my life in Aden fighting them as they were trying to get the oil refinery and killed many british servicemen who are buried out there. We spent months up in the mountains stopping them coming through the pass at Dhala. I also remember the time we had to go up to near Sana their main fort and collect all the dead bodies of the ITV crew and some Coldstream guards bodies as well. It was not nice and I have no sympathy for them at all ....its come back to bite them that's for sure!


What exactly does this anecdote have to do with the fact that the Saudis, backed by the British and the Americans, are bombing civilian areas in which the average age is 15, most probably committing war crimes in the process? All you seem to have really done here is highlight the tragedy of war, as I'm sure the Yemeni people fighting against you could do with as much ease.

from your previous post:
a guy from Yemen, who are being bombed by Saudi Arabia, and the vitriol he poured on Britain for supplying arms to a Wahabist extremist state who have murdered around 20 000 Yemeni in 6 months was so uncharacteristic of someone who was otherwise an incredibly polite, humble man it really made me think.

Did he not tell you about the people murdered in Aden by them and that was their own Arabs plus other people including British personnel and it was all done with Russian weapons so don't give me the soft story from your so called humble friend?? Give it a rest and see the wider picture and not just the one you like to paint. The Yemin STILL to this day behead people, stone women and cut peoples limbs off......great people!!! deserve all they get if you ask me IMO.

You know what, since I met him that's exactly what I've tried to do. I've read up a bit on Yemeni modern history and it is plagued by war and atrocities from almost everyone who has attempted to change politics, be they Yemeni, Saudi, British, Egyptian or the other gulf states. From what I can see, the war in which British servicemen were killed was a conflict between two sides with very little moral credibility. The Royalists who us and the Saudis joined forces with were headed by a King who regularly murdered his own people, with our intervention being principally to preserve oil interests in the area. On the other side, Egypt's support of the Republic killed thousands of people, using chemical weapons in the process. Undoubtedly horrible, but as I said previously this is just one of many examples of the horrors of war, and to tar all Yemeni people today as deserving to die, especially given many tribespeople and royalists supported the British, is ludicrous.

But I maintain that this is beside the point. You are using your personal experience of war in Yemen to justify what the Saudis are currently doing, which, I repeat, is committing war crimes in major cities where the average age is FIFTEEN, in order to protect a former president whose popularity was so low he had to flee, and they are being supported by the British government. Tell me, does a 12 year old child blown up by a air-range missile 'deserve all they get' because of what some of their ancestors did?


And as an aside, you seem to forget that the Saudis, our allies, are the most culpable of beheading, stoning and delimbing!

Edited by serial thriller (14 Sep 2015 5.11pm)

Some Aden history for you:
[Link]

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 15 Sep 15 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)

corbyn.jpg Attachment: corbyn.jpg (31.38Kb)

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

DanH Flag SW2 15 Sep 15 9.03am

Quote dannyh at 15 Sep 2015 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)


Sounds like Corbyn could actually try and make it a worthwhile question and answer session rather than a pointless playground comparison of who has the biggest boll*cks.

A big part of the reason of Corbyn's success is people being turned off by the status quo of modern politics. Even if you don't agree with a word he says you must admit it's about time we had something different in parliament?


Edited by DanH (15 Sep 2015 9.04am)

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 15 Sep 15 9.11am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 9.03am

Quote dannyh at 15 Sep 2015 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)


Sounds like Corbyn could actually try and make it a worthwhile question and answer session rather than a pointless playground comparison of who has the biggest boll*cks.

A big part of the reason of Corbyn's success is people being turned off by the status quo of modern politics. Even if you don't agree with a word he says you must admit it's about time we had something different in parliament?


Edited by DanH (15 Sep 2015 9.04am)


Exactly. My ears are pricked. And won't it be fun when we get the red-faced Tory bluster when JC makes some very valid points at PQT that the people can relate to.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


chris123 Flag hove actually 15 Sep 15 9.53am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 9.03am

Quote dannyh at 15 Sep 2015 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)


Sounds like Corbyn could actually try and make it a worthwhile question and answer session rather than a pointless playground comparison of who has the biggest boll*cks.

A big part of the reason of Corbyn's success is people being turned off by the status quo of modern politics. Even if you don't agree with a word he says you must admit it's about time we had something different in parliament?


Edited by DanH (15 Sep 2015 9.04am)


I would suggest that it was also due to the paucity of quality opposition.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 15 Sep 15 9.58am

Quote Kermit8 at 15 Sep 2015 9.11am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 9.03am

Quote dannyh at 15 Sep 2015 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)


Sounds like Corbyn could actually try and make it a worthwhile question and answer session rather than a pointless playground comparison of who has the biggest boll*cks.

A big part of the reason of Corbyn's success is people being turned off by the status quo of modern politics. Even if you don't agree with a word he says you must admit it's about time we had something different in parliament?


Edited by DanH (15 Sep 2015 9.04am)


Exactly. My ears are pricked. And won't it be fun when we get the red-faced Tory bluster when JC makes some very valid points at PQT that the people can relate to.


This is an observation: Corbyn doesn't appear to want to speak at all in public. He appears to be taking a strategy of speaking at rally's and protests. I am all for PMQ to be reformed as it is a bit silly (albeit entertaining) but a refusal to participate in it, which is what he is hinting at, will cause problems for him. He simply does need to speak in Parliament as this is the primary visual representation of government for much of the electorate.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Sep 15 10.02am

Quote matt_himself at 15 Sep 2015 9.58am


This is an observation: Corbyn doesn't appear to want to speak at all in public. He appears to be taking a strategy of speaking at rally's and protests. I am all for PMQ to be reformed as it is a bit silly (albeit entertaining) but a refusal to participate in it, which is what he is hinting at, will cause problems for him. He simply does need to speak in Parliament as this is the primary visual representation of government for much of the electorate.

As Mrs Thatcher would say "He's frit".


 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 15 Sep 15 10.14am

Quote matt_himself at 15 Sep 2015 9.58am

Quote Kermit8 at 15 Sep 2015 9.11am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 9.03am

Quote dannyh at 15 Sep 2015 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)


Sounds like Corbyn could actually try and make it a worthwhile question and answer session rather than a pointless playground comparison of who has the biggest boll*cks.

A big part of the reason of Corbyn's success is people being turned off by the status quo of modern politics. Even if you don't agree with a word he says you must admit it's about time we had something different in parliament?


Edited by DanH (15 Sep 2015 9.04am)


Exactly. My ears are pricked. And won't it be fun when we get the red-faced Tory bluster when JC makes some very valid points at PQT that the people can relate to.


This is an observation: Corbyn doesn't appear to want to speak at all in public. He appears to be taking a strategy of speaking at rally's and protests. I am all for PMQ to be reformed as it is a bit silly (albeit entertaining) but a refusal to participate in it, which is what he is hinting at, will cause problems for him. He simply does need to speak in Parliament as this is the primary visual representation of government for much of the electorate.


Maybe it is the childish nit-picking, the blame culture and the nauseating spin which comes with PMQ - as well as the important stuff - that he has aversion to. But don't we all?

He needs to get his head around it, involve himself, I agree. He doesn't have play 'the game' but he will need a will of steel and thick rhino skin not to take the bait that will be generously offered, and often, from the government benches.

Interesting times in Westminster at last.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


DanH Flag SW2 15 Sep 15 10.15am

Quote matt_himself at 15 Sep 2015 9.58am

Quote Kermit8 at 15 Sep 2015 9.11am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 9.03am

Quote dannyh at 15 Sep 2015 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)


Sounds like Corbyn could actually try and make it a worthwhile question and answer session rather than a pointless playground comparison of who has the biggest boll*cks.

A big part of the reason of Corbyn's success is people being turned off by the status quo of modern politics. Even if you don't agree with a word he says you must admit it's about time we had something different in parliament?


Edited by DanH (15 Sep 2015 9.04am)


Exactly. My ears are pricked. And won't it be fun when we get the red-faced Tory bluster when JC makes some very valid points at PQT that the people can relate to.


This is an observation: Corbyn doesn't appear to want to speak at all in public. He appears to be taking a strategy of speaking at rally's and protests. I am all for PMQ to be reformed as it is a bit silly (albeit entertaining) but a refusal to participate in it, which is what he is hinting at, will cause problems for him. He simply does need to speak in Parliament as this is the primary visual representation of government for much of the electorate.


I guess we'll see. Plus those were hardly in private.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Sep 15 10.19am

It would appear that general view within Westminster and the general public is that Labour has perpetuated a grotesque joke.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 15 Sep 15 10.19am

Quote Kermit8 at 15 Sep 2015 10.14am

Quote matt_himself at 15 Sep 2015 9.58am

Quote Kermit8 at 15 Sep 2015 9.11am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 9.03am

Quote dannyh at 15 Sep 2015 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)


Sounds like Corbyn could actually try and make it a worthwhile question and answer session rather than a pointless playground comparison of who has the biggest boll*cks.

A big part of the reason of Corbyn's success is people being turned off by the status quo of modern politics. Even if you don't agree with a word he says you must admit it's about time we had something different in parliament?


Edited by DanH (15 Sep 2015 9.04am)


Exactly. My ears are pricked. And won't it be fun when we get the red-faced Tory bluster when JC makes some very valid points at PQT that the people can relate to.


This is an observation: Corbyn doesn't appear to want to speak at all in public. He appears to be taking a strategy of speaking at rally's and protests. I am all for PMQ to be reformed as it is a bit silly (albeit entertaining) but a refusal to participate in it, which is what he is hinting at, will cause problems for him. He simply does need to speak in Parliament as this is the primary visual representation of government for much of the electorate.


Maybe it is the childish nit-picking, the blame culture and the nauseating spin which comes with PMQ - as well as the important stuff - that he has aversion to. But don't we all?

He needs to get his head around it, involve himself, I agree. He doesn't have play 'the game' but he will need a will of steel and thick rhino skin not to take the bait that will be generously offered, and often, from the government benches.

Interesting times in Westminster at last.

Reading your first sentence, I thought you were talking about this forum.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

npn Flag Crowborough 15 Sep 15 10.20am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 10.15am

Quote matt_himself at 15 Sep 2015 9.58am

Quote Kermit8 at 15 Sep 2015 9.11am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 9.03am

Quote dannyh at 15 Sep 2015 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)


Sounds like Corbyn could actually try and make it a worthwhile question and answer session rather than a pointless playground comparison of who has the biggest boll*cks.

A big part of the reason of Corbyn's success is people being turned off by the status quo of modern politics. Even if you don't agree with a word he says you must admit it's about time we had something different in parliament?


Edited by DanH (15 Sep 2015 9.04am)


Exactly. My ears are pricked. And won't it be fun when we get the red-faced Tory bluster when JC makes some very valid points at PQT that the people can relate to.


This is an observation: Corbyn doesn't appear to want to speak at all in public. He appears to be taking a strategy of speaking at rally's and protests. I am all for PMQ to be reformed as it is a bit silly (albeit entertaining) but a refusal to participate in it, which is what he is hinting at, will cause problems for him. He simply does need to speak in Parliament as this is the primary visual representation of government for much of the electorate.


I guess we'll see. Plus those were hardly in private.


Also of course there is nobody there to respond and say "but Jeremy, that's b0llocks!".

Talking to a rally of your supporters is a very different proposition to trying to persuade people who are against you that your view is the right one.

Only time will tell how it plays out. Personally, I still give him 6-12 months, and would be amazed if he leads Labour (or at least a united Labour) into the next election

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Sep 15 10.25am

Quote npn at 15 Sep 2015 10.20am


Only time will tell how it plays out. Personally, I still give him 6-12 months, and would be amazed if he leads Labour (or at least a united Labour) into the next election

Yes I will also be surprised if he leads Labour into the 2020 election.Corbyn's masquerade as Opposition leader will collapse enabling his replacement by a leader more in tune with the public mood.One suspects that the plotting has already started.


Edited by Willo (15 Sep 2015 10.28am)

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 15 Sep 15 10.30am

Quote Willo at 15 Sep 2015 10.25am

Quote npn at 15 Sep 2015 10.20am


Only time will tell how it plays out. Personally, I still give him 6-12 months, and would be amazed if he leads Labour (or at least a united Labour) into the next election

Yes I will also be surprised if he leads Labour into the 2020 election.Corbyn's masquerade as Opposition leader will collapse enabling his replacement by a leader more in tune with the public mood.One suspects that the plotting has already started.

Edited by Willo (15 Sep 2015 10.28am)

Yes, but when will the Tories drop that left/lib wet Cameron?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

DanH Flag SW2 15 Sep 15 10.31am

Quote npn at 15 Sep 2015 10.20am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 10.15am

Quote matt_himself at 15 Sep 2015 9.58am

Quote Kermit8 at 15 Sep 2015 9.11am

Quote DanH at 15 Sep 2015 9.03am

Quote dannyh at 15 Sep 2015 8.39am

One of the ingenuous comments from "two legs bad, 4 legs good" is that people should be able to opt out of the part of Income Tax that funds the MOD.

Does that mean I don't have to protect them anymore then.

I'm not a fan of DC, but he must be pissing his sides at the minute, I think I shall be glued to Prime Ministers question time, should be a hoot.

Edited by dannyh (15 Sep 2015 8.40am)


Sounds like Corbyn could actually try and make it a worthwhile question and answer session rather than a pointless playground comparison of who has the biggest boll*cks.

A big part of the reason of Corbyn's success is people being turned off by the status quo of modern politics. Even if you don't agree with a word he says you must admit it's about time we had something different in parliament?


Edited by DanH (15 Sep 2015 9.04am)


Exactly. My ears are pricked. And won't it be fun when we get the red-faced Tory bluster when JC makes some very valid points at PQT that the people can relate to.


This is an observation: Corbyn doesn't appear to want to speak at all in public. He appears to be taking a strategy of speaking at rally's and protests. I am all for PMQ to be reformed as it is a bit silly (albeit entertaining) but a refusal to participate in it, which is what he is hinting at, will cause problems for him. He simply does need to speak in Parliament as this is the primary visual representation of government for much of the electorate.


I guess we'll see. Plus those were hardly in private.


Also of course there is nobody there to respond and say "but Jeremy, that's b0llocks!".

Talking to a rally of your supporters is a very different proposition to trying to persuade people who are against you that your view is the right one.

Only time will tell how it plays out. Personally, I still give him 6-12 months, and would be amazed if he leads Labour (or at least a united Labour) into the next election


Agreed - but when was the last time anyone managed to do that in PMQs?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Sep 15 10.34am

Quote leggedstruggle at 15 Sep 2015 10.30am

Quote Willo at 15 Sep 2015 10.25am

Quote npn at 15 Sep 2015 10.20am


Only time will tell how it plays out. Personally, I still give him 6-12 months, and would be amazed if he leads Labour (or at least a united Labour) into the next election

Yes I will also be surprised if he leads Labour into the 2020 election.Corbyn's masquerade as Opposition leader will collapse enabling his replacement by a leader more in tune with the public mood.One suspects that the plotting has already started.

Edited by Willo (15 Sep 2015 10.28am)

Yes, but when will the Tories drop that left/lib wet Cameron?

I don't wholly subscribe to the description although I wish he would veer to the 'Right' a bit more ! As he mentioned he will be gone at the end of this Parliament and Osborne is in the "Box Seat" to replace him as things stand.


 

Page 17 of 19 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour Leadership - Bald men fighting over a comb?