You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Sunderland Match Thread
November 16 2026 10.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Sunderland Match Thread


Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 04 Feb 17 7.13pm

Originally posted by cpj

On what basis? Did nothing when he played for us, except let is some very weak goals (Defoe scored two at their place against him). Speroni hasn't had a clean sheet in his last 14 league games. The problem is not the keeper.

I appreciate you love Wayne but

He is supposed to be the keeper who commands his area. He doesn't.

He is supposed to be the keeper that distributes well - he doesn't.

Speroni may be a step behind but he is nearly 38. Wayne is 29 so in theory in his prime. I dread to think what his "downhill slide" will be like!

 

palaceontheup Flag 04 Feb 17 7.48pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

I have not got a negative mindset. The opposite in fact. I am very positive we will go down and have been since Arsenal away.


And do you want the really bad news? I always get it right re:play-off finals and relegation over the last 28 years.

Edited by Kermit8 (04 Feb 2017 7.03pm)

Haha.

 


Yannick Bolasie - Glenn Murray - Wilfried Zaha

Most exciting attacking trio at Selhurst Park in years.

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 04 Feb 17 7.56pm

Originally posted by palaceontheup

Come on lads. Bad day, really really bad day. but if we had of lost 4-0 to Bournemouth and beat Sunderland would it be as bad. Perspective. only 2 points off. Hope Swansea lose tomorrow and it stays 2 points. Big Sam was very honest in his interview after and said "HE WILL" sort this. Can't blame Big Sam when we have had a problem playing at Selhurst for a long time. We have time. Sakho and Milo will now play a part.

WE WILL STAY UP. COYP!!

Losing to Bournemouth and beating Sunderland was a much better scenario than what has happened.

How long before we can blame Allardyce? We have gone from scoring and conceding a lot to conceding a lot.

7 league games so far

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 04 Feb 17 8.30pm

Just back and still truly baffled by our approach today. This is not hindsight, I said it when I saw the team. Yes, I know the old don't change a winning team adage, but surely you don't set up at home to bottom team Sunderland as you do away to Bournemouth?
It started OK, but you cannot have a keeper that gifts the opposition goals, especially if you are a team with fragile confidence at home and hope to get away with it.
The loss of Cabaye really hurt us, because although many like to complain about him, he's a busy urgent type of player who always looks forward first before he inevitably has to pass back or sideways because of a lack of movement in front of him. He also leads the team in interceptions BTW. When he went off the obvious move to me was Townsend and push Macca into the middle, as he's also a busy forward thinking player. Townsend would of also stretched the field a bit making life easier for Wilf and taken us back to our double wing threat days. Townsend proved in the second half how poor that decision was as he beat the right back time and again. Ledley has served us well, but he's not up to it in the prem anymore and with Punch our midfield became too slow and laboured. Punch is so low on confidence right now that he just keeps turning in circles and holding the ball too long.
We set up too conservatively and once Hennessey and Ledley gave away the first two goals we were done. Really cannot understand Sam's approach in the game that I really believed was gonna kick start our season. Also can't believe Sam didn't believe we desperatley needed a new keeper in the window?
Was truly soul destroying today, but I expected no points at Bournemouth and a win today, so I got the 3pts I expected, just the wrong way round.
Personally think we are going down, but I've been wrong before and there are plenty of points to play for, it's really now down to how mentally scarred we are after today.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 04 Feb 17 9.28pm

There is nothing wrong with playing 3 at the back and 1 up-front at home. Chelsea have played the same system home and away all season. (No I know we are not Chelsea but the system can work home and/or away.)

We did not lose because the players didn't try or because of the system. We made a bad mistake for the first goal and for nearly half an hour the team looked like we were back in it. The second goal completely sapped the confidence and before you know it we have conceded a hat-full. This has happened to loads of teams over the years.

I liked what SA said after the game and it gave me some hope that maybe all is not lost. Hope we can get our new recruits into the team for Stoke and we might just have a chance

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 04 Feb 17 9.31pm

agree

Originally posted by rollercoaster

There is nothing wrong with playing 3 at the back and 1 up-front at home. Chelsea have played the same system home and away all season. (No I know we are not Chelsea but the system can work home and/or away.)

We did not lose because the players didn't try or because of the system. We made a bad mistake for the first goal and for nearly half an hour the team looked like we were back in it. The second goal completely sapped the confidence and before you know it we have conceded a hat-full. This has happened to loads of teams over the years.

I liked what SA said after the game and it gave me some hope that maybe all is not lost. Hope we can get our new recruits into the team for Stoke and we might just have a chance

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 04 Feb 17 9.51pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

There is nothing wrong with playing 3 at the back and 1 up-front at home. Chelsea have played the same system home and away all season. (No I know we are not Chelsea but the system can work home and/or away.)

We did not lose because the players didn't try or because of the system. We made a bad mistake for the first goal and for nearly half an hour the team looked like we were back in it. The second goal completely sapped the confidence and before you know it we have conceded a hat-full. This has happened to loads of teams over the years.

I liked what SA said after the game and it gave me some hope that maybe all is not lost. Hope we can get our new recruits into the team for Stoke and we might just have a chance

Formation is not the set up. I have no problem with 4-5-1 or 3-5-2, but the personel and the jobs assigned seemed exactly the same as midweek and far too conservative for me. I know it could of worked out differently if we didn't hand them two goals, especially two such very soft goals, but as usual we shot ourselves in the foot.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Aray Flag South London 04 Feb 17 9.56pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Formation is not the set up. I have no problem with 4-5-1 or 3-5-2, but the personel and the jobs assigned seemed exactly the same as midweek and far too conservative for me. I know it could of worked out differently if we didn't hand them two goals, especially two such very soft goals, but as usual we shot ourselves in the foot.

winning team with no injuries demand an unchanged team. at least SA said the right things in the post-match interview. no hiding the truth.

 

bashy2 Flag London 04 Feb 17 9.58pm

new signing ain't the answer its the pathetic egos of the players WE already have that's the problem we are going down and wouldn't be surprised if we do a wolves and go down to league one its happened before and I wouldn't be surprised if it happens to palace wins breed confidence and the way we are going its definitely a possibility

 

Legal_Eagle11 Flag Essex 04 Feb 17 10.04pm

Originally posted by askyourself

Just back from the game.
That was horrible.
The worse thing for me was the way so many Palace fans are so quick to turn on their own team. Even a square pass in the face of a packed defence attracted huge moans.
The booing is self-destructive. If you want to demoralise your own team and boost the oppo, that's what you do. It made us fans look poor and fair-weather, light-weights.
I hate it and feel that part of the fans efforts today was worse than what I saw on the pitch.
My friends know I'm Palace, so now I'll be associated with a light-weight bunch of footy fans.
My opinion

This comment - seriously? You want a round of applause at half time?

The players have demoralised me for 18 months.

 

McPalace Flag Carshalton Village 04 Feb 17 10.05pm

Was shocked and disappointed to hear some supporters sing for Speroni, that's gonna do Hennessy a lot of good during the match, leave the name calling till after the game has ended

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 04 Feb 17 10.27pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

There is nothing wrong with playing 3 at the back and 1 up-front at home. Chelsea have played the same system home and away all season. (No I know we are not Chelsea but the system can work home and/or away.)

We did not lose because the players didn't try or because of the system. We made a bad mistake for the first goal and for nearly half an hour the team looked like we were back in it. The second goal completely sapped the confidence and before you know it we have conceded a hat-full. This has happened to loads of teams over the years.

I liked what SA said after the game and it gave me some hope that maybe all is not lost. Hope we can get our new recruits into the team for Stoke and we might just have a chance

This formation can work well but it just doesn't work for us. Our main strength over the past few years has been our players on the wing but with this system it means that we only really have one player who is wide and no real support for them. I couldn't really tell where Wilf and Macca had been told to play, they were not able to be effective and this was partly due to the fact that Punch and Cabaye/Ledders were way too deep. Having wingbacks instead of full backs didn't really work defensively either, they kept getting caught up the field (well ward more than Patrick). Also even with Wilf and Macca behind Benteke, he was still isolated

 

mattteo Flag 04 Feb 17 10.37pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

There is nothing wrong with playing 3 at the back and 1 up-front at home. Chelsea have played the same system home and away all season.

One of Chelsea's back 3 defenders is Azpilicueta, who is actually a fullback. The right wing is Moses, an attacking player. Notice the difference between him and Ward?? On the left, they have another player great going forward- Marcos Alonso.
Their 2 defensive midfielders have been box-to-box this season, with more assists than any other central midfielders.

So there's a difference between what Chelsea plays and what Palace plays. Look at Hull, they've been the worst side using 3-5-2. New manager, switched to 4-4-2 and beat Liverpool and drew with United.
So 3-5-2 is only very rarely a system that gets you somewhere in the championship (where you need to accumulate points). In cup competitions it's another discussion, I agree

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 04 Feb 17 11.04pm

Originally posted by askyourself

Just back from the game.
That was horrible.
The worse thing for me was the way so many Palace fans are so quick to turn on their own team. Even a square pass in the face of a packed defence attracted huge moans.
The booing is self-destructive. If you want to demoralise your own team and boost the oppo, that's what you do. It made us fans look poor and fair-weather, light-weights.
I hate it and feel that part of the fans efforts today was worse than what I saw on the pitch.
My friends know I'm Palace, so now I'll be associated with a light-weight bunch of footy fans.
My opinion

Agreed, before the collapse. Certainly doesn't help

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

slubglurge Flag welling 04 Feb 17 11.50pm

The biggest problem we've got is that Sunderland Hull and Swansea have all improved and most damning is that they are up for the fight whereas we are not and if you havent got that at the bottom you are finished

 

Coach 3 Flag Sandown Isle of Wight 05 Feb 17 12.38am

I've just got home following the game, like many others I have to travel a good distance to attend "home" games. The traveling time does give you time to reflect on the game.

Today's performance was beyond poor. The reaction of the fans at half time was the worst I've ever seen at selhurst in 44 years of having a season ticket. It may well have been over the top but showed that the supporters care. On the day the players simply weren't up for the fight, some of the performances were to say the least unprofessional. it would be easy to critiscise, god knows we could all name 5 players who shouldn't be in the team for the next match. It won't help. I would like to hear something from the team, not the manager, the team apologising for that display. It's time the team stood up to be counted. We can all have a bad day but the lack of effort in the last 15 minutes of the first half was inexcusable.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 05 Feb 17 7.34am

Originally posted by Izmo

If we are south London's number one, wouldn't want to be in number 2's pants!

Especially if their fall-out is greater.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 05 Feb 17 8.28am

Originally posted by cpj

On what basis? Did nothing when he played for us, except let is some very weak goals (Defoe scored two at their place against him). Speroni hasn't had a clean sheet in his last 14 league games. The problem is not the keeper.

Not all of the problem, BUT a VERY large part of the problem. Hennessey for a tall guy doesnt command his area at all, and he seems unable to catch the ball cleanly, usually dropping it. Decision making is appalling, just not a good keeper at all, certainly not at Premier level. We are almost starting at 1-0 down when he plays, defence has no confidence in him...He must go soon if we are to have a chance of staying up,if he plays v Stoke after that, we will lose..

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 05 Feb 17 8.45am

There seems so much blame for the players and far less for Allardyce. Imho, it was clear to see where the problem was from the start and it was all down to Allardyce's choices.

The most glaring mistake was with Puncheon and McCarthur. Simply swapping them would have gone a fair way to helping. Punch was clueless, lacked any confidence, weak in the challenge and had zero positional disciple. His ball rention was alarmingly low (two shockers on the first 5mins set the tone).
Ward and Zaha needed a player inside them to create the triangles up the wing that they so desperately needed but Punch and the manager didn't see it.
And in spite of such a woeful performance, Punch gets to stay on the pitch and we watched Jimmy Mac get taken off. So many boos at that decision but I guess we all saw it very differently to our knowledgable manager.

Another clanger was bringing on Ledley. Aside from the goal, Sunderland were no great shakes but they were seemingly able to wander through central midfield. Surely, once Cabaye had to go off, dropping McArthur into his natural position and bringing on Townsend would have kept a more similar balance to the initial set-up that Allardyce had chosen? Ledley's penchant for playing two yards inside and ahead of left-back has me aghast but hey, what do any of us know? We aren't getting paid millions so our understanding of the game is clearly zero.

So then we go a second goal down. At this point, surely the alarm bells are ringing and swapping a centre-back for Townsend, dropping McArthur into inside right and bringing Townsend on is required? 1. To give us more attacking threat and 2. To shore up our absent midfield?
But no Big Sam stands there, doesn't waver, doesn't consult his coaching staff and just watches on as the disaster unfolds.

I am upset by everything yesterday but can only hope that the mistakes by so many, are learnt from and we never see such a debacle again.

 


Spirit of 1974

Zschopautaler Flag 05 Feb 17 8.59am

The injury to Cabaye and subsequent substitution changed the game plan but 2 goals in injury time of the first half should not be allowed to happen. Sam we were assured by his self would eradicate this problem. He has had 7 games to work on this problem.
Why isnt Benteke doing the same as Defoe he certainly has the ability? I still tip Suderland to go down but at least they give themselves a chance by playing to Defoes strengths. Unless we can get Benteke scoring goals again we are staring relegation in the face. Keeping clean sheets although needed are not going to keep us up and are looking highly unabtainable. In 7 games we have kept 1 clean sheet and conceded 13 goals.

 

Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Sunderland Match Thread