You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 17 of 71 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Oct 18 12.38pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Yup they have only won eleven straight already this season without atmosphere. Hell even we have won four away without "atmosphere". But of course there are still those who think if the HF had been in situ Sakho would not have missed the header against Newcastle or Benteke against Soton or Schlupp from close range against Wolves.

I don’t think that but they may have felt that inspiration to push that little bit more in this division of fine margins. You also know I wouldn’t have felt as hopeful going into April over the last 9 seasons going into April in silence or chants lasting 7 seconds. I’ve seen some of the relegated teams live going into squeaky bvm time and I didn’t think it looked good for them. Luckily that was them and not us.

 


COYP

Eagles05 Flag 26 Oct 18 12.44pm

What a very sad situation. Such a shame that fans are turning against other over this. Personally think the abuse the HF are getting over this is very wrong. Is it not SP telling season tickets holders they have to move? The HF have just asked the question, and SP is rightly or wrongly agreeing to it. Not attending because their initial request was denied isn't good though. But are the constant jibes at being spotty school kids dressed in black just as childish?
Also, should you really be entitled to keep your seat season after season? What if someone else would like to experience that view? Do they just have to wait until the current occupier's life comes to an end?
Suppose this is a bit of a pointless post, and there isn't really a solution to keep all involved happy.
Just hope we can all have something to cheer about on Sunday. Surely doesn't matter where you're sat then.....

 

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 26 Oct 18 12.51pm

Originally posted by eagleman13


What popular opinion? Where? HF or CPFC PR? BBC? Sky? BBS? i could go on. Have you asked anyone who is going to lose out from Block E? There are posts on here to explain the rubbish they've been offered.


Btw, there were far more honest, loyal, long standing fans outside Lloyds & on the march than the 'so-called' HF.

Edited by eagleman13 (21 Oct 2018 10.40am)


Apparently the HF were outside Barclays!

 


All good. Nothing bad.

i8clowntown Flag sunny essex 26 Oct 18 12.54pm

Originally posted by Eagles05

What a very sad situation. Such a shame that fans are turning against other over this. Personally think the abuse the HF are getting over this is very wrong. Is it not SP telling season tickets holders they have to move? The HF have just asked the question, and SP is rightly or wrongly agreeing to it. Not attending because their initial request was denied isn't good though. But are the constant jibes at being spotty school kids dressed in black just as childish?
Also, should you really be entitled to keep your seat season after season? What if someone else would like to experience that view? Do they just have to wait until the current occupier's life comes to an end?
Suppose this is a bit of a pointless post, and there isn't really a solution to keep all involved happy.
Just hope we can all have something to cheer about on Sunday. Surely doesn't matter where you're sat then.....


You think the reaction the HF are getting is wrong? But like when the oiks stopped 200 fans with tickets at Brighton from getting in... &#129300;

 


Twitter, message boards and Facebook give the tw@ts a voice. The kind of people you'd ignore in the pub.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 26 Oct 18 12.57pm

Originally posted by Eagles05

What a very sad situation. Such a shame that fans are turning against other over this. Personally think the abuse the HF are getting over this is very wrong. Is it not SP telling season tickets holders they have to move? The HF have just asked the question, and SP is rightly or wrongly agreeing to it. Not attending because their initial request was denied isn't good though. But are the constant jibes at being spotty school kids dressed in black just as childish?
Also, should you really be entitled to keep your seat season after season? What if someone else would like to experience that view? Do they just have to wait until the current occupier's life comes to an end?
Suppose this is a bit of a pointless post, and there isn't really a solution to keep all involved happy.
Just hope we can all have something to cheer about on Sunday. Surely doesn't matter where you're sat then.....

If you had supported palace all your life, been sitting with your wife and son in the same seat for many years, building up friendships with the people around you. Then told you've got to move so that a 'singer' can have your seat. With no guarantee that you will he able to get seats together with wife and kid next season. How would you feel?

 

Eagles05 Flag 26 Oct 18 1.02pm

Yes I do. Certainly not condoning their actions in some instances, but generally they are a positive aspect of our fan base.

Originally posted by i8clowntown


You think the reaction the HF are getting is wrong? But like when the oiks stopped 200 fans with tickets at Brighton from getting in... &#129300;

 

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Oct 18 1.06pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I don’t think that but they may have felt that inspiration to push that little bit more in this division of fine margins. You also know I wouldn’t have felt as hopeful going into April over the last 9 seasons going into April in silence or chants lasting 7 seconds. I’ve seen some of the relegated teams live going into squeaky bvm time and I didn’t think it looked good for them. Luckily that was them and not us.

You really think that a 100 people singing and banging a drum makes the players give a little more? The other 25,000 have no effect at all then

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 26 Oct 18 1.09pm

Whether fans or fore or against, can we not just move on and support the team.

It’s just a seat at a football match. I too am upset and feel this could be handled a lot better. I personally don’t agree with how certain parties have gone about certain things. But there is zero that can be done.

Just move on

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Oct 18 1.09pm

Originally posted by Painter

You really think that a 100 people singing and banging a drum makes the players give a little more? The other 25,000 have no effect at all then

It starts with the 100 HF and spreads to more hundreds and at times, thousands. The other 22,000 don’t start anything or if they do, it fizzles out fast. Remember the ‘90s and after Goldberg?

 


COYP

Dip Flag 26 Oct 18 1.26pm

I, as are the vast majority, am aligned with the club on this .Watching Sporting Lisbon's singing section fans ie the entire stand behind the goal, continually vocally back the team as they created chances ,despite going behind, gave us a vision of what the Selhurst atmosphere could become once the section has been established.
The decision is made - let's get on with it .

One question - will we see the return of the HF section at a home game soon - boy we need all the help we can get ?

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 26 Oct 18 2.03pm

Originally posted by Painter

Utter nonsense, atmosphere has nothing at to do with performance or results. Arsenal play in silence at the Emirates, it hasn’t done them any harm. When results started to fall, I didn’t hear about them demanding a singing section, just get rid of Wenger.

For many, the return of the HF is not about results and performance. It's about enjoying the Selhurst Park atmosphere and day out, which has been terrific, and to support Palace - win, lose or draw. Results are secondary to me.

After how unenjoyable the Southampton game was, due to atmosphere, not performance, I won't be returning until the HF are back. I'm sure I'm not alone in this and many fans feel the same.

 

Eagles05 Flag 26 Oct 18 2.20pm

I have, and also sit with my wife and son, in Block G. I do feel for you, however refuse to believe the club won't be able to find 3 seats together for you. We have about 17K season ticket holders don't we? That leaves 8500 of which are 'free'. My wife and son struggle to see when everyone stands in block G, so I'm sure the HF moving will affect us too. Guess we'd just have to move elsewhere. As long as we're watching somewhere not a huge problem.

Originally posted by spartakev2

If you had supported palace all your life, been sitting with your wife and son in the same seat for many years, building up friendships with the people around you. Then told you've got to move so that a 'singer' can have your seat. With no guarantee that you will he able to get seats together with wife and kid next season. How would you feel?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Oct 18 2.21pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

After how unenjoyable the Southampton game was, due to atmosphere, not performance, I won't be returning until the HF are back. I'm sure I'm not alone in this and many fans feel the same.

Quite right too and I'm not going back until the burgers have improved

 

Cpfc_eagles18 Flag 26 Oct 18 3.08pm

Any chance of the HF being in block b on Sunday?

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 26 Oct 18 3.10pm

Originally posted by turbohorsebox


Apparently the HF were outside Barclays!

WOW . . Do you have anything constructive to add to this debate, or, just thought you'd take a swipe at me?

-.-'

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Oct 18 3.38pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Quite right too and I'm not going back until the burgers have improved

He really means no atmosphere, and with no BF, there’s no atmosphere. It’s not the HF that people miss per se, it’s the atmosphere. People don’t go to a restaurant just for the food. They’ll go for the ambience too. We’ve lost lots of fans in the past because the atmosphere can be poor. We have the chance to prevent some of that dip in crowds happening in the future.

 


COYP

Turd Alert Flag Woldingham 26 Oct 18 3.42pm

That seat in block E is not of your ownership. The simple fact of the matter is the club by a way of contract allow the recipient a license to occupy that seat. It is their property, what they do with it, is - unfortunately or fortunately depending on what side of the fence you sit on - their right.

These memories, friendships and so forth are all collateral damage unfortunately.

It is sad, but the show must go on!

 


RIP staffie

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 26 Oct 18 5.06pm

Originally posted by Turd Alert

That seat in block E is not of your ownership. The simple fact of the matter is the club by a way of contract allow the recipient a license to occupy that seat. It is their property, what they do with it, is - unfortunately or fortunately depending on what side of the fence you sit on - their right.

These memories, friendships and so forth are all collateral damage unfortunately.

It is sad, but the show must go on!

So, what if season after next, after the so-called HF have had their way, SP decidies, that NO, he doesn't want them in Block E, he wants them out becos of more 'favourable & profitable' fans, will you still say the same?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

bicycle repair man 26 Oct 18 5.35pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

If you had supported palace all your life, been sitting with your wife and son in the same seat for many years, building up friendships with the people around you. Then told you've got to move so that a 'singer' can have your seat. With no guarantee that you will he able to get seats together with wife and kid next season. How would you feel?

A splendid heartfelt response,that sums up the whole situation in a nutshell,and shows how little thought Parish has given to this mess,caused totally by the HF.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 26 Oct 18 5.46pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

A splendid heartfelt response,that sums up the whole situation in a nutshell,and shows how little thought Parish has given to this mess,caused totally by the HF.

True, this HF fiasco is the biggest cock up I've ever known in a lifetime of following Palace. It is a farce of monumental proportions.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Page 17 of 71 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic