You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson has to go


Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 20 Jan 19 1.11am

I think it's easy to criticize after a game.. god knows i do it, but i do think he is the best bet until the end of the year.

The board, in my opinion should be on the phone to a new manager, let's say wagner, get him lined up for the summer and have him do his homework from now and until then with who we will ship out, who he will be left with, what he wants to do with them and then who he wants to buy in with what cash he will have.

 


This was once a quality forum....

essetwentyone Flag london 20 Jan 19 6.54am

As a counter attacking team I can see why we do well away from home where we have scored 8 goals in the last 3 games but I just don’t see why we play so defensively at home - I goal and 1 point from the last 3 at Selhurst?
We’ve shown that we can score so Roy needs to adopt a more attacking style for most home games and rotate players more.
Give us something better to watch at home than the recent boring style!

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 20 Jan 19 7.07am

The Team The Management could not be doing any better to keep us in the prem. Will people please stop fxxking whinging. We are Palace, we are not a top 6 side we not even a middle ranking side given theb money this club can generate. Enjoy the ride Today we played really well liverpool we lucky werem't end of the day

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 20 Jan 19 8.15am

Hodgson to STAY in my books. Has Palace coursing through his veins and has what it takes to keep us up and beyond.

Team downfall continues to be non-satisfactory progress made in transfer windows of late as we are witnessing at present.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 20 Jan 19 8.50am

Hodgson to stay for me.
Seen some of the best football played under Roy whilst our defensive record is the best in the league outside the top 4.
Our only issue is scoring goals and it’s no surprise considering we’ve not had an out and out striker for months. Yet we still create opportunities at home and most definitely away, it’s not Roy’s fault Zaha can’t put away a 1 on 1 against Watford or worse Mcarthur misses a tap in and this has be continuing theme throughout the season. He’s not perfect but none of our players are either, otherwise they’d be at a bigger club. We’re Palace a team striving for mid table.
His persistence with Schlupp as an impact sub is frustrating but he brought on Wickham and Meyer and they combined for the 3rd goal. Let’s hope this gives him something to think about for Spurs next weekend.

People calling for Wagner leaves my mind boggled. Took Huddersfield up with a negative goal difference and continued playing the most boring defensive football for 2 more seasons before giving up.. No thanks.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 20 Jan 19 9.47am

Originally posted by A89M

Hodgson to stay for me.
Seen some of the best football played under Roy whilst our defensive record is the best in the league outside the top 4.
Our only issue is scoring goals and it’s no surprise considering we’ve not had an out and out striker for months. Yet we still create opportunities at home and most definitely away, it’s not Roy’s fault Zaha can’t put away a 1 on 1 against Watford or worse Mcarthur misses a tap in and this has be continuing theme throughout the season. He’s not perfect but none of our players are either, otherwise they’d be at a bigger club. We’re Palace a team striving for mid table.
His persistence with Schlupp as an impact sub is frustrating but he brought on Wickham and Meyer and they combined for the 3rd goal. Let’s hope this gives him something to think about for Spurs next weekend.

People calling for Wagner leaves my mind boggled. Took Huddersfield up with a negative goal difference and continued playing the most boring defensive football for 2 more seasons before giving up.. No thanks.

i was one of those saying Wagner only if Roy goes,no money championship side and he got the best out of them, didnt they batter us before Wilf scored,also 2 mangers come to mind who everyone wanted to keep but played defensive football,Pullis,Big Sam ,

so going back to Roy he hasnt had a fit striker or a striker inform from the start,so who ever comes in has the same probs, just like other teams in the bottom 14 we are looking for that striker who will get 15+ goals a season,not easy

 

A89M Flag Streatham 20 Jan 19 10.03am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

i was one of those saying Wagner only if Roy goes,no money championship side and he got the best out of them, didnt they batter us before Wilf scored,also 2 mangers come to mind who everyone wanted to keep but played defensive football,Pullis,Big Sam ,

so going back to Roy he hasnt had a fit striker or a striker inform from the start,so who ever comes in has the same probs, just like other teams in the bottom 14 we are looking for that striker who will get 15+ goals a season,not easy

I wasn’t one of those fans wanting Allardyce, we had the players to play better football and Roy is proving that. Pulis was what we needed at the time so was more disappointed he left. Watching the highlights again, the first goal we scored was brilliant, worked out from the back and obviously set up brilliantly by wilf, we just wouldn’t get that with either Pulis or Allardyce and it’s proof how much we’ve improved as a team under Roy. The 3rd was lovely also.

Wagner, may be a success or he could continue to play the dull football he did with Huddersfield. We don’t know yet as he’s only shown one way of playing. Let’s see how Roy gets on with two fit out and out strikers, could be a very good second half of the season and hopefully he proves all ththe doubters wrong.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 20 Jan 19 4.04pm

Originally posted by A89M

I wasn’t one of those fans wanting Allardyce, we had the players to play better football and Roy is proving that. Pulis was what we needed at the time so was more disappointed he left. Watching the highlights again, the first goal we scored was brilliant, worked out from the back and obviously set up brilliantly by wilf, we just wouldn’t get that with either Pulis or Allardyce and it’s proof how much we’ve improved as a team under Roy. The 3rd was lovely also.

Wagner, may be a success or he could continue to play the dull football he did with Huddersfield. We don’t know yet as he’s only shown one way of playing. Let’s see how Roy gets on with two fit out and out strikers, could be a very good second half of the season and hopefully he proves all ththe doubters wrong.

yes so many if factors hope we do have that holy grail of a striker who can score at least 15 goals,im still not worried looking more at next season in the prem

 

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Jan 19 4.05pm

Originally posted by A89M

Hodgson to stay for me.
Seen some of the best football played under Roy whilst our defensive record is the best in the league outside the top 4.
Our only issue is scoring goals and it’s no surprise considering we’ve not had an out and out striker for months. Yet we still create opportunities at home and most definitely away, it’s not Roy’s fault Zaha can’t put away a 1 on 1 against Watford or worse Mcarthur misses a tap in and this has be continuing theme throughout the season. He’s not perfect but none of our players are either, otherwise they’d be at a bigger club. We’re Palace a team striving for mid table.
His persistence with Schlupp as an impact sub is frustrating but he brought on Wickham and Meyer and they combined for the 3rd goal. Let’s hope this gives him something to think about for Spurs next weekend.

People calling for Wagner leaves my mind boggled. Took Huddersfield up with a negative goal difference and continued playing the most boring defensive football for 2 more seasons before giving up.. No thanks.

It was until yesterday, now 3 clubs outside top 4 have a better goals against.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 20 Jan 19 4.16pm

Originally posted by Painter

It was until yesterday, now 3 clubs outside top 4 have a better goals against.

yer right so 7 teams in that league have better defensive records 4 in the top 4 the other 3 are 2 to 3 goals better stop nit picking

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 20 Jan 19 4.28pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

You mean there's more than one of you? Good Grief. Go and support City or someone.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 20 Jan 19 4.30pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Given his importance in proceedings today that kinda proves further that you were talking out of your trousers.


 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 20 Jan 19 4.41pm

I'm really torn about Roy.
Pros.
Team are playing for him.
Sets us up very well, so we always have a chance.
Very level headed.
Not gonna storm off if we don't buy enough or the players he wants. Which if you believe the anti Parish brigade is why TP and SA left.


Cons.
Think he uses his squad very poorly.
Game management has IMO let us down regularly this season. Subs and timing an issue.
Set plays have been dire.
Plays too safe at home.
Very loyal, but that loyalty could lead to injuries in the run in.

In his defence he is working with a squad assembled by Pulis, Warnock, Pardew, Big Sam and FdB. I'm sure he's wanted to bring in players and I'm sure if we could we would, but FFP on the wages appears to be the problem. Plus he can't score the open goals we've missed all season long.

So all things considered, I'm just not sure what's for the best?


Edited by Dangermouse (21 Jan 2019 7.51pm)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

michaelpearce Flag grays 20 Jan 19 5.01pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

I'm really torn about Roy.
Pros.
Team are playing for him.
Sets us up very well, so we always have a chance.
Very level headed.
Not gonna storm off if we don't buy enough or the players he wants. Which if you believe the anti Parish brigade is why TP and SA left.
Play too safe at home.

Cons.
Think he uses his squad very poorly.
Game management has IMO let us down regularly this season. Subs and timing an issue.
Set plays have been dire.
Very loyal, but that loyalty could lead to injuries in the run in.

In his defence he is working with a squad assembled by Pulis, Warnock, Pardew, Big Sam and FdB. I'm sure he's wanted to bring in players and I'm sure if we could we would, but FFP on the wages appears to be the problem. Plus he can't score the open goals we've missed all season long.

So all things considered, I'm just not sure what's for the best?


how true only the older ones understand

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 20 Jan 19 5.28pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

I'm really torn about Roy.
Pros.
Team are playing for him.
Sets us up very well, so we always have a chance.
Very level headed.
Not gonna storm off if we don't buy enough or the players he wants. Which if you believe the anti Parish brigade is why TP and SA left.
Play too safe at home.

Cons.
Think he uses his squad very poorly.
Game management has IMO let us down regularly this season. Subs and timing an issue.
Set plays have been dire.
Very loyal, but that loyalty could lead to injuries in the run in.

In his defence he is working with a squad assembled by Pulis, Warnock, Pardew, Big Sam and FdB. I'm sure he's wanted to bring in players and I'm sure if we could we would, but FFP on the wages appears to be the problem. Plus he can't score the open goals we've missed all season long.

So all things considered, I'm just not sure what's for the best?


It's not going to happen at the moment, but fresh legs are much needed. Roy only has a plan A, and there is nothing else. I appreciate that he doesn't have that much to work with, but some of these players are on 130k a week. Run around. Work hard. Let's not have 8 defensive players at home. First 11 are pretty decent, but being used wrongly. Look at Manure, fresh outlook, players enjoying their roles.

 

timmyb Flag Banstead 20 Jan 19 5.54pm

Reasons to be cheerful, in no particular order...

4 unexpected points from trips to Manchester

Only team to score three against liverpool all season.

Goals beginning to come from everyone apart from centre forwards who are largely there in decoy capacity only.

Already played Liverpool and Chelsea twice.

Goal difference not bad at all

Our manager is a Palace fan.

AWB is great and has single footedly brought the slide tackle back in fashion

Delete / add as you seem fit

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 20 Jan 19 6.23pm

With our team we should realistically be 9th-12th. Under Hodgson we'll most likely finish 13th-15th.

We're at a crossroads, a mid-table crisis that every team experiences.

What do we actually want? That's the Premier League problem. A mid table side can't be satisfied.

Hodgson is slightly underachieving but not Pardew levels of desperation. In the Championship you always have the aim of getting to the Premier League.

In the Premier League it's an existential crisis. Enjoy it while it lasts.

 

timmyb Flag Banstead 20 Jan 19 9.06pm

For starters, play like we did yesterday in the cup next week. Put out a decent team, be bold and have a go at a weakened Spurs team. I don't see how a damp squib exit from the cup would help our league form at all.

It doesn't need to follow that a cup run goes hand in hand with a slump in the league like it did under Pards in 2016. It didn't do us any harm in 1990...it built momentum.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jan 19 7.42am

Originally posted by timmyb

For starters, play like we did yesterday in the cup next week. Put out a decent team, be bold and have a go at a weakened Spurs team. I don't see how a damp squib exit from the cup would help our league form at all.

It doesn't need to follow that a cup run goes hand in hand with a slump in the league like it did under Pards in 2016. It didn't do us any harm in 1990...it built momentum.

We don’t have a huge amount of choice as to who we pick as the squad is now so thin?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 21 Jan 19 8.54am

Originally posted by timmyb

For starters, play like we did yesterday in the cup next week. Put out a decent team, be bold and have a go at a weakened Spurs team. I don't see how a damp squib exit from the cup would help our league form at all.

It doesn't need to follow that a cup run goes hand in hand with a slump in the league like it did under Pards in 2016. It didn't do us any harm in 1990...it built momentum.

We play Spurs Sunday then Saints on Wednesday. Saints have the weekend off. We can't afford to play a full strength team in my opinion. If we were half a dozen points better off I'd agree with you, but we're not, so I say put in the reserves where possible and let them battle it out with Spurs' reserves. Definitely bring Ward, Kelly and Dann in. Give Meyer 90 minutes and also give Wickham a start (if he's up to it). Also, please don't risk Zaha, as he has lost his invincibility when it comes to injuries. Maybe Kai Kai can get another chance before we offload him?

 

Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go