This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I wouldn't be proud to say it but it isn't racist and that's what is being discussed. Why wouldn't you be proud to say it.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
| Pussay Patrol |
|
|---|---|
|
Racism is born out of ignorance and immaturity, both attributes being displayed on this thread
Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah |
|
|
Originally posted by Pussay Patrol
Racism is born out of ignorance and immaturity, both attributes being displayed on this thread
Personal opinion : language and religion matter. Far happier to see immigrants from : Australia, ireland, new Zealand, USA, Zimbabwe, afrikaaners, Canada etc... especially if those family roots mirror ours. Nothing to do with race .... but everybody else can join the back of the queue , especially those groups who hate us and always cause trouble or always scrounging.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It seems to me that you are proposing an equivalence that is incorrect. These terms are used for different reasons because of different circumstances. It is because of racism that "Black and proud" has grown as a means for people of colour to establish respect and gain dignity when in the past they were considered as lesser beings by those with white skins. It is because of racist attitudes that "White and proud", as used by particular groups of white skinned people, has been tainted with sinister attributes. If the day ever arrives when both terms mean the same to everyone then I for one will be very happy that racism has been eliminated throughout society. Right now there is no equivalence. As with so many things context is everything and to ignore it is misleading or even possibly dangerously disingenuous. I know exactly why you believe this but your attitude has very short term credibility which is quickly running out. We all know about recent Black history in the West but the idea that one group has to retain guilt for this history and be deprived of racial pride while everyone else can freely express it is bonkers. It is as racist as you can get. Slavery and subsequent persecution of Black people was a symptom of the prevailing circumstances. It was a consequence of human behaviour that has probably existed since there have been humans. It was a tiny blip in the grand scheme of history. If you think that one particular demographic should feel an endless responsibility for that and have to hang their heads till the end of time, then you are a lunatic.
Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Apr 2019 5.05pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pussay Patrol
Racism is born out of ignorance and immaturity, both attributes being displayed on this thread
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I know exactly why you believe this but your attitude has very short term credibility which is quickly running out. We all know about recent Black history in the West but the idea that one group has to retain guilt for this history and be deprived of racial pride while everyone else can freely express it is bonkers. It is as racist as you can get. Slavery and subsequent persecution of Black people was a symptom of the prevailing circumstances. It was a consequence of human behaviour that has probably existed since there have been humans. It was a tiny blip in the grand scheme of history. If you think that one particular demographic should feel an endless responsibility for that and have to hang their heads till the end of time, then you are a lunatic.
Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Apr 2019 5.05pm) There is more than a hint of original sin to the idea of white guilt. It also ignores the fact that almost everyone else is descended from a long line of serfs and peasants rather than exploitative fat cats. If any of my ancestors exploited anyone they must’ve been spectacularly bad at it because they didn’t leave me a pit to hiss in.
|
|
|
From a few years ago...the pushers of 'white guilt' doing a bit of perverse physical enactment. Whoever the parents of this child are they are a disgrace....child abuse. Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Apr 2019 5.44pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
From a few years ago...the pushers of 'white guilt' doing a bit of perverse physical enactment. Whoever the parents of this child are they are a disgrace....child abuse. Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Apr 2019 5.44pm) Bah. They used to do that to us at school for forgetting our PE kit.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Bah. They used to do that to us at school for forgetting our PE kit. Historically part related to slave owners......The sins of the fathers visited onto the god knows how distant children.....and all voluntarily.....perverse.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Historically part related to slave owners......The sins of the fathers visited onto the god knows how distant children.....and all voluntarily.....perverse. Why idiots feel responsible for their ancestor's behaviour regarding anything is beyond me. These people are loons.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Why idiots feel responsible for their ancestor's behaviour regarding anything is beyond me. These people are loons. Obviously been listening to people like Wisbech....someone needs to give them the directions to Wakanda.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Obviously been listening to people like Wisbech....someone needs to give them the directions to Wakanda. Giving them the number for a mental health clinic might serve them better.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Historically part related to slave owners......The sins of the fathers visited onto the god knows how distant children.....and all voluntarily.....perverse. Well, yes. Why not also assume a relationship to abolitionists, charity workers and other saintly individuals then we could all feel good about ourselves.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well essentially you are on here stating that it's fine for black people to state 'black and proud' but there are 'racist attitudes' around saying 'white and proud'. I'm ok for others to conclude as to where the 'racism' is there. The previous posts are there to read. I defend your right to hold hypocritical views on race if you want to....you certainly aren't alone. But you are rightly open to criticism for these views from the right....well, I know some on the left who wouldn't like them as well. I asked you to tell me which Conservative in history has publicly stated your views on white people here. You failed to provide one. I certainly can't think of one and that's even amongst the ridiculous collection we have at the moment. Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Apr 2019 2.15pm) I think you are talking complete nonsense. No-where have I suggested that I even have a view on white people because I don't, anymore than I have a view on black people. No public figure can express views that don't exist! All I have said is that the two claims need to be seen in context because context matters. Both could be racist, just as both might not be. It is though more understandable for those who have suffered exclusion and prejudice to try to raise their profile by reacting to that prejudice than it is for those from that part of the community who created that prejudice in the first place. Exactly the same would apply if, in a predominately black skinned country, white skinned people were previously marginalised. Historically though that doesn't seem to have happened does it? "White and proud", as used today, communicates a distasteful message, even if you cannot recognise it, whilst "British and proud" does not. There is nothing hypocritical involved in facing up to the truth.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Why idiots feel responsible for their ancestor's behaviour regarding anything is beyond me. These people are loons. They need to watch the black historian seeing it for what it is. A historical passage of time and not an everlasting grudge, score to settle or to be ashamed of in generations before you were sperm.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Park Road
Why wouldn't you be proud to say it? I wouldn't be proud because I have no interest whatsoever in that type of culture. However, so long as they don't interfere with the lives of others that's OK with me.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I think you are talking complete nonsense. No-where have I suggested that I even have a view on white people because I don't, anymore than I have a view on black people. No public figure can express views that don't exist! Not true because you stated an opinion of how people should feel over their race just a couple of posts ago. To quote you, you stated that: 'It is because of racist attitudes that "White and proud", as used by particular groups of white skinned people, has been tainted with sinister attributes.' This is you smearing white people who would say 'white and proud'......This smearing only exists because people like you do it. Yet for black people you stated: 'It is because of racism that "Black and proud" has grown as a means for people of colour to establish respect and gain dignity when in the past they were considered as lesser beings by those with white skins'. Hence you state that it's ok for one group and not ok with another based purely upon your definition of the past and what is and isn't valid. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
All I have said is that the two claims need to be seen in context because context matters. Both could be racist, just as both might not be. All you are doing is suggesting that your idea of 'racism' is justified because of the 'context' that you personally believe in. Yet the 'context' of those that you don't agree with you ....well, that doesn't appear to matter. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It is though more understandable for those who have suffered exclusion and prejudice to try to raise their profile by reacting to that prejudice than it is for those from that part of the community who created that prejudice in the first place. Exactly the same would apply if, in a predominately black skinned country, white skinned people were previously marginalised. Historically though that doesn't seem to have happened does it? "White and proud", as used today, communicates a distasteful message, even if you cannot recognise it, whilst "British and proud" does not. There is nothing hypocritical involved in facing up to the truth. It's a double standard pure and simple. You spoke about black people being regarded as 'lesser beings' and here you refer to the 'exclusion' of people, yet this is precisely what you do when you demonise one set of people for having pride in their genetic heritage.....yet say it's alright for another. As for white people being 'previously marginalized', haven't you heard of 'white slavery'? Don't you know anything about the history of the middle east? Perhaps because certain groups don't practice victimisation as much as others you just don't know. 'White and Proud' is just as valid as 'Black and Proud' and anything saying otherwise is discriminating upon the basis of skin colour.....and by the very definition practicising that most terrible of crimes. Stupidity. Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Apr 2019 7.06pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I think you are talking complete nonsense. No-where have I suggested that I even have a view on white people because I don't, anymore than I have a view on black people. No public figure can express views that don't exist! All I have said is that the two claims need to be seen in context because context matters. Both could be racist, just as both might not be. It is though more understandable for those who have suffered exclusion and prejudice to try to raise their profile by reacting to that prejudice than it is for those from that part of the community who created that prejudice in the first place. Exactly the same would apply if, in a predominately black skinned country, white skinned people were previously marginalised. Historically though that doesn't seem to have happened does it? "White and proud", as used today, communicates a distasteful message, even if you cannot recognise it, whilst "British and proud" does not. There is nothing hypocritical involved in facing up to the truth.
There is clearly no difference between White and Black pride. It is racist to believe otherwise. You can't justify penalising one demographic simply because at one brief time in history some of them exploited other people for profit who happened to be Black. Get off your narrow minded, self righteous high horse and consider how ridiculous that is in the grand scheme.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Not true because you stated an opinion of how people should feel over their race just a couple of posts ago. To quote you, you stated that: 'It is because of racist attitudes that "White and proud", as used by particular groups of white skinned people, has been tainted with sinister attributes.' This is you smearing white people who would say 'white and proud'......This smearing only exists because people like you do it. Yet for black people you stated: 'It is because of racism that "Black and proud" has grown as a means for people of colour to establish respect and gain dignity when in the past they were considered as lesser beings by those with white skins'. Hence you state that it's ok for one group and not ok with another based purely upon your definition of the past and what is and isn't valid. More nonsense. I have not attacked white people. I have noticed before that you try to put everything into neat square boxes but things are always more nuanced than that. Look again at my quote. Do you understand the difference between "particular groups of white skinned people" and white people in general? I am not "smearing white people"! I am criticising particular people who happen to have white skins. I go on to refer to the reason why, in my view, it is more understandable for people of colour to react to historical realities which even you cannot deny. That's not attacking white people. It is stating fact.
You spoke about black people being regarded as 'lesser beings' and here you refer to the 'exclusion' of people, yet this is precisely what you do when you demonise one set of people for having pride in their genetic heritage.....yet say it's alright for another. As for white people being 'previously marginalized', haven't you heard of 'white slavery'? Don't you know anything about the history of the middle east? Perhaps because certain groups don't practice victimisation as much as others you just don't know. 'White and Proud' is just as valid as 'Black and Proud' and anything saying otherwise is discriminating upon the basis of skin colour.....and by the very definition practicising that most terrible of crimes. Stupidity. Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Apr 2019 7.06pm) The double standard exists only in your imagination. I have no problem at all in anyone having pride in their heritage. My criticism is the use of "white" to refer to it when more appropriate language would avoid the inferences which result from it's use. It's use seems a quite deliberate attempt to make a racist point which is designed to divide and not heal division. Of course I have heard of "white slavery" emanating in the middle east. I condemn any kind of slavery and would support any residual group seeking to establish their identity. It did not though happen here or to any of the groups under review. "White and Proud" is indeed as valid, and invalid, as "Black and Proud". It all depends on how, why, where and by whom it is used. In other words, on context and not just when placed in simplistic little square boxes. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (16 Apr 2019 8.04pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The double standard exists only in your imagination. I have no problem at all in anyone having pride in their heritage. My criticism is the use of "white" to refer to it when more appropriate language would avoid the inferences which result from it's use. It's use seems a quite deliberate attempt to make a racist point which is designed to divide and not heal division. The double standard exists in your very own words. You choose them, you wrote them. If you are going to state that use of a skin colour is inappropriate in some cases....I wouldn't necessarily disagree with you. However, I'm not going to attribute 'racist attitudes' to one skin colour, yet ascribe a positive intent for a different skin colour. You did. Indeed, you speak of healing divisions here, yet it was me who stated at the start that pride in your genetic heritage is fine. Sure, it's good that you recognise that this can all be perfectly valid. But it was you putting caveats in, not me......with the suspicion for one group but not the other. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Of course I have heard of "white slavery" emanating in the middle east. I condemn any kind of slavery and would support any residual group seeking to establish their identity. It did not though happen here or to any of the groups under review. Well done, you condemn slavery. Are you arguing now that the location of where 'slavery' happened is important? How far down the genetic rabbit hole do you wish to go? Why is the location important unless you are making a 'genetic' connection and responsibility argument? Personally I don't sign up to the 'sins of the grandfathers' stuff......I don't do, 'born guilty'. I sign up to the various discussions on the importance of genes but certainly not a culturally mandated way to feel about it. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
"White and Proud" is indeed as valid, and invalid, as "Black and Proud". It all depends on how, why, where and by whom it is used. In other words, on context and not just when placed in simplistic little square boxes. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (16 Apr 2019 8.04pm) I didn't give a context other than to demonstrate the double standard. I put the two statements out there to show how a certain demographic react differently to skin colour. You jumped in and proved my point. Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Apr 2019 8.29pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.