This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
Exactly this! Ever since we lost at Home to Burnley six games ago it was a nailed on cert we were going to finish 14th. No one below us could catch us and with our remaining fixtures we weren’t remotely likely to pick up sufficient points to overhaul any of the teams above us at that time (June 29th). Correct, just thankful we were safe before we faced a run in of difficult fixtures, apart from Bournemouth, they were always going to be difficult with the fight going for european places at the top the division. Those who thought we could be that fight of course were not being realistic.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Sadly you are correct, I personally believe that Roy has done an amazing job over the last three seasons in keeping us in the PL with an average squad which in the main was inherited from other managers. The loss of form of key players and injuries to an aging squad is out the managers control. The system he plays is to the strengths of those from who he has to choose from. He has made it perfectly clear over several past transfer windows that the squad needs new faces and more talent and yet he has not been backed at board level. We have DoF who appears to be useless. Those who ask for youngsters to be tried from the U23's need to look at their results, 2nd to bottom of their modest league with only 27 goals scored. To change managers now would not be sensible. Roy is the stability that we need whilst we plan for a handover towards the end of next season. In the meantime both DoF and Parish need to get active finding us some smart new talent (4/5) in key positions (ie defender, attacking midfielder and a striker at the very least). This is an excellent post and broadly I concur with the sentiments. I would add that Freedman gets ordure heaped upon him on HOL and I suspect most of his detractors are unaware of the work he does behind the scenes.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Correct, just thankful we were safe before we faced a run in of difficult fixtures, apart from Bournemouth, they were always going to be difficult with the fight going for european places at the top the division. Those who thought we could be that fight of course were not being realistic. I did comment to someone at the club that I viewed our run-in with some trepidation and that was before the 'Lockdown'. When I heard about the restart I added that my concerns were heightened due to the schedule of games and the fact that we had an aged squad.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I did comment to someone at the club that I viewed our run-in with some trepidation and that was before the 'Lockdown'. When I heard about the restart I added that my concerns were heightened due to the schedule of games and the fact that we had an aged squad. How right you have been proved, any team in PL who can only score 0.8 goals per game should under normal circumstances be relegated. We have got away with it because we had a manager who was able to deal with the squads limitations. I do wish those Roy dissenters would understands this.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
This is an excellent post and broadly I concur with the sentiments. I would add that Freedman gets ordure heaped upon him on HOL and I suspect most of his detractors are unaware of the work he does behind the scenes. We are unaware as there are never any decent signings - or even adequate cover where we have no one. Has to be the worst DOF ever witnessed.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Sadly you are correct, I personally believe that Roy has done an amazing job over the last three seasons in keeping us in the PL with an average squad which in the main was inherited from other managers. The loss of form of key players and injuries to an aging squad is out the managers control. The system he plays is to the strengths of those from who he has to choose from. He has made it perfectly clear over several past transfer windows that the squad needs new faces and more talent and yet he has not been backed at board level. We have DoF who appears to be useless. Those who ask for youngsters to be tried from the U23's need to look at their results, 2nd to bottom of their modest league with only 27 goals scored. To change managers now would not be sensible. Roy is the stability that we need whilst we plan for a handover towards the end of next season. In the meantime both DoF and Parish need to get active finding us some smart new talent (4/5) in key positions (ie defender, attacking midfielder and a striker at the very least). The problem I see is that the handover will be to a manager that would struggle to keep this aging team in the championship - it needs the handover now to prepare for promotion back out of the championship the season after next or just to make the play offs at least. This present team is heading out of the prem and I would say the championship after that :-(
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
How right you have been proved, any team in PL who can only score 0.8 goals per game should under normal circumstances be relegated. We have got away with it because we had a manager who was able to deal with the squads limitations. I do wish those Roy dissenters would understands this. For once!
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
There is always a "Bigger picture".
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace chick
The problem I see is that the handover will be to a manager that would struggle to keep this aging team in the championship - it needs the handover now to prepare for promotion back out of the championship the season after next or just to make the play offs at least. This present team is heading out of the prem and I would say the championship after that :-( Yes I agree the smart signings need to be not unlike what Sheff Utd did with 62M,they proved that good players are out there coupled with some smart loan deals. I believe they added considerably to their squad in that spend and look how well they have done. We will not attract a proven quality manager if they think the club will not invest in the team. That's why we have to be very appreciative of Roy as he has not walked away when in the past others did.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
For once! Like us all!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
There is always a "Bigger picture". Sorry Willo, but that is part and parcel of doing that job to factor these things in. if you can't do it, you're not fit for purpose. DF is not fit for purpose.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
There is always a "Bigger picture". If we have no finances, then not worth having Freedman, or any Director of Football. Free up the wages.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Sorry Willo, but that is part and parcel of doing that job to factor these things in. if you can't do it, you're not fit for purpose. DF is not fit for purpose. The point I am making is just because a club does not get some targets "Over the line" is not necessarily the fault of a 'Director of football' whose remit can be widespread depending on the TORs.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
The point I am making is just because a club does not get some targets "Over the line" is not necessarily the fault of a 'Director of football' whose remit can be widespread depending on the TORs. The buck stops with Parish and the rest of the board. At the end of the day consistent failure to improve the team will ultimately lead to failure and cost the club a fortune, in terms of value and income!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Sorry Willo, but that is part and parcel of doing that job to factor these things in. if you can't do it, you're not fit for purpose. DF is not fit for purpose. Playing Devil’s Advocate Identifies Guiata and Sorloth. The latter doesn’t get to play his natural position, ships out on loan and starts scoring again. I’m not sure Roy would be the easiest sell to an attacking player. “So Dougie, my job is to score goals” “Yes son, as long as you don’t forget you’re the first line of defence first and foremost”
|
|
|
Originally posted by robdave2k
Playing Devil’s Advocate Identifies Guiata and Sorloth. The latter doesn’t get to play his natural position, ships out on loan and starts scoring again. I’m not sure Roy would be the easiest sell to an attacking player. “So Dougie, my job is to score goals” “Yes son, as long as you don’t forget you’re the first line of defence first and foremost” Yes I do feel sorry for Dougie, it must be a tough job to have to put in a shift at the office all week and then have to go out and scout players whilst hardly getting paid for it. Oh no wait, he gets paid handsomely to watch football and identify players who will benefit our club, full time, he has the ultimate gig. If he cannot identify players who can be successfully attracted and brought into the club, within our budget and to suit the managers and teams style, he cannot do his job - it's a simple spec.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yes I do feel sorry for Dougie, it must be a tough job to have to put in a shift at the office all week and then have to go out and scout players whilst hardly getting paid for it. Oh no wait, he gets paid handsomely to watch football and identify players who will benefit our club, full time, he has the ultimate gig. If he cannot identify players who can be successfully attracted and brought into the club, within our budget and to suit the managers and teams style, he cannot do his job - it's a simple spec. I agree with you but don't forget Parish and the board are also to blame as they seem to have no vision or will to invest in the team, all the Americans want is their investment back plus interest and then to walk away!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
I agree with you but don't forget Parish and the board are also to blame as they seem to have no vision or will to invest in the team, all the Americans want is their investment back plus interest and then to walk away! No absolutely, I could rant about them seperately! I just don't buy the 'Dougie has faced obstacles' narrative. Every line of work had obstacles, it's your job to overcome them, if you don't you've failed!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
The only people saying that there's nothing to play for have been on here when slating Hodgson for not playing youngsters. blaming 'nothing to play for' is absolutely pathetic. This is competitive sport ffs. If that really were the case then it smacks of the unambitious 'our objective is to stay up each season' approach, that has lowered the players' individual and collective standards. If that's the bar that is set then that is all they will aim for. Another reason why we need a new manager who will aim higher than bare minimum.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
blaming 'nothing to play for' is absolutely pathetic. This is competitive sport ffs. If that really were the case then it smacks of the unambitious 'our objective is to stay up each season' approach, that has lowered the players' individual and collective standards. If that's the bar that is set then that is all they will aim for. Another reason why we need a new manager who will aim higher than bare minimum. I think you've misunderstood. At no time has the manager said that there is nothing to play for - quite the opposite. My point was that people were criticising Hodgson in these end of season games for not playing youngsters as there was, in their eyes, nothing to play for.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.