This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Excellent summary Willo,! Thank you very much,most kind of you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Liverpool, high press, destroyed us, Wolves the same, Man City the same. What’s the easiest way to beat a high press, take them out of the game and get them turning round and chasing the ball by playing it long to two target men and look to the two wide men to pick up the knockdowns. So what did we do against Citeh? We play Ayew on his own who can’t win the ball in the air and can’t hold it up. The reason the midfield looked terrible was because there was no out ball. We are not good enough to pass it round them and everyone knows it, so that left us looking congested in our own half and they just picked us off with their midfield hunting the ball in twos and then utilising their quick passing and movement to cut us apart. We couldn’t have set up any better to play into their hands and we got what we deserved from the game, absolutely nothing. 2 goals for their centre half who wouldn’t even be there if we had two forwards offering an out ball on the last shoulder of defence. I can’t believe people are blaming individual errors for their goals either. If you are under sustained pressure for the entire match, eventually mistakes will occur. How often do you see error free defensive displays. No questions over the ability of Man City, they are a damn good team and will probably win the league, but we made it easy for them. For those who have the time, look back at the games where we were terrible and you will see it is mostly instigated by teams playing a high press against us. We panic, and end up giving the ball away. I don’t disagree about our ageing side and their limitations as they are clear to see, however I do see the same mistakes being made against certain teams and certain tactics. Now whose responsibility is that I wonder? With respect, the goals scored by Stones were following corners and one would suspect a tall centre-half to be brought up in this phase of the game. Apropos Ayew, perhaps the thinking was that he has shown what he can do running the channels and offers more mobility than Benteke and that this might have been required to relieve the pressure. Edited by Willo (19 Jan 2021 9.46am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect, the goals scored by Stones were following corners and one would suspect a tall centre-half to be brought up in this phase of the game. Apropos Ayew, perhaps the thinking was that he has shown what he can do running the channels and offers more mobility than Benteke and that this might have been required to relieve the pressure. Edited by Willo (19 Jan 2021 9.46am) With the greatest of respect Stones spent as much of the match in our half as he did his own, the primary reason being they didn’t need 4 defenders to mark Ayew who mostly picked up the ball in our half anyway. How on earth can he help relieve the pressure if he is one of 11 chained to defensive duties.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect, the goals scored by Stones were following corners and one would suspect a tall centre-half to be brought up in this phase of the game. Apropos Ayew, perhaps the thinking was that he has shown what he can do running the channels and offers more mobility than Benteke and that this might have been required to relieve the pressure. Edited by Willo (19 Jan 2021 9.46am) As soon as I saw the lineup I thought the thinking was let's not bother trying to get anything out of this game: 11 men behind the ball, lads!
"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt." |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect, the goals scored by Stones were following corners and one would suspect a tall centre-half to be brought up in this phase of the game. Apropos Ayew, perhaps the thinking was that he has shown what he can do running the channels and offers more mobility than Benteke and that this might have been required to relieve the pressure. Edited by Willo (19 Jan 2021 9.46am) Fully agree and there is no hiding the fact that the entire team on Sunday played abysmal football, the other two goals were a mistake by Guaita when he rolled out the ball to the opposition and then the free kick we gave away right on the edge of the penalty area from which Sterling scored. The squad of players available to Roy, with the exception one or two have limited ability in the way they can play, the tactics are dictated by the players available and their ability to adapt. The tactics are largely governed by the talent and team balance you have available!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Fully agree and there is no hiding the fact that the entire team on Sunday played abysmal football, the other two goals were a mistake by Guaita when he rolled out the ball to the opposition and then the free kick we gave away right on the edge of the penalty area from which Sterling scored. The squad of players available to Roy, with the exception one or two have limited ability in the way they can play, the tactics are dictated by the players available and their ability to adapt. The tactics are largely governed by the talent and team balance you have available! They were set up to fail, it’s as simple as that.
|
|
|
Question: can it be charged that the game has been brought into disrepute by a side that has no intention to attack and has zero attempts on goal?
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Question: can it be charged that the game has been brought into disrepute by a side that has no intention to attack and has zero attempts on goal? We’d certainly be seen as a qualifying test case. We did the equivalent of not trying for a Cup match in a League game which is unacceptable. It wouldn’t be so bad if we hadn’t done it several times already this season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
They were set up to fail, it’s as simple as that. Roy, is a well respected and experience Professional Manager, he would never set up a team to fail, they were set up IMHO for a point, once Zaha became unavailable his options on the break were limited by what we have available it as simple as that. The entire team were poor on the night and their limitations were exposed!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Roy, is a well respected and experience Professional Manager, he would never set up a team to fail, they were set up IMHO for a point, once Zaha became unavailable his options on the break were limited by what we have available it as simple as that. The entire team were poor on the night and their limitations were exposed! That team was in search of a miracle point. I have already posted how I thought we might be able to combat how City play so I won’t post again but needless to say it involved breaking down their high press which is the reason we were never in the game. If you want to explain to me how you might have approached it then I’m happy to listen.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
That team was in search of a miracle point. I have already posted how I thought we might be able to combat how City play so I won’t post again but needless to say it involved breaking down their high press which is the reason we were never in the game. If you want to explain to me how you might have approached it then I’m happy to listen. Yes I read that, the only trouble is that we do not have the players to do what you are suggestion (Eg:quality striker!) and I'm certainly not suggesting that I can do a better job than Roy as I do not have the skills, experience or indeed the previous experience as a football coach.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Yes I read that, the only trouble is that we do not have the players to do what you are suggestion (Eg:quality striker!) and I'm certainly not suggesting that I can do a better job than Roy as I do not have the skills, experience or indeed the previous experience as a football coach. Hey, we are all football supporters and we’ve all played. You don’t need to be a top manager to spot we were never going to get anything from that match. I’m pretty sure a manager like Allardyce would have played Benteke and Bats together up front and looked for the long ball as the release rather than tippy tapping it in the midfield which is what got us into trouble.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Hey, we are all football supporters and we’ve all played. You don’t need to be a top manager to spot we were never going to get anything from that match. I’m pretty sure a manager like Allardyce would have played Benteke and Bats together up front and looked for the long ball as the release rather than tippy tapping it in the midfield which is what got us into trouble.
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Question: can it be charged that the game has been brought into disrepute by a side that has no intention to attack and has zero attempts on goal? When i used to play the opposing centre forward was booked for continuously being offside. Ref said it was for disregarding the rules
|
|
|
Originally posted by General
It’s Manchester City v Palace! We had a great record v the Manchester teams due to a few players.. One was not playing, one I feel very sad that he cannot rediscover the quality he once had, one was the best right sided defender I’ve ever seen, one was a midfielder in the best form of his career None of which were playing.. And we literally gave them two goals! Onwards and upwards I predict Agree.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
Agree. Which players is he referring to?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.