You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle United Vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle United Vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 17 of 19 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
sprites Flag Auckland 02 Feb 21 11.54pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I am being deadly serious. Of course his pass accuracy is 90 percent . He passes the ball backwards and sideways to the nearest man then the rest of the game just passes him by. You may think I am just saying this for a reaction but watching him floundering about in midfield like he’s wearing lead boots is pitiful.

Edited by EddieMac (02 Feb 2021 10.44pm)

Clueless. The guy's composed and quality.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Feb 21 12.09am

We seem to enjoy being boxed into tight areas involving half our team without the foggiest idea of what to do with the ball, why can't anyone look up and switch play away!

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 03 Feb 21 12.11am

More effective in the current team formation.

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Thought Luka was very good this evening and Saturday but I agree he hasn't been great at times over the last twelve months particularly without the ball.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 03 Feb 21 12.26am

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

More effective in the current team formation.

He’s played in a 442 plenty previously this season.

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 03 Feb 21 3.15am

Riedewald seems like a defensive liability. On Newcastle's goal, he made sure to get out of the way of the strike. At least he made up for it.

I've defended Bats before, but he was offsides by 3 yards on a great scoring chance. Ridiculous.

I'm still trying to figure out what the F we were doing in the first half. It was like Luka was dropping back into the back 4 to pick the ball up from them. But...Luka??? Of all people? Roy is expecting Luka to carry the ball upfield???

PVA was being played way up the field. I don't get it. PVA is the only one of the back 4 capable of getting the ball up to midfield, and he was playing way out in space while Luka's job was to be the playmaking passer? It was so ridiculous, I couldn't believe what I was seeing.

Can anyone explain what that was all about?

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 03 Feb 21 4.12am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Riedewald seems like a defensive liability. On Newcastle's goal, he made sure to get out of the way of the strike. At least he made up for it.

I've defended Bats before, but he was offsides by 3 yards on a great scoring chance. Ridiculous.

I'm still trying to figure out what the F we were doing in the first half. It was like Luka was dropping back into the back 4 to pick the ball up from them. But...Luka??? Of all people? Roy is expecting Luka to carry the ball upfield???

PVA was being played way up the field. I don't get it. PVA is the only one of the back 4 capable of getting the ball up to midfield, and he was playing way out in space while Luka's job was to be the playmaking passer? It was so ridiculous, I couldn't believe what I was seeing.

Can anyone explain what that was all about?

I thought Riedewald was man of the match best game I've seen him play for us. He was the only one who closed shelvey down for their goal so I've got no idea what you mean by jump out of the way, he didn't get there in time thats all.

Bats doesn't know the offside rule, the chance when the ball ended up with pva was the worst when he was stood offside by the half way line.

Luka dropping closer to the cbs is a common thing most teams do, he had a better game passing forwards than usual. He's expected to pass it out of our half not carry it.

I actually think pva is only any good in the final 3rd, terrible at defending but is one of our best for putting the ball across goal. Clyne was in the same position several times aswell.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 03 Feb 21 4.27am

Just one of those wins that taste like sweet strawberries. A goal down early and outplayed for most of the match except for 10 minutes in the first half.
Whatever anyone says, Riedewald makes our midfield more composed and our captain a better player.
Pleased with our fullbacks, credit to Scott Dann and Eze is the real thing.
Guaita again with some crucial saves (and a bit of luck). Ayew works his socks off, but wish he sometimes could make a quick pass, not try to beat 2-3 players all the time.
Why Mateta is not given a look-in is beyond me. Palace has been chasing him for a long time and must have seen him in action a dozen times (and thus know what he stands for.)
Batman, Townsend and Benteke - the less said the better.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 03 Feb 21 6.14am

Originally posted by steven_t92

I thought Riedewald was man of the match best game I've seen him play for us. He was the only one who closed shelvey down for their goal so I've got no idea what you mean by jump out of the way, he didn't get there in time thats all.

Bats doesn't know the offside rule, the chance when the ball ended up with pva was the worst when he was stood offside by the half way line.

Luka dropping closer to the cbs is a common thing most teams do, he had a better game passing forwards than usual. He's expected to pass it out of our half not carry it.

I actually think pva is only any good in the final 3rd, terrible at defending but is one of our best for putting the ball across goal. Clyne was in the same position several times aswell.

Luka took the yellow as well to stop a late attack.
Defo wears his heart on his sleeve.
Dann looked tidy again and it looks like hes beefed up a bit. Helps with those high crosses against bigger strikers. 6/10 game but a good 3 points.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Feb 21 6.22am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt


He's a funny one Riedewald. He's built like a heavyweight boxer, so much so that he seems too heavy and slow when trying to get around the pitch,

But is he? Mark Bright said that he isn't overweight but doesn't like wearing tight shirts and prefers wearing over sized baggy ones that make him look fat

 

A89M Flag Streatham 03 Feb 21 6.56am

Riedewald had a great game, he adds composure to our midfield. Milo was decent today with some nice through the lines passing but he's far from the form he had when he first joined, him and MacArthur. Riedewald is my first choice CM.

Ayew was excellent with his effort, the amount of free kicks he wins cannot be underestimated, whether its in the final third or defensively its a huge help to the team and something we've missed. Bats out with Benteke or Mateta replacing him.

Glad to see Dann and Cahill fit again but I think its unfair on Kouyate the stick he's got recently, he done a massive job for us in the first half of the season when we had no available CBs. Hopefully he can get minutes in his preferred position.

Eze just oozes class, his ability to just glide passed players is great to watch. I'm not so worried Wilfs out now Eze is gaining some form. Roy should play him as second striker (Wilfs role) and have Townsend on the left doing the tracking back.

 

EddieMac Flag 03 Feb 21 7.11am

Originally posted by A89M

Riedewald had a great game, he adds composure to our midfield. Milo was decent today with some nice through the lines passing but he's far from the form he had when he first joined, him and MacArthur. Riedewald is my first choice CM.

Ayew was excellent with his effort, the amount of free kicks he wins cannot be underestimated, whether its in the final third or defensively its a huge help to the team and something we've missed. Bats out with Benteke or Mateta replacing him.

Glad to see Dann and Cahill fit again but I think its unfair on Kouyate the stick he's got recently, he done a massive job for us in the first half of the season when we had no available CBs. Hopefully he can get minutes in his preferred position.

Eze just oozes class, his ability to just glide passed players is great to watch. I'm not so worried Wilfs out now Eze is gaining some form. Roy should play him as second striker (Wilfs role) and have Townsend on the left doing the tracking back.

I find it unbelievable that people think Jairo makes Luka a better player and people even criticise Luka for his recent performances. Luka has been one of our best players recently and it certainly isn’t down to Jairo. He has to do double the work when he is beside him.

 

PatrickA Flag London 03 Feb 21 7.22am

A decent performance with some good attacking spells.
Just need a focal point to the attacks.
In this regard I was impressed by Wilson in the first half for them.
Quick, powerful and always a pest to our defence.
I hope Mateta can perform a similar function for us as it doesn’t look that either Benteke or Batshuayi are up to the task.
Benteke is too static and the game seems to pass Batshuayi by.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Feb 21 7.36am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I find it unbelievable that people think Jairo makes Luka a better player and people even criticise Luka for his recent performances. Luka has been one of our best players recently and it certainly isn’t down to Jairo. He has to do double the work when he is beside him.

You obviously don’t like Jairo, your perogative but this constant bashing of him after every game is uncalled for imo


Edited by Spiderman (03 Feb 2021 7.39am)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Feb 21 7.37am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

But is he? Mark Bright said that he isn't overweight but doesn't like wearing tight shirts and prefers wearing over sized baggy ones that make him look fat

Exactly! As for being slow around the pitch, of course he is not like Wilf or Eze but he gets up and down sufficiently., not every player needs to be quick. Was Hoddle fast around the pitch? I don’t think so

Edited by Spiderman (03 Feb 2021 7.38am)

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 03 Feb 21 8.13am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I find it unbelievable that people think Jairo makes Luka a better player and people even criticise Luka for his recent performances. Luka has been one of our best players recently and it certainly isn’t down to Jairo. He has to do double the work when he is beside him.

Although I agree Luka does come in for some unfair critiscism, I don't know how you can give Jairo stick. I've seen him give the ball away ONCE in last 3 games and that was last night when he was trying to pass a high bouncing ball.
He may not be the quickest but he got forward a fair bit as shown with his goal and also in 90th minute when he sprinted forward to win ball and pass to Townsend to miss.
My only fault with him was trying to overstretch to win balls that he can't reach and then he has to get up and recover. But hopefully with a few games that match sharpness will come.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 03 Feb 21 8.23am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

But is he? Mark Bright said that he isn't overweight but doesn't like wearing tight shirts and prefers wearing over sized baggy ones that make him look fat

Yeah, that's my excuse too!

 

taylors lovechild Flag 03 Feb 21 9.14am

You watch the top teams and they don't panic and are content to keep possession for long periods without really going anywhere. It frustrates the opposition and takes the pressure off your own defence. The first half that's what Jairo enabled us to do. He was always calling for the ball, keeping it ticking over and taking the momentum out of Newcastle after they took an early lead. This caused them to fall back and sit deep. When there was a clear opportunity Jairo used his passing range and hit a couple of longer balls to the wings. So effective was he that Newcastle eventually resorted to Almiron almost man marking him at times.

The downside of the Luka/Jairo partnership is that neither are quick which when added to the elephant pace of Dann and Cahill means if we push more than 15-yards away from our penalty area teams can just slip balls behind, which nearly undone us in the first half. By tactic or choice we then sat in a low block in the second half to prevent that and Jairo became less effective as we rescinded possession. For me, he is a better player in possession than out of it, which is possibly why Roy doesn't favour him as his tactics are often all about shape and organisation and work without the ball.

One last thing I will say is that last night was the first game since I can remember where Luka didn't get caught in possession at least once. Was that because he had someone by his side constantly looking for the ball? Possibly. As I said, my only big worry with the Luka/Jairo partnership is the lack of pace, but it's not like we have any other options right now other than possibly Kouyate returning to the middle when fully fit.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Feb 21 10.22am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

You watch the top teams and they don't panic and are content to keep possession for long periods without really going anywhere. It frustrates the opposition and takes the pressure off your own defence. The first half that's what Jairo enabled us to do. He was always calling for the ball, keeping it ticking over and taking the momentum out of Newcastle after they took an early lead. This caused them to fall back and sit deep. When there was a clear opportunity Jairo used his passing range and hit a couple of longer balls to the wings. So effective was he that Newcastle eventually resorted to Almiron almost man marking him at times.

The downside of the Luka/Jairo partnership is that neither are quick which when added to the elephant pace of Dann and Cahill means if we push more than 15-yards away from our penalty area teams can just slip balls behind, which nearly undone us in the first half. By tactic or choice we then sat in a low block in the second half to prevent that and Jairo became less effective as we rescinded possession. For me, he is a better player in possession than out of it, which is possibly why Roy doesn't favour him as his tactics are often all about shape and organisation and work without the ball.

One last thing I will say is that last night was the first game since I can remember where Luka didn't get caught in possession at least once. Was that because he had someone by his side constantly looking for the ball? Possibly. As I said, my only big worry with the Luka/Jairo partnership is the lack of pace, but it's not like we have any other options right now other than possibly Kouyate returning to the middle when fully fit.


Excellent analysis. To use Willo's well-worn turn of phrase "I doff my hat at you sir"

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 03 Feb 21 10.54am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

...

One last thing I will say is that last night was the first game since I can remember where Luka didn't get caught in possession at least once. Was that because he had someone by his side constantly looking for the ball? Possibly. As I said, my only big worry with the Luka/Jairo partnership is the lack of pace, but it's not like we have any other options right now other than possibly Kouyate returning to the middle when fully fit.

I think the Luka/Jairo partnership really worked yesterday, good mix of having two holding midfielders shut down newcastle along with moving the ball around well. I don't remember us getting stuck in midfield once, it wasn't long before the ball was out wide, the full backs and wingers had the ball along during the game which is a step forward for us.

 

TheFish Flag 03 Feb 21 11.59am

Really frustrating night for us. We were taking shots and, for the first time this season, had more possession than the opponents. Don't remember your 'keeper having to make too many top tier saves though.

Interested to hear your thoughts on the Milivojevic foul?

In isolation that game was fine for us, created chances, didn't look too troubled by your attack until the game was stretched in the closing stages. Undone by a superb goal and a set piece. Meh, it happens.

Trouble is, that's now 1 win in 13 and we're running out of winnable games.

 

Page 17 of 19 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle United Vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread