You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Sheffield United Match thread
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace v Sheffield United Match thread


Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Jan 24 5.33pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

So is it Roy's fault every time a player misses a shot as well? For not nurturing enough confidence?

JP had that one on his left last night that missed the target, I can't believe Roy did that to him. Disgraceful management.

Now who's being silly? For one thing you are mistaking a player failing in the attempt with him having the confidence to try it, but that's not really the point.

The development of Eze and Olise over time under Hodgsons management is plain to see. To suggest the manager has no part to play in that is ridiculous.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 31 Jan 24 5.37pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Now who's being silly? For one thing you are mistaking a player failing in the attempt with him having the confidence to try it, but that's not really the point.

The development of Eze and Olise over time under Hodgsons management is plain to see. To suggest the manager has no part to play in that is ridiculous.

Ah, so Roy deserves praise for all shots, whether successful or not. Wonderful stuff.

I have in no way suggested Roy hasn't contributed to Eze and Olise's overall development - don't move the goalposts now your original point is drowning.

 

PatrickA Flag London 31 Jan 24 5.39pm

This thread has developed into a wider discussion around Roy, as opposed to the match v Sheffield United.
Nonetheless, I have found the posts this afternoon to be balanced, interesting and respectful.

Trying to be objective, I was happy that Roy returned this season.
I was persuaded by the argument that the reason his last spell had ended so miserably was because he didn’t have the resources.
‘Give him the players and see what he can do’ ran the argument and this seemed to have merit through the form at the end of last season and I anticipated this continuing this season.
If it ain’t broke why fix it?

There are mitigating factors this season with injuries to key players and lack of depth in the squad.
It would seem unreasonable to expect us to replicate the form from the end of last season given these factors.

However, even with lesser resources it’s difficult to justify and accept the lack of basics in terms of organisation , structure, set piece preparation, alternative tactical approach and some bizarre player selections.
This is in contrast to Roy’s last couple of seasons of his previous tenure where at least we looked organised, even if the football wasn’t great.
I can’t think of one player who’s enhanced their reputation or improved under Roy this season.
Normally at this stage you would have 2 or 3 players as potential candidates for player of the season.
I can’t think of one other than possibly Olise and he’s hardly played so it’s hardly an accurate reflection of this season to include him.

I think the decision to bring back Roy has not really worked and I was incorrect in wanting him to manage us this season.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 31 Jan 24 5.40pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

You've made this point before, that Roy holds back players with potential. He's given game time to Ozoh at 18 years of age, to Franca at 19, and Ahamada didn't manage to convince Vieira any more than he's convinced Hodgson.

We are not sitting on some goldmine of top class talent.

Totally disagree - they simply haven’t been afforded sufficient opportunities and are being overlooked in favour of seasoned proven mediocrity, negative tactics and poor Management..!!

Consequently their development in terms of fulfilling their undoubted potential is being stunted and constrained..!!

That’s why irrespective of last nights result Roy has got to go..!!

COYP

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 31 Jan 24 5.43pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I think it's very simplistic to blame Richards for the first goal - Guehi somehow ended up miles out of position tracking McBurnie 20 seconds into the game, and they then had an overload on Richards side to exploit. He could probably have got tighter as Diaz got into the box, but the damage was done when McBurnie took Guehi out of the game with his flick round the corner, and Hamer switched the play.

Look at the still as Hamer hits his pass - if Richards is any wider there, he's got a simple pass to put the central player through on goal, which is far more dangerous - Richards was correct to be narrow, and the bigger question is why we're exposed 3 v 3 20 seconds into a game...

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (31 Jan 2024 4.18pm)

good point, however, when the ball did go left Richards was very slow closing him down, almost allowing him to pick his spot

 

WJK1960 Flag 31 Jan 24 5.45pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I think it's very simplistic to blame Richards for the first goal - Guehi somehow ended up miles out of position tracking McBurnie 20 seconds into the game, and they then had an overload on Richards side to exploit. He could probably have got tighter as Diaz got into the box, but the damage was done when McBurnie took Guehi out of the game with his flick round the corner, and Hamer switched the play.

Look at the still as Hamer hits his pass - if Richards is any wider there, he's got a simple pass to put the central player through on goal, which is far more dangerous - Richards was correct to be narrow, and the bigger question is why we're exposed 3 v 3 20 seconds into a game...

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (31 Jan 2024 4.18pm)

Great Post. I like everyone else assumed Richards had gone awol when it was Guehi out of position. Didn't Brentford score a similar goal against us, a dummy or flick in the first 3 minutes getting our defence out of position and they scored. That time Clyne wasn't close enough to the scorer but I don't recall him getting the stick that Richards, and by implication, the manager for picking him, has received on these pages.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 31 Jan 24 5.58pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Agree on Hughes - he's not perfect and probably not good enough against better sides, but he was very impactful yesterday I thought.

Absolutely Eze/Olise's understanding is a massive factor in it, and to be clear, allowing your most creative winger space to deliver crosses and ensuring there are bodies in the box when he does, is a really low bar in terms of crediting a manager, but I thought I'd try and offer some balance!

Necessary!

I thought you did so fairly too. I'll always welcome differing perspectives, so long as they're presented as such.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Jan 24 6.39pm

Originally posted by palace99

good point, however, when the ball did go left Richards was very slow closing him down, almost allowing him to pick his spot

Brereton Diaz prefers to play off the left and is a powerful runner with the ball.Having watched him a few times I have seen him cutting in from the left on to his favoured right-foot and shooting.Had Richards forced Brereton Diaz on to his left,which I was urging, the outcome would have been different.

Edited by Willo (31 Jan 2024 6.42pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 31 Jan 24 6.44pm

Thought we played really well first half after the early setback and deserved more goals but United (I refuse to call them Sheffield) changed things and made us work harder for opportunities second half. Eze and Olise were magnificent in a pressure game.

No problem with the subs as such but our collective lack of quality and ability to retain the ball once they went off was frightening.

I don't think last night was the time to bring on Franca or Ahamada who've both been very unconvincing IMO. Ozoh did quite well when he came on but took a few minutes to find his feet and play himself into the game.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 31 Jan 24 6.55pm

Originally posted by Willo

Brereton Diaz prefers to play off the left and is a powerful runner with the ball.Having watched him a few times I have seen him cutting in from the left on to his favoured right-foot and shooting.Had Richards forced Brereton Diaz on to his left,which I was urging, the outcome would have been different.

Edited by Willo (31 Jan 2024 6.42pm)

Fancy a job as defensive coach?

 

Kenteagle80 Flag Kent 31 Jan 24 8.11pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Fancy a job as defensive coach?

I am going a bit off topic here but talking of coaching, did anyone read kofi balmers interview after joining afc Wimbledon on loan

He credited Vieira with helping develop the younger players. Looking at city scoring the free kick tonight with an excellent training ground move. In the summer I hope whoever comes in (I suspect Steve cooper) has a modern approach to develop our tactics / squad

 

dg1937 Flag 31 Jan 24 9.06pm

Originally posted by WJK1960

Great Post. I like everyone else assumed Richards had gone awol when it was Guehi out of position. Didn't Brentford score a similar goal against us, a dummy or flick in the first 3 minutes getting our defence out of position and they scored. That time Clyne wasn't close enough to the scorer but I don't recall him getting the stick that Richards, and by implication, the manager for picking him, has received on these pages.

I agree, the photo was very illuminating. Richards’ original positioning is more understandable now, but he was slow to get out to his man. As has been said, an awful goal to concede at any time let alone in the first minute.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 31 Jan 24 11.28pm

Originally posted by JRW2

This discussion is far too sophisticated for me to get involved, but I nevertheless feel confident in asserting that it is not the duty of the manager to do what the fans want.

My point was, as I suspect you know, that there is so much Roy hatred at the moment that he was criticised for not making a change, and now is being criticised for making that said change.

I'm no Roy lover but at times the abuse is OTT

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 31 Jan 24 11.29pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Thought we played really well first half after the early setback and deserved more goals but United (I refuse to call them Sheffield) changed things and made us work harder for opportunities second half. Eze and Olise were magnificent in a pressure game.

No problem with the subs as such but our collective lack of quality and ability to retain the ball once they went off was frightening.

I don't think last night was the time to bring on Franca or Ahamada who've both been very unconvincing IMO. Ozoh did quite well when he came on but took a few minutes to find his feet and play himself into the game.

A good, balanced post

 

CT Charlie Flag 01 Feb 24 1.56am

Guehi and Richards share responsibility for the first goal, but there was more to it. At that point in the game, the midfielders weren't in play, so Richards ended up in a 1-v-1 in a lonely position with space all around. Still, most of the credit goes to BBD for a exceptionally clean cut and wonderful strike.

Guehi also wasn't in top form defending Sheffield's second goal, and his belated toe deflection probably made the difference between a routine save and a goal. Andersen gave a sour look, whether at Guehi's or Henderson's play, or our bad luck, I couldn't be sure.

Oh – and please start Johnstone, Roy.

Edited by CT Charlie (01 Feb 2024 5.36am)

Edited by CT Charlie (01 Feb 2024 4.15pm)

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 01 Feb 24 5.47am

Sheff UTD -

Originally posted by CT Charlie

Guehi and Richards share responsibility for the first goal, but there was more to it. At that point in the game, the midfielders weren't in play, so Richards ended up in a 1-v-1 in a lonely position with space all around. Still, most of the credit goes to BBD for a exceptionally clean cut and wonderful strike.

Guehi also wasn't in top form defending Forest's second goal, and his belated toe deflection probably made the difference between a routine save and a goal. Andersen gave a sour look, whether at Guehi's or Henderson's play, or our bad luck, I couldn't be sure.

Oh – and please start Johnstone, Roy.

Edited by CT Charlie (01 Feb 2024 5.36am)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 01 Feb 24 8.53am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Thought we played really well first half after the early setback and deserved more goals but United (I refuse to call them Sheffield) changed things and made us work harder for opportunities second half. Eze and Olise were magnificent in a pressure game.

No problem with the subs as such but our collective lack of quality and ability to retain the ball once they went off was frightening.

I don't think last night was the time to bring on Franca or Ahamada who've both been very unconvincing IMO. Ozoh did quite well when he came on but took a few minutes to find his feet and play himself into the game.

The issue with the subs was that it left us without any real creativity on the pitch which meant United were more confident to push on and if they scored we'd have had almost zero chance of recovering the lead. Franca is obviously raw, but this season Schlupp has looked lost, out of shape and offers little going in either direction. He's been a loyal servant but how does he keep getting on the pitch ahead of anyone? Even Eduoard on the left would have been a better option. The fact Ozoh came on ahead of Ahamada I think also shows where Roy's trust is. I also wondered why he didn't bring Clyne on if he wanted to go defensive (was Clyne carrying a knock?) I think a lot of people I've seen and heard commenting on the game also felt the subs caused us to lose our shape and players didn't look quite as clear as to what they should be doing.

Overall I enjoyed the game and going forward we looked the best we've looked in months. How much credit should go to Roy and how much to our dynamic duo is up for debate, but let's not pretend that Sheffield Utd were a Premier League level team. Their defence was shocking and their midfield non existent. If Olise and Eze stay fit then the next few games will give us a much better indication of where we're at.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 01 Feb 24 9.53am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Thought we played really well first half after the early setback and deserved more goals but United (I refuse to call them Sheffield) changed things and made us work harder for opportunities second half. Eze and Olise were magnificent in a pressure game.

No problem with the subs as such but our collective lack of quality and ability to retain the ball once they went off was frightening.

I don't think last night was the time to bring on Franca or Ahamada who've both been very unconvincing IMO. Ozoh did quite well when he came on but took a few minutes to find his feet and play himself into the game.

Yep I agree.

Double edged sword, as we effectively lost all creativity. BUT franca is too messy with the ball and lightweight to be risked.

Right subs IMO, but highlights that we need at least 1 senior wide man in the squad.

(and get the kids out of loan so they can be some use nxt season)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 01 Feb 24 9.59am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

The issue with the subs was that it left us without any real creativity on the pitch which meant United were more confident to push on and if they scored we'd have had almost zero chance of recovering the lead. Franca is obviously raw, but this season Schlupp has looked lost, out of shape and offers little going in either direction. He's been a loyal servant but how does he keep getting on the pitch ahead of anyone? Even Eduoard on the left would have been a better option. The fact Ozoh came on ahead of Ahamada I think also shows where Roy's trust is. I also wondered why he didn't bring Clyne on if he wanted to go defensive (was Clyne carrying a knock?) I think a lot of people I've seen and heard commenting on the game also felt the subs caused us to lose our shape and players didn't look quite as clear as to what they should be doing.

Overall I enjoyed the game and going forward we looked the best we've looked in months. How much credit should go to Roy and how much to our dynamic duo is up for debate, but let's not pretend that Sheffield Utd were a Premier League level team. Their defence was shocking and their midfield non existent. If Olise and Eze stay fit then the next few games will give us a much better indication of where we're at.

That's 100% true.

But IMO the issue isn't with Roy its that our options are so unbelievably raw, and in Franca's case lightweight that they cant be trusted in those conditions.

And as much as I rate Eddy's talents, he's lazy. Would have provided more threat on the left, but wouldn't have trusted him to track back.

 

eaglesdare Flag 01 Feb 24 10.25am

I just dont think franca would have had the impact that we would have liked or hoped. towards the end we were hoofing it up field and against the Sheffield united tall defenders he stood no chance.

In schulpps defence he can win a header even tho he is short and he put himself about.

I think it was the right call.

 

Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Sheffield United Match thread