This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| deleted 25 |
|
|---|---|
|
Lot of people talking about what’s best for Ukraine, think you’d better ask them
|
|
|
Originally posted by Vincehair
Lot of people talking about what’s best for Ukraine, think you’d better ask them
If you mean ask the Zelensky government. Well, the Americans have given them 50 billion and both them and the EU have contributed with heavy weapons to continue fighting. Along with press statements the general theme has been to continue fighting until the Russians are pushed out of the Ukraine....with the general picture as it is that's just not going to happen....in fact Russian gains are accelerating in the donbas. I'll make the point that the amount of sophisticated weapons now within the general Ukraine population...most of whom are skint is pretty dangerous for us moving forward terrorism wise....but that was obvious a long time ago. Zelensky is in a very difficult position, if he does make peace with the Russians and gives up the east and south then his life is on a timer with the nationalists who will blame him for the failures....he would need to get out of the Ukraine sharp. What happens next? Will Belarus join the war and open up a northern front onto Kiev? Does that mean Poland join the war as a counter? What would that mean in terms of Nato? Zelensky's hope is for the west to commit to an all out war against Russia...and that's been his tactic since the beginning. I shouldn't need to say just how bad an outcome that would be for everyone. The risks taken there don't bare thinking about....in fact I think outrageous risks have already been taken....especially long term for us. Personally I think our nations need to look for an out before that. Will Russia offer terms after finally taking the Donbas and south... .will they push on to Odessa and so take away the Ukraine's only seaport? Have they decided on taking all of the Ukraine? I doubt it personally but they might just continue until they get capitulation on a muppet government. Having Biden as president with all the stupid things he has said means that negotiation between him and Putin looks pretty unlikely. So would Macron be the proxy? No one wants to take responsibility for a loss, yet no one wants to risk a fully fledged war.....Also it's highly unlikely that the EU would accept a war that continued into the winter for economic reasons. So will they just let Russia make gains until it offers terms? I don't know but I think Nato and Johnson suggesting that the war could last years was unrealistic and it's more likely that moves will be afoot to bring this to a conclusion before winter brings serious energy requirements. All conjecture of course, pure speculation. In my view, this has been pure incompetence from the start....low quality elites.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
He will do ANYTHING to keep this war going as long as he can. For once, and it causes me to question my sanity, beginning to think that Macron might actually have the better, overall, strategic view on all of this. I genuinely cannot understand who stands to gain by dragging this war out any longer than it needs to be. Suspect there is a lot of money floating around in the halls of the Ukranian Government with a lot of people getting wealthy on the back of this all along with every chancer in Europe currently on the 'humanitarian' aid bandwagon.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Whilst I don't disagree with the 'low quality', I also suspect that they are a lot more cynical with it than people give credit for. I am now convinced that it is Johnson, purely based on the fact that it is perhaps the one area of his current political life, in which the polling is not horrendous. He will do ANYTHING to keep this war going as long as he can. For once, and it causes me to question my sanity, beginning to think that Macron might actually have the better, overall, strategic view on all of this. I genuinely cannot understand who stands to gain by dragging this war out any longer than it needs to be. Suspect there is a lot of money floating around in the halls of the Ukranian Government with a lot of people getting wealthy on the back of this all along with every chancer in Europe currently on the 'humanitarian' aid bandwagon. I've heard conjecture that the Johnson approach is more inclined to a kind of partnership with the eastern EU countries as a form of support within the EU power structure. Don't know....However, if the ultimate concern is for the Ukrainian people, I don't think they actually factor in that much. They are the pawns suffering over a highly avoidable war.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I've heard conjecture that the Johnson approach is more inclined to a kind of partnership with the eastern EU countries as a form of support within the EU power structure. .
But Johnson is also more than capable of waging wars if it means he keeps his job.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Possible. And Poland, probably the most powerful regional player at the moment, is firmly within the Anglo-Saxon remit. But Johnson is also more than capable of waging wars if it means he keeps his job. I've become increasingly convinced that if they are actually serious about kicking Russia out of the Ukraine then the west needs its own troops and equipment on the ground...its own armies.....it can't be done piecemeal, training foreign troops on equipment on the fly.....it's never going to have the numbers nor expertise in depth.....it's not realistic. You need armies ready to go, it appears obvious now that Russia have been planning this since Biden came in and were considering it long before that......but the whole idea of a land war is madness anyway.....it's existential and should only be done if Nato countries are invaded (Nato, in my view over expanded). Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Jun 2022 9.17am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I've become increasingly convinced that if they are actually serious about kicking Russia out of the Ukraine then the west needs its own troops and equipment on the ground...its own armies.....it can't be done piecemeal, training foreign troops on equipment on the fly.....it's never going to have the numbers nor expertise in depth.....it's not realistic.
Russia can survive any kind of prolonged war. And without its gas, Europe is in a LOT of trouble. This is the insanity. Russia can keep its people warm and their stomachs full. Europe cannot. It is as though people want Europe to be utterly f***ed with our leadership cheering this on. Pan-National suicide.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
| W12 23 Jun 22 1.05pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It's only recently that the mainstream media have been coming to terms with the realities of the battlefield in the Ukraine....while still looking to minimize negatives and hype positives. They have been reporting absolute dross for months and made emotive and biased predictions that are embarrassing to me as a westerner raised in a different era. The number of reports that Russia was on its last legs both economically and militarily both in the print and broadcast media contrast with the actual realities occurring in the real world. It's actually very soviet....If someone had told me the west would become this thirty years ago I just wouldn't have believed it. It's far better to be accurate than appeal to a reality you prefer...aka propaganda.....For example, the BBC of the past was lauded for being reliant for telling people what was actually happening but I think that's been damaged since they became ideological. There is no excuse. All the information from the battlefield and economic situations are out there and in my view the mainstream media have failed their publics via omissions and one eyed interpretations from talking heads who talked absolute drivel. No better than the Russian media itself.
There are so many huge geopolitical changes going on beyond this war and our media is silent. No least the alliances being formed within the BRICS nations that will fundamentally change the world. The attached shows just how way off the media are from popular sentiment when it comes to basic issues (US example). Tells quite a story.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No better than the Russian media itself. Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Jun 2022 11.57am) Even acknowledging that a war is taking place is Russia is taboo, speaking out against it a swift way to arrest and imprisonment. The Kremlin media narrative by virtue of this cannot even legally provide real world details of this invasion (or 'special military operation' The BBC is far from perfect , but much of your perception of it and attitude to your country are clearly due to your own weakening allegaince to it due to what you see as its cultural direction (you even stated concerns at Western influence to Ukraines culture, but not Russias at any point - considering multiple high profile Russian sources have stated that any Ukrainians opposing Russias actions and worldview should be wiped out, as should Ukranian identity, that's quite some stance to adopt), and your own stark politics. For it's faults, nobody keyed into reality thinks the situation here is anything as bad as Russia. If you're fed 'truly' ultra skewed emotional led alt-media offal for the most part, of course that's going to be the take home though. That's not to say that of late you've not posted some more objective sources, but ultimately whatever matches the fit for one eyed demographic dislike or aversions seems to be what pulls people back in, and that can be true of far left, as well as far right.
|
|
| deleted 25 |
|
|---|---|
|
AKA ‘westplaining’
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by W12
There are so many huge geopolitical changes going on beyond this war and our media is silent. No least the alliances being formed within the BRICS nations that will fundamentally change the world. The attached shows just how way off the media are from popular sentiment when it comes to basic issues (US example). Tells quite a story. Polling firms should be impartial but unfortunately many aren't. One look at Rasmussen's twitter feed reveals them to be heavily politicised, which would seem to defeat the entire point of polling to begin with. Of course it ends up a case of being follow the money, with these firms leaning into this party or that in order to sustain and grow their business. I'm sure there are still some reliable polling companies, so as I say their clear slant, when these companies should be objective, doesn't fill you with confidence. That aside, I don't actually disagree with the point that 'legacy media' fixates on issues stated. Unfortunate people seem to have missed the fact that online media of left and right, even more starkly in fact. People seem to think you've 'cracked the code' just because they can use a laptop. It's ultimately the same forces at play, and it's even easier to dehumanise various groups or perspectives online, because its more detached, and there are more niche little enclaves and echo chambers that pipe out their nonsense on a shoestring. People have already been 'trained' for infighting rather than those pulling the strings and the ultra monied, so it's just a more warped and exagerated version of the same probems, not less so.
|
|
| W12 23 Jun 22 1.53pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Even acknowledging that a war is taking place is Russia is taboo, speaking out against it a swift way to arrest and imprisonment. The Kremlin media narrative by virtue of this cannot even legally provide real world details of this invasion (or 'special military operation' The BBC is far from perfect , but much of your perception of it and attitude to your country are clearly due to your own weakening allegaince to it due to what you see as its cultural direction (you even stated concerns at Western influence to Ukraines culture, but not Russias at any point - considering multiple high profile Russian sources have stated that any Ukrainians opposing Russias actions and worldview should be wiped out, as should Ukranian identity, that's quite some stance to adopt), and your own stark politics. For it's faults, nobody keyed into reality thinks the situation here is anything as bad as Russia. If you're fed 'truly' ultra skewed emotional led alt-media offal for the most part, of course that's going to be the take home though. That's not to say that of late you've not posted some more objective sources, but ultimately whatever matches the fit for one eyed demographic dislike or aversions seems to be what pulls people back in, and that can be true of far left, as well as far right. No, it's just because they lie about pretty much everything. I've no idea what the Russians get from their own media (as I can't speak Russian and Russian channels are censored) but I do remember though that at least RT had long form interviews. Compared to the BBC's 2min soundbites and only inviting certain people on current affairs shows for character assassinations of people that didn't follow the correct agenda (media pile ons of people airing legitimate grievances like Tommy Robinson) . Anyway, probably best discussed on the BBC forum although it's familiar to most western mainstream media now. To view alternative media as "pro-Russian" by the way is just a mistake. Whether they are left or right leaning they tend to have a much more truly diverse make up and deal with things in much more detail and with nuance covering the "commissions" that tend to tell the important stories.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by W12
I've no idea what the Russians get from their own media (as I can't speak Russian and Russian channels are censored) There are plenty of stark examples out there for you to watch. I've explained where that content sits, we know what they're legally allowed to state (its a 'special military operation' to 'denazify' of course), and consequences for those who don't tow the line. As I said you'll be waiting a long time for comentator after comentator on the BBC suggest we should nuke Russia or obliterate every person (civilain or otherwise) stand against their national agenda.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Worked out well for my side but suspect it paints far too many wrong pictures so everybody should be wary. Yes, it's another area where it pays to take in multiple sources and to try to get a feel of which firms are more reliable and trusted over time, just to get a view 'in the round'.. Because as you say they are not removed from bias and so can be used to provide or push a warped picture of a more nuanced reality. It can even happen unintentionally to some extent based on what people say to polling companies vs what they actually believe, but its potentially useful tool to get a feel of things.. Nowadays I'm as likely to look at betting odds though to be honest, as you can often deduce a lot from the 'money where your mouth is' perspective!
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Interesting that there are reports that Russia has dismantled and stolen the largest Solar panel plant in Ukraine (near the town of Tokmak). Occupied and transitioning to the Ruble from April, you'd think if they expected to hold the territory, they'd not dismantle it. It's almost as if the narrative that they sought to 'protect' these people and regions is a lie and they they'd rather drain these areas of anything of use... Imagine my shock.. The Soviet Union did the exact same thing with conquered territories. Moving industrial equipment back to Russia. Bleeding areas dry. Remember in Donbass in 2014, ideas of providing help to those in need, just PR stunts, sending empty 'humaniatarian aid' trucks [Link] As likely to remove than provide. Russians in Ukranian territory are useful to the contrived invasion narrative but that seems to be about the extent of it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Interesting that there are reports that Russia has dismantled and stolen the largest Solar panel plant in Ukraine (near the town of Tokmak).
But who honestly knows anything with this wretched war?
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Matov
But who honestly knows anything with this wretched war? Certainly possible, but I'm sure the same reasoning could be stated if we suddenly see that they've been put back together firmly in Russian territory. Though yes, I agree, nobody really comes out of this a winner in terms of the price that is paid on all fronts.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.