You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end
November 22 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end


Page 18 of 25 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >
Palace_Guard Flag Kyiv 12 Dec 14 5.04pm

Quote Plane at 12 Dec 2014 2.28pm

Quote Palace_Guard at 12 Dec 2014 2.22pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 04 Dec 2014 1.31pm

Quote sanitycheck at 04 Dec 2014 1.16pm

I was under the impression that people pay their rent to a landlord. If we all followed where every penny we spend went to I'm sure we'd all realise we're hypocrites.

It's easy to point the finger but at least Brand is fighting to help with issues like the new era estate even if he does get flack along the way. Without his fame and riches no-one even would be listening - that's his entire point. If he lived in a £100,000 grand house the narrative would be that he's mentally ill, so there's always an angle.

National Newspapers view those speaking out on these issues to be worthy of front page character assassinations. That is the real story.


Edited by sanitycheck (04 Dec 2014 1.17pm)

Before we get too carried away, how interested would Brand be in all this if it didn't result in lots and lots of media coverage for Mr R. Brand Esq?

I was at a gala dinner recently where they handed out a charity award. The ten or so charities on the shortlist were run by modest people who devote their lives, quietly and not in front of the cameras, to helping people worse off than them.

But some alleged comedian who went out with Katy Perry spouts some facile, intellectually redundant student lefty rubbish and the media are all over him like a tramp on chips.

I understand the reasons why, but let's please put Mr Brand's supposed do-gooding into perspective. He's not exactly Robin bleeding Hood.


Why is it so hard to believe Brand is using his public image and voice for a good cause? And not selfish reasons.

He speaks from the heart and is passionate.

If he wanted more media coverage, he could just make another movie, tv show or comedy tour.

Ha ha ha ha ha, he'll get more coverage as some kind of warrior than any of those pursuits you mention.


Mate, two movies in the past he has been involved in "Get Him to the Greek" & "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" made $91.3 million & $105,173 at the box office respectively. I am sure if he started making another movie now, he would get plenty of media coverage.

Also, I am sure he could easily get a weekly spot on TV having his on TV chat show.

My point is, he can get coverage elsewhere (doing other things), but he has found something he is passionate in and its easy to see that in the way he speaks. I very much doubt it is because of selfish reasons.

 


Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia?
Support Crystal Palace?

Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club:
[Link]

Adelaide, South Australia? Join here:
[Link]

sanitycheck Flag 12 Dec 14 5.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Dec 2014 4.45pm

Quote NEILLO at 12 Dec 2014 1.31pm

Quote sanitycheck at 12 Dec 2014 12.59pm

Quote NEILLO at 12 Dec 2014 12.51pm

Having just watched last night's Question Time, I have to say Brand's behaviour and his simplistic ' solutions ' to complex problems has resulted in my re-enforced view that he truly is a bell end.

I thought he was called out by the guy that suggested he stood as an MP himself. It's all very well railing against politicians on all sides but this is a system that can only be changed from within.

I never have found him funny as a ' comedian ', but these attempts at being taken seriously i find hilarious.

You are allowed forthright opinions without being obligated to stand as an MP. Arguably it's easier to help people while outside of the system because once you're an MP expectations are heaped upon you, many of which have nothing to do with helping anyone.


I agree....nothing wrong with having forthright opinions, and I fully respect RB's right to his.

As was pointed out on the show, he has millions of Twitter followers so he has an audience for his views that politicians do not have. The best advice he could come up with was to not vote for anybody....what will that change ?

I'm interested to know how you arrived at the above ? And where it fits in with what RB is doing ? That's not meant as a criticism, I just don't quite get it !

I generally agree, although the correct sentiment should be 'don't vote for anyone you don't support the policies of'. If your a green, don't vote labour just because you prefer them to the conseravtives etc. That's just self defeating logic.

Vote for the candidate that represents your politics, not your disdain.

That's pretty much his view anyway. If people think he's stated 'do not vote under any circumstances' then that's clearly a misrepresentation. A proportional representation system would make voting more worthwhile and diversify choice. There's not much support for that though.

 

Palace_Guard Flag Kyiv 12 Dec 14 5.10pm

Brand never said "do not vote", he said "there is nothing worth voting for".

A difference.

ALso, there must be other ways to change the system other than from the inside? No?

 


Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia?
Support Crystal Palace?

Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club:
[Link]

Adelaide, South Australia? Join here:
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Dec 14 5.15pm

Quote Palace_Guard at 12 Dec 2014 5.04pm

Quote Plane at 12 Dec 2014 2.28pm

Quote Palace_Guard at 12 Dec 2014 2.22pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 04 Dec 2014 1.31pm

Quote sanitycheck at 04 Dec 2014 1.16pm

I was under the impression that people pay their rent to a landlord. If we all followed where every penny we spend went to I'm sure we'd all realise we're hypocrites.

It's easy to point the finger but at least Brand is fighting to help with issues like the new era estate even if he does get flack along the way. Without his fame and riches no-one even would be listening - that's his entire point. If he lived in a £100,000 grand house the narrative would be that he's mentally ill, so there's always an angle.

National Newspapers view those speaking out on these issues to be worthy of front page character assassinations. That is the real story.


Edited by sanitycheck (04 Dec 2014 1.17pm)

Before we get too carried away, how interested would Brand be in all this if it didn't result in lots and lots of media coverage for Mr R. Brand Esq?

I was at a gala dinner recently where they handed out a charity award. The ten or so charities on the shortlist were run by modest people who devote their lives, quietly and not in front of the cameras, to helping people worse off than them.

But some alleged comedian who went out with Katy Perry spouts some facile, intellectually redundant student lefty rubbish and the media are all over him like a tramp on chips.

I understand the reasons why, but let's please put Mr Brand's supposed do-gooding into perspective. He's not exactly Robin bleeding Hood.


Why is it so hard to believe Brand is using his public image and voice for a good cause? And not selfish reasons.

He speaks from the heart and is passionate.

If he wanted more media coverage, he could just make another movie, tv show or comedy tour.

Ha ha ha ha ha, he'll get more coverage as some kind of warrior than any of those pursuits you mention.


Mate, two movies in the past he has been involved in "Get Him to the Greek" & "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" made .3 million & 5,173 at the box office respectively. I am sure if he started making another movie now, he would get plenty of media coverage.

Also, I am sure he could easily get a weekly spot on TV having his on TV chat show.

My point is, he can get coverage elsewhere (doing other things), but he has found something he is passionate in and its easy to see that in the way he speaks. I very much doubt it is because of selfish reasons.


Those two movies were released the other way around and show that taking out the two birds, it cost $10m more to make and took $14 less at the box office.

I'm not surprised you didn't choose Arthur though, which he was in (note, was in and not made) after those, as the star, and it bombed.

I'll make it easier. When was the last time he was in the paper for days on end? Answer, after abusing Sachs.

 


Optimistic as ever

sanitycheck Flag 12 Dec 14 5.30pm

Quote Stuk at 12 Dec 2014 5.15pm

Quote Palace_Guard at 12 Dec 2014 5.04pm

Quote Plane at 12 Dec 2014 2.28pm

Quote Palace_Guard at 12 Dec 2014 2.22pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 04 Dec 2014 1.31pm

Quote sanitycheck at 04 Dec 2014 1.16pm

I was under the impression that people pay their rent to a landlord. If we all followed where every penny we spend went to I'm sure we'd all realise we're hypocrites.

It's easy to point the finger but at least Brand is fighting to help with issues like the new era estate even if he does get flack along the way. Without his fame and riches no-one even would be listening - that's his entire point. If he lived in a £100,000 grand house the narrative would be that he's mentally ill, so there's always an angle.

National Newspapers view those speaking out on these issues to be worthy of front page character assassinations. That is the real story.


Edited by sanitycheck (04 Dec 2014 1.17pm)

Before we get too carried away, how interested would Brand be in all this if it didn't result in lots and lots of media coverage for Mr R. Brand Esq?

I was at a gala dinner recently where they handed out a charity award. The ten or so charities on the shortlist were run by modest people who devote their lives, quietly and not in front of the cameras, to helping people worse off than them.

But some alleged comedian who went out with Katy Perry spouts some facile, intellectually redundant student lefty rubbish and the media are all over him like a tramp on chips.

I understand the reasons why, but let's please put Mr Brand's supposed do-gooding into perspective. He's not exactly Robin bleeding Hood.


Why is it so hard to believe Brand is using his public image and voice for a good cause? And not selfish reasons.

He speaks from the heart and is passionate.

If he wanted more media coverage, he could just make another movie, tv show or comedy tour.

Ha ha ha ha ha, he'll get more coverage as some kind of warrior than any of those pursuits you mention.


Mate, two movies in the past he has been involved in "Get Him to the Greek" & "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" made .3 million & 5,173 at the box office respectively. I am sure if he started making another movie now, he would get plenty of media coverage.

Also, I am sure he could easily get a weekly spot on TV having his on TV chat show.

My point is, he can get coverage elsewhere (doing other things), but he has found something he is passionate in and its easy to see that in the way he speaks. I very much doubt it is because of selfish reasons.


Those two movies were released the other way around and show that taking out the two birds, it cost m more to make and took less at the box office.

I'm not surprised you didn't choose Arthur though, which he was in (note, was in and not made) after those, as the star, and it bombed.

I'll make it easier. When was the last time he was in the paper for days on end? Answer, after abusing Sachs.

Being in the papers doesn't invalidate your point of view. At least it's happening while he is highlighting issues that impact peoples lives. There's more value to that than a Kerry Katona 'I gained/lost 50 pounds' headline. Almost every aspect of what we all do is self serving when viewed what one angle or another. It doesn't mean that's our only motivation for our behaviour though.


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Dec 14 6.00pm

[Link]

It wasn't me...

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 12 Dec 14 7.37pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Dec 2014 6.00pm

[Link]

It wasn't me...

Doesnt really have much to do with anything though does it?
For example should a relative of mine break the law should I in some way be implicated even if im innocent?
As is Quoted ''he is his own man''.

Edited by Ouzo Dan (12 Dec 2014 7.37pm)

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 12 Dec 14 7.51pm

Clearly a plant as was the purple haired nutter who called out Farage.

Shame as it just further discredits the program for seeking controversy as opposed to debating the issues at hand.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

OldFella Flag London 12 Dec 14 9.02pm

I've just spent 30 minutes of my life reading 29 pages of posts about Russell Brand. I see it clearly - RB is not a sage/soothsayer/revolutionary/visionary/or similar. He is, imho, a fool and a tool. As Johnny Rotten once said, "Ever get the feeling you've been had". At least the Sex Pistols were just about money, and John Lydon has acknowledged that. RB is about sad, inflated, dyslexic self promotion. Half of the people on here see it for what it is - the other half need to find a new god to represent them. For their chosen one really is a plonker, Rodney.

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

TUX Flag redhill 12 Dec 14 9.23pm

Quote OldFella at 12 Dec 2014 9.02pm

I've just spent 30 minutes of my life reading 29 pages of posts about Russell Brand. I see it clearly - RB is not a sage/soothsayer/revolutionary/visionary/or similar. He is, imho, a fool and a tool. As Johnny Rotten once said, "Ever get the feeling you've been had". At least the Sex Pistols were just about money, and John Lydon has acknowledged that. RB is about sad, inflated, dyslexic self promotion. Half of the people on here see it for what it is - the other half need to find a new god to represent them. For their chosen one really is a plonker, Rodney.


You're right.
I too get the feeling I've been 'had', but it 'aint from Brand 'because he has NO POWER!

Plonker.




 

sanitycheck Flag 12 Dec 14 9.24pm

Quote OldFella at 12 Dec 2014 9.02pm

I've just spent 30 minutes of my life reading 29 pages of posts about Russell Brand. I see it clearly - RB is not a sage/soothsayer/revolutionary/visionary/or similar. He is, imho, a fool and a tool. As Johnny Rotten once said, "Ever get the feeling you've been had". At least the Sex Pistols were just about money, and John Lydon has acknowledged that. RB is about sad, inflated, dyslexic self promotion. Half of the people on here see it for what it is - the other half need to find a new god to represent them. For their chosen one really is a plonker, Rodney.

Half the people see it "as it is"? They just so happen to be the half that you agree with of course. Funny that.

People are broadly split ideologically in terms of how they view very polarising figures like Brand and Farage. It doesn't mean that they have a screw loose for doing so or that automatically someone they agree with on some issues is suddenly their "god". If we need to start inventing false scenarios to make a point, we don't have a point to begin with.


Edited by sanitycheck (12 Dec 2014 9.50pm)

 

TUX Flag redhill 12 Dec 14 9.49pm

......and why does 'Stuk', who appears to hate Brand, spend so much time researching the man who has NO POWER?

This thread is brilliant example of all that's wrong in OUR country today.
The focus is constantly about 'celebrity over substance'.
I don't agree with Brand all the time and equally cringe occasionally, but he tells it as it is and highlights many issues that rarely come to light in the mainstream media. Who cares if he doesn't have a solution, do the 'others'? Obviously not!
If the silly 'oldgit' above can't see it then what hope for the youngsters?



 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 12 Dec 14 10.36pm

Quote TUX at 12 Dec 2014 9.49pm

......and why does 'Stuk', who appears to hate Brand, spend so much time researching the man who has NO POWER?

This thread is brilliant example of all that's wrong in OUR country today.
The focus is constantly about 'celebrity over substance'.
I don't agree with Brand all the time and equally cringe occasionally, but he tells it as it is and highlights many issues that rarely come to light in the mainstream media. Who cares if he doesn't have a solution, do the 'others'? Obviously not!
If the silly 'oldgit' above can't see it then what hope for the youngsters?


I think your man's been found out bud. He's bereft of any answers to most of the questions aimed at him last night and frankly looked out of his depth. That said he's not alone there..




 


Pro USA & Israel

TUX Flag redhill 12 Dec 14 11.08pm

Quote Jimenez at 12 Dec 2014 10.36pm

Quote TUX at 12 Dec 2014 9.49pm

......and why does 'Stuk', who appears to hate Brand, spend so much time researching the man who has NO POWER?

This thread is brilliant example of all that's wrong in OUR country today.
The focus is constantly about 'celebrity over substance'.
I don't agree with Brand all the time and equally cringe occasionally, but he tells it as it is and highlights many issues that rarely come to light in the mainstream media. Who cares if he doesn't have a solution, do the 'others'? Obviously not!
If the silly 'oldgit' above can't see it then what hope for the youngsters?


I think your man's been found out bud. He's bereft of any answers to most of the questions aimed at him last night and frankly looked out of his depth. That said he's not alone there..




Another sad soul who spends more of his time reflecting on the 'apparent failings of a comedian' than he does about the MP's who directly affect peoples lives.
Why would anyone do that?

Another gift, along with many, that just keeps on giving.


Edited by TUX (12 Dec 2014 11.09pm)

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 12 Dec 14 11.13pm

Quote TUX at 12 Dec 2014 11.08pm

Quote Jimenez at 12 Dec 2014 10.36pm

Quote TUX at 12 Dec 2014 9.49pm

......and why does 'Stuk', who appears to hate Brand, spend so much time researching the man who has NO POWER?

This thread is brilliant example of all that's wrong in OUR country today.
The focus is constantly about 'celebrity over substance'.
I don't agree with Brand all the time and equally cringe occasionally, but he tells it as it is and highlights many issues that rarely come to light in the mainstream media. Who cares if he doesn't have a solution, do the 'others'? Obviously not!
If the silly 'oldgit' above can't see it then what hope for the youngsters?


I think your man's been found out bud. He's bereft of any answers to most of the questions aimed at him last night and frankly looked out of his depth. That said he's not alone there..




Another sad soul who spends more of his time reflecting on the 'apparent failings of a comedian' than he does about the MP's who directly affect peoples lives.
Why would anyone do that?

Another gift, along with many, that just keeps on giving.


Edited by TUX (12 Dec 2014 11.09pm)


Your man took a beating bud and your backtracking to cover your Ass how sad. The classic counter denial rebuttal.

 


Pro USA & Israel

TUX Flag redhill 12 Dec 14 11.35pm

Quote Jimenez at 12 Dec 2014 11.13pm

Quote TUX at 12 Dec 2014 11.08pm

Quote Jimenez at 12 Dec 2014 10.36pm

Quote TUX at 12 Dec 2014 9.49pm

......and why does 'Stuk', who appears to hate Brand, spend so much time researching the man who has NO POWER?

This thread is brilliant example of all that's wrong in OUR country today.
The focus is constantly about 'celebrity over substance'.
I don't agree with Brand all the time and equally cringe occasionally, but he tells it as it is and highlights many issues that rarely come to light in the mainstream media. Who cares if he doesn't have a solution, do the 'others'? Obviously not!
If the silly 'oldgit' above can't see it then what hope for the youngsters?


I think your man's been found out bud. He's bereft of any answers to most of the questions aimed at him last night and frankly looked out of his depth. That said he's not alone there..




Another sad soul who spends more of his time reflecting on the 'apparent failings of a comedian' than he does about the MP's who directly affect peoples lives.
Why would anyone do that?

Another gift, along with many, that just keeps on giving.


Edited by TUX (12 Dec 2014 11.09pm)


Your man took a beating bud and your backtracking to cover your Ass how sad. The classic counter denial rebuttal.

JimBob.
Why does Brand take up so much of your time? And you've still nothing to add on those that 'rule over us'?

Go figure.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 12 Dec 14 11.41pm

Quote TUX at 12 Dec 2014 11.35pm

Quote Jimenez at 12 Dec 2014 11.13pm

Quote TUX at 12 Dec 2014 11.08pm

Quote Jimenez at 12 Dec 2014 10.36pm

Quote TUX at 12 Dec 2014 9.49pm

......and why does 'Stuk', who appears to hate Brand, spend so much time researching the man who has NO POWER?

This thread is brilliant example of all that's wrong in OUR country today.
The focus is constantly about 'celebrity over substance'.
I don't agree with Brand all the time and equally cringe occasionally, but he tells it as it is and highlights many issues that rarely come to light in the mainstream media. Who cares if he doesn't have a solution, do the 'others'? Obviously not!
If the silly 'oldgit' above can't see it then what hope for the youngsters?


I think your man's been found out bud. He's bereft of any answers to most of the questions aimed at him last night and frankly looked out of his depth. That said he's not alone there..




Another sad soul who spends more of his time reflecting on the 'apparent failings of a comedian' than he does about the MP's who directly affect peoples lives.
Why would anyone do that?

Another gift, along with many, that just keeps on giving.


Edited by TUX (12 Dec 2014 11.09pm)


Your man took a beating bud and your backtracking to cover your Ass how sad. The classic counter denial rebuttal.

JimBob.
Why does Brand take up so much of your time? And you've still nothing to add on those that 'rule over us'?

Go figure.

Actually he doesn't Bud!! Go Figure how American? 'Rule over us' your a grown man yet your still spouting the sort of guff you'd here at a local Polytechnic (sorry community college) I expect better from you Bud!!

 


Pro USA & Israel

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 13 Dec 14 12.24am

Just watched QT. Tried hard to be objective.

I thought:

Russell Brand played the man not the ball in swiping at Nigel Farage. He didn't engage with the questions much and got found out by the bloke who asked him why he wouldn't stand for parliament (but given the state of the shouty idiots in the audience you have to wonder what sane person would want to listen to them moan at you for a living).

He made his populist lefty points well enough. They were simplistic but no more simplistic than any one else's except maybe the journalist.

He's actually gone (very slightly) up in my estimation. I think he does care and he does actually bother. If only the world were as simple as he'd like it to be but as it isn't it probably does need people like him.

I'd still vote for Nige over him any day though.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

snytaxx Flag London 13 Dec 14 2.17am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 Dec 2014 12.24am

Just watched QT. Tried hard to be objective.

I thought:

Russell Brand played the man not the ball in swiping at Nigel Farage. He didn't engage with the questions much and got found out by the bloke who asked him why he wouldn't stand for parliament (but given the state of the shouty idiots in the audience you have to wonder what sane person would want to listen to them moan at you for a living).

He made his populist lefty points well enough. They were simplistic but no more simplistic than any one else's except maybe the journalist.

He's actually gone (very slightly) up in my estimation. I think he does care and he does actually bother. If only the world were as simple as he'd like it to be but as it isn't it probably does need people like him.

I'd still vote for Nige over him any day though.

A fair assesement I think....

Thought the woman from the UAF kind of shot herself in the foot a bit with the constant shouting down of basically everyone.

 

SwalecliffeEagle Flag Swalecliffe 13 Dec 14 7.53am

You've got to hand it to him. I mean, he's masterfully constructed this image of himself as a champion of the people. Whilst the majority of adults see him for what he is, he has a strong base of popularity among many naive, young people and he's exploiting it to great effect. Regardless of the whole 'Champagne Socialist' tag that's rightly been pinned onto him, he continues to build his profile through promoting some tenuous connection he has with the working man and disillusioned youth. Anyone watching QT last night can't have missed his syrupy use of the term 'mate', not to mention the clasping of hands together as if in prayer which surely communicates his sincerity.

He addresses ills in the Westminster establishment recklessly but sensationally (because that sells books), advises all young people to boycott elections (which would lead to minority parties he purports to detest gaining the ascendancy), then laments the lack of a clear choice between the parties (yet, in the next breath, he's slating the one party promoting an obvious deviation from the political norm in UKIP).

But his cleverness lies in his ability to critique the establishment and then, when picked up on his suggestions or challenged on matters of substance, he stands back and protests that he's 'not a politician'. Or at least I'd like to think he's clever, because the only other conclusion is that some people are incredibly thick.

 

Page 18 of 25 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end