You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Richard Dawkins Hero


Page 1 of 14 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
TheJudge Flag 12 Jun 15 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 12 Jun 15 2.05pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.


The same Richard Dawkins who wanted all Downs babies aborted? Yes - proper hero, full of compassion.

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 12 Jun 15 2.13pm

Of course Dawkins is a hero.

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 12 Jun 15 2.15pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 2.05pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.


The same Richard Dawkins who wanted all Downs babies aborted? Yes - proper hero, full of compassion.

He never said that though did he?
He later elaborated that discovering your unborn child had a genetic disease leaves the parents with a difficult decision to face, surely pro choice is what we all want isnt it?

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

derben Flag 12 Jun 15 2.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.

I read most of the God Delusion (gave up before the finish though). I thought his ideas were poorly argued, almost made me take religion more seriously.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 12 Jun 15 2.19pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 12 Jun 2015 2.15pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 2.05pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.


The same Richard Dawkins who wanted all Downs babies aborted? Yes - proper hero, full of compassion.

He never said that though did he?
He later elaborated that discovering your unborn child had a genetic disease leaves the parents with a difficult decision to face, surely pro choice is what we all want isnt it?

"Abort it and try again. It would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have the choice."

Sounds pretty categorical.


 

johnfirewall Flag 12 Jun 15 2.31pm

Clever bloke.

The Internet was seemingly invented for him, or at least social media and its descent to complete irrationality.

Stands by his views. Can't see him resigning over some daft sexist comment.

Interesting article about what he had for dinner and his home decor. Did the writer actually get to the point? Because I didn't.

Edited by johnfirewall (12 Jun 2015 2.34pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jun 15 2.56pm

I quite like him and read a lot of his books. Personally I don't really rate the God Delusion that much, he's clumsy with his theological and philosophical arguments and relies to heavily on semantics and rhetoric; falling into the same mistaken approach that Creationists do with evolution - they clearly don't understand what they're arguing against, and end up arguing against something entirely different.

Now the 'Blind Watchmaker' makes the arguments much better, by sticking to a subject he clearly understands and you won't find a much better primer on Evolution than this and the 'Selfish Gene'. In fact the Blind Watchmaker is one of the best defenses of Evolution ever produced.

Creationism doesn't need evidence to disprove, it immediately fail due to it being an attempt to present unscientific theory as a scientific theory. Similarly with intelligent design (Dawkins and many others have long since proved these to be unscientific and thus invalid science theories). Unfortunately Dawkins seems to have embraced the role of poster boy for atheism, and has increasingly found himself drawn into a slagging match, rather than argument.

His initial issues with religion were valid, his later decent into a more adversarial atheist, undermine what was a valid argument.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jun 15 2.59pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 12 Jun 2015 2.15pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 2.05pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.


The same Richard Dawkins who wanted all Downs babies aborted? Yes - proper hero, full of compassion.

He never said that though did he?
He later elaborated that discovering your unborn child had a genetic disease leaves the parents with a difficult decision to face, surely pro choice is what we all want isnt it?

Pretty much, of course its his opinion. Its not necessarily an entirely flawed one, given that a lot of people do opt for an abortion on discovering Downs Syndrome. Then again he's very keen on evolutionary psychology, which generally given to such 'morality' (as its based in biology, its divorced from the idea of the individual - so from the perspective he's arguing its a species based moral imperative not a individual personal ethical one).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jun 15 3.02pm

Also he's 74 year old man, it shouldn't be entirely surprising if he isn't a bit sexist or otherwise holding of prejudiced values.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 12 Jun 15 3.16pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 2.19pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 12 Jun 2015 2.15pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 2.05pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.


The same Richard Dawkins who wanted all Downs babies aborted? Yes - proper hero, full of compassion.

He never said that though did he?
He later elaborated that discovering your unborn child had a genetic disease leaves the parents with a difficult decision to face, surely pro choice is what we all want isnt it?

"Abort it and try again. It would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have the choice."

Sounds pretty categorical.


Happy to give you this round but his opinion was expanded on, think about how much of a disadvantage a child born with downs faces vs a child without, this is the crux of Dawkins argument in a majority of cases people with downs are pushed to the fringes of society & forgotten about.

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

npn Flag Crowborough 12 Jun 15 3.20pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 12 Jun 2015 3.16pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 2.19pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 12 Jun 2015 2.15pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 2.05pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.


The same Richard Dawkins who wanted all Downs babies aborted? Yes - proper hero, full of compassion.

He never said that though did he?
He later elaborated that discovering your unborn child had a genetic disease leaves the parents with a difficult decision to face, surely pro choice is what we all want isnt it?

"Abort it and try again. It would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have the choice."

Sounds pretty categorical.


Happy to give you this round but his opinion was expanded on, think about how much of a disadvantage a child born with downs faces vs a child without, this is the crux of Dawkins argument in a majority of cases people with downs are pushed to the fringes of society & forgotten about.


Yes, but he's an expert in evolution - the occasional 'different' offspring surely is a factor in aiding nature to adjust to fit into various niches. Who's to say that downs is not something which may prove advantageous in some as yet undiscovered field? Surely it's up to nature to decide.

I could even cope with his personal decision to abort, but to claim it's immoral not to seems to go against nature's way.

 

TheJudge Flag 12 Jun 15 3.25pm

I would suggest that it is easy to take one statement he has made and criticise it fairly or unfairly, but religious doctrine certainly would not stand up as well to that sort of scrutiny would it.
Even if you don't like his approach, he is a one man crusade against the idiocy of religion and uses the scientific method to counter theology.
For that reason alone he is a hero.

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 12 Jun 15 3.40pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 3.20pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 12 Jun 2015 3.16pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 2.19pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 12 Jun 2015 2.15pm

Quote npn at 12 Jun 2015 2.05pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.


The same Richard Dawkins who wanted all Downs babies aborted? Yes - proper hero, full of compassion.

He never said that though did he?
He later elaborated that discovering your unborn child had a genetic disease leaves the parents with a difficult decision to face, surely pro choice is what we all want isnt it?

"Abort it and try again. It would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have the choice."

Sounds pretty categorical.


Happy to give you this round but his opinion was expanded on, think about how much of a disadvantage a child born with downs faces vs a child without, this is the crux of Dawkins argument in a majority of cases people with downs are pushed to the fringes of society & forgotten about.


Yes, but he's an expert in evolution - the occasional 'different' offspring surely is a factor in aiding nature to adjust to fit into various niches. Who's to say that downs is not something which may prove advantageous in some as yet undiscovered field? Surely it's up to nature to decide.

I could even cope with his personal decision to abort, but to claim it's immoral not to seems to go against nature's way.


I would argue genetic diseases are a rock solid argument against the existence of an interventionist god but I digress.

Evolution is made up of something like 99% genetic failures & 1% success.

It's the human race's responsibility to fit people with downs & those with other genetic diseases into society until such a time happens then yes it's begs the question of if it is morally the right thing to do or not, certainly it comes down to how much of a good life you can guarantee for that child.

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

SirPeanut Flag Keston 12 Jun 15 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Jun 2015 2.56pm

I quite like him and read a lot of his books. Personally I don't really rate the God Delusion that much, he's clumsy with his theological and philosophical arguments and relies to heavily on semantics and rhetoric; falling into the same mistaken approach that Creationists do with evolution - they clearly don't understand what they're arguing against, and end up arguing against something entirely different.

Now the 'Blind Watchmaker' makes the arguments much better, by sticking to a subject he clearly understands and you won't find a much better primer on Evolution than this and the 'Selfish Gene'. In fact the Blind Watchmaker is one of the best defenses of Evolution ever produced.

Creationism doesn't need evidence to disprove, it immediately fail due to it being an attempt to present unscientific theory as a scientific theory. Similarly with intelligent design (Dawkins and many others have long since proved these to be unscientific and thus invalid science theories). Unfortunately Dawkins seems to have embraced the role of poster boy for atheism, and has increasingly found himself drawn into a slagging match, rather than argument.

His initial issues with religion were valid, his later decent into a more adversarial atheist, undermine what was a valid argument.


Spot on. The God Delusion is not his best book but The Blind Watchmaker is superb.

I think he is just getting a bit frustrated in his old age with the ignorance of the religious arguments put to him continually. Must feel like he has been banging his head against a wall for years.

 


There are two kinds of person in this world:
1) Those who can extrapolate from incomplete data

TheJudge Flag 12 Jun 15 3.45pm

Quote SirPeanut at 12 Jun 2015 3.43pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Jun 2015 2.56pm

I quite like him and read a lot of his books. Personally I don't really rate the God Delusion that much, he's clumsy with his theological and philosophical arguments and relies to heavily on semantics and rhetoric; falling into the same mistaken approach that Creationists do with evolution - they clearly don't understand what they're arguing against, and end up arguing against something entirely different.

Now the 'Blind Watchmaker' makes the arguments much better, by sticking to a subject he clearly understands and you won't find a much better primer on Evolution than this and the 'Selfish Gene'. In fact the Blind Watchmaker is one of the best defenses of Evolution ever produced.

Creationism doesn't need evidence to disprove, it immediately fail due to it being an attempt to present unscientific theory as a scientific theory. Similarly with intelligent design (Dawkins and many others have long since proved these to be unscientific and thus invalid science theories). Unfortunately Dawkins seems to have embraced the role of poster boy for atheism, and has increasingly found himself drawn into a slagging match, rather than argument.

His initial issues with religion were valid, his later decent into a more adversarial atheist, undermine what was a valid argument.


Spot on. The God Delusion is not his best book but The Blind Watchmaker is superb.

I think he is just getting a bit frustrated in his old age with the ignorance of the religious arguments put to him continually. Must feel like he has been banging his head against a wall for years.

I actually agree but the God Delusion is a good place to start IMO.

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 12 Jun 15 4.20pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.

The Guardian article's really positive towards Dawkins.

I'll just go out there and say that I think Dawkins is awful and his operation as champion of a wholly rationalist approach is harmful and heartless.
No I haven't read the God Delusion nor The Selfish Gene and yes I'm a Christian. Dawkins is a villain not a hero.

My main reservation is to do with his aggression. As a biologist he has every right to promote evolution as an academic and criticise religion.
BUT. I don't think it's heroic to try and intimidate and aggressively ridicule people and accuse them of being worse than child abusers for being religious and passing on their views. He doesn't exactly promote respect between diverse persons. Or does he? Am I completely wrong?

Like Pope Francis says, one should not provoke or be insulting to people of faith. It shows a lack of respect. I'm not saying that atheists in general are like this but Dawkins is and I think he is undignified.

That is pretty much the basis for my dislike of him. I have not mentioned the down syndrome incident specifically because it is all tied up with this principle of disrespect and hate.

Is there disrespect and hate among some religious people? Of course and it's dreadful, but Dawkins is just as bad. If you go so far as to agree with his standpoint, attitude and the way he addresses religious persons then you are also filled with hate and lack compassion. An interest in his academic publications about biology is different.

Sorry to have bombed the Dawkins party. I know I haven't read his works but I've read his tweets, articles and seen extended video footage of him. I think that's quite enough to make a judgement.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (12 Jun 2015 4.22pm)

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

reborn 12 Jun 15 4.35pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 1.53pm

[Link]

In my opinion, he deserves hero status.

The God Delusion is a must read.

This headline is typical Guardian nonsense.


In my opinion he is a hate filled, frothing at the mouth madman.

Fine, don't believe it, but why spend your life so aggressively demanding others agree with you.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

ChuFukka Flag 12 Jun 15 4.39pm

Dawkins is a brilliant scientist and writer, understandably jaded after years of trying to educate imbeciles who have no intent to listen. It must be extremely frustrating to be repeatedly dragged into arguments where your life's work is undermined by people who don't even begin to understand it.

 

derben Flag 12 Jun 15 4.55pm

The funniest thing with Dawkins is how much he actually hates something that he says he does not believe exists.

 

Page 1 of 14 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero