This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by MKCPFC
That is just your opinion, you do not know and neither do I. I see the team playing well with him in it and I see him involved in goals. So do you but that is not enough for you. I guess the question is are we playing well because of benteke or despite him. And if we had someone else would we be doing even better. That's a question we all seem divided on and we're just going around in circles. Guess we'll just have to wait until the end of thd season and see how many goals he's scored by then. Giving up on this one till then.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Yes I take you point. My rebuttal to that would be... the main differentiator is we've got Zaha! Edited by MonsterMunch (17 Jan 2018 10.47am) Cheers, and you are correct about Zaha, we are looking at smaller details here.
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
I guess the question is are we playing well because of benteke or despite him. And if we had someone else would we be doing even better. That's a question we all seem divided on and we're just going around in circles. Guess we'll just have to wait until the end of thd season and see how many goals he's scored by then. Giving up on this one till then. Correct Spartak, and yes we should wait and see.
|
|
|
I got so bored off your constant petulant comments. I gave up readingg your last message after about 3 seconds. Get a sense of humour and try not to feel a victim when anyone throws a bit of banter your way. Sigh Originally posted by chateauferret
If you've responded to losing an argument by shouting and swearing then it's you who needs to get a grip. FWIW, I'm not engaging with anyone who behaves like a spoiled toddler, so have a nice evening.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jayjaychil
I got so bored off your constant petulant comments. I gave up readingg your last message after about 3 seconds. Get a sense of humour and try not to feel a victim when anyone throws a bit of banter your way. Sigh
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
He said £30 mil and Crouch. Not a straight swap. Exactly. We all know we have space in the squad for extra strikers. I also think Crouch can still offer us something by holding the ball up and bringing other players in. Just give him contract until may 2019
|
|
|
Originally posted by youngpalacefan111
You don't seem to understand what I'm saying, the two players in question are the two players who have massively underperformed this season, however one of the players is our most expensive signing in the history of the club and highest earner, the other is one of our lowest earners at the club and only cost 3mill. I've never moaned about Hennessey for those reasons even though his performances have been equally as bad as bentekes. You also can't fault henessey s attitude and commitment, I can't say the same about benteke. Agreed in part, however 30 million for a Striker is not unheard of, and is common place in the premier league and Europe's other top leagues. in fact if you look at what players are going for this window 28 million is almost chicken feed in comparison, and it pains me to say it, but it really is. Its an average amount for a Striker of proven ability. Now when you look at keepers, there are only two I think, Buffon and Ederson, that where anything close to 28 Million. Manuel Neuer who is easily in the top three keepers in the world, if not the best, only cost 19 million, thats ten million less than tekkers. Thats why your argument about how much players cost in relation to there out put on the pitch is invalid. Now if you had compared him to Bakary Sako, who pulls up treesevery game, and who IS scoring goals and cost much much less, but IS a striker then I'd agree with you. But to compare GK's to Striker's is daft IMO, it's not like a keeper can be lazy is it ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
I guess the question is are we playing well because of benteke or despite him. And if we had someone else would we be doing even better. That's a question we all seem divided on and we're just going around in circles. Guess we'll just have to wait until the end of thd season and see how many goals he's scored by then. Giving up on this one till then. This is the crux of this argument. You can't argue that we don't play as well when Sako goes into the CF spot because he isn't a CF and we have seen how damaging he has become cutting in from the wings. If we had another CF to compare form with we would have a better idea, but we don't, so we can't, so as Kev says, we might as well just wait and see what happens once we do get a new striker.
|
|
|
Originally posted by AERO
Yes the team are doing well but could be even better .wayne Hennessy must have kicked at least 10 or more kicks to him second half and he managed to get to one ,with wilf waiting for flick on,s .He was yards away and got pushed off all to easily. I accept Benteke has a lot of room for improvement in terms of his goal return this season, but this is the sort of nonsense which really winds me up; the bloke literally won the most headers of any player in Europe's top 5 leagues in 2017 - by all means criticise him, but to suggest he doesn't win enough headers is ludicrous. There's literally nobody better in Europe at it, statistically. Our fan base will always criticise anyone who arrives with a significant transfer fee; happens time and time again. You only have to look at the responses on this thread to see that the crux of most people's issues with Benteke is that he was expensive and hasn't fulfilled their perception of what a £30m striker should be. There's always a cheaper option who turned out to be better value, but it's not realistic to think we're always going to find that gem - sometimes you have to splash out to get the man. Last year's 17 goals have been very very quickly forgotten by some.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Last year's 17 goals have been very very quickly forgotten by some. And those goals kept us up - which covers his fee. At the moment we're a better team with him in than out, so it's an easy pick for Roy.
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by EagleinSF
And those goals kept us up - which covers his fee. At the moment we're a better team with him in than out, so it's an easy pick for Roy. indeed!
|
|
|
Originally posted by EagleinSF
And those goals kept us up - which covers his fee. At the moment we're a better team with him in than out, so it's an easy pick for Roy. We are a better team only because his inclusion allows us to field an actual striker. Last season gives him a certain amount of credit in the bank, whether this is now exhausted is another question. I'm repeating myself here but if we sign any of the strikers linked so far he will be getting splinters on his backside very soon there is surely no doubt about that. Edited by MonsterMunch (17 Jan 2018 9.24pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
We are a better team only because his inclusion allows us to field an actual striker. Last season gives him a certain amount of credit in the bank, whether this is now exhausted is another question. I'm repeating myself here but if we sign any of the strikers linked so far he will be getting splinters on his backside very soon there is surely no doubt about that. Edited by MonsterMunch (17 Jan 2018 9.24pm) Possibly, but that's all supposition.... Suppose we get a striker in and also that he fits into the team better than Tekkers. Personally I hope so - Big Ben needs someone pushing him. We saw him at his best last season when Wickham was competing for the striker spot.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I accept Benteke has a lot of room for improvement in terms of his goal return this season, but this is the sort of nonsense which really winds me up; the bloke literally won the most headers of any player in Europe's top 5 leagues in 2017 - by all means criticise him, but to suggest he doesn't win enough headers is ludicrous. There's literally nobody better in Europe at it, statistically. Our fan base will always criticise anyone who arrives with a significant transfer fee; happens time and time again. You only have to look at the responses on this thread to see that the crux of most people's issues with Benteke is that he was expensive and hasn't fulfilled their perception of what a £30m striker should be. There's always a cheaper option who turned out to be better value, but it's not realistic to think we're always going to find that gem - sometimes you have to splash out to get the man. Last year's 17 goals have been very very quickly forgotten by some. Yohan had exactly the same threads about him 18 months/1 year ago.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
Yohan had exactly the same threads about him 18 months/1 year ago. Benteke off to Chelsea as a permanent move? Would be a good move if we could sign Babacar and Dembele in return
|
|
|
Originally posted by Petereagle
Benteke off to Chelsea as a permanent move? Would be a good move if we could sign Babacar and Dembele in return Daily Mail Peter !!!!!!
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.