You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 18 of 44 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 18 1.56pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

To answer the original question it is the fault of whoever is in charge of recruitment. The last 2 windows have been abysmal. I firmly believe Hodgson is doing the best with what he has to work with

I understand the criticisms about recruitment but perhaps we should consider the backdrop which of course is the financial constraint we have been operating under.In January 2017, season 2017-18, our expenditure was about £11.6 Mill (Excluding the Sorloth add-ons) and in the last window in the summer our expenditure was around £10 Mill so both figures are relevant 'Peanuts' in PL terms.That said,our transfer activity hasn't bore fruit as yet and perhaps unlikely to do so.Must do better in January !

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 09 Dec 18 1.56pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

The problem as I see it is that we really lack quality beyond the starting eleven. And for that reason we have players playing out of position and a manager reluctant to make changes to either the starting line up or during matches.

Look at the bench yesterday and then make a convincing case for starting any of those players - I'm struggling to. Are they ' game changers ' ? - Roy doesn't think so and I agree with him.

In a results business I think Roy is staring down the end of a barrel now. 12 months on and we are back to where we were a year ago only instead of results improving they are getting worse.But then who do you replace him with ? We're running out of the short term fix appointment candidates.

My perception of the way that the club is run is that there is no cohesive strategy or planning for the medium term on the playing side. Instead it's an annual fire fighting exercise. Parish seems to have too much direct influence and input rather than hire people that have proven experience in the running of football clubs.

I was told yesterday that Simon Jordan has hinted that Palace are unofficially up for sale ( £220m asking price ) - not seen that myself, but could that be a factor in where we currently find ourselves ?

Well the one saving grace is that is about £220m out of his price range.

Hodgson to me just looks tired. I think the England situation damaged him. Last season he was on a hiding to nothing as we were gone. There was no expectation so it was a free shot. Much like when he took over with England.

When the expectation kicks in that’s where it becomes an issue.

He never fancied Zaha for England and Roy’s approach is safety first. Unfortunately sides are figuring him out. Our wingbacks are attacking and neither mark up particularly close. PVA in particular. They then have MacArthur and Meyer in front of them - not Wilf and Andros so are caught.

Even Sam preferred Schlupp to PVA to start and in a side that needs to be defensively sound PVA wouldn’t be my first name on the sheet. Schlupp is a woeful footballer, but he doesn’t spend the game thinking he is a right winger when playing left back.

It’s all a bit Mike Bassett. The flair players are being asked to do a job that isn’t there normal one - negating them. Meyer and MacArthur aren’t wingers. But they are being asked to do the same - now you have four players out. Luka doesn’t have Cabaye anymore and doesn’t have Meyer either as he is out of position.

There is no point having two defensive midfielders if your fullbacks are being found out and things are coming from crosses.

 

Jacey Flag 09 Dec 18 2.13pm

Agree Roy looks very tired,fed up and is finding it,amongst a run of very poor results,so very difficult to motivate and inspire the squad.

To save our season,do we need the benefit of a new manager bounce???

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 09 Dec 18 2.16pm

[quote=It's only a game;3388530]

An additional hand dryer installed in each of the toilets & fragrant soap maybe?


Love it. Very funny.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 09 Dec 18 2.18pm

Originally posted by rikz

Wagner

Just going through the Ring Cycle with him. Expect the Valkyries might be screeching if he was appointed. However if he can get the players playing like an orchestra and sort out the present racket then sign him up.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

JoeViper Flag bromley 09 Dec 18 2.42pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

Someone on facebook saying there's gonna be a big announcement tomorrow.

They have caught the mouse at the training ground canteen. It was Speedy Gonzales and Parish has offered him a trial.

Update: Speedy has now got an agent and wants a 4yr deal at £90k a week

Edited by JoeViper (09 Dec 2018 2.48pm)

 


One of the biggest mysteries in life is that loud stupid people normally don't have even the slightest inclination that they are stupid.

davehuggins Flag 09 Dec 18 3.45pm

Perhaps it is time to rip the squad apart and start again??? Let us be honest this seems to happen every season and I just ask why??? Time for change???

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Dec 18 3.47pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

Perhaps it is time to rip the squad apart and start again??? Let us be honest this seems to happen every season and I just ask why??? Time for change???

The only way that would happen is with relegation. Back to the wilderness.

 


Red and Blue Army!

davehuggins Flag 09 Dec 18 3.57pm

Young manager in if we survive and then sell and change, seems drastic but this happens every season.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 09 Dec 18 4.16pm

We've a midfield full of tidy players who are comfortable with the ball. Throw in Riedewald and Puncheon. Tomkins and Sahko don't score enough from CB.

McArthur, Wilf and PVA get their fair share but the last looks a liability in defence. Townsend is generally shocking when asked the question and we've not got a fit centre forward worth the name. Where is the attacking / creative quality ?

Roy has to take the can for Sorloth but the rest ?

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (09 Dec 2018 4.17pm)

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Dec 18 8.07pm

100% the board. Amateurs.

 


Bring back Brolin

Den1923 Flag 09 Dec 18 8.20pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

100% the board. Amateurs.

Sadly think you are right, SP has to be responsible with the rest of the board, RH can only play with the card that he has been dealt. At least half our first team squad, if not more would struggle to hold a place in any progressive team in the championship. Parish, oversees all signings, that his way so he has to take the can. Even on modest budgets, teams seem to progress, just look at Bournemouth, Watford & B&HA they all have Chairman who allow their Managers to manage, something SP does not do, he is a control freak and can't " walk the talk"!

 

davehuggins Flag 09 Dec 18 8.48pm

This I'm afraid seems to be true,

 

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Dec 18 9.13pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Sadly think you are right, SP has to be responsible with the rest of the board, RH can only play with the card that he has been dealt. At least half our first team squad, if not more would struggle to hold a place in any progressive team in the championship. Parish, oversees all signings, that his way so he has to take the can. Even on modest budgets, teams seem to progress, just look at Bournemouth, Watford & B&HA they all have Chairman who allow their Managers to manage, something SP does not do, he is a control freak and can't " walk the talk"!

Can you name the other board members as its a joint decision on transfers.
Watford and the Pozzos have gone through more managers than most and you think they allow them to manage!
Results determine peoples opinion, if Lukas free kick had gone in instead of crashing back off the bar, the chances at 2-0 we would of gone on to win.
Anti Parish posts always appear after a defeat, last week after Burnley win nothing. Says a lot about supporters.

 

SouthLondonAP Flag Near Earth Orbit 09 Dec 18 9.15pm

Originally posted by rikz

Wagner

TBH I wouldn't trust a manager who leaves any team to join us mid-season even if I wanted Wagner when we signed FdB.

 


South London and Proud - an Crystal Palace blog, podcast and discussion forum. CLICK HERE [Link]

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Dec 18 9.34pm

Originally posted by Painter

Can you name the other board members as its a joint decision on transfers.
Watford and the Pozzos have gone through more managers than most and you think they allow them to manage!
Results determine peoples opinion, if Lukas free kick had gone in instead of crashing back off the bar, the chances at 2-0 we would of gone on to win.
Anti Parish posts always appear after a defeat, last week after Burnley win nothing. Says a lot about supporters.


'Says a lot about supporters' .....yeap it's a result based business and I as a supporter of close on 56 years have every right to say my bit. So I will turn it round to you; are you happy with how our club is being run with regards to planning, transfer policy and scouting, the first and last could be included within TP. When at the top you take the plaudits and critisism. Performances on the pitch at the moment will produce quite rightly the latter. You have rose tinted spectacles on!!

 


Bring back Brolin

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 09 Dec 18 10.15pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

Young manager in if we survive and then sell and change, seems drastic but this happens every season.

Didn’t we try that and attempt a different style. I think we all welcomed Roy in with open arms after 4 games

 

leejaneagles Flag 09 Dec 18 11.39pm

I actually think I'd like to see Roy prove it is the board/the hand he's been dealt.

Why not just play the next 3 games with Meyer in behind Sorloth, Wilf and Townsend on the wings and just see what happens.

If we win then he's a genius. If he loses even worse than we are now, all the fans will back him and say Sorloth's had 3 games with Wilf and Zaha in their correct positions and still not able to hit a cow's backside then heat will be on Parish.

I actually think Roy has the most football knowledge out of anyone at the club and certainly anyone on this board (shock horror) so if he thinks this 442 with Wilf and Andros is the most likely way for us to win then it almost certainly is.

So he's probably a bit cursed as it must go against everything in him to put out a different 11 just to prove the point he already knows. But football isn't an exact Science, if the ball goes off Sorloth's hand into the net and no one notices, he could go on a run you just can't predict. I think that's where Roy may have to lay faith in football God's, as on paper the best 11 are starting every week.

 

Den1923 Flag 09 Dec 18 11.47pm

Originally posted by Painter

Can you name the other board members as its a joint decision on transfers.
Watford and the Pozzos have gone through more managers than most and you think they allow them to manage!
Results determine peoples opinion, if Lukas free kick had gone in instead of crashing back off the bar, the chances at 2-0 we would of gone on to win.
Anti Parish posts always appear after a defeat, last week after Burnley win nothing. Says a lot about supporters.

Sadly, SP records speaks for itself, 6 years in PL and no progress, he is obsessed about the stadium refurbishment, which will look great in the championship half empty, he has regularly botched up transfer deals that are consistently left to the last minute and then fall through. The club is toxic from within, evidenced by quality players talking to the club but then the deal never gets over the line. Freedman is the Director of Football in name only because he has done nothing to get players in, probably, he is not allowed enough rope by SP. Good previous managers have fallen out with SP. He has allowed us to drift with a paper thin squad for over two years now and without a decent striker for over 12 months and then there is just three wins this season and if we do go down he would have overseen the biggest loss in revenue in the clubs history, not a bad record I suppose?

As for the other board member they are responsible for allowing him to get this far without questioning him on his performance which is at best E-.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Dec 18 3.05am

Originally posted by Den1923

Sadly think you are right, SP has to be responsible with the rest of the board, RH can only play with the card that he has been dealt. At least half our first team squad, if not more would struggle to hold a place in any progressive team in the championship. Parish, oversees all signings, that his way so he has to take the can. Even on modest budgets, teams seem to progress, just look at Bournemouth, Watford & B&HA they all have Chairman who allow their Managers to manage, something SP does not do, he is a control freak and can't " walk the talk"!

Never heard such tosh.

Every single one of our first 11 would walk into any championship squad. 5 or 6 of them would walk into most premiership teams outside the top 10.

Then there's our squad players, who are also decent championship level - Punch, Riederwald, Kelly, Ward etc.

 

Page 18 of 44 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?