You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Brighton Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Brighton Match Thread


Page 18 of 21 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >
The Dolphin Flag 10 Mar 19 4.12pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Need to take a look at Soton 2nd goal. Midfielder belting along with the play, earning a free kick (and possible red card with another ref) which they score from. No side ways passing mids there and a decent dead ball taker. Two areas we are weak in. Lots to do in our attacking presence over the pre season if we survive.

Edited by Booted Eagle (10 Mar 2019 11.38am)

Kouyate does that but didn't get picked!!!!!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Mar 19 4.21pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Kouyate does that but didn't get picked!!!!!

I was going to mention this. He is the one player who has the ability to drive 10 yards into the space in front of him thus opening up various new passing angles / options. Why he doesn't start is beyond me.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 10 Mar 19 8.09pm

Originally posted by Alexi_the_Eagle

Aside from winning the penalty. Andros had a shocker of a game. So did Batshuayi. Don’t think I’ve ever yelled at my TV that loud whenever Bats and his first touch let him down.

Batshuayi is woeful at football save one important thing. Everyone knows it. No point saying it.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 10 Mar 19 8.24pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Kouyate does that but didn't get picked!!!!!

RLC used to do this as well. With him in the midfield and Cabaye last season about this time we did the Weed in a blistering 1st half. Our midfield yesterday was definitely weaker in terms of attacking threat than last year. As you say Kouyate can fill this role. If Meyer isn't going to play then we need another attacking midfielder who can take a decent free kick/corner. A cursory glance at the goal differences in the league table tells you that our defence is really solid and whilst there is a question mark over attack, until the midfield starts producing attacking threat then it is hard to judge. Some goals have to come from somewhere and they are not coming from free kicks or corners at the mo. If goals come from this direction perhaps a more calm and relaxed feeling will happen with our goal scoring chances.

Edited by Booted Eagle (10 Mar 2019 8.30pm)

Edited by Booted Eagle (10 Mar 2019 8.31pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Borismogg Flag South Croydon 10 Mar 19 9.59pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Batshuayi is woeful at football save one important thing. Everyone knows it. No point saying it.

I don't know it. Please tell me.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 11 Mar 19 3.56am

The one player we really missed yesterday was Sakho. For most of the game Dann and Tomkins were under no pressure when they were on the ball, where as most teams would have 1 attacker putting the central defenders under pressure. Brighton just put the attacker behind the ball meaning when we tried to pass forward it was trying to find 1 of 8 palace players been marked by 10 Brighton players. Sakho though can usually either find the pass or have the confidence to take the ball forward and in doing so drag the one of the 2 spare Brighton players out of their marking zone. This would have then made it a bit easier for the midfielders and forwards to find space. Dann and Tomkins played it safe and stayed back and it made it easy for Brighton.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Mar 19 6.20am

Originally posted by silvertop

Batshuayi is woeful at football save one important thing. Everyone knows it. No point saying it.

A few times he flicked it behind him without looking? None of them went to our player. Just needed to control it and lay it off.
But he’s the only one that can finish.
Still so f*vked off with saturdays performance.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 11 Mar 19 6.33am

Originally posted by viveasheagle

The one player we really missed yesterday was Sakho. For most of the game Dann and Tomkins were under no pressure when they were on the ball, where as most teams would have 1 attacker putting the central defenders under pressure. Brighton just put the attacker behind the ball meaning when we tried to pass forward it was trying to find 1 of 8 palace players been marked by 10 Brighton players. Sakho though can usually either find the pass or have the confidence to take the ball forward and in doing so drag the one of the 2 spare Brighton players out of their marking zone. This would have then made it a bit easier for the midfielders and forwards to find space. Dann and Tomkins played it safe and stayed back and it made it easy for Brighton.

It would help if one or two of those players actually moved and tried to loose their marker instead of just standing there waiting for the ball to come to them.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Mar 19 7.14am

Originally posted by becky

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lucky or not ' by Midlands Eagle

At one point, near the end of the match, a ball came across the goal, about 6 yards from the line and something like 1 foot above Benteke....... the commentators reaction - Oh that's just too high for Benteke to get.......

Even at my age, I could jump 1 ft off the ground if need be!

I came to the conclusion long ago that he is a w@nker.

 


COYP

tjc47380 Flag 11 Mar 19 7.19am

Originally posted by spartakev2
I agree with many of the posts on here. I have the greatest respect for Roy Hodgson, but if I found myself sitting next to him on train, I would ask him the following questions :

a) Why do we need to play three defensive midfielders at home against a bottom-six team? We know that they will come to defend, so why not sacrifice one of those defensive midfield players for a creative midfielder who can move the ball forward through the lines. We have that player : Max Meyer

b) Why do we persist with the same corner routine when it does not seem to have any success. It must be worth trying a short corner to Zaha every now and again to let him run at defenders just outside the box.

c) Once Benteke comes on to the field as a substitute, why not just try something different and bombard their area with high balls in the hope of getting something from a knock-down. However poor Benteke’s confidence is at the moment, he has a really impressive sets of statistics for winning headed duels.

d) We assume that our players spend time studying their opponents before games. Most people watching that game knew that Knockaert would have wanted to cut inside and shoot with his left foot. How on earth can PVA give him so much room to do just what he wanted?

e) To echo the previous poster : why are our attacking players so static? They seem to be on their heels waiting for the ball to come to them. It seems clear from the stands that they should be constantly on the move, encouraging their team mates to find them with a pass. We see this done so often and so effectively every week by other Premiership teams. Why are our players not instructed to make these runs?


It would help if one or two of those players actually moved and tried to loose their marker instead of just standing there waiting for the ball to come to them.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Mar 19 8.51am

Originally posted by Alexi_the_Eagle

Aside from winning the penalty. Andros had a shocker of a game. So did Batshuayi. Don’t think I’ve ever yelled at my TV that loud whenever Bats and his first touch let him down.

Townsend has been somewhat abject recently and was only sub for the Burnley game. Why on earth did Hodgson not go with the side that started at Burnley? He went back to the same players who have failed to deliver at home game on game and us poor supporters had to endure more predictable dross.

Both the Southampton and Newcastle managers made decisions which turned the game around for their teams but Hodgson is loathe to really deviate from a poor ‘Plan A’.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Mar 19 9.35am

Originally posted by Willo

Townsend has been somewhat abject recently and was only sub for the Burnley game. Why on earth did Hodgson not go with the side that started at Burnley? He went back to the same players who have failed to deliver at home game on game and us poor supporters had to endure more predictable dross.

Both the Southampton and Newcastle managers made decisions which turned the game around for their teams but Hodgson is loathe to really deviate from a poor ‘Plan A’.


The Hodgson mantra:


If Plan A isn't working

Revert to Plan A

 

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Mar 19 9.44am

I don't support those calling for Hodgson being replaced but I will say this about Palace.

110 home league fixtures since coming back into the Premiership winning just 36 of them. losing 54 of them and drawing 20 of them.

Season tickets aren't cheap. I think the average Palace home fan hasn't been served very well and can rightly feel a little miffed.

Every season we are looking over our shoulders at relegation while teams like Wolves come straight up and compete with the big boys.


Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2019 9.45am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Mar 19 9.52am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I don't support those calling for Hodgson being replaced but I will say this about Palace.

110 home league fixtures since coming back into the Premiership winning just 36 of them. losing 54 of them and drawing 20 of them.

Season tickets aren't cheap. I think the average Palace home fan hasn't been served very well and can rightly feel a little miffed.

Every season we are looking over our shoulders at relegation while teams like Wolves come straight up and compete with the big boys.


Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2019 9.45am)

For every Wolves there are two Fulhams though Stirling

In truth, Wolves is a bigger team in terms of history and fan base. And currently has much deeper pockets with a hugely experienced investor.

[Link]

 

batcountry Flag Melbourne 11 Mar 19 10.03am

I don’t know why we don’t play to our strengths which maybe means if we play role a dope then so be it.
I find that some of our best moments are when Zaha, Meyer and Schlupp / McArthur use their quick feet in a triangle in or near the opponents penalty area and this only occurs with a quick break from deep so we’re not outnumbered by defenders. Too much possession doesn’t help us at all.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 11 Mar 19 10.29am

Originally posted by batcountry

I don’t know why we don’t play to our strengths which maybe means if we play role a dope then so be it.
I find that some of our best moments are when Zaha, Meyer and Schlupp / McArthur use their quick feet in a triangle in or near the opponents penalty area and this only occurs with a quick break from deep so we’re not outnumbered by defenders. Too much possession doesn’t help us at all.

When we play the top teams at home we don't expect, seek or get more possession of the ball. As you rightly say, too much possession doesn't help us.

Opponents such as Brighton know that their best chance of getting anything from a game is to deny the opposition space. They do this at home, not just away.So little chance of drawing them out unless they have to chase the game.

If we went into every home game with those tactics there would be people moaning that we aren't taking the game to teams enough.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Mar 19 10.48am

Originally posted by Mapletree

For every Wolves there are two Fulhams though Stirling

In truth, Wolves is a bigger team in terms of history and fan base. And currently has much deeper pockets with a hugely experienced investor.

[Link]

All true of course, but having said that....if you're a Fulham fan you have cause for even louder complaint....though their rise was always built upon quicksand and eventually died with their backer.

I think a Palace season ticket holder should be getting a little better for their money at the moment. Still, like I say....Hodgson has done relatively well for us.

This has been a long standing problem.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Thereandbackagain Flag Crawley 11 Mar 19 11.23am

Once again the Brighton Manager out foxes good old Roy who has been in business for many more years ...He must of known that Brighton would start the same game like when we had them at their place , They doubled up on Wilf and Andros ever time we had the ball , but rather than move the ball quick we again tried to take them on which again wasn't working , to beat a back line of Eight defenders you have to be clever and move it quick and then in turn move yourself quicker ...it was far to easy for them and Roy couldn't even see it ...5 plus corners all the same which they dealt with and our old foe Glenn took the piss all game as a lone striker as he bullied us , chased lost balls and gave away time consuming fouls . It took us till nearly 90 minutes before we showed any form of aggression unlike them who dished it out from the first whistle ...but that would of only come from the manager ...If I am honest it was not Wilfs game again as tries to hard against them and it has the opposite effect , I am sure that if we did meet them in the FA semi it again would be the same type of game set out by them and again we would not have the no how of how to break it down as it seem we have no Plan B and sometimes struggle with Plan A ...Roy is too nice and even when we do beat a team he shakes his head and holds his hand out in the most apologetic way to the opposite number ...I have to work with Two seaweed and on Friday they thought they was going to be on the end of a hiding and now today they are actually not taking the Piss but giving me pity which pains me more

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 11 Mar 19 11.31am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

All true of course, but having said that....if you're a Fulham fan you have cause for even louder complaint....though their rise was always built upon quicksand and eventually died with their backer.

I think a Palace season ticket holder should be getting a little better for their money at the moment. Still, like I say....Hodgson has done relatively well for us.

This has been a long standing problem.


Its very frustrating, 15 home games this season, 3 wins and 11 goals, a few of which are penalties.
Away from home i get that we play defensive and hit on the break, but at home where we have to take the game to the opposition (minus top 6 teams) we need to play the attack minded players.

Why Meyer doesn't get a game at home is beyond me.. Jimmy Mac was absolutely terrible on Saturday, yet he lasted the majority of the game while Max was made to watch on until towards the end.

Townsend has arguably been our player of the season, yet he's the first player hooked off.. for Benteke!?
Benteke's career at palace is over, hes rapidly becoming a laughing stock, and has to be carried when he plays.

When Max did come on, we played him on the opposite side to Wilf, even though he and wilf link up together superbly in tight spots in and around the area.

Our set piece routines are clearly not worked on as we seem to have no clue with corners or crossed free kicks.
I recall the days under Pulis and Pardew where we were a real threat from corners, whats happened?

PVA clearly has played himself out of form and needs some time on the bench to realise hes not un-droppable.

Its clear we miss Sakho, he so often starts our attacks with a clever pass, or carries the ball into their half. Our current pairing are less competent footballers and rely more on long ball upto Batshuyai whos not a target man.

Im not going to go on as my venting is probably very boring, but theres so many factors that need addressing.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Mar 19 1.03pm

Originally posted by RyWa


Its very frustrating, 15 home games this season, 3 wins and 11 goals, a few of which are penalties.
Away from home i get that we play defensive and hit on the break, but at home where we have to take the game to the opposition (minus top 6 teams) we need to play the attack minded players.

Why Meyer doesn't get a game at home is beyond me.. Jimmy Mac was absolutely terrible on Saturday, yet he lasted the majority of the game while Max was made to watch on until towards the end.

Townsend has arguably been our player of the season, yet he's the first player hooked off.. for Benteke!?
Benteke's career at palace is over, hes rapidly becoming a laughing stock, and has to be carried when he plays.

When Max did come on, we played him on the opposite side to Wilf, even though he and wilf link up together superbly in tight spots in and around the area.

Our set piece routines are clearly not worked on as we seem to have no clue with corners or crossed free kicks.
I recall the days under Pulis and Pardew where we were a real threat from corners, whats happened?

PVA clearly has played himself out of form and needs some time on the bench to realise hes not un-droppable.

Its clear we miss Sakho, he so often starts our attacks with a clever pass, or carries the ball into their half. Our current pairing are less competent footballers and rely more on long ball upto Batshuyai whos not a target man.

Im not going to go on as my venting is probably very boring, but theres so many factors that need addressing.

All your observations are sound, and many here see the same problems. The problem is RH doesn't - he needs to wake up and smell the coffee.


Edited by southnorwoodhill (11 Mar 2019 1.04pm)

 

Page 18 of 21 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Brighton Match Thread