You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal palace v Bright*n match thread
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal palace v Bright*n match thread


Page 18 of 23 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >
Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Oct 20 7.20pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Chris Hughton had to leave in order for Brighton to become more attractive, the same will be for Roy .. meanwhile we have to sit on our hands.

Roy is not going to be around for long.

It's not too difficult to be more attractive and get relegated too. It's happened many times. Would that make everyone happy? Or should we hang on in there whilst the academy stabilises and maybe the ownership changes? Who would you think more likely to go down between today's two teams?

Today's game was changed by the goal. I think we would have allowed Brighton to bang on the closed door for the first half and then got more expansive in the second with Eze coming on. Going in front changed that and we then just kept the door shut. Only the smallest of margins stopped us going 2 up too.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Oct 20 7.23pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

I am somewhere in the middle. I think we have the makings of a solid mid table team. But we need to strengthen across the spine of the team in January?

I would have a massive clear out at the end of the season if I had the choice. Wilf needs to go but the dilemma will be the peanuts on offer. Eze needed to come on today at just after half time, regardless of any tantrums from Wilf. There are a dodgy couple of years ahead. I expect us to survive but the squad has less than eleven decent players, let alone 25.

 


Red and Blue Army!

hcjbrooks Flag 18 Oct 20 7.28pm

I pray Roy shows some positivity next week against Fulham as that is a must and should be win game Playing Riedewald regularly who is a talent and Eze who was bought as a flair player will put a smile on we long suffering supporters if Roy releases the shackles on his ever cautious mind set and Is not totally reliant on a downhearted Zaha as our would be match winner

 

PatrickA Flag London 18 Oct 20 7.39pm

I’m willing to take a bet that Roy won’t willingly start Eze and Riedewald in central midfield with two up front.
He’s too cautious.
Hindsight is a wonderful think but when Batshuayi came off today surely Eze or even Benteke would have made more sense than Luka as a replacement.
We were left with a half fit Zaha up front and totally handed the initiative to Brighton.
Roy is what he is and won’t change, but it makes for a frustrating watch.
We shouldn’t be defending with 10 behind the ball at home to Brighton.
Roy seems stuck in a time warp of Italian 1960’s catenaccio defensive tactics for those old enough to remember.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Oct 20 7.43pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m willing to take a bet that Roy won’t willingly start Eze and Riedewald in central midfield with two up front.
He’s too cautious.
Hindsight is a wonderful think but when Batshuayi came off today surely Eze or even Benteke would have made more sense than Luka as a replacement.
We were left with a half fit Zaha up front and totally handed the initiative to Brighton.
Roy is what he is and won’t change, but it makes for a frustrating watch.
We shouldn’t be defending with 10 behind the ball at home to Brighton.
Roy seems stuck in a time warp of Italian 1960’s catenaccio defensive tactics for those old enough to remember.

At least the Italians made it look stylish. We make it look like an afternoon in Bewise.

 


Red and Blue Army!

BelfastEagle Flag 18 Oct 20 7.50pm

We got the ball into their box 4 times in the entire game and our only shot was penalty.


Managers have been sacked immediately for far less.

 

deleted9 Flag 18 Oct 20 7.54pm

The further into the game we went, the more I wanted us to lose. I feel awful saying that but we need a wake up call.

As many have already said, 1 attempt at home to a bottom half team is not acceptable. I firmly believe we have enough talent in our squad/team to score plenty of goals with equally enough tactical defensive nouse to remain solid.

Zaha, Eze, Batshuayi, Townsend interchanging could be a real threat but are so thwarted in this style of play.

I’m not saying anything new here. I just feel so deflated and embarrassed that millions would have watched the team I love and rave about put in a display like that.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Oct 20 8.04pm

Let's get drunk and call in sick to work. One of you can pretend to be my doctor.

 


Red and Blue Army!

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Oct 20 8.06pm

I seem to recall an article by an American sports writer during one of our one season wonder years. We were very negative hoping to score on the break. He described it as a tactic of the weak. I was incensed at the time but looking at us now that is exactly what we are doing and what we are. Trouble is most fans find it difficult to admit that we are one of the weakest squads in this division but are holding a central line by following the moneyballs design of conceding the fewest goals.

Someone said the manure game was the anomaly. I disagree. Of the 5 games played I think the awful 2nd half against Chelsea was the anomaly. The rest of the games have all gone to plan and we would be on 10 points from 5 had the toffees not got that pen and we held out for a few more minutes today.

Not bad for a club with f¥¥k all.

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 18 Oct 20 8.08pm

That was proper s*** today. Home form has been deteriorating season after season so performances like this are no longer a surprise unfortunately. The amount of time and money we’ve had since promotion is astonishing when seeing just how s*** we are. There’s one person that needs to take the blame and he needs to sort this s*** out but I don’t think Parish knows how to. This won’t change all the time Roy’s in charge so we’ll just have suck this up no matter how fvcking embarrassing it is. Just glad we didn’t have to go to selhurst to watch that crap today.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 18 Oct 20 8.14pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I seem to recall an article by an American sports writer during one of our one season wonder years. We were very negative hoping to score on the break. He described it as a tactic of the weak. I was incensed at the time but looking at us now that is exactly what we are doing and what we are. Trouble is most fans find it difficult to admit that we are one of the weakest squads in this division but are holding a central line by following the moneyballs design of conceding the fewest goals.

Someone said the manure game was the anomaly. I disagree. Of the 5 games played I think the awful 2nd half against Chelsea was the anomaly. The rest of the games have all gone to plan and we would be on 10 points from 5 had the toffees not got that pen and we held out for a few more minutes today.

Not bad for a club with f¥¥k all.

Not bad indeed!

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 18 Oct 20 8.19pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

This says it all.. BBC

'We opted for the siege mentality'
Crystal Palace 1-1 Brighton


Crystal Palace

Crystal Palace boss Roy Hodgson, speaking to BBC Sport: "The quality of the defensive performance and effort they put in against a good team. We defended our way almost to a very good three points. It is something that can happen, in the first or the 95th minute - if the opponent have the ball around your area it can fall kindly or get the fortune with a deflection, which I'm sure they would say is fully deserved.

"We started to show our teeth at times in the first half. But unfortunately there is always something in a game when you lead 1-0 and the opponent is taking the game to you, there is something that brings a siege mentality to see the game through. Had we got the second goal you would have seen a different mentality, But we decided on the siege mentality and it almost saw us through.

"There is a lot more we have to give. We ran into a Brighton team that played well today. We were good enough defensively and with our discipline and spirit to come away with three points but we wouldn't be whooping for joy saying that is all our tactical work solved. Luckily I am now doing it with a group with competition for places."

On VAR: "It has been opted for. VAR was opted for. It was seen as better and ruling out clear errors of judgment. As it happens I don't know that there are so many from the on-field officials. It has brought us into a different world where when a goal is scored you wit to see if it will be chalked off. There are always going to degrees after a round of games of managers feeling they were either harshly or less harshly treated."

'We defended our way almost to three points'

And that is all that you need to know about Roy's approach to football and how we will be set up for the rest of the season.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

cannoneagle Flag 18 Oct 20 8.23pm

Can't help thinking that we more than most teams have been affected by no crowds.

We all have witnessed terrible performances by Wilf and when the crowd get on his back he puts the work in. Today he was anonymous, but the team would have been booed stupid today if we had been there and no player wants that. I think someone would have raised their game and showed their passion.

But we are now gutless with a manager happy on the sidelines thinking we are defending well. To see Roy smiling in his interview was perplexing, has he forgotten how poor we were against Chelsea with no shots on goal. Bet MOTD make a point of this...... No improvement whatsoever.

One shot on goal in 180 minutes and it was a penalty!!!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Oct 20 10.04pm

Originally posted by cannoneagle

Can't help thinking that we more than most teams have been affected by no crowds.

We all have witnessed terrible performances by Wilf and when the crowd get on his back he puts the work in. Today he was anonymous, but the team would have been booed stupid today if we had been there and no player wants that. I think someone would have raised their game and showed their passion.

But we are now gutless with a manager happy on the sidelines thinking we are defending well. To see Roy smiling in his interview was perplexing, has he forgotten how poor we were against Chelsea with no shots on goal. Bet MOTD make a point of this...... No improvement whatsoever.

One shot on goal in 180 minutes and it was a penalty!!!

With respect we were hardly entertaining WITH crowds at Selhurst Park.

Turgid,negative dross against opponents who have hardly
sparkled over recent seasons,yet we allowed them to dominate and were too afraid to push them on to the back foot.

I'm afraid this is what we can expect, yet again this season under Roy Hodgson who was smiling after the game and praising our defensive resilience.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 18 Oct 20 10.39pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I seem to recall an article by an American sports writer during one of our one season wonder years. We were very negative hoping to score on the break. He described it as a tactic of the weak. I was incensed at the time but looking at us now that is exactly what we are doing and what we are. Trouble is most fans find it difficult to admit that we are one of the weakest squads in this division but are holding a central line by following the moneyballs design of conceding the fewest goals.

Someone said the manure game was the anomaly. I disagree. Of the 5 games played I think the awful 2nd half against Chelsea was the anomaly. The rest of the games have all gone to plan and we would be on 10 points from 5 had the toffees not got that pen and we held out for a few more minutes today.

Not bad for a club with f¥¥k all.

So playing for a draw at home to brighton was part of the plan?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Oct 20 10.44pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

So playing for a draw at home to brighton was part of the plan?

Hodgson appears to be happy with a draw as we were resilient defensively.

I was in a public house tonight and a couple of supporters (Whom I have never seen before), were very vocal in their criticism of Hodgson.There was a degree of profanity amongst their ordure.
My dear wife who has had to put up with my foam-flecked frenzy about our performance, implored me NOT to join their debate.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Oct 20 10.52pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I seem to recall an article by an American sports writer during one of our one season wonder years. We were very negative hoping to score on the break. He described it as a tactic of the weak. I was incensed at the time but looking at us now that is exactly what we are doing and what we are. Trouble is most fans find it difficult to admit that we are one of the weakest squads in this division but are holding a central line by following the moneyballs design of conceding the fewest goals.

Someone said the manure game was the anomaly. I disagree. Of the 5 games played I think the awful 2nd half against Chelsea was the anomaly. The rest of the games have all gone to plan and we would be on 10 points from 5 had the toffees not got that pen and we held out for a few more minutes today.

Not bad for a club with f¥¥k all.

Yep, and I'm sick and tired about hearing how well Everton are doing, our game against them had nothing to do with them beating us at all and in actual fact we had them in that second half, the Chelsea game was full of nasty niggling fouls from them and us defending in the second half like the boys brigade in a hurricane and as you say today if the offside was just a cm back it would've been in the bag.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Oct 20 11.00pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

'We defended our way almost to three points'

And that is all that you need to know about Roy's approach to football and how we will be set up for the rest of the season.

..and it will guarantee safety until a suitable replacement.

 

eaglesdare Flag 18 Oct 20 11.03pm

I'm sure we have had worse starts to the season? ;-)

2 wins, 2 losses and a draw ain't bad at all!

If I wanted to watch good football every week I'd start following Liverpool / man city! We have always played crap football bar the season we got promoted and then some time under pardew! In my opinion anyway!

Win some we loose some, we win 5 in row we loose 5 in row! Draw the odd few games! We go a couple of games without conceding them somtimes we can't score or defend!

I am quite happily enjoying our best years in the prem.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 18 Oct 20 11.06pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

..and it will guarantee safety until a suitable replacement.

We hope

 

Page 18 of 23 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal palace v Bright*n match thread