You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > WBA v Crystal palace match thread
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

WBA v Crystal palace match thread


Page 18 of 19 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 07 Dec 20 2.34pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect, "Intent" is not a factor in respect of red and yellow cards.

OK .......You are so wrong.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Dec 20 3.03pm

Originally posted by Joe Bloggs

OK .......You are so wrong.

One can get into protracted debate on the issue of "Intent" in relation to fouls.
Not every incident viewed as a foul or indeed worthy of a caution has an element of "Intent".
There might of course be intent but decisions are based on the Law.

Anyway, such exchanges of views on the 'Intent' element of fouls do not serve to keep this thread on-track and could evolve into yet another dastardly WILLO thread!


Edited by Willo (07 Dec 2020 3.11pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Dec 20 3.15pm

Originally posted by cantrbury eagle

Just watched match of the day lots of discussion on the penalty Wrighty banging on that PVA was not hurt.an inch to the left and he would have been caught in the crown Jewels If Neymar had been caught the same place he would still be left on turf now 24 hrs after the incident. It was a red card.Pva just didn't make to much of the kick and respect to him for that.

To be honest I did not watch MOTD.
Was Ian Wright of the opinion that the incident was NOT worthy of a 'Red' ?

In terms of WBA, they had Kieran Gibbs sent off at Everton just before half-time when they were losing 2-1.Just like yesterday they collapsed and went on to lose 5-2.

Edited by Willo (07 Dec 2020 3.17pm)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 07 Dec 20 3.49pm

What Souness was saying was that the goals weren't hard enough to score. And if I were a west brom fan, I would agree. It's not a criticism of us.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

cantrbury eagle Flag Canterbury 07 Dec 20 3.55pm

hi WILLO Wrighty and Jenas both said that knew the incident was a red but felt that it shouldnt have been as PVa wasnt hurt that badly

Originally posted by Willo

To be honest I did not watch MOTD.
Was Ian Wright of the opinion that the incident was NOT worthy of a 'Red' ?

In terms of WBA, they had Kieran Gibbs sent off at Everton just before half-time when they were losing 2-1.Just like yesterday they collapsed and went on to lose 5-2.

Edited by Willo (07 Dec 2020 3.17pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Dec 20 3.57pm

Originally posted by Willo

To be honest I did not watch MOTD.
Was Ian Wright of the opinion that the incident was NOT worthy of a 'Red' ?

In terms of WBA, they had Kieran Gibbs sent off at Everton just before half-time when they were losing 2-1.Just like yesterday they collapsed and went on to lose 5-2.

Edited by Willo (07 Dec 2020 3.17pm)

Basically they said, by the letter of the law it was a red but the law is wrong and refs should use common sense. Refs and common sense don’t always go together.
Wright said PVA was not hurt as he played on but you could here him scream! I didn’t and how does he know he was not hurt, fair play to PVA for not rolling around.
Some West Brom fans said he deserved it as is known to show a petulant side

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Dec 20 3.58pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

What Souness was saying was that the goals weren't hard enough to score. And if I were a west brom fan, I would agree. It's not a criticism of us.

That was my interpretation as well

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Dec 20 3.59pm

Originally posted by cantrbury eagle

hi WILLO Wrighty and Jenas both said that knew the incident was a red but felt that it shouldnt have been as PVa wasnt hurt that badly

Canterbury Eagle - Thank you for your response.

Suffice to say I am not in the same page as Wright and Jenas.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Dec 20 4.08pm

Re the red card, it was certainly one of those that had it been a Palace player I would have thought it was both soft and a stupid thing to do. Don't give the ref ( or VAR ) a decision to make.

As to the game, I thought we didn't go looking for a 2nd goal hard enough at 1-0. Awful ball watching from PVA, rookie defending, and at 1-1 it's up for grabs.

But at last we have punished a team down to 10 men. That extra bit of time and space was used to effect.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Jefroc Flag Crete 07 Dec 20 4.58pm

Originally posted by peterg

Of course, West Brom owed us one after Craig Dawson's gbh assault on Jules in October 2014. Any fair or competent ref would have sent Dawson off, VAR or no VAR, but the ref that day was none other than the notorious Mark Cl#nterburg, who not only failed to give a foul against Dawson but even allowed West Brom's consequent goal. I was appalled to see that the late Clattenf*ck made a return on Saturday, as the go-to ref for comments in the Liverpool Wolves tv broadcast. He was as up himself as ever, and was clearly hankering for the days when he could laugh and chat with Ferguson in the tunnel before the Palace/Man U cup final.

Nice post. What goes round comes round!!

 


Always remembering walking from the Holmesdale to the Whitehorse end at half time!

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 08 Dec 20 6.02pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Yes, they had the momentum. West Brom conceded an own goal, their tails were up after they scored their equaliser, they were playing better than us and looked like scoring again, as at the time we were defending very poorly. The sending off of Pereira changed the game completely.

We took advantage of it, for which I am very grateful, but it doesn’t change the fact that we were poor up until they were reduced to ten men. It doesn’t change the fact that we were also extremely poor against Chelsea, Brighton, Wolves, Burnley & Newcastle in our previous games and there is nothing pathetic in suggesting that Leeds would’ve gone on to win, had their perfectly good goal not been disallowed by VAR, because it was a distinct possibility the way the game was going.

Poor in result only, performance wise we were decent apart from the Brighton game where they controlled us brilliantly, Chelsea fouled their way to victory with Sakho ruining a very impressive defensive first half, Wolves again we defended like buffoons allowing them too much space with Bats being offside for our best goal of the season, Wolves were excellent defending us, Burnley & Newcastle could've very easily gone our way and I think you know that.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 08 Dec 20 6.17pm

Originally posted by peterg

Of course, West Brom owed us one after Craig Dawson's gbh assault on Jules in October 2014. Any fair or competent ref would have sent Dawson off, VAR or no VAR, but the ref that day was none other than the notorious Mark Cl#nterburg, who not only failed to give a foul against Dawson but even allowed West Brom's consequent goal. I was appalled to see that the late Clattenf*ck made a return on Saturday, as the go-to ref for comments in the Liverpool Wolves tv broadcast. He was as up himself as ever, and was clearly hankering for the days when he could laugh and chat with Ferguson in the tunnel before the Palace/Man U cup final.

Yes the game where he didn't allow us the advantage every time we ran out with the ball after being fouled or should I say cheated on, man.u knew how to stop us breaking on them and that massive huge arse of a ref helped them.

Good organised efficient ref's are not noticed.

 

peterg Flag Anerley 09 Dec 20 9.11am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Yes the game where he didn't allow us the advantage every time we ran out with the ball after being fouled or should I say cheated on, man.u knew how to stop us breaking on them and that massive huge arse of a ref helped them.

Good organised efficient ref's are not noticed.

He's asking us to feel sorry for him here. Including for the fact that he reffed Palace in 15 matches and we won none of them.

[Link]

 


The right place at the right time

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Dec 20 9.28am

Originally posted by peterg

He's asking us to feel sorry for him here. Including for the fact that he reffed Palace in 15 matches and we won none of them.

[Link]

I see he skipped over the bit where Wickham put the ball in the back of the net only for him to call play back for a Palace free kick.

He also forgot to mention his photo opportunity with a grinning Sir Alex before the game in the tunnel.

Edited by Badger11 (09 Dec 2020 9.29am)

 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 20 9.36am

Originally posted by peterg

He's asking us to feel sorry for him here. Including for the fact that he reffed Palace in 15 matches and we won none of them.

[Link]

With the greatest of respect, Mark is not asking or yearning for any sympathy at all.He has been refreshingly honest and that should be applauded.

One suspects that there are those who believe that he was solely responsible for the fact that we failed to record a victory in those games he refereed.
Clearly the Hennessey 'Faux pas' to which Mark referred was due to the fact that our goalkeeper had Mark in his eyeline and was distracted!!!

I will not add any more to my sentiments in this post as any further comment will only be the catalyst for a dastardly Willo thread and the great and good in all honesty have had enough of them.

In any event, the discussion concerns the WBA game and NOT officiating in the FA Cup Final!

Edited by Willo (09 Dec 2020 9.39am)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 Dec 20 9.51am

Originally posted by Willo

I will not add any more to my sentiments in this post as any further comment will only be the catalyst for a dastardly Willo thread and the great and good in all honesty have had enough of them.

In any event, the discussion concerns the WBA game and NOT officiating in the FA Cup Final!

What you really mean is that you will not add any more to this thread as long as you have the last word.

 

eaglesdare Flag 09 Dec 20 10.01am

I don't listen to pundits anymore.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 Dec 20 10.51am

Originally posted by eaglesdare

I don't listen to pundits anymore.

I'm surprised that anyone does as very few have anything interesting to say. I would also like Sky to stop using co-commentators who have a vested interest in one of the clubs that they are commentating on. I watched Man United playing West Ham last weekend and I don't think that Gary Neville was aware that there was another team playing as it was Man United this and Man United that.

Spitting Jamie is just as bad too

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 09 Dec 20 1.30pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I'm surprised that anyone does as very few have anything interesting to say. I would also like Sky to stop using co-commentators who have a vested interest in one of the clubs that they are commentating on. I watched Man United playing West Ham last weekend and I don't think that Gary Neville was aware that there was another team playing as it was Man United this and Man United that.

Spitting Jamie is just as bad too

Ah yes, all round expert Gary "Valencia" Neville ha ha

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 09 Dec 20 2.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

With the greatest of respect, Mark is not asking or yearning for any sympathy at all.He has been refreshingly honest and that should be applauded.

It's taken him a bit of time, though, to own up to those awful refereeing blunders (unless I've missed something - in which case I put my hands up and apologise).

 

Page 18 of 19 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > WBA v Crystal palace match thread