You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle United Vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle United Vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 18 of 19 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
GujiMadDog Flag England 03 Feb 21 12.06pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

One last thing I will say is that last night was the first game since I can remember where Luka didn't get caught in possession at least once.

True, I cant remember him being caught on the ball. However he gave the ball away a mulititude of times with misplaced passes. This and the obligatory yellow - you just know its gonna happen sooner or later - is turning him into a liability.

Agree with Jairo's pace and passig sentiment. What I would add is that he does add to the overall defensive stability by moving into spaces vacated by our fullbacks. This we saw against West Ham. Newcastle were so slow to move forward yesterday that he was rarely called upon to do this.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Feb 21 12.07pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Really frustrating night for us. We were taking shots and, for the first time this season, had more possession than the opponents. Don't remember your 'keeper having to make too many top tier saves though.

Interested to hear your thoughts on the Milivojevic foul?

In isolation that game was fine for us, created chances, didn't look too troubled by your attack until the game was stretched in the closing stages. Undone by a superb goal and a set piece. Meh, it happens.

Trouble is, that's now 1 win in 13 and we're running out of winnable games.

I think Luka was extremely lucky not to get a red card. Cannot understand how VAR didn’t appear to study it ( not complaining), given the other red cards last night, a strange decision

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 03 Feb 21 12.08pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Really frustrating night for us. We were taking shots and, for the first time this season, had more possession than the opponents. Don't remember your 'keeper having to make too many top tier saves though.

Interested to hear your thoughts on the Milivojevic foul?

In isolation that game was fine for us, created chances, didn't look too troubled by your attack until the game was stretched in the closing stages. Undone by a superb goal and a set piece. Meh, it happens.

Trouble is, that's now 1 win in 13 and we're running out of winnable games.

I was thinking that would be the Newcastle perspective. We are well used to that ourselves! I don't want to say too much about Milo - basically a yellow every game. I was surprised no VAR on a couple of decisions. Shelvey probably did a worse tackle but the ref gave a yellow meaning VAR would not be used. I thought the grappling in the box might go against us, but it didn't. We were a bit lucky for the win, but we'll take it. It's not really often that we get much luck.
As for you, you have St. Maximim back, he seems lively. There are probably three worse teams (something we have been known to rely on). Where I thought you were poor was defending balls into the box. A couple of times we got clear at set pieces and clear at the far post. I guess you missed a couple of close chances too.
We can sympathise but we will bask in the glory of our lofty league position for now, of course. Can't see Bruce lasting. Rafa was decent, I thought. Of course, it's all Ashley's fault. A Saudi Prince or two will sort you out.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Feb 21 12.10pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Really frustrating night for us. We were taking shots and, for the first time this season, had more possession than the opponents. Don't remember your 'keeper having to make too many top tier saves though.

Interested to hear your thoughts on the Milivojevic foul?

In isolation that game was fine for us, created chances, didn't look too troubled by your attack until the game was stretched in the closing stages. Undone by a superb goal and a set piece. Meh, it happens.

Trouble is, that's now 1 win in 13 and we're running out of winnable games.

It was quite a 'Thwack' by Riedewald but had it not been for the deflection off Clark I believe Darlow would have saved the shot.

In terms of the Cahill goal, he made a run from the back post but his marker got blocked by Batshuayi, more by accident than design so Cahill had a free header.That was the only positive contribution by Batshuayi the whole game,he was truly abysmal.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Feb 21 12.26pm

Originally posted by Willo

It was quite a 'Thwack' by Riedewald but had it not been for the deflection off Clark I believe Darlow would have saved the shot.

In terms of the Cahill goal, he made a run from the back post but his marker got blocked by Batshuayi, more by accident than design so Cahill had a free header.That was the only positive contribution by Batshuayi the whole game,he was truly abysmal.

Glad to see you are your usual positive self today

 

taylors lovechild Flag 03 Feb 21 12.34pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Really frustrating night for us. We were taking shots and, for the first time this season, had more possession than the opponents. Don't remember your 'keeper having to make too many top tier saves though.

Interested to hear your thoughts on the Milivojevic foul?

In isolation that game was fine for us, created chances, didn't look too troubled by your attack until the game was stretched in the closing stages. Undone by a superb goal and a set piece. Meh, it happens.

Trouble is, that's now 1 win in 13 and we're running out of winnable games.

It was classic Hodgson: get in front and close the game down. If we'd carried on pushing forward the game could have ended 5-5, but at half-time the decision seemed to be made to close up shop and you didn't really look threatening until ASM came on and we actually looked the more likely to score due to the gaps you were leaving. If Zaha hadn't got injured we may well have scored again.

I wish we had a striker like Wilson though, who looks like an amazing piece of business (even if he did keep collapsing at the nearest whiff of a touch). You didn't really deserve three points last game, so I think a share of the spoils this season seems reasonable.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Feb 21 12.50pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Really frustrating night for us. We were taking shots and, for the first time this season, had more possession than the opponents. Don't remember your 'keeper having to make too many top tier saves though.

Interested to hear your thoughts on the Milivojevic foul?

In isolation that game was fine for us, created chances, didn't look too troubled by your attack until the game was stretched in the closing stages. Undone by a superb goal and a set piece. Meh, it happens.

Trouble is, that's now 1 win in 13 and we're running out of winnable games.

I am afraid that is why we won. Whenever I see a team ceding possession to us, I know we are in for a beating.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Feb 21 12.55pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

A decent performance with some good attacking spells.
Just need a focal point to the attacks.
In this regard I was impressed by Wilson in the first half for them.
Quick, powerful and always a pest to our defence.
I hope Mateta can perform a similar function for us as it doesn’t look that either Benteke or Batshuayi are up to the task.
Benteke is too static and the game seems to pass Batshuayi by.

Bats needs to study the off side law as he was a foot away from an assist, but otherwise he was not as bad as people are saying he was.

Benteke was the correct substitute. We were winning nothing in the air, especially in their half, and he helped even things up. He also slowed things down with free kicks and caused defenders to stay back and not press up field. I can't believe I am saying this, but good team effort Ben.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 03 Feb 21 1.01pm

I think that last night's performance was something we have seen in the past from Hodgson's teams but not often enough this season.

Once we had recovered from the shock of the early goal, we used possession well and defended resolutely. Guita wasn't seriously extended all night.

As Silvertop pointed out, when we have the majority of the possession we tend to struggle.

Given Newcastle's result and performance at Everton, the conditions last night, a long way from home at that - that was an excellent win.

Some people on here are not getting past their anti Hodgson bias to see it that way however.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

TheBigToePunt Flag 03 Feb 21 1.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

It was quite a 'Thwack' by Riedewald but had it not been for the deflection off Clark I believe Darlow would have saved the shot.

In terms of the Cahill goal, he made a run from the back post but his marker got blocked by Batshuayi, more by accident than design so Cahill had a free header.That was the only positive contribution by Batshuayi the whole game,he was truly abysmal.

Agreed that Darlow may well have saved it, but I think that's the beauty of such a powerful, true strike - any slight nick off anyone and the keeper has no chance.

Personally I love a goal like that, it's like the shot is struck so well that it refuses to do anything other than go in, no matter what the defenders try to do to stop it!

Batshuayi was indeed awful again, but in fairness he isn't doing anything unexpected. We already knew his leading of the line was almost non-existent, that he can't time or curve a run if his life depends on it, and that if he isn't finishing a chance then he is something of a passenger. On the flip side, he is a more instinctive finisher than anyone else we've got (Mateta may change that hopefully), but as he isn't getting chances in the box, apart from that one that spun up at him against Wolves, we are only getting all the negative sides of his game.

I thought Benteke did pretty well when he came on, and remain of the view that he may be worth retaining on reduced wages, with Batshuayi going back to Chelsea.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Feb 21 1.57pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Really frustrating night for us. We were taking shots and, for the first time this season, had more possession than the opponents. Don't remember your 'keeper having to make too many top tier saves though.

Interested to hear your thoughts on the Milivojevic foul?

In isolation that game was fine for us, created chances, didn't look too troubled by your attack until the game was stretched in the closing stages. Undone by a superb goal and a set piece. Meh, it happens.

Trouble is, that's now 1 win in 13 and we're running out of winnable games.


Our manager doesn't give two hoots for possession stats. It's all down to the style a team plays. Your manager said after the game that you are trying to change from the sit deep and counter-attack style (which is, of course, what we and Burnley do). The more expansive the way you play the more possession you might get but the more you open yourself up to a counter-attacking team. The classic example of that this season was Man City's defeat at Spurs.

The more possession we seem to have, the less likely we are to win the game because our ageing defenders and CDMs (excluding Riedewald) don't have the legs to get back when we lose the ball (think our demolition by Liverpool when we tried to play attacking football).

I was frustrated when you did us in the reverse fixture earlier in the season. We had a lot of possession that day; your keeper made some great saves and we got done in the final minutes. So as has been said - honours even for the season.

As for Luka, lucky boy, BUT these tackles always look far worse in slo-mo. Mind you the red card for that new So'ton lad was a no brainer.

Talking of So'ton, will be interesting to see how they react to last night when they face you on Saturday.

 

Mathers Flag 03 Feb 21 2.02pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I find it unbelievable that people think Jairo makes Luka a better player and people even criticise Luka for his recent performances. Luka has been one of our best players recently and it certainly isn’t down to Jairo. He has to do double the work when he is beside him.

What game are you watching? Luka has been complete s***e for 12 months. He is painfully slow, passing is shoddy and set pieces are a joke. I will give him credit as far as the last two performances have been marginally better but he is clearly a player on the decline. No goals or assists since Bournemouth away and weekly bookings highlight this.

I’m not saying Jairo is the best midfielder in the world but there’s no way Luka is carrying him. As a team we’ve been carrying Luka for far too long.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Feb 21 2.03pm

Well, I for one, am glad Jairo has just signed extension to 2024

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 03 Feb 21 2.05pm

Something else from last night..

I've never been convinced by the argument that Van Aanholt makes up for his piss poor defending by adding attacking verve to our play, though I see the logic in that argument.

What bothers me more is his sloppy, careless use of possession.

If I had a pound every time he did something stupid with the ball in our third right after we've worked hard to win it back, I'd have nearly as much money as he actually gets paid not to fecking do it.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Feb 21 2.08pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Well, I for one, am glad Jairo has just signed extension to 2024

In my humble estimation he has been a 'Positive' in our team, with the ability to actually pass a ball to one of our own players and has a calmness and composure when in possession.He has also scored goals for us.Well done to Jairo !

I did feel that towards the end last night he was 'Running on empty' and wasn't surprised when he was substituted.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 03 Feb 21 2.24pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Well, I for one, am glad Jairo has just signed extension to 2024

Great news. I was worried he might go elsewhere looking for more starting opportunities. Hopefully he doesn't get dropped the moment McArthur or McCarthy are fit again.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 03 Feb 21 2.30pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Really frustrating night for us. We were taking shots and, for the first time this season, had more possession than the opponents. Don't remember your 'keeper having to make too many top tier saves though.

Interested to hear your thoughts on the Milivojevic foul?

In isolation that game was fine for us, created chances, didn't look too troubled by your attack until the game was stretched in the closing stages. Undone by a superb goal and a set piece. Meh, it happens.

Trouble is, that's now 1 win in 13 and we're running out of winnable games.

Guaita made a terrific one handed save from Fraser which was huge in securing us the win.

As for the Luka challenge, I thought at the time he’s gone and watching it again on MOTD I’m absolutely amazed that VAR didn’t review it and recommend a red card. Not the most dangerous tackle in the world but it still ticks all the boxes as far as the PGMOL are concerned. I’m amazed he stayed on.

You should be safe this season, as there will be SUFC & WBA below you and the return of ASM and your performance against Everton last Saturday would suggest you will be able to outperform at least one other team.

 

EddieMac Flag 03 Feb 21 2.32pm

Originally posted by GujiMadDog

True, I cant remember him being caught on the ball. However he gave the ball away a mulititude of times with misplaced passes. This and the obligatory yellow - you just know its gonna happen sooner or later - is turning him into a liability.

Agree with Jairo's pace and passig sentiment. What I would add is that he does add to the overall defensive stability by moving into spaces vacated by our fullbacks. This we saw against West Ham. Newcastle were so slow to move forward yesterday that he was rarely called upon to do this.

For all people saying Luka's was outpassed by Jairo last night and Luka's passing was poor. Just take into account that Luka attempted 45 passes last night with a success rate of 93.3% while Jairo attempted a lot less at 27 passes with a success rate of 92.6%.

We are all biased towards certain players but the stats don't lie.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Feb 21 5.08pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

For all people saying Luka's was outpassed by Jairo last night and Luka's passing was poor. Just take into account that Luka attempted 45 passes last night with a success rate of 93.3% while Jairo attempted a lot less at 27 passes with a success rate of 92.6%.

We are all biased towards certain players but the stats don't lie.

So perhaps Luka does play better with Jairo then

My son is training to do analytical graphs for teams, he has done this for Jairo . Lines are his passes, black circles his tackles and clear circles his interceptions. The star is, of course, his goal.

Edited by Spiderman (03 Feb 2021 5.14pm)

92F65769-A222-4187-9152-96D747E432E7.jpeg Attachment: 92F65769-A222-4187-9152-96D747E432E7.jpeg (151.94Kb)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Feb 21 5.43pm

Apparently his goal has been timed as the most powerful from open play in PL league this season 71.2 mph

 

Page 18 of 19 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle United Vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread