You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson
November 16 2026 3.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson


Page 18 of 27 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >
fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 28 Dec 23 9.37am

To be honest Willo, I wouldn't fancy any of them as manager. We already have in place the only manager who could be deemed a relegation 'saver'. Pulis I imagine we would never want and he wouldn't come back. Allardyce possibly similar and failed last 2 times. Bruce and McCarthy are busted flushes whose days in the Premier League are behind them.

I suspect we will appoint another manager who will fail spectacularly as he tries to introduce a different way to play at the wrong time of the season.

The Board mucked up spectacularly in the summer transfer window, the overall depth of the squad is weaker. That seriously needs to be addressed and needs a couple of players in by mid January. SP and the board won't though.

Our squad depth isn't good enough. End of. Roy may have made mistakes but unless we invest in January, I can't see any manager coming in and making a massive difference with what we have.

Last year Leicester sacked Rodgers and got even worse, the same with Leeds.


Originally posted by Willo

Tony Pulis and Sam Allardyce are currently not in management jobs .Neither are Steve Bruce or Mick McCarthy.Experienced heads to end of the season.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 23 9.42am

Originally posted by fish mitten

To be honest Willo, I wouldn't fancy any of them as manager. We already have in place the only manager who could be deemed a relegation 'saver'. Pulis I imagine we would never want and he wouldn't come back. Allardyce possibly similar and failed last 2 times. Bruce and McCarthy are busted flushes whose days in the Premier League are behind them.

I suspect we will appoint another manager who will fail spectacularly as he tries to introduce a different way to play at the wrong time of the season.

The Board mucked up spectacularly in the summer transfer window, the overall depth of the squad is weaker. That seriously needs to be addressed and needs a couple of players in by mid January. SP and the board won't though.

Our squad depth isn't good enough. End of. Roy may have made mistakes but unless we invest in January, I can't see any manager coming in and making a massive difference with what we have.

Last year Leicester sacked Rodgers and got even worse, the same with Leeds.

Leicester relieved Rodgers of his duties when they were 18th with only 10 games remaining and they ended the season in 18th place.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 28 Dec 23 9.46am

How can anyone be surprised with what we’ve seen from Roy this season? Didn’t we all expect this type of football from his team? He is an irritatingly cautious manager and has been this way throughout his career.

He is a very decent man , but it is deeply frustrating (and at times depressing) to see such talented young players constrained by the defensive approach to every game. When you look at the likes of Bournemouth/Wolves/Brighton you can see the respective managers have improved individual players through good coaching and providing opportunities for game time - which has developed them.

Roy will only provide opportunities when pushed into it through injury- Chris Richards/Ozoh are examples of this. (I think they have both been very good).
I have written off the January window on the basis that anyone new arriving at the club won’t be used anyway - unless 2-0 down with 10 minutes to go! The only crumb of comfort is that I do actually believe Luton, Burnley and Sheffield U Will finish below us…..but it may be by as comfortable as thought a few weeks ago.

I don’t see us making the change with Roy until the end of the season unfortunately - which will be a shame for the younger players - and a growing number of increasingly disillusioned fans.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 28 Dec 23 9.53am

Originally posted by fish mitten

To be honest Willo, I wouldn't fancy any of them as manager. We already have in place the only manager who could be deemed a relegation 'saver'. Pulis I imagine we would never want and he wouldn't come back. Allardyce possibly similar and failed last 2 times. Bruce and McCarthy are busted flushes whose days in the Premier League are behind them.

I suspect we will appoint another manager who will fail spectacularly as he tries to introduce a different way to play at the wrong time of the season.

The Board mucked up spectacularly in the summer transfer window, the overall depth of the squad is weaker. That seriously needs to be addressed and needs a couple of players in by mid January. SP and the board won't though.

Our squad depth isn't good enough. End of. Roy may have made mistakes but unless we invest in January, I can't see any manager coming in and making a massive difference with what we have.

Last year Leicester sacked Rodgers and got even worse, the same with Leeds.


Really? Look at our form. Ask Watford fans how that episode of avoiding relegation went.

It’s criminal that the only time we have really given it a go at attacking the opposition - we scored two goals at the Etihad against Man City. That’s the only time. The rest is history.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 23 9.55am

Originally posted by Elphers40

How can anyone be surprised with what we’ve seen from Roy this season? Didn’t we all expect this type of football from his team? He is an irritatingly cautious manager and has been this way throughout his career.

He is a very decent man , but it is deeply frustrating (and at times depressing) to see such talented young players constrained by the defensive approach to every game. When you look at the likes of Bournemouth/Wolves/Brighton you can see the respective managers have improved individual players through good coaching and providing opportunities for game time - which has developed them.

Roy will only provide opportunities when pushed into it through injury- Chris Richards/Ozoh are examples of this. (I think they have both been very good).
I have written off the January window on the basis that anyone new arriving at the club won’t be used anyway - unless 2-0 down with 10 minutes to go! The only crumb of comfort is that I do actually believe Luton, Burnley and Sheffield U Will finish below us…..but it may be by as comfortable as thought a few weeks ago.

I don’t see us making the change with Roy until the end of the season unfortunately - which will be a shame for the younger players - and a growing number of increasingly disillusioned fans.

We are slipping into the abyss and the relegation trapdoor is staring us in the face.

Perhaps there is a manager out there whom Steve Parish rates and who is available and he might be tempted to appoint this person as soon as possible before he is employed by a rival club.The 'Transfer Window' is about to open and Mr Hodgson will not be at the club next season.

 

Goalpost1 Flag Worcester Park 28 Dec 23 10.00am

Whilst I have supported Roy I am now if the view that it is time to make a change. If we lose to Brentford I think it may happen after that game.

What is frustrating is most weeks we seem to be just on the losing side. Injuries are playing a big part in that and obvious that we need two or three experienced heads in Jan. IMO let a new manager make that choice. Get it right and I can see us being relatively comfortable.

 

derfes Flag upper norwood 28 Dec 23 10.05am

i think there are two simple metrics on which we can determine whether to sack a manager.

Win %

viera: 29.73
Hodgson: 32.26 from 31 games

if we lose to brentford, everton, arsenal and shefield wednesday then Hodgson's win percentage will fall below vierra's

Points per game
Viera :1.229
Hodgson:1.258

current points won is 39
accordingly we have vierra equivalent point attaintment equivalents.
Brentford:39.35
everton : 40.58
Arsenal : 41.81
Sheff wed:43.04


current points won is 39. I'd want to examine after sheffield wednesday, but Hodgson's record this season( never mind the bournemouth performance) isn't encouraging.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 28 Dec 23 10.09am

Originally posted by fish mitten

To be honest Willo, I wouldn't fancy any of them as manager. We already have in place the only manager who could be deemed a relegation 'saver'. Pulis I imagine we would never want and he wouldn't come back. Allardyce possibly similar and failed last 2 times. Bruce and McCarthy are busted flushes whose days in the Premier League are behind them.

I suspect we will appoint another manager who will fail spectacularly as he tries to introduce a different way to play at the wrong time of the season.

Our squad depth isn't good enough. End of. Roy may have made mistakes but unless we invest in January, I can't see any manager coming in and making a massive difference with what we have.


I cannot understand this mentality that Roy is the ONLY person who can keep us up?!

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 28 Dec 23 10.11am

Originally posted by derfes

i think there are two simple metrics on which we can determine whether to sack a manager.

Win %

viera: 29.73
Hodgson: 32.26 from 31 games

if we lose to brentford, everton, arsenal and shefield wednesday then Hodgson's win percentage will fall below vierra's

Points per game
Viera :1.229
Hodgson:1.258

current points won is 39
accordingly we have vierra equivalent point attaintment equivalents.
Brentford:39.35
everton : 40.58
Arsenal : 41.81
Sheff wed:43.04


current points won is 39. I'd want to examine after sheffield wednesday, but Hodgson's record this season( never mind the bournemouth performance) isn't encouraging.

Sheffield Wednesday or Sheffield Utd?

 

derfes Flag upper norwood 28 Dec 23 10.20am

ah yes my bad , sheffield united.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 28 Dec 23 10.22am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Sheffield Wednesday or Sheffield Utd?

That’s next season

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 28 Dec 23 10.29am

See the bookies have installed Roy as favourite to the next EPL manager to be sacked . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 28 Dec 23 10.33am

We got 2 points more in the last 4 games than I expected, but with proper in game management from the manager, it would have been at least 4 points. Sadly the only time he used his bench and managed properly was against City, where he was forced by an injury and the fact we were two down into doing the right thing. He's running his chosen few into the ground and it's costing us points IMO. There are no guarantees in football, but the last four games have proved that we are good enough to give every team in this division a very close game. We've deserved more, but we just run out of steam or we just refuse to try and win a game, cos the manager is terrified of changing things in case we lose, but in doing so he's ensuring we lose anyway. The only way we find out if players are good enough is to play them. Fcuk it, after 19 games we should already know if they are good enough, cos they should have the minutes under their belts already. For the record I'd have bought on França for Eze and Ahamada for Mateta on 75-80 mins, moving Ayew up top. Then Ozoh for Richards a few minutes later. As I say there are no guarantees, but at least I can say that I tried everything to get something from the game.
Roy is just waiting for the cup game where he will throw all of them in at once, into a totally ill prepared one off team and then claim, "told you so".
I'm sad that Roy will eventually leave as a villain, but he should never have come back.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

PatrickA Flag London 28 Dec 23 11.05am

If you're going to change the manager, the time to do it is during the break in January.
I can see it happening and it wouldn't surprise me if it was Cooper. These stories have been around for weeks and it may well be a question of time.
Although such a move would disappoint some fans, I can see some merits.
He's done well in every job he's undertaken, including taking the basket case of Forest up and keeping them up.
His dismissal seemed as much to do with conflicts with the owner including over players brought into the club.

It would be good for all the players at Palace to start with a clean slate and have a fresh opportunity.
Roy often seems to base his selections on players who are familiar with his methods last time around as manage.
A new manager would not be similarly encumbered.

 

Plumpton eagle Flag East Sussex 28 Dec 23 11.20am

Dangermouse

We got 2 points more in the last 4 games than I expected, but with proper in game management from the manager, it would have been at least 4 points. Sadly the only time he used his bench and managed properly was against City, where he was forced by an injury and the fact we were two down into doing the right thing. He's running his chosen few into the ground and it's costing us points IMO. There are no guarantees in football, but the last four games have proved that we are good enough to give every team in this division a very close game. We've deserved more, but we just run out of steam or we just refuse to try and win a game, cos the manager is terrified of changing things in case we lose, but in doing so he's ensuring we lose anyway. The only way we find out if players are good enough is to play them. Fcuk it, after 19 games we should already know if they are good enough, cos they should have the minutes under their belts already. For the record I'd have bought on França for Eze and Ahamada for Mateta on 75-80 mins, moving Ayew up top. Then Ozoh for Richards a few minutes later. As I say there are no guarantees, but at least I can say that I tried everything to get something from the game.
Roy is just waiting for the cup game where he will throw all of them in at once, into a totally ill prepared one off team and then claim, "told you so".
I'm sad that Roy will eventually leave as a villain, but he should never have come back.

-------------------------------------------------------

Spot on for me.

At one point in the commentary it was revealed Palace have had 80 corners this season with not one goal resulting (only team in the prem without a corner goal). This can't all be bad luck or poor finishing. It smacks of a lack of a corner strategy, or routines or just trying different things. We have become very solid defending corners but bereft of ideas or imagination in taking them. This has to be a coaching issue. Perhaps, another example where defensive coaching is more evident than offensive.

Roy has been brilliant for us but he looked a tired and beaten man last night. I would be disappointed to see him leave on a low but if we fail to beat Brentford then I think he will go.


 

IP4Eagle Flag Ipswich 28 Dec 23 11.28am

It reminds me of when I handed in my notice at my first proper job I honestly thought I'd still be the model employee in my two weeks of notice - in the end I was sent home after 3 days because actually I couldn't give a stuff because why would I? You need a manager, regardless of ability, who's fighting for their career, their reputation or to try and get a better job. Someone with skin in the game.

I like Roy, but Roy can do what he likes, say what he likes and deep down has absolutely nothing to motivate or push him so he's not gonna be staying up all night trying to find the way to unlock the teams potential, why should he?

Whilst refreshing candour is always appreciated his slating the fans for being spoilt, telling the press Chelsea wont be "worried about the team he's bringing" and everything else is just symptomatic of someone who is beyond comfortable in their situation, and his comfort will in no way be impacted by the teams form.

He needs to go, and we just need frankly anyone right now who might give it a f**king good go at it because as someone else said we're in freefall right now.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 23 11.30am

Originally posted by Plumpton eagle

Dangermouse

We got 2 points more in the last 4 games than I expected, but with proper in game management from the manager, it would have been at least 4 points. Sadly the only time he used his bench and managed properly was against City, where he was forced by an injury and the fact we were two down into doing the right thing. He's running his chosen few into the ground and it's costing us points IMO. There are no guarantees in football, but the last four games have proved that we are good enough to give every team in this division a very close game. We've deserved more, but we just run out of steam or we just refuse to try and win a game, cos the manager is terrified of changing things in case we lose, but in doing so he's ensuring we lose anyway. The only way we find out if players are good enough is to play them. Fcuk it, after 19 games we should already know if they are good enough, cos they should have the minutes under their belts already. For the record I'd have bought on França for Eze and Ahamada for Mateta on 75-80 mins, moving Ayew up top. Then Ozoh for Richards a few minutes later. As I say there are no guarantees, but at least I can say that I tried everything to get something from the game.
Roy is just waiting for the cup game where he will throw all of them in at once, into a totally ill prepared one off team and then claim, "told you so".
I'm sad that Roy will eventually leave as a villain, but he should never have come back.

-------------------------------------------------------

Spot on for me.

At one point in the commentary it was revealed Palace have had 80 corners this season with not one goal resulting (only team in the prem without a corner goal). This can't all be bad luck or poor finishing. It smacks of a lack of a corner strategy, or routines or just trying different things. We have become very solid defending corners but bereft of ideas or imagination in taking them. This has to be a coaching issue. Perhaps, another example where defensive coaching is more evident than offensive.

Roy has been brilliant for us but he looked a tired and beaten man last night. I would be disappointed to see him leave on a low but if we fail to beat Brentford then I think he will go.


There are those who believe he will be in situ for the Brentford game and dearly hope that we fail to secure the victory as they believe this will signal the departure of our manager.

Suffice to say he has become 'Persona Non Grata' amongst sections of our fanbase.In football as in life one day one is cock of the walk, another a feather duster.

 

Jacey Flag 28 Dec 23 11.37am

Originally posted by Willo

There are those who believe he will be in situ for the Brentford game and dearly hope that we fail to secure the victory as they believe this will signal the departure of our manager.

Suffice to say he has become 'Persona Non Grata' amongst sections of our fanbase.In football as in life one day one is cock of the walk, another a feather duster.

Can you translate,please,to a thicko??

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 Dec 23 11.39am

I still think he’ll be here for the rest of the season, I’m sure SP will be thinking he’s still that safe option that will still grind out enough points to get us to safety despite the terrible run we’re on
A change now could be a disaster, by the time the new man shakes things up and settles down we could be in the bottom three and it might be a struggle to get out then.

This is what I think parish will be thinking, not me, personally I’d take the chance now and pull the trigger just to liven things up but then relegation doesn’t particularly bother me, been there, done that several times

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 23 11.48am

Originally posted by Jacey

Can you translate,please,to a thicko??

It is 'Yours Truly' who fits this description not you.
I am just an intellectually starved fusty relic.

 

Page 18 of 27 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson