You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?
November 22 2026 3.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?


Page 182 of 280 < 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 >
cryrst Flag The garden of England 03 Jul 22 10.03pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Well, the people that got all those shares will pay lots of tax. So that’s all good then.

What those rich successful people of whom you despise so much.
A tad ironic you think !!!

 

BlueJay Flag UK 04 Jul 22 12.41am

Russian scientist Kolker held in spy probe dies of cancer -

Quote A terminally ill Russian physicist who was arrested in Siberia on suspicion of treason has died in custody after being flown to Moscow.

Federal Security Service (FSB) officers took Dmitry Kolker, 54, from his hospital bed in Novosibirsk on 30 June. He had pancreatic cancer.

On Sunday his son Maxim reported his death, criticising Russian prosecutors and "the state machine" over the case.

The quantum and laser specialist was suspected of spying for China.

On 30 June a Novosibirsk court had ordered that he be detained for two months. He was taken to Moscow's Lefortovo prison and died later in a nearby hospital.

He had recently read lectures to Chinese students, with an FSB agent ever present by his side.

"These charges are absolutely ridiculous and extremely cruel and unusual to be levied on such a sick man," his cousin Anton Dianov told Reuters news agency.

"They knew that he was on his deathbed and they chose to arrest him."

Edited by BlueJay (04 Jul 2022 12.42am)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 04 Jul 22 12.52am

Zelenskyy vows to restore control over Ukraine’s Lysychansk in Donbas - [Link]

Seems unlikely in my view, but it was no doubt sensible to withdraw.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jul 22 8.03am

Battlefield update:
Ukraine make some gains in the south.

[Link]

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

deleted 25 Flag 05 Jul 22 8.24am

Ukr have taken out quite a few russ amo bases with himars guided missiles which are making a big difference

3 week later update ;

[Link]

Edited by Vincehair (22 Jul 2022 4.30pm)

 

Grumbles 05 Jul 22 5.20pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Battlefield update:
Ukraine make some gains in the south.

[Link]


Interested to know if the RF have given up on Odessa for the moment to focus on the entire Donbas, Luhansk and perhaps Zaporizhia.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jul 22 7.29pm

Originally posted by Grumbles


Interested to know if the RF have given up on Odessa for the moment to focus on the entire Donbas, Luhansk and perhaps Zaporizhia.

I know that Putin said that the forces that took Luhansk would now rest, while different units took over. He spoke of concentration on other fronts....Mind you as always there is what is said and what actually happens.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jul 22 7.34pm

Originally posted by Vincehair

Ukr have taken out quite a few russ amo bases with himars guided missiles which are making a big difference

Not really.

The Ukraine are massively out gunned with artillery.

In truth, if you expect to beat Russia you'd need all of Nato's heavy equipment.....not drips and drabs spread over months....and in truth Nato's trained armies to operate them.

The strategy never made much sense to begin with.....in terms of winning.

It was always about forcing Russia to stop due to economics.

It was pretty dim to begin with but that's the problem with group think and politicians scared to admit failure.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Grumbles 05 Jul 22 8.16pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Not really.

The Ukraine are massively out gunned with artillery.

In truth, if you expect to beat Russia you'd need all of Nato's heavy equipment.....not drips and drabs spread over months....and in truth Nato's trained armies to operate them.

The strategy never made much sense to begin with.....in terms of winning.

It was always about forcing Russia to stop due to economics.

It was pretty dim to begin with but that's the problem with group think and politicians scared to admit failure.

This will go on for years. You can't hold land with artillery.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jul 22 8.29pm

Originally posted by Grumbles

This will go on for years. You can't hold land with artillery.

I doubt it personally.

There are plenty of pro Russians in the dombas to hold it once this ends.

Their problem starts if they want to control beyond pro Russian majority areas.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Jul 2022 8.30pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Grumbles 05 Jul 22 8.58pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I doubt it personally.

There are plenty of pro Russians in the dombas to hold it once this ends.

Their problem starts if they want to control beyond pro Russian majority areas.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Jul 2022 8.30pm)

The problem is they had already annexed the bits they could hold in 2014.

 

deleted 25 Flag 05 Jul 22 9.27pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Not really.

The Ukraine are massively out gunned with artillery.

In truth, if you expect to beat Russia you'd need all of Nato's heavy equipment.....not drips and drabs spread over months....and in truth Nato's trained armies to operate them.

The strategy never made much sense to begin with.....in terms of winning.

It was always about forcing Russia to stop due to economics.

It was pretty dim to begin with but that's the problem with group think and politicians scared to admit failure.

Agree if Ukraine had the weapons earlier the war could in theory be over already as Western weapons more technically advanced in general. Ukr army seem perfectly capable of using them

It was only because the west was listening to Russian bulls*** about Nato expansion and sabre rattling that it took so long to give Ukr what they have been asking for.

Seizure of Russian assets to pay for reconstruction seems like a way forward.

Edited by Vincehair (05 Jul 2022 9.37pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jul 22 10.03pm

Originally posted by Vincehair

Agree if Ukraine had the weapons earlier the war could in theory be over already as Western weapons more technically advanced in general. Ukr army seem perfectly capable of using them

It was only because the west was listening to Russian bulls*** about Nato expansion and sabre rattling that it took so long to give Ukr what they have been asking for.

Seizure of Russian assets to pay for reconstruction seems like a way forward.

I respect your opinion but I'm afraid we don't agree on most of that.

Personally I don't think this was ever practically a winnable war and I stated that at the start.

In my view this war will be over by mid winter at the most and Russia will have their gains in the east and south....probably after negotiating away territory won beyond that.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jul 2022 8.32am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

deleted 25 Flag 05 Jul 22 10.18pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I respect your opinion but I'm afraid we don't agree on most of that.

Personally I don't think this was ever practically a winnable war and I started that at the start.

In my view this war will be over by mid winter at the most and Russia will have their gains in the east and south.

Putins war I agree was never winnable, just look at Vietnam and Afghanistan for previous examples of a so called superpower not winning - and what Putin now considers a victory, isn’t what he started off believing he would achieve . Really just a popularity conquest with the Russian public but at what cost

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Jul 22 6.50am

Originally posted by Vincehair

Putins war I agree was never winnable, just look at Vietnam and Afghanistan for previous examples of a so called superpower not winning - and what Putin now considers a victory, isn’t what he started off believing he would achieve . Really just a popularity conquest with the Russian public but at what cost

Where I think we can agree here is that Putin and his circle have the responsibility for starting the war.....sure you can talk about the breaking of the Minsk agreements, the 'Ukraine isn't a real country', and cross border shelling but in my view....that and the ridiculous Nazi stuff in no way constitutes a valid reason for an invasion...which essentially means untold numbers of people die....there were other options.

In this thread the different arguments for how this war came about have been discussed and on that I don't agree with the western position and presentation....and that's me going against my own, because my loyalty is to my own people (but not in support of social/neo liberalism and its consequences), but I'm not going to lie.

I don't agree with the western response to this war as rational......which has been to decide on creating a cold war in response and on massively supporting the Zelensky regime....which the more you look into it is far from its portrayal. But to go on about that would be to endlessly repeat points made earlier in the thread.

Still, this war was entirely avoidable and is a tragedy not only economically for the world (with death from hunger a real probability in vulnerable regions) but for every single life lost in the military conflict whoever they were.

I'm not going to waffle on and on but essentially I blame both power structures for why we are here.....but I don't ignore that Russia invaded.

What I want is actual realistic peace to be seriously negotiated....the world of the possible not a future where essentially the vulnerable of the world suffer for the hubris of world leaders who have preferred to prolong this war for their own, in my view, misguided and miscalculated interests.

Peace could have happened back in March but unfortunately I think the wrong decisions were made.


Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jul 2022 7.39am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

deleted 25 Flag 06 Jul 22 8.33am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Where I think we can agree here is that Putin and his circle have the responsibility for starting the war.....sure you can talk about the breaking of the Minsk agreements, the 'Ukraine isn't a real country', and cross border shelling but in my view....that and the ridiculous Nazi stuff in no way constitutes a valid reason for an invasion...which essentially means untold numbers of people die....there were other options.

In this thread the different arguments for how this war came about have been discussed and on that I don't agree with the western position and presentation....and that's me going against my own, because my loyalty is to my own people (but not in support of social/neo liberalism and its consequences), but I'm not going to lie.

I don't agree with the western response to this war as rational......which has been to decide on creating a cold war in response and on massively supporting the Zelensky regime....which the more you look into it is far from its portrayal. But to go on about that would be to endlessly repeat points made earlier in the thread.

Still, this war was entirely avoidable and is a tragedy not only economically for the world (with death from hunger a real probability in vulnerable regions) but for every single life lost in the military conflict whoever they were.

I'm not going to waffle on and on but essentially I blame both power structures for why we are here.....but I don't ignore that Russia invaded.

What I want is actual realistic peace to be seriously negotiated....the world of the possible not a future where essentially the vulnerable of the world suffer for the hubris of world leaders who have preferred to prolong this war for their own, in my view, misguided and miscalculated interests.

Peace could have happened back in March but unfortunately I think the wrong decisions were made.

I’m not politically aligned but what baffles me is rose tinted socialists who believe that it’s possible to negotiate with a dictator who rules by fear and tyranny. This can only come about with some parity in weapons because Putin won’t negotiate from a position of strength, not in March or now. That was a publicity stunt to look like they are reasonable whilst they implement genocide

Ukraine ask for weapons to defend their land and sanctions but it’s their existence they are fighting for, the wider political context is irrelevant to them. It’s the Baltic states / Eastern European and Anglo speaking countries that are consistent.

Russia have redirected troops from Finnish border because that is now not a viable target to bully now they are all but a NATO member. So not a question of NATO expansion but more who is vulnerable


Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jul 2022 7.39am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Jul 22 8.49am

Originally posted by Vincehair

I’m not politically aligned but what baffles me is rose tinted socialists who believe that it’s possible to negotiate with a dictator who rules by fear and tyranny.

The west had been negotiating with Putin since the nineties.

Aren't you aware that the west not only negotiates with 'dictators' but that large amounts of western companies and infrastructure are owned by them....there are the Saudis, who own considerably amounts of finance in London and even some well known football clubs. And of course there is China.

So I find your point about dictators a bit....well, non reflective of what actually happens.

As an aside, if your 'socialist' comment refers to me I think many people on the forum would find that somewhat....how shall we say, far from the reality.

Originally posted by Vincehair

This can only come about with some parity in weapons because Putin won’t negotiate from a position of strength, not in March or now. That was a publicity stunt to look like they are reasonable whilst they implement genocide

To say that genocide is going on in the Ukraine is pure nonsense.

I've seen this modern interpretation of 'genocide' before and sorry, it's not for me.....It's like the use of the word 'assault' to include things that plainly aren't what people actually think when hearing the word.

Originally posted by Vincehair

Ukraine ask for weapons to defend their land and sanctions but it’s their existence they are fighting for, the wider political context is irrelevant to them. It’s the Baltic states / Eastern European and Anglo speaking countries that are consistent.

Sure, however they aren't an article five country. If you are going to partake in wars outside of alliances....what is the point of being in Nato, you might as well just say....whatever the elites want at the time.


Originally posted by Vincehair

Russia have redirected troops from Finnish border because that is now not a viable target to bully now they are all but a NATO member. So not a question of NATO expansion but more who is vulnerable

While I don't agree with Nato expansion along these confrontational lines most people including Russia recognise that both Sweden and Finland have been western countries for many decades.....long since before Nato existed.

There are no significant pro Russian populations in those countries.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jul 2022 8.55am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

deleted 25 Flag 06 Jul 22 8.58am

genocide
/&#712;d&#658;&#603;n&#601;s&#652;&#618;d/
Learn to pronounce
noun

the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group.
"a campaign of genocide"

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Jul 22 9.04am

Originally posted by Vincehair

genocide
/&#712;d&#658;&#603;n&#601;s&#652;&#618;d/
Learn to pronounce
noun

the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group.
"a campaign of genocide"

Yep, and that's not what is happening.

There will be a Ukraine after this war....the idea that Russia is going to attempt to reach the Polish border isn't reality.

That would be WW3.

If they tried to hold areas of the Ukraine that didn't have significant areas of pro Russian support they would be making a rod for their own back.....which is why I think they will negotiate back to the Donbas regardless of gains made after that.....but what happens to Odessa I couldn't say.

All just my opinion of course and I respect your view.


Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jul 2022 9.05am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

deleted 25 Flag 06 Jul 22 9.54am

It is exactly genocide and Russia war hawks aim is still to take the whole of Ukraine, wipe it out and regime change in Kyiv.

If Ukraine do not get weapons then it will more likely happen

Pro Russian support? Sorry but that is Russian propaganda - go home to Russia if that’s what you consider yourself and send back Ukrainians forcibly removed to Russia

 

Page 182 of 280 < 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?